Skip to main content

Tag: Holmes Beach

Builder and city head back to court

Builder, city head back to court

HOLMES BEACH – City leaders and local developer/builder Shawn Kaleta are no strangers to meeting each other in court. This time, Kaleta’s attorney, Michelle Grantham, has filed a suit against city leaders in the U.S. District Court for the Middle District of Florida Tampa Division alleging that city leaders are discriminating against him and his various businesses in the city.

In the paperwork filed Dec. 31, Kaleta states he is filing for damages, along with declaratory and injunctive relief, alleging deprivation of property and civil rights by the city. The filing alleges that city leaders have violated Kaleta’s right to free speech and equal protection under the law, both protected by the First and Fourteenth Amendments to the U.S. Constitution.

The lawsuit argues that city leaders have passed regulations specifically targeting Kaleta and his businesses, particularly concerning the development and regulation of short-term rentals, and that he is held to a different standard by the city for the operation of his businesses than other business owners. It also argues that Kaleta, along with his development and rental properties, are singled out by the city for code enforcement and other potential violations and that city leaders publicly subject Kaleta to slander and blackballing.

Included in the lawsuit is the ongoing struggle between the city and Kaleta over the operation of a bar/lounge at the Bali Hai Beach Resort. Kaleta and Louis Najmy, serving as the attorney for the resort’s owners, have argued before the Holmes Beach code compliance special magistrate and city commissioners that there was a bar/lounge previously existing on the property, granting Kaleta the right to have one serving alcohol to patrons now. Due to the remodel of the space used as a bar/lounge at the Bali Hai, along with the introduction of a spa service area and construction work done at the site without prior building permits, the property ended up before city commissioners in 2021 for a site plan approval. After being discussed by commissioners at several meetings, commissioners eventually voted to not allow the operation of the bar/lounge on the resort property, one of the stipulations of the site plan approval. This action is listed in the current lawsuit as one example of how city leaders are allegedly discriminating against Kaleta and his businesses.

The lawsuit also alleges that the city and its special magistrate, attorney Michael Connolly, who is not mentioned by name in the paperwork, have arbitrarily regulated and fined Kaleta’s businesses.

The relief sought through the court by Grantham on Kaleta’s behalf includes having a trial by jury, a declaratory judgment on the city’s policies, interpretations, practices and actions as they related to the protection of Kaleta’s rights to free speech and equal protection clauses under the Constitution, an order by the court granting Kaleta injunctive relief ordering the city “to cease the unconstitutional and unlawful practices directed at plaintiff’s (Kaleta’s) ability to be properly notified and represented at code enforcement hearings, be treated fairly at code enforcement hearings, conduct his business, including hotel/motel and short-term vacation rentals, in compliance with city code and without arbitrary interruption by the city, and order the city, their officers, agents, employees and attorneys to cease from making false and slanderous public statements regarding plaintiff and his businesses and to record all future code enforcement hearings.” Other relief sought would require the city to issue a public apology to Kaleta through local newspapers and award Kaleta damages, pre-judgment interest, reasonable attorney’s fees and costs.

At press time for The Sun, the case had not been assigned to a judge and no hearings have been scheduled.

In the Manatee County Circuit Court, Kaleta had a win against the city as Judge Charles Sniffen denied the city of Holmes Beach’s motion to dismiss the second amended counterclaim submitted on behalf of the Bali Hai during a Jan. 5 hearing held by teleconference. The case before Sniffen concerns the operation of the bar/lounge and right of the bar/lounge to serve alcohol at the Bali Hai resort property.

Attorneys for the city argued that the second amended counterclaim failed to state a cause of action upon which relief could be granted and that the promissory estoppel claim listed in the second amended counterclaim should be dismissed with prejudice, arguing that city leaders never gave the Bali Hai’s representatives a promise that alcohol could be served indefinitely at the property.

With Sniffen’s denial of the city’s motion, the case will move forward in Manatee County Circuit Court.

Related coverage

 

Special magistrate reconsiders fines

 

Coconuts owner faces off with city code officers

 

Legal issues put a damper on wedding plans

Holmes Beach: The Year in Review

HOLMES BEACH – Anna Maria Island’s biggest city was home to some of the Island’s biggest issues in 2021.

The year began in the same manner as some previous years, with city leaders facing off in legal battles with the owners of the two-story beachfront treehouse at Angelino’s Sea Lodge. With legal issues still pending in Manatee County Circuit Court, tree house owners Lynn Tran-Hazen and Richard Hazen getting no relief on fines from the Holmes Beach special magistrate during hearings, the fate of the treehouse is still up in the air after almost a decade of legal battles. At the beginning of 2022, the treehouse is still right where it was a year ago – aloft in its beachfront perch with its future undecided, though Tran-Hazen did state in mid-2021 that if once all legal options are exhausted, the court decides in the city’s favor, the couple will have the treehouse removed.

The fate of the beachfront tree house at Angelino’s Sea Lodge still hasn’t been decided so the two-story structure remains aloft in its Australian pine perch. – Cindy Lane | Sun

The relationship between Holmes Beach city leaders and Manatee County commissioners also took a hit in 2021 over public beach parking. To resolve issues from the overcrowding of vehicles in residential areas, city leaders enacted a permit parking program, allowing public parking on some city streets near beach accesses only after 5 p.m. daily. Starting with the Memorial Day holiday weekend in 2021, Manatee County commissioners pushed back, demanding that Holmes Beach leaders reopen all residential streets to public parking to allow for more beachgoers to park in those areas. City leaders held firm to their stance and the argument is continuing in 2022, with a meeting planned to be held between the two parties to discuss issues in the coming months.

Golf cart/low-speed vehicle safety and the future of businesses renting the vehicles was a hot topic in Holmes Beach. – Kristin Swain | Sun

In good news, the city’s multiple Bert Harris lawsuits were concluded in the fall of 2021 with a global settlement option. In exchange for the owners to be able to develop three properties in the city to sizes beyond what is allowed by Holmes Beach building codes, all of the outstanding Bert Harris Jr. Act lawsuits against the city were dismissed. This brought more than three years of litigation to a close, though the residential neighbors of one of the properties weren’t too happy about a large vacation rental being allowed to be constructed in their neighborhood.

Golf cart and low-speed vehicle safety and regulations were a topic among commissioners and business owners all year. With a six-month moratorium stopping the establishment of golf cart and LSV brick-and-mortar rental companies in Holmes Beach set to expire in February, commissioners ended 2021 still discussing how to best regulate businesses and the booming use of the vehicles by visitors and residents in the city. While the discussion moving into 2022 is still on safety, commissioners have largely decided that preventing a business from opening up shop in Holmes Beach won’t stop the influx of the vehicles in the Island city as they can simply be trucked in from another location. To address safety issues, commissioners are considering lowering the speed limit city-wide to 25 miles per hour, requiring every seat on the vehicles to have a seat belt and looking at insurance concerns.

Commissioners Pat Morton, Carol Soustek and Terry Schaefer won another two years on the city commission in the Nov. 2 election. – Kristin Swain | Sun

The Nov. 2, 2021 election brought a familiar face back to the city commission dais as Commissioner Pat Morton was re-elected after losing his seat in 2020 to newcomer Commissioner Jayne Christenson. Also re-elected for additional two-year terms were Commissioners Terry Schaefer and Carol Soustek. This year’s election brought out more than one challenger for the incumbents as residents Renee Ferguson and John Monetti also tossed their hats in the ring for one of the three seats up for grabs on the city commission. Incumbent Commissioner Jim Kihm opted to not run for an additional term.

LSV, golf cart talks take a turn

HOLMES BEACH – A new idea is before Holmes Beach city commissioners to help make streets safer for golf carts, low-speed vehicles, motor vehicles, bicyclists and everyone else – lowering the speed limit citywide to 25 mph.

In previous years, lowering the speed limit anywhere in the city has been met with concern from commissioners and residents because of a potential increase in time that it would take to travel along Holmes Beach’s main thoroughfares. Now, with a moratorium in place to give commissioners time to work on regulations for LSV rental companies and a boom in the use of the vehicles by residents and visitors, setting a citywide speed limit is being strongly considered with the support of Chief Bill Tokajer and City Engineer Sage Kamiya.

For the safety of golf cart and LSV users, commissioners have been considering lowering the speed limit along one stretch of Gulf Drive in the A-1 district from 35 mph to 25 mph and pushing the limited speed vehicles into more residential neighborhoods and off Palm/Marina Drive. During a Dec. 14 work session, Kamiya proposed a different solution – lowering the speed limit citywide to 25 mph or less.

In a Dec. 20 talk with The Sun, Tokajer said that he supports lowering the speed limit citywide for several reasons. The first is that it would eliminate the need to have a golf cart/LSV trail through Holmes Beach that would push more of the vehicles into residential neighborhoods where the speed limit is already 25 mph.

He said that by setting a 25 mph citywide speed limit, the need to educate visitors on the city’s LSV speed regulations and what streets they can drive the vehicles on would be eliminated because they could be driven on any city street other than Manatee Avenue and East Bay Drive, where the speed limit will remain 35 mph for the foreseeable future. Those two streets are state roads and regulated by the Florida Department of Transportation, which has stated in memos to the city that golf carts and LSVs are not permitted to be operated on the two state roads.

In Holmes Beach there are only a few city-controlled areas where the speed limit is 35 mph – about three blocks in front of Anna Maria Elementary School on Gulf Drive, 10 blocks along Palm Drive and about eight blocks on Gulf Drive.

During his presentation to commissioners, Kamiya said that he drove three times through the city’s various 35 mph corridors to determine what the average time savings would be at 35 mph versus 25 mph. From White Avenue to 27th Street along Gulf/Marina Drive, he determined that the difference in travel time averaged 58 seconds. From White Avenue to Gulf Drive along Marina Drive, he determined that the average difference in travel time was only 28 seconds.

Tokajer said that the proposed citywide speed limit would be less confusing for motorists and golf cart/LSV users. He added that it would also reduce sign pollution in the city, eliminating the need for signs pointing to golf cart/LSV-friendly streets and allowing for many of the speed limit signs already in the city to be removed.

For Holmes Beach police officers, the change to a citywide speed limit would allow them to worry more about enforcing safety regulations such as the occupancy of LSVs and golf carts and the city’s seat belt regulations rather than being concerned about which speed zone the vehicles are being operated in.

The discussion will continue in January at an upcoming commission work session.

Related coverage

 

LSV talks proceed slowly

 

Commissioners talk golf cart/LSV regulations

 

Holmes Beach candidates sound off on golf cart/LSV use

Public gives input on comprehensive plan changes

Public gives input on comprehensive plan changes

HOLMES BEACH – Work on the proposed revisions to the city’s comprehensive plan are almost complete and planning commissioners are seeking input from the public on the changes they’ve come up with.

About 30 members of the public along with city staff, Mayor Judy Titsworth and Commissioner Terry Schaefer gathered on Dec. 8 at City Hall for a town hall meeting on the comprehensive plan held by the city’s planning commissioners. The purpose of the meeting was to discuss the proposed changes to the comprehensive plan and get feedback from members of the community. From residents to business owners and visitors, everyone was invited to come and have their opinions heard.

Planning commissioners will discuss the feedback they received at an upcoming public meeting. However, those who were unable to attend may submit public comment by email through the middle of January at cityclerk@holmesbeachfl.org.

The comprehensive plan is a document that is adopted by city commissioners to provide a guide for the future of Holmes Beach and what types of policies they should implement in the city. There are 10 elements to the comprehensive plan: Future Land Use; Property Rights; Infrastructure; Capital Improvements; Coastal Management and Conservation; Recreation, Open Space, Arts and Culture; Transportation; Housing; Intergovernmental Coordination; and Public School Facilities. Here are the primary proposed changes to each element:

Future Land Use

– Added objective relating to the city’s desire to promote arts, culture and creative design

– Added language which reinforces the city’s stated vision and values

Property Rights

– New element being added to comply with recent legislation enacted by the Florida Legislature

  • Four statements of rights that require the city to consider private property rights in all local decision-making

Infrastructure

– Continue to urge Manatee County to eliminate all septic tanks and to hook up to the central sewer system when available

– Incorporate drainage projects within the five-year schedule of capital projects

  • Pursue mitigation efforts associated with stormwater, drainage and floodplain management

Capital Improvements

– Language added to reinforce the city’s stated vision and values to fund strong safety programs, such as police, fire and emergency personnel

– Emphasis on sharing of school recreation facilities, including funding if appropriate

– The five-year schedule of capital improvement projects has been updated

– Removal of:

  • Rigid and poorly-worded guidelines for prioritization of capital improvement projects
  • Rigid levels of service for recreational facilities
  • Outdated lists of capital improvement projects
  • Outdated concurrency management section so that provisions in the Land Development Code can be updated as needed

Coastal Management and Conservation

– Reorganization of elements

– Objective added to address energy efficiency, waste reduction and other sustainability measures

– Objective added regarding the protection of habitat and endangered/threatened species

– Objective added to address the city’s desire to promote ecotourism

– Objective added to reduce impervious surfaces

Recreation, Open Space, Arts and Culture

– Incorporation of arts and culture as a part of recreation activities

– Maximize and continue improvement of municipal recreation facilities

– Protection of Grassy Point Preserve as a conservation asset while providing passive access

– Emphasis on linking transportation generators and attractors with bicycle and pedestrian paths

Transportation

– Added policies to improve transit routes, options and facilities

– Added objective related to the city’s mission to improve the resiliency of transportation facilities

Housing

– Policies added to maintain and encourage affordable and workforce housing

– Objective added to address the city’s desire to encourage energy efficiency and sustainability

– Objective added to encourage resilient building practices

– Objective added to address the city’s desire to encourage development within the mixed-use overlay district to promote the live, work, play lifestyle within the city

Intergovernmental Coordination

– Objective added to emphasize the city’s position that home rule and local authority be preserved

Public School Facilities

– Language added to reinforce the city’s position that Anna Maria Elementary should be retained as a community school

– Re-establishment of the Manatee County School District’s responsibility to adequately fund capital improvements for public schools

– Removal of redundant policies

To learn more about the proposed changes to the comprehensive plan and how they can affect the future of Holmes Beach, visit the LaRue Planning website.

City recognizes outstanding community service

City recognizes outstanding community service

HOLMES BEACH – City commissioners gave community members and staff cause to celebrate with the presentation of their annual awards and community service recognitions.

During their final meeting of the calendar year, commissioners recognized community members who served on Holmes Beach committees and outstanding staff members. They also presented the third annual Louis Strickland Citizen of the Year Award.

Mayor Judy Titsworth was joined by City Clerk Stacey Johnston in recognizing former members of the city’s Parks and Beautification Committee for their years of service to the community. The recognitions included former members Susan Anderson, Carol Hatz, Allyson Gilles and Donna Ryan. None of the parks members were present for the presentation.

Titsworth also recognized former Planning Commissioner Barbara Hines for her years of service on that committee. Hines joined the planning commission as an alternate in 2012 before becoming a full member just a few weeks later in December 2012. She stepped down from the planning commission in August 2021, choosing to ask to not be reappointed to allow for someone else to have the opportunity to serve the city in that position.

“I cannot thank you enough,” Titsworth said to Hines, presenting her with a plaque commemorating her years of service.

City recognizes outstanding community service
Former Planning Commissioner Barbara Hines, right, is honored for her years of service to the city of Holmes Beach by Mayor Judy Titsworth, left, and city Clerk Stacey Johnston. – Kristin Swain | Sun

Hines thanked city leaders for the acknowledgment of her service on the planning commission.

Titsworth presented Code Compliance Administrative Assistant Kim Charron with the 2021 Employee of the Year Award. In thanking Charron, Titsworth said that she’s the first person to step up and help out wherever needed with any task, no matter what department. Charron came to the city of Holmes Beach in December 2020. The mayor was joined in recognizing Charron by Code Compliance Supervisor James Thomas, who thanked commissioners for allowing him to hire Charron.

“She’s a great employee,” he said of Charron. “She’s the best that we have.”

In other recognitions, Titsworth awarded the city’s Community Partnership Award to the Hagen Family Foundation for their ongoing support of the city, particularly in providing funding for city parks and other public spaces. In 2021, the foundation provided $56,000 to build dugouts at the city field ball field – they are currently under construction by public works staff – and to purchase exercise equipment for a walking trail. The trail, planned for installation at the city field complex located adjacent to Holmes Beach City Hall, is currently in the design phase.

The final award of the evening was the third annual Louis Strickland Citizen of the Year Award, which is given to an individual for outstanding community service. This year’s award was given to Deb Sneddon, who was surprised by the honor.

City recognizes outstanding community service
Holmes Beach resident Deb Sneddon, left, is surprised as she is given the Louis Strickland Citizen of the Year award by Mayor Judy Titsworth, center, and city Clerk Stacey Johnston during a Dec. 14 commission meeting. – Kristin Swain | Sun

Sneddon is a six-year resident of Holmes Beach who coordinates community volunteer opportunities and events with her neighbors, ranging from providing Valentine’s Day cards for area first responders and gift baskets to thanking veterans with a celebratory dance party and gathering $2,500 at a Halloween fundraiser for Hope Family Services and other efforts to better the community.

“I cannot thank you enough. You are so deserving of this award,” Titsworth said to Sneddon, presenting her with the award.

“It’s a pleasure to live here and it’s a pleasure to be around people who are ready to step up and support this community and their neighbors in a way that is really unlike any other place that I’ve been. This really goes out to everybody because everybody is ready to do that,” Sneddon said, thanking city leaders for the award.

Commission splits on dress code decision

Commission splits on dress code decision

HOLMES BEACH – In trying to ease rifts among Holmes Beach commissioners, new commission Chair Carol Soustek inadvertently gave them something to argue about.

Soustek presented her fellow commissioners with a proposed Code of Core Values for Civility and Ethics created by altering a document adopted by the city of Dunedin.

The code sets out expectations and rules of conduct for commissioners, noting that other cities have similar guidelines for commissioners.

Commissioner Kim Rash shows off one of his custom-made T-shirts with the statement, “I represent the residents” printed on the front. – Kim Rash | Submitted

“You’re held to a very high standard when you’re elected and everything you do is a reflection upon your city. It’s not like when you leave this dais you can go rob a bank. It wouldn’t be very good for the city,” she said, adding that she feels the proposed guidelines eliminate any gray areas in how commissioners conduct themselves.

The values outlined in the document include integrity, ethics, communication, teamwork, leadership, quality of work and recognition of each other’s individual contributions to the Holmes Beach community. Commissioners didn’t express any issues with those items.

The one that caused a disagreement was the stewardship addition made by Soustek, which stated: “I shall strive to make a positive role model as a city commissioner. Proper attire should always be appropriate to the situation. While in the commission chambers, clothing with slogans or words, political or otherwise, shall not be worn. No food is allowed in the chambers. The smell, noise or transfer to documents when eating food can be disruptive. Drinks will be allowed by the city commission and staff but when not in use, the container needs to be capped securely and not placed on the dais.”

While Commissioners Pat Morton and Terry Schaefer agreed with the stewardship provision, Commissioners Jayne Christenson and Kim Rash did not.

Rash said that he felt the dress code section of the stewardship provision was targeted at him for the custom-made T-shirts he has worn in recent months when attending city meetings. The shirts previously were brought under fire by Mayor Judy Titsworth, who said that she felt that statements like “I represent the residents” were misleading because she said all elected officials represent the residents, not just Rash. Rash, who has a T-shirt with that statement, ran both his election and re-election campaigns with a similar slogan.

During the Dec. 14 meeting, he argued that forbidding him to wear the shirts to a commission meeting was a violation of his constitutional First Amendment right to free speech. Rash pressed for city leaders to obtain a ruling from Florida Attorney General Ashley Moody on whether or not instituting the dress code would be a violation of his or any other commissioner’s civil rights.

“In my research, dress codes cannot discriminate on the basis of controversial messages on clothing. I do not feel that my T-shirts have been controversial in nature, but the chair and the mayor obviously believe otherwise,” Rash stated. “There is nothing destructive or vulgar about statements about the city officials supporting residents who elect them to serve in office, in my opinion.”

City Attorney Patricia Petruff said that she was unprepared to have a discussion about the legality of a dress code, however, she said that dress codes were consistently implemented in the school system for both students and staff without, to her knowledge, infringing on civil liberties. She encouraged commissioners to table the discussion until more information could be gathered and presented by either herself or incoming city attorney Erica Augello.

Christenson said that while she’d be willing to discuss a dress code for commissioners, she didn’t feel that its placement in a code of ethics was warranted, stating that she doesn’t believe it’s an ethics issue. She urged her fellow commissioners to consider removing the provision and discussing it as a separate item.

“I felt that this was a nice document,” she said, adding that she would like to see provisions for civility, respect for the individual, creativity and innovation, efficiency, adaptability and organizational sensitivity added.

“When we get into attire and what we can eat and drink in the room, I think it’s a little overreaching,” Christenson said. While she said she’s open to the discussion, she felt it’s more of a policy decision versus an ethics issue. She suggested discussing the two items as a separate building policy.

While commissioners did not vote to remove the stewardship provision, a majority did seem agreeable to adopting the Code of Core Values for Civility and Ethics with the inclusion of the provisions suggested by Christenson. They agreed with Petruff’s suggestion and voted unanimously to table the discussion to be brought up at a future meeting.

“I think it’s a very good step forward,” Schaefer said of the proposed code of core values, noting that he felt Soustek hit on some very good points in the proposed document that he would like to see instituted.

Morton said that he feels the adoption of the document was long overdue and that he would like it extended beyond elected officials to include city staff as well. Mayor Judy Titsworth noted that a similar code is included in the Holmes Beach employee handbook.

Soustek said that the matter was brought directly to a regular meeting instead of first being debated at a work session because she’d like to start the new year with an understanding of what is expected of city commissioners going forward.

“We’re five individuals as a group. Decisions are a group decision and I have seen some of this being splintered and I’m tired of it,” Soustek said, adding that for the commission to make great progress in the future to move forward she feels that the group needs to work more toward unification.

“We are responsible for being very good at what we do. I don’t want people to start laughing at my commission. I want them to start respecting this commission and thinking they do an excellent job,” she said.

Soustek said that the purpose of the code was to address issues that she’s noticed and have been brought to her attention by the public.

“I want us to move into a new year with clear understanding and no question of what this commission is responsible for,” Soustek finished.

Titsworth added that she hopes adopting the proposed code or one similar will help city commissioners to be more like “statesmen” when representing the city of Holmes Beach.

Events calendar

Tuesday, Dec. 14

Farmer’s market, City Pier Park, 103 N. Bay Blvd., Anna Maria, 8:30 a.m. to 2 p.m.

RoserRobics, Roser Church, 512 Pine Ave., Anna Maria, 9:30 a.m., no cost but donations welcome.

Family story time, Island Branch Library, 5701 Marina Drive, Holmes Beach, 10 a.m. Reserve online

Mahjong, Island Branch Library, 5701 Marina Drive, Holmes Beach, 11:30 a.m. to 1:30 p.m. Register online

One-on-one tech help, Island Branch Library, 5701 Marina Drive, Holmes Beach, 2 p.m. to 3:30 p.m. Reserve online 

Christmas in the Garden, Longboat Island Chapel, 6200 Gulf of Mexico Drive, Longboat Key, 5-9 p.m.

Wednesday, Dec. 15

Beach market, Coquina Beach, 2650 Gulf Drive S., Bradenton Beach, 10 a.m. to 4 p.m.

Lawton Chiles Christmas for Kids Party, Sandbar Restaurant, 100 Spring St., Anna Maria, 11 a.m. to 2 p.m.

Ukulele Instruction for Beginners, Island Branch Library, 5701 Marina Drive, Holmes Beach, 1 p.m. Register online at manateelibrary.libcal.com/event/8315413

AMI Chamber Business Card Exchange, Mainsail Beach Inn, 101 66th St., Bradenton Beach, 5-7 p.m., $5 for members or $10 for non-members. Reserve online 

Christmas in the Garden, Longboat Island Chapel, 6200 Gulf of Mexico Drive, Longboat Key, 5-9 p.m.

CrossPointe Fellowship Christmas Concert, 8605 Gulf Drive, Holmes Beach, 7 p.m.

Thursday, Dec. 16

RoserRobics, Roser Church, 512 Pine Ave., Anna Maria, 9:30 a.m., no cost but donations welcome.

Island Library Book Club, “The Midnight Library,” Island Branch Library, 5701 Marina Drive, Holmes Beach, 10:15 a.m. Reserve online 

Sunshine Stitchers knit and crochet, Island Branch Library, 5701 Marina Drive, Holmes Beach, 2-4 p.m. Register online

Thursdays in Paradise Stroll featuring local art, music and food, Bridge Street, Bradenton Beach, 5-8 p.m.

AMI Chamber business card exchange, Mainsail Beach Inn, 101 66th St., Holmes Beach, 5 p.m., $5 for members or $10 for prospective members. Reserve online

Shutter Stroll, Robinson Preserve, 840 Ninth Ave. N.W., Bradenton, 5:15 p.m. Register online

Christmas in the Garden, Longboat Island Chapel, 6200 Gulf of Mexico Drive, Longboat Key, 5-9 p.m.

Friday, Dec. 17

Forty Carrots, Island Branch Library, 5701 Marina Drive, Holmes Beach, 10-11 a.m. Register online

Mahjong Club, Island Branch Library, 5701 Marina Drive, Holmes Beach, 11:30 a.m. to 1:30 p.m. Register online 

Christmas in the Garden, Longboat Island Chapel, 6200 Gulf of Mexico Drive, Longboat Key, 5-9 p.m.

Saturday, Dec. 18

Robinson Runners, Robinson Preserve, 1704 99th St. N.W., Bradenton, 8 a.m.

Saturday mornings at the NEST, Robinson Preserve Mosaic Nest, 840 Ninth Ave. N.W., Bradenton, 9 a.m. to noon. Face masks required.

Master Gardener Tour, Perico Preserve, 11700 Manatee Ave. W., Bradenton, 9 a.m. Reserve online 

Families Flock Together: Ornament Making, Robinson Preserve, screened pavilion, 840 Ninth Ave. N.W., Bradenton, 10 a.m., $5. Reserve online 

Meditation, Island Branch Library, 5701 Marina Drive, Holmes Beach, 11 a.m. Reserve online 

Christmas in the Garden, Longboat Island Chapel, 6200 Gulf of Mexico Drive, Longboat Key, 5-9 p.m.

Seeing Stars, Robinson Preserve, 840 Ninth Ave. N.W., Bradenton, 6:30 p.m. Reserve online 

Sunday, Dec. 19

Farm stand, Holmes Beach City Hall, 5801 Marina Drive, Holmes Beach, 8-10 a.m.

Roser Memorial Community Church Christmas Cantata, 512 Pine Ave., Anna Maria, 8:30 a.m. and 10 a.m.

Beach market, Coquina Beach, 2650 Gulf Drive S., Bradenton Beach, 10 a.m. to 4 p.m.

Rise and Shine Power Flow Yoga, Robinson Preserve Mosaic Nest, 840 Ninth Ave. N.W., Bradenton 10:30-11:45 a.m., $10 fee payable online. Bring your own yoga mat. Register online or call 941-742-5923 ext. 6042 for more information.

Christmas in the Garden, Longboat Island Chapel, 6200 Gulf of Mexico Drive, Longboat Key, 5-9 p.m.

Monday, Dec. 20

Episcopal Church of the Annunciation Hanging of the Greens, 4408 Gulf Drive, Holmes Beach, 9 a.m.

Christmas in the Garden, Longboat Island Chapel, 6200 Gulf of Mexico Drive, Longboat Key, 5-9 p.m. Music begins at 6 p.m.

Tuesday, Dec. 21

Winter Solstice Sunrise Paddle, Robinson Preserve, north entrance, 1704 99th St. N.W., Bradenton, 6 a.m. Reserve online 

Farmer’s market, City Pier Park, 103 N. Bay Blvd., Anna Maria, 8:30 a.m. to 2 p.m.

RoserRobics, Roser Church, 512 Pine Ave., Anna Maria, 9:30 a.m., no cost but donations are welcome.

Santa visits story time, Island Branch Library, 5701 Marina Drive, Holmes Beach, 9 a.m.

Family story time, Island Branch Library, 5701 Marina Drive, Holmes Beach, 10 a.m. Register online 

Mahjong Club, Island Branch Library, 5701 Marina Drive, Holmes Beach, 11:30 a.m. Register online 

Tech Help, Island Branch Library, 5701 Marina Drive, Holmes Beach, 2-2:30 p.m. Register online 

Christmas in the Garden, Longboat Island Chapel, 6200 Gulf of Mexico Drive, Longboat Key, 5-9 p.m.

Wednesday, Dec. 22

Beach market, Coquina Beach, 2650 Gulf Drive S., Bradenton Beach, 10 a.m. to 4 p.m.

Ukulele Instruction for Beginners, Island Branch Library, 5701 Marina Drive, Holmes Beach, 1 p.m. Register online 

Christmas in the Garden, Longboat Island Chapel, 6200 Gulf of Mexico Drive, Longboat Key, 5-9 p.m.

Thursday, Dec. 23

RoserRobics, Roser Church, 512 Pine Ave., Anna Maria, 9:30 a.m., no cost but donations welcome.

Thursdays in Paradise Stroll featuring local art, music and food, Bridge Street, Bradenton Beach, 5-8 p.m.

Christmas in the Garden, Longboat Island Chapel, 6200 Gulf of Mexico Drive, Longboat Key, 5-9 p.m.

Friday, Dec. 24

Christmas Eve

Saturday, Dec. 25

Merry Christmas!

Sunday, Dec. 26

Farm stand, Holmes Beach City Hall, 5801 Marina Drive, Holmes Beach, 8-10 a.m.

Beach market, Coquina Beach, 2650 Gulf Drive S., Bradenton Beach, 10 a.m. to 4 p.m.

Rise and Shine Power Flow Yoga, Robinson Preserve Mosaic Nest, 840 Ninth Ave. N.W., Bradenton 10:30-11:45 a.m., $10 fee payable online. Bring your own yoga mat. Register online or call 941-742-5923 ext. 6042 for more information.

Christmas in the Garden, Longboat Island Chapel, 6200 Gulf of Mexico Drive, Longboat Key, 5-9 p.m.

Monday, Dec. 27

Christmas in the Garden, Longboat Island Chapel, 6200 Gulf of Mexico Drive, Longboat Key, 5-9 p.m. Music begins at 6 p.m.

Tuesday, Dec. 28

Farmer’s market, City Pier Park, 103 N. Bay Blvd., Anna Maria, 8:30 a.m. to 2:30 p.m.

RoserRobics, Roser Church, 512 Pine Ave., Anna Maria, 9:30 a.m., no cost but donations are welcome.

Wonder Walk, Robinson Preserve, 840 Ninth Ave. N.W., Bradenton, 10 a.m. Reserve to coral.bass@mymanatee.org.

Family story time, Island Branch Library, 5701 Marina Drive, Holmes Beach, 10 a.m. Register online

Tech Help, Island Branch Library, 5701 Marina Drive, Holmes Beach, 2-2:30 p.m. Register online 

Christmas in the Garden, Longboat Island Chapel, 6200 Gulf of Mexico Drive, Longboat Key, 5-9 p.m.

Wednesday, Dec. 29

Beach market, Coquina Beach, 2650 Gulf Drive S., Bradenton Beach, 10 a.m. to 4 p.m.

Tortoise Talk, Robinson Preserve Valentine House, 1704 99th St. N.W., Bradenton, 10 a.m.

Ukulele Instruction for Beginners, Island Branch Library, 5701 Marina Drive, Holmes Beach, 1 p.m. Register online

Christmas in the Garden, Longboat Island Chapel, 6200 Gulf of Mexico Drive, Longboat Key, 5-9 p.m.

Thursday, Dec. 30

Seashell Shore Walk, Coquina Beach, 2650 Gulf Drive S., Bradenton Beach, 9 a.m.

RoserRobics, Roser Church, 512 Pine Ave., Anna Maria, 9:30 a.m., no cost but donations welcome.

Seaside Quilters, Island Branch Library, 5701 Marina Drive, Holmes Beach, 10 a.m. Register online

Sunshine Stitchers knit and crochet, Island Branch Library, 5701 Marina Drive, Holmes Beach, 2 p.m. Register online

Thursdays in Paradise Stroll featuring local art, music and food, Bridge Street, Bradenton Beach, 5-8 p.m.

Christmas in the Garden, Longboat Island Chapel, 6200 Gulf of Mexico Drive, Longboat Key, 5-9 p.m.

Friday, Dec. 31

New Year’s Eve

Christmas in the Garden, Longboat Island Chapel, 6200 Gulf of Mexico Drive, Longboat Key, 5-9 p.m.

Saturday, Jan. 1

Happy New Year!

Robinson Runners, Robinson Preserve, 1704 99th St. N.W., Bradenton, 8 a.m.

Manatee Audubon Society Birding Tour, Perico Preserve, 11700 Manatee Ave. W., Bradenton, 8:30 a.m.

Saturday mornings at the NEST, Robinson Preserve Mosaic Nest, 840 Ninth Ave. N.W., Bradenton, 9 a.m. to noon. Face masks required.

Shamrock Shiver sponsored by Clancy’s Irish Pub, Cortez Beach between Fourth St. South and 12th St. South, Bradenton Beach, noon. All proceeds benefit The Blessing Bags Project, Feeding Empty Little Tummies, Healthy Teens Coalition of Manatee County and Parenting Matters Charities.

Sunshine Stitchers knit and crochet, Island Branch Library, 5701 Marina Drive, Holmes Beach, 2 p.m. Reserve online 

Christmas in the Garden, Longboat Island Chapel, 6200 Gulf of Mexico Drive, Longboat Key, 5-9 p.m.

Sunday, Jan. 2

Farm stand, Holmes Beach City Hall, 5801 Marina Drive, Holmes Beach, 8-10 a.m.

Beach market, Coquina Beach, 2650 Gulf Drive S., Bradenton Beach, 10 a.m. to 4 p.m.

Rise and Shine Power Flow Yoga, Robinson Preserve Mosaic Nest, 840 Ninth Ave. N.W., Bradenton 10:30-11:45 a.m., $10 fee payable online. Bring your own yoga mat. Register online or call 941-742-5923 ext. 6042 for more information.

Tuesday, Jan. 4

Farmer’s market, City Pier Park, 103 N. Bay Blvd., Anna Maria, 8:30 a.m. to 2 p.m.

RoserRobics, Roser Church, 512 Pine Ave., Anna Maria, 9:30 a.m., no cost but donations welcome.

Family story time, Island Branch Library, 5701 Marina Drive, Holmes Beach, 10 a.m. Reserve online

Mahjong, Island Branch Library, 5701 Marina Drive, Holmes Beach, 11:30 a.m. to 1:30 p.m. Register online

One-on-one tech help, Island Branch Library, 5701 Marina Drive, Holmes Beach, 2-2:30 p.m. Reserve online 

Special magistrate reconsiders fines

Special magistrate reconsiders fines

HOLMES BEACH – This month’s code compliance special magistrate hearing was all about fines – reducing and eliminating them.

First up was a case involving 305 73rd St. and owners 305 73rd LLC. Though Special Magistrate Michael Connolly had already issued a final order imposing fines, attorney Louis Najmy asked for a reduction in fines on the owners’ behalf.

The violations found against the property in previous code compliance hearings included a dilapidated structure that the city had to secure against intrusion and engage a contractor to remove potentially dangerous building materials from the yard. The city also did not receive a timely response from the property owner, who did work outside the scope of permits.

Speaking on behalf of the city, attorney Erica Augello argued that the property has had two stop-work orders issued on it since code violations were first identified in September 2019. She said the property finally came into compliance with city codes and Connolly’s previous rulings on Aug. 31, 2021.

The total outstanding fines on the property were $51,900 plus $127.24 in administrative costs.

Najmy argued that his clients tried to work with the city but proceedings were delayed due to COVID-19 and other issues.

Connolly agreed to lessen the fines from $150 per day to $100 per day, bringing the total down to $34,500 plus the $127.24 administrative costs. Najmy said the reduction in fines should prevent the matter from being heard in Manatee County district court.

Another of Najmy’s clients, Bali Hai JV LLC, owners of the Bali Hai Beach Resort, had two matters involving fines heard by Connolly. In both cases, the city petitioned Connolly to rescind the fines against the property due to a due process issue where the hearing in which fines were levied against the resort’s ownership was not recorded. Since there is ongoing litigation in Manatee County circuit court between the resort owners and city leaders and the recording is a matter of due process, Augello asked Connolly to vacate the prior final orders and orders imposing fines in two of the nine code compliance cases against the resort. Augello stipulated that she would like the orders vacated without prejudice to allow the city to have the cases reheard and fines imposed for the alleged violations.

While Najmy said his clients do not object to the vacation of the fines, he does object to the reason for the city asking the fines to be vacated. He said he doesn’t believe that the city’s representatives were being totally honest about why they were asking for the reconsideration of the fines and final orders by the special magistrate.

Connolly ruled in favor of vacating the final orders and fines without prejudice.

The next code compliance special magistrate hearing is scheduled for Jan. 19 at Holmes Beach City Hall.

Related coverage

 

Holmes Beach leaders and Bali Hai owners face off

 

Legal issues put a damper on wedding plans

 

Bali Hai legal dispute continues

 

Castles in the Sand

Global property boom

The old adage that all real estate is local for the most part still holds. For instance, properties on Anna Maria Island have significantly different price points than properties in other areas of Manatee County. However, there is a global reset in one area since the entire real estate market around the world after COVID-19 has experienced a property boom.

Europe, Australia, New Zealand and the Asian markets are all struggling with the affordability of home prices. In most of these areas, as well as in the United States, the home price to income ratio is at a very high level; in some regions, the highest ever recorded. Governments are at a loss as to whether stepping in will help or hinder the marketplace. In China, efforts to slow down the market have been a failure and the rest of the world has been watching.

Homeowners who purchased their properties prior to the pandemic are substantially richer than they were on closing day. And Anna Maria Island may be the perfect example of what has happened during the last two years.

For several years I did a quarterly review of properties listed and sold over $1 million in the three cities on Anna Maria and Cortez. I’ve decided to change that analysis to every six months to better give a more consistent overall picture of the market. The following statistics are covering sales from May through October of this year, closing at or above $1 million as recorded by the Manatee County Property Appraiser’s office.

The city of Anna Maria closed 56 properties at or over $1 million, averaging slightly over nine properties per month. The highest sales were $6,800,000 and $6,750,000; there were three sales over $4 million; seven sales over $3 million; 13 sales over $2 million and the balance were $1 million or over.

The combined cities of Bradenton Beach and Holmes Beach closed 97 properties at or over $1 million, averaging slightly over 16 properties per month. The highest sale was for $5,450,000; there were three sales over $4 million; five sales over $3 million; 29 sales over $2 million and the balance were $1 million or over.

Cortez closed two sales, both over $1 million.

On the market or pending as of this writing in the city of Anna Maria, there are 35 properties $1 million or over. The highest is $16,500,000; there are two over $9 million; one over $6 million; one over $5 million; one over $4 million; six over $3 million; 12 over $2 million and 11 over $1 million.

The combined cities of Bradenton Beach and Holmes Beach have 61 properties on the market or pending as of this writing. The highest are $7,995,000 and $7,957,000; one over $6 million; one over $5 million; seven over $3 million; 16 over $2 million and 34 over $1 million.

Cortez has three properties; the highest is $4,750,000, a parcel of land at $1,300,000 and new construction in the Hunters Point development for $1,000,000.

If these numbers don’t blow you away, I don’t know what will. Some economists think it’s best to leave the market alone and let it find its own way, which I agree with. Most economists think that we will not have a 2008-type housing crash that was mostly created from poor lending standards, all of which have been tightened up.

There has been some very minor slowdown in sales in the national market recently, nevertheless, prices aren’t expected to fall significantly. Have a Happy Thanksgiving; we homeowners have much to be thankful for.

Commissioners talk building recertification regulations

Commissioners talk building recertification regulations

HOLMES BEACH – Building Official Neal Schwartz is working with Holmes Beach commissioners to develop a recertification program for large buildings to identify structural issues before they become a serious safety hazard.

After the collapse of a condominium building in Surfside, Holmes Beach commissioners became concerned about the safety of older buildings in their city, which are subject to harsh conditions due to water, sea air and erosion. Schwartz began researching and gave a staff report on Nov. 9 on building recertification guidelines that need to be implemented in Holmes Beach.

Under such a program, applicable buildings would be inspected by a third-party engineering service to determine if they are structurally and electrically sound. These inspections would take place every few decades, with the results given to the city and all issues corrected within a specified time for the building to be recertified. If the inspection and/or repairs are not completed, the building’s owner would face potentially hefty fines from the city.

Schwartz suggested adopting the same guidelines for reinspection used by Miami/Dade counties and the city of Boca Raton, with a few adjustments.

A Florida Bar task force is recommending that the Legislature require structural inspections within the next three years for condominiums three stories or taller, with re-inspections every five years.

The Condominium Law and Policy on Life Safety Issues Advisory Task Force issued a report on Oct. 12 with recommendations on how to avoid another condo collapse like the Surfside disaster on June 24 that killed 98 residents.

State condo law contains “no express maintenance, repair, or replacement standards for boards to follow in the act, or in most governing documents,” according to the report, which recommends revisions to the law requiring inspection protocols for 13 items, including roof, structure, fireproofing, elevators, plumbing and electrical systems.

The report also recommends that by Dec. 31, 2026, associations be required to establish a fund that would be equal to or greater than 50% of the cost of replacing each component in the inspection report “based on the estimated remaining useful life.”

A provision of Florida condo law allows condominium associations, with a 50% vote, to waive a state requirement to maintain adequate reserves. The report recommends that the threshold for waiving the requirement be raised to 75%.

He also suggested that all single-family and duplex structures be exempt from the recertification requirements, regardless of size or age. The recertification requirements would apply to all buildings that are more than three stories tall, meaning three stories over parking if there is parking on the ground level, all mixed-use buildings over one story and all commercial buildings that measure more than 3,500 square feet. The commercial building requirement would apply to all shopping centers in Holmes Beach. Schwartz said he would look into whether or not churches would be required to participate in a recertification program.

Each building would need to be initially reinspected 30 years after a certificate of occupancy is issued for the structure, with additional recertifications taking place every 10 years afterward.

To pass the recertification, the engineer inspecting the property would ensure the structure and electrical systems meet the minimum guidelines for building safety as outlined in the Florida Building Codes and Holmes Beach building codes. Once any repairs were completed, a second inspection would be needed to verify all repairs were completed and up to code standards. Schwartz suggested a $300 fee for the reinspection, which would not include the reporting or inspection fees charged by a third-party engineer or any repair costs.

The city would notify the building owners when recertification was due for the property but would not be responsible for having the recertification completed or hiring an engineer to do the work. City building inspectors would not be on the property as a part of the recertification process.

Schwartz said he believes there would be about 30 buildings in Holmes Beach that would be affected by the program.

Once the program was adopted by commissioners, Schwartz estimated it would take a year to fully implement.

The matter will go for a vote before city commissioners at a future meeting.

Related coverage

 

Building evacuated due to structural issues

 

Former Island building official last to inspect Surfside condo

 

Island building owners warned to investigate structural issues

And the winners are…

And the winners are…

HOLMES BEACH – After months of campaigning, the 2021 election results are in and Anna Maria Island’s biggest city has three commissioners to swear in later this month.

The night’s big winners are former Commissioner Pat Morton and incumbent Commissioners Carol Soustek and Terry Schaefer.

Schaefer came in as the night’s big winner with the top number of votes at 655, while Soustek came in second with 637 votes and Morton came in third with 629 votes.

Though there were five candidates, only three seats were available on the city commission dais, leaving Renee Ferguson, who received 608 votes, and John Monetti, who received 473 votes, as the fourth and fifth place candidates with no seat on the dais for the coming year.

For Schaefer, this will be his second two-year term on the city commission dais. Morton will be returning to the dais for an additional term after losing his bid for re-election in the 2020 election. This will be Soustek’s fourth full term on the city commission after being first appointed in November 2014 to fill the unexpired term of David Zaccagnino.

A swearing-in ceremony and organizational meeting for Holmes Beach commissioners is tentatively scheduled for Nov. 15 at 9 a.m.

The other item on this year’s ballot for Holmes Beach residents was the consideration of a land swap with Jon Cooper and his family. The land swap received voter approval with 851 votes in favor or 69.64% of votes cast in the matter.

The swap means that, in exchange for a 50- by 100-foot section of right of way, the Coopers give the city of Holmes Beach a section of beachfront property along with $10,000 for dune restoration or another environmental project of city leaders’ choosing. The city right of way, part of an undeveloped street, bisects two sections of the Coopers’ beachfront property.

Now that the land swap is approved, it will go before commissioners to be ratified before becoming official.

Holmes Beach has 2,757 voters. Approximately 45% of Holmes Beach registered voters cast their ballots in this election.

Related coverage

 

Holmes Beach candidates sound off on golf cart/LSV use

 

Candidates give their opinions on a Holmes Beach city manager

 

Election candidates speak out on balance in Holmes Beach

LSV talks proceed slowly

HOLMES BEACH – Commissioners continue to discuss making the roads safer through Holmes Beach, particularly for drivers of cars, golf carts and low-speed vehicles (LSVs). Though commissioners made one decision, talks are planned to continue at a future work session.

When commissioners met on Oct. 26 for a work session, Mayor Judy Titsworth warned them that there is only so much they’re going to be able to do to regulate the use of LSVs in the city because they are considered vehicles by the state. She advised them instead to focus on the golf cart/LSV moratorium they enacted which involves new rental businesses coming to the city.

Police Chief Bill Tokajer said for safety purposes, the things he’d like to see reinforced through commission action is to have individual seatbelts on vehicles for each passenger, require the vehicles to be operated only by licensed drivers, remind drivers that they’re not allowed to operate golf carts and LSVs in bike lanes or on Manatee Avenue, East Bay Drive, or on the beach and require child restraints for small children. If approved by commissioners, those reminders to drivers will go on a sticker to be placed on rental vehicles as a visual reminder to those operating them in Holmes Beach.

Commissioners also are considering pushing the operation of golf carts and LSVs to roads in the city with a speed limit of 25 mph or less. To do that, commissioners also will need to agree to lower the speed limit in one section of Gulf Drive along the beach from 35 mph to 25 mph.

While commissioners agreed that each passenger needs to have an individual seatbelt, which also will limit the number of riders on the vehicles to the number of seats there are, all other considerations were continued to a future work session for further discussion.

Since commissioners began discussions on the regulation of golf carts, LSVs and rental businesses, some questions have been raised by the community about where the vehicles currently can be operated and whether trying to move the vehicles to more residential roads is a good idea.

Commissioner Carol Soustek said she is in favor of moving the operation of slower-moving vehicles to roads with a 25 mph speed limit to give motor vehicle drivers traveling along Marina and Palm drives some relief and hopefully lessen road rage in the city.

Addressing the issue of LSVs and golf carts not being allowed on state roads, Tokajer said he’s received memos from both the Florida Department of Transportation and the Florida Highway Patrol ruling that the vehicles are not allowed to be operated on state roads, though they can cross them. The state roads in Holmes Beach are Manatee Avenue and East Bay Drive. Because the vehicles are not allowed to be operated on Manatee Avenue, Tokajer added that they should not be driven across the Anna Maria Island Bridge.

Under state law, counties and local municipalities are allowed to prohibit the operation of LSVs within their jurisdiction on roads where the operation of those vehicles is determined to not be safe.

Related coverage

 

Commissioners talk golf cart/LSV regulations

 

Holmes Beach candidates sound off on golf cart/LSV use

 

Rules of the road decals to be placed in rented golf carts

Bert Harris cases come to a close in Holmes Beach

HOLMES BEACH – After more than five years of legal battles, all the Bert Harris Act cases lodged against the city are officially settled, but some neighbors think officials were too generous to developers.

The Bert J. Harris, Jr. Private Property Rights Protection Act allows for compensation when a new law unfairly affects real property rights.

When city leaders enacted restrictions on occupancy and the number of bedrooms in short-term rental units nearly six years ago, they wound up with more than 60 Bert Harris complaints coming into city hall with many of those going before judges in Manatee County Circuit Court. Despite winning cases concerning occupancy, there were several still active with appeals to both the circuit and higher courts in Florida, along with a few concerning the maximum allowed number of bedrooms.

In Holmes Beach, the maximum occupancy for short-term rentals is two people per bedroom or six total, whichever is greater. New development of rental properties is also limited to a total of four bedrooms for a single-family property or two bedrooms per side of a duplex.

Bert Harris cases come to a close in Holmes Beach
The vacant lot outlined in blue could house a single-family home with up to seven bedrooms as a part of the city’s Bert Harris Act case settlements. – Manatee County Property Appraiser | Submitted

After holding a shade meeting with attorneys earlier in the month, commissioners met on Oct. 26 to publicly acknowledge the proposed legal settlements and vote to accept four of the five agreements.

The fifth settlement, Mayor Judy Titsworth said, is to be signed by representatives from the Florida League of Cities and states that the league, which has been covering court costs for the city, will not attempt to recoup legal fees from plaintiffs in 24 occupancy cases that the city won.

The other settlements concerning development rights were accepted by commissioners in a 3-2 vote, with Commissioners Jayne Christenson and Kim Rash dissenting.

Under the settlement terms, the vacant lot at 303 56th St. will be able to be developed into a single-family home with a maximum of seven bedrooms instead of the four currently allowed per city regulations. The structure would be considered a non-conforming structure under city codes and would be required to meet all other city and state building codes, including setbacks, lot coverage and maximum building height, among others. Should the property owner, local builder Shawn Kaleta, opt to sell the property instead of develop it, the enhanced development rights would not be transferred to the new owner.

At 108 78th St., a single-family property also owned by Kaleta, the settlement allows for a single-family home to be built on the property with a maximum of eight bedrooms. The development rights outlined in the settlement also do not transfer to a new owner should the property be sold before it’s expanded. Similarly, the settlement for 102 77th St. allows Kaleta to construct a single-family home on the property with a maximum of seven bedrooms with the same limitations as the other two settlements.

The settlement between the city and Bryan Zinober, the owner of 105 39th St., allows for the development of two duplexes with a maximum of five bedrooms per side for a total of 20 bedrooms on the property. The non-transferable development rights have an expiration of 25 years from the date of the agreement.

Neighbors object

While no one from the public stepped up to speak against most of the settlements, the one concerning development rights of the 56th Street property didn’t go over well with neighbors.

One neighbor, Gary Brill, said that he and his wife purchased their property at 306 56th St. after looking at what the city’s codes would allow to be built on nearby vacant lots. He asked commissioners to deny the settlement with Kaleta and keep to the four-bedroom maximum.

Next door neighbor Margie Motzer also spoke during public comment, noting that with the increased number of bedrooms allowed on the vacant lot next door to her and her husband’s property, if it were to become a vacation rental, their home would be surrounded by rentals with a total of 23 bedrooms and a maximum occupancy of 46 people. Motzer said she feels that allowing the development of a seven-bedroom structure on the property is not in the best interests of residents or in keeping with the city’s comprehensive plan. She added that she wished city leaders had done some outreach to the neighboring residents to inform them of what kind of development could be coming into their neighborhood as a result of the settlement.

“I think they deserve that respect if nothing else,” she said.

Neighborhood resident Nancy Deal also came to the podium to state that she can hear the noise from adjacent rental properties from up to four houses away on some days. She agreed with Motzer that the public should have been notified and involved in the decision-making process with city leaders.

“This is not right,” Deal said of the settlement, noting that she’s not in favor of granting additional development rights to property owners who know what they can and cannot build on their property when they purchase it. “You work for us,” she said to commissioners. “You work for me. This is wrong.”

Titsworth said that while she feels for the Motzers and their neighbors, that the good of one property owner cannot outweigh the good of the entire city.

Attorney Erica Augello said that if commissioners did not agree to the settlements, it exposed the city to about $7 million in claims if the cases were not decided in the city’s favor plus the added expense of attorney fees if and when the funding from the Florida League of Cities ran out. City leaders have budgeted for only $750,000 to go toward Bert Harris case attorney fees, court costs and potential settlements, if needed.

Commissioner Terry Schaefer said that if he lived where the Motzers do, he would feel the same way about the potential of a seven-bedroom rental property going in next door. However, he added that he believes most Holmes Beach residents would be in favor of the settlement agreements and so he had to vote for them.

“This was a difficult decision,” Commissioner Jim Kihm said. “No one liked the solution being presented but the other option was less palatable.”

Schaefer said that if commissioners decided not to settle the cases, he was afraid of the money it could cost the city down the road, a burden that would likely be put on taxpayers.

Christenson and Rash both said they would like to get community involvement in the decision or at least notify all of the neighboring property owners before voting on whether or not to accept the settlement agreements. Augello said the city is under no obligation to notify adjacent property owners and residents and pushed for commissioners to move forward with the settlements to avoid any additional attorney fees or the possibility of the settlement agreements falling apart.

Related coverage

 

Holmes Beach takes home six Bert Harris wins

 

Bert Harris cases go back to court

Coconuts owner faces off with city code officers

Coconuts owner faces off with city code officers

HOLMES BEACH – The October code compliance special magistrate hearing featured eight cases and they were all issues occurring at the same complex, The Coconuts.

The property, located at 100 73rd St. in Holmes Beach, has four units managed by Coconuts Management Inc. and 11 units owned by local builder Shawn Kaleta. While the four units managed by Coconuts Management Inc. are rented weekly in compliance with the city’s codes and ordinances, Holmes Beach code compliance officers allege that some of the units owned by Kaleta are being rented in violation of the city’s vacation rental ordinance. Attorney Louis Najmy was on hand to represent Kaleta during an Oct. 20 code compliance hearing held at Holmes Beach City Hall.

Wanda Bell of Coconuts Management Inc. stated in an email to The Sun that Kaleta bought a number of units in The Coconuts complex and forced the management company to vacate the onsite office Dec. 19, 2020 after firing the company in favor of his own AMI Locals group. Bell added that the four onsite units still managed by Coconuts Management Inc. are owned by other owners.

Code Compliance Supervisor James Thomas presented the case in front of Special Magistrate Michael Connolly. Thomas alleged that units in the complex are being rented without valid vacation rental certificates (VRC) and advertised for improper lengths of stay, specifically stays for less than seven days.

The property is located in the beachfront A-1 district which, while a residential district, is also home to some of the city’s hotels and motels, along with several condominium units. Thomas argued that The Coconuts is a condominium complex and is subject to the seven-day minimum stay requirements for residential properties in the A-1 district. To rent the units, he said, would also require a valid VRC issued by the city.

Thomas said the infractions before Connolly were repeat violations because a citation had been issued to the units’ owner in June. Attorney for the city, Erica Augello, said the citation had been paid and there had been no challenge submitted to the city by the property owner.

She added that all of the units previously had VRCs but that they expired in June, except for one unit, which she said still has a valid VRC.

Thomas asked Connolly to levy costs for each of the eight cases of $127.24 against the property owner and to charge $250 per day fines in each case retroactive to Sept. 24 until the units are brought into compliance with city codes.

City Planner Bill Brisson said that The Coconuts, and specifically the units in question, do not have a hotel/motel license from the Florida Department of Business and Professional Regulation.

Najmy argued that the resort’s management has a license from DBPR that is interchangeable with a hotel/motel license and that the property was built to be a resort, not a residential condominium complex. He added that the property’s units have been regularly rented for nightly stays since The Coconuts was built in the early 1970s. For the one unit that has a VRC, he said he feels that it’s improper for the unit to have one and for the city to require it. Out of the 18 units on The Coconuts property, Najmy said 11 of them are rented nightly.

As to the violation of city codes, Najmy argued that there are no minimum night stay requirements in the A-1 district and that every property should be able to be rented nightly.

Connolly said that he would have to rule in all eight cases based on the city codes. He instructed Brisson to forward the sections of code he referenced to determine rental regulations for the A-1 district to himself, Najmy and Augello and for the two attorneys to prepare and email arguments to him based on the sections of code provided.

With a ruling in the eight cases not planned to be issued until at least mid-November, Connolly warned Najmy that if the cases are decided in the city’s favor, his client risks fines of up to $250 per day dating back to Sept. 24 until the units are brought into compliance.

Related coverage

 

Election candidates speak out on balance in Holmes Beach

 

Introducing the 2021 Holmes Beach commission candidates

 

Holmes Beach leaders and Bali Hai owners face off

Commissioners talk golf cart/LSV regulations

Commissioners talk golf cart/LSV regulations

HOLMES BEACH – Commissioners met Oct. 12 for a work session about potential golf cart and low-speed vehicle regulations, focusing on how to have those vehicles travel safely through the city.

A vehicle defined as a golf cart in Holmes Beach does not require a license plate. A low-speed vehicle can look like a golf cart, one of the mini-cars rented on the Island or other street-legal, non-traditional vehicles. These have license plates and can be driven in all three Island cities, except that they cannot be legally driven on state roads, including Manatee Avenue and East Bay Drive in Holmes Beach, although the vehicles can cross these streets. Because they are not supposed to be driven on Manatee Avenue, they should not be driven across the Anna Maria Island Bridge.

Holmes Beach Police Chief Bill Tokajer said his concerns about golf carts and low-speed vehicles primarily include safety and speed. The slower-moving vehicles on main roads, such as Marina Drive, which has a 35 mph speed limit in some places, can cause issues for car and truck drivers because the lower-speed vehicle slows traffic down. It also creates a safety hazard, he said, because some LSV and golf cart drivers will pull into bicycle lanes to allow cars to pass or cars will pass slower-moving vehicles on the right through the bicycle lane. Both maneuvers are illegal and could seriously injure a bicyclist traveling in the bicycle lane if a driver pulls over without seeing them or stops ahead of the cyclist. Due to traffic congestion, sometimes cyclists move faster than the vehicles, Tokajer said.

His suggestion is to change the speed limit on a section of Gulf Drive along the beach from 35 mph to 25 mph to match the speed limit on the rest of the road. Doing this would give drivers of LSVs and golf carts a way to travel through Holmes Beach while driving only on roads with a speed limit of 25 mph or less.

To direct drivers to the correct path, he said stencils on the street can be used instead of signs and stickers placed on LSV rentals to alert drivers of the requirement to drive only on streets with a 25 mph or less speed limit, along with other regulations.

Tokajer also suggested mandating that all passengers on golf carts and LSVs be required to have their own individual seat belts. For children, a proper child restraint device is required.

The discussion is expected to continue at a future work session.

Related coverage

 

Rules of the road decals to be placed in rented golf carts

 

New moratorium in effect on vehicle rental businesses

 

Golf carts causing frustration, accidents