Skip to main content

Tag: Holmes Beach

Holmes Beach candidates sound off on golf cart/LSV use

Holmes Beach candidates sound off on golf cart/LSV use

HOLMES BEACH – Voting by mail is already underway and the five candidates vying for three seats on the city commission only have a few weeks left until the Nov. 2 election to let voters know where they stand on the issues. This week, they give their thoughts in their own words on the use of golf carts and low-speed vehicles in Holmes Beach by answering the question, “How do you feel about golf carts and low-speed vehicles?”

Renee Ferguson

“We are beginning to make strides on this issue. Our commissioners established a moratorium on future golf cart businesses, we have shared ideas with our sister cities and our traffic engineer is looking at other paths for directing traffic. We need input from all stakeholders to look at alternatives to achieve our goal of safety on this issue.”

John Monetti

“I would preface my response with the recognition that I do not have all the current information available since I currently am not a city commissioner. My feelings on the topics reflect topical knowledge though I do stay abreast of these issues as an interested resident.

I own one. I stay off the main streets and respect the impact I could have on traffic flow if I stray onto our main streets.”

Pat Morton

“I will support the chief and mayor in lowering the speed on Gulf Drive to 25 miles per hour and limit golf carts and low-speed vehicles to roads 25 miles per hour.”

Terry Schaefer

“We have established a six-month moratorium on approval of any new dealers while providing the time to study the larger issue of how these vehicles are and should be integrated into traffic patterns and parking. These vehicles have and will become more popular with residents and visitors and this time to study the trend is appropriate to consider safety of use and effects on traffic flow and parking. There have been many sightings of potential safety concerns and this entire investigation will be open for public comment and suggestion. I believe these vehicles provide efficient transportation on the Island and that this is the time to explore whether additional controls are necessary to protect the safety of those passengers and whether existing controls are adequate.”

Carol Soustek

“Low-speed vehicles. There are a lot of them and safety, not speed, is my concern.”

Related coverage

 

Commission candidates address beach parking

 

Election candidates speak out on balance in Holmes Beach

 

Commission candidates weigh in on noise

 

Holmes Beach candidates talk water quality issues

Candidates give their opinions on a Holmes Beach city manager

Candidates give their opinions on a Holmes Beach city manager

HOLMES BEACH – The Nov. 2 election is almost upon us and Holmes Beach voters have to decide between five candidates to fill three seats on the city commission – incumbent Commissioners Terry Schaefer and Carol Soustek, newcomer Renee Ferguson and former commissioners John Monetti and Pat Morton.

Continuing The Sun’s series on how the candidates feel about issues facing the city, this week the five commission candidates are answering the question, “How do you feel about a city manager in Holmes Beach?” in their own words.

Renee Ferguson

“I am aware that people have different perspectives on this issue; that is an essential part of democracy. At this time, I feel our city is in good hands. If the situation should change, I believe this would need to be put before the voters. As the city moves through many changes, we must always focus on what is best for the city at the time in this fluid situation.”

John Monetti

“I would preface my response with the recognition that I do not have all the current information available since I currently am not a city commissioner. My feelings on the topics reflect topical knowledge though I do stay abreast of these issues as an interested resident.

I don’t feel we have a need for one at this point but every idea deserves a look.”

Pat Morton

“I have a lot of respect for the balance that the charter allows us. I would leave a change of this magnitude up to the charter review committee to consider. This is an elected board. If they feel a change is needed, it would be up to them to draft a referendum to be placed on the ballot. At this time, I think our mayor is doing a great job.”

Terry Schaefer

“I served on the city’s ad-hoc committee which studied the various forms of government in Florida. That experience resulted in a full understanding of the city manager form, strong mayor form, which our charter presently specifies, and the two other forms also allowed. I believe the city manager form has numerous benefits, especially in communities with little or no capable citizen interest and capabilities in serving occurs. City managers bring a specifically degreed person with municipal experience to manage the city’s operations. I believe when and if we reach a period where no qualified citizen with proper capabilities and commitment occurs, that the city manager form would be a viable option. I am not convinced that is the case presently for the following reasons: The balance between a non-voting mayor with veto power, combined with the five commissioners with legislative responsibilities, balances authority concerns. Mayors are elected by the people and serve two-year terms. City managers are hired by the consensus of five commissioners, have no veto power unless provided for by city charter, and can be extended or fired by a simple majority of the commission. For example, Manatee County’s decision by three new commissioners with the support of the chair who fired what the public and county staff considered to be a very loyal and effective county administrator. Presently, we have strong leadership at each department head position, all of whom report to the mayor for overall management. In my opinion, the city is operating effectively with specific expertise at each department and a community-oriented mayor. Discussion of the options is healthy and it would take the consensus vote of registered voters to ultimately decide with a structural change to our city charter.”

Carol Soustek

“Good and bad. Some city managers have done wonderful for their cities, just as some mayors have done wonderful things for their cities. I believe that if the person knows the city and brings their best talents to guide the city and community well, then it is the person, not the title, that the community needs.”

Related coverage

 

Commission candidates address beach parking

 

Election candidates speak out on balance in Holmes Beach

 

Commission candidates weigh in on noise

 

Holmes Beach candidates talk water quality issues

New funding for police officer

HOLMES BEACH – It took some discussion, but city commissioners voted to allow the Holmes Beach Police Department to add another officer to its ranks.

Commissioners voted three to two in favor of releasing funds earmarked in the budget for the new hire with Commissioners Kim Rash and Jayne Christenson voting no. Police Chief Bill Tokajer said that he’s vetted someone to potentially take the position but that, as of the Oct. 12 meeting, no one had been hired for the position since funding for it was pending commission approval.

The additional officer will bring the total of officers in the HBPD, including Tokajer, to 18, with 14 of those being patrol officers. By hiring the new officer, Tokajer said it brings the department up to a good staffing level and allows Lt. Brian Hall to take the second in command role that was eliminated to put more officers on patrol when Tokajer took over as chief nine years ago.

While Tokajer said the new hire is a part of his succession planning strategy, that strategy is to put a solid structure in place prior to his eventual retirement, not determine who the next chief of police will be in Holmes Beach.

Commissioner Jim Kihm said during the discussion that he’s concerned about Hall being pegged as Tokajer’s successor since he is related to Mayor Judy Titsworth. Kihm said he felt that relationship would be a conflict of interest in the city’s government structure. Titsworth said that she’s very proud of Hall and the career that he’s built over the years serving in the HBPD. Tokajer added that no one is guaranteed his job when he decides to retire, which he doesn’t plan to do any time soon.

While the mayor is an elected position serving a two-year term, the police chief is a city employee whose hiring is voted on by commissioners.

In her comments, Christenson said that she supports the HBPD and its officers but believes that an outside consultant should be hired to determine if the department needs another officer and, if so, Manatee County officials should be responsible for paying for that person rather than the city’s residents, due to the influx of tourism to Holmes Beach. Currently, Manatee County gives the HBPD $50,000 per year to patrol the county-owned beaches in Holmes Beach. Tokajer said he and Titsworth continue to work to get that amount raised.

Kihm added that he agrees the amount given to Holmes Beach for police by the county should be higher due to the public safety issues surrounding increased tourism to the Island.

Rash said that while he fully supports the police department, he also agrees that the county needs to increase what they’re giving to the department on an annual basis.

“Manatee County is profiting off of the Island and needs to step up to the bar,” he said. “The residents shouldn’t have to carry the burden for all of Manatee County’s wants.”

Commissioner Carol Soustek said that she voted in favor of hiring a new officer because she wants to stay ahead of enforcement in Holmes Beach. She added that she believes adequate staffing in the HBPD is essential to keeping crime rates low in the city.

Tokajer said in 2020, HBPD officers made 379 arrests, a significantly higher number than those made by Bradenton Beach and Longboat Key police officers.

HBPD Officer Michael VanHorn addressed commissioners during public comment, relaying some of the difficulties that the city’s police force faces on a regular basis, including a large number of calls that require multiple officers to respond, particularly if there is an aggressive suspect, such as in drug, intoxication and gun-related incident responses. He relayed examples of multiple incidents which occurred on one recent weekend where more than one officer was needed to respond to a call due to a violent suspect. In each instance, VanHorn said multiple officers were needed to subdue the suspect with minimal force and to try to prevent injury to their fellow officers.

The minimum shift staff for the HBPD includes two patrol officers, a sergeant and a mid-shift officer to ease the workload during shift change hours.

Related coverage

 

Final budget hearing gets heated

 

Rash triumphs in state investigation

Commission candidates address beach parking

Commission candidates address beach parking

HOLMES BEACH – The vote by mail ballots have already been sent out and Holmes Beach residents are already considering who to vote for ahead of the Nov. 2 election. There are three seats on the city commission up for grabs and five candidates with their hats in the ring.

This week, the candidates speak out on public parking by answering the question “How do you feel about public parking and beach access?” The answers are in each candidate’s own words.

Renee Ferguson

“Six years ago, I had the pleasure of working on the Congestion Committee which was solicited by the city. It was an amazing experience for me because I was able to speak to a lot of residents and business owners. For more than two years we researched and consistently worked with the city to develop a plan which was ultimately implemented last year. There have been some bumps, but there are provisions for permit parking for residents and property owners, and it has helped quality of life in our neighborhoods. The county opened up the elementary school and library parking lots, and this appears to be working. Holmes Beach has more than the state-required number of spots for beach renourishment, and the ULI said that renourishment should not be based on parking anyway. “

John Monetti

“In each topic, I would preface my response with the recognition that I do not have all the current information available since I currently am not a city commissioner. My feelings on the topics reflect topical knowledge though I do stay abreast of these issues as an interested resident.

Once more this is a topic that has unfortunately become very divisive. It should not be an us-versus-them topic. It seems like some want to make this a showdown between the city and county while somehow forgetting that there were many Holmes Beach citizens who also resisted policies adopted. All shareholders should be considered.”

Pat Morton

“I support the decreased parking in residential neighborhoods and the permit parking. All beach communities have limits as to what they can safely accommodate.”

Terry Schaefer

“This issue underscores the absolute necessity of HOME RULE. Without this right, Manatee County and the state would be making decisions on parking, traffic, and other civic decisions. I am supportive of our existing parking ordinance and open to future considerations should demands change affecting residents’ needs or compliance with state law concerning renourishment funding. Presently, we provide more beach parking than the state requires for beach renourishment funding and adequate parking for residents, and ample visitor parking during normal times. The rub comes during holidays and extremely high visitor periods, during which 5,000 spaces wouldn’t be adequate and thus, we place residents’ rights above the demands of the county and visitors. It is the county that has promoted the Island and they share the responsibility to provide parking to address the traffic created by their promotion. Beach access is more than adequate in our city and should be to accommodate all, however, parking solutions to accommodate growing demands should not be the exclusive responsibility of the city’s neighborhoods to meet that demand. This issue is only going to intensify and will need steady management by our city.”

Carol Soustek

“We are blessed to have so many beach accesses and they are open to all. Designated parking spots are on the access roads and across on the streets. We are a small city. We do not have ample land to have unlimited parking. So many want to come and we do not have the capacity to handle the demand. I voted to remove street parking in the residential areas along the beach for safety reasons. The results have shown this was the right move.”

Related coverage

 

Commission candidates weigh in on noise

 

Holmes Beach candidates talk water quality issues

 

Introducing the 2021 Holmes Beach commission candidates

Election candidates speak out on balance in Holmes Beach

Election candidates speak out on balance in Holmes Beach

HOLMES BEACH – The five candidates for three city commission seats in Holmes Beach are counting down the days of the election. With voters already receiving mail-in ballots and those voting in person getting ready to head to the polls Nov. 2, there are only a few more weeks for the candidates to make their stance on city issues known.

This week, we asked, “How do you feel about the balance in Holmes Beach between renters and residents?” The answers are in each candidate’s own words.

Renee Ferguson

“There is an expression that the horse may have left the barn. The Comprehensive Plan and ULI Study are clear about the importance of balance. I believe we missed a huge opportunity years ago to address this matter. Our island changed from being “The Best Kept Secret in Florida” to being discovered and promoted daily by the TDC both nationally and internationally. Holmes Beach brings approximately 30% of the total county resort taxes from rentals operating in our residential neighborhoods. Our city sees very little of that, and it must be used for promotion and advertising of tourism. I will promote having a liaison with the TDC to have a stronger voice regarding receiving our fair share.”

John Monetti

“In each topic, I would preface my response with the recognition that I do not have all the current information available since I currently am not a City Commissioner.  My feelings on the topics reflect topical knowledge though I do stay abreast of these issues as an interested resident.

Fortunately, we do have varied zoning in Holmes Beach with differing rental limitations. I personally was a commissioner who instrumentally steered us to those compromises.”

Pat Morton

“Balance is key. Too much legislation to benefit only one aspect of the city will tip the scales in only one direction. I will continue to look at the entire picture. This, after all, is a wonderful place to visit but an even better place to live and raise a family.”

Terry Schaefer

“I have referred to this subject in previous answers, it is that balance that we attempt to achieve. Methods, ordinances and codes from the past must be re-evaluated in order to adjust to current and future trends. That approach is continually addressed by staff and the commission; the parking ordinance and upcoming discussion of golf carts are examples of this necessary process. With continuing volume of visitors coupled with the strong objective to maintain desired quality of life advantages, solutions must be addressed continuously to protect the rights of all, which is why I believe it to be one of the two most important issues facing the city. I pledge to be open-minded in helping find the solutions benefitting our community, not just catering to a small group of vocal citizens. Essentially, I believe the solutions must benefit the majority of all concerned.”

Carol Soustek

“In the beginning, when we became discovered by the tourist trade, there was no balance between visitors and residents. The new commission began working on a code department to regulate issues and bring violators into compliance. The commission passed ordinance after ordinance regulating parking, pools, number of guests, loud parties, noise and more. We developed a vacation rental certificate which gave us the information we needed and gave rental companies direction on what we expected from them. We have come a long way and we still are looking at ways to improve where we can.”

Related coverage

 

Commission candidates weigh in on noise

 

Holmes Beach candidates talk water quality issues

 

Introducing the 2021 Holmes Beach commission candidates

Final budget hearing gets heated

HOLMES BEACH – City leaders hit a snag during the final hearing for the 2021-22 fiscal year budget when two commissioners voted against approving the proposed budget.

When commissioners met on Sept. 28 for the final public hearing of the budget, Commissioners Jayne Christenson and Kim Rash voted against adopting the proposed budget, causing an issue requiring a quick amendment to get the budget passed before the new fiscal year began Oct. 1.

Rash, who voted against the budget in the first hearing earlier in September, reiterated his position that he and some of the Holmes Beach residents he’s spoken to feel that the city’s budget has ballooned out of control and is too large for the size of the city.

During discussion, Christenson said she was voting against the budget because she didn’t support the proposed budget for the Holmes Beach Police Department, which includes funds to support the hiring of a new officer and all of the equipment that goes along with a new hire.

A new hire in the department would bring the total number of sworn officers, including Chief Bill Tokajer, to 18. Tokajer had previously stated that hiring a new officer is essential to policing the city and its growing number of visitors along with planning for the future of the department. Since Tokajer came on board nine years ago, there hasn’t been a deputy chief in the department, which would be standard and something that he wants to remedy as he begins to look toward retirement.

Christenson said she wasn’t in favor of approving the budget as presented and made a motion to exclude the funding for a new officer that ultimately failed to win approval from the majority of her fellow commissioners. When it came time to vote for the budget as presented, Christenson and Rash voted against it, causing the measure to fail for not receiving a supermajority vote of a minimum of four to one.

The police department budget represents $4,200,339 of the total $22,226,872 budget, including carryover and reserves.

During discussion, Tokajer was given the opportunity to reply to the concerns Christenson raised about the police department budget. He said that in his opinion, the department with 18 sworn officers including himself, one detective and a school resource officer for Anna Maria Elementary School, is adequately staffed for the number of residents in Holmes Beach, not the number of visitors the city hosts, which his officers are tasked with policing. Typically, he said there is one sergeant and two officers on each shift with a mid-shift officer working afternoons during shift change.

“This budget has been discussed between department heads and individual commissioners since May of this year,” Tokajer said. “To drop this bomb at the final hour is wrong and a slap in the face to the entire department. This has also put our city treasurer who has been open and transparent and readily available to all commissioners in a challenging position as revenue is at risk if budget deadlines are not met. I wouldn’t have brought this forth this year if I didn’t feel succession planning was necessary. Prior to my arrival, there was a deputy chief in the lieutenant position. I gave up this position to put more boots on the ground and to develop my team.”

“I would hope that after nine years as your chief of police, the professionalism your officers show every day and the significant reduction in crime we have shown that I would have the unconditional support of the entire commission. I know that I have the support of the community at large,” Tokajer continued. He added that he had hosted one-on-one meetings with commissioners throughout the budget process and had not received any negative feedback concerning the hiring of a new officer. Tokajer went on to say that if the funding for a new hire was not approved by commissioners that the department’s overtime budget would have to be adjusted.

“For this to happen at the last minute is not responsible governing,” he concluded.

Christenson said that she felt Tokajer’s comments were “bullying” and that he was attempting to use intimidation to get what he wants, in this case, funds for a new officer. She also said that she didn’t see how her decision to not vote for the budget as presented was “dropping a bomb” because Tokajer had given a prepared statement on the matter.

Mayor Judy Titsworth spoke up and said that she had been alerted to Christenson’s objections just before the meeting by city Treasurer Lori Hill and had told Tokajer, to allow him approximately 45 minutes to come up with a response. Hill and Christenson had met earlier in the day to discuss the commissioner’s concerns over the budget.

Christenson added that if the department needs additional officers or if more policing is needed that it shouldn’t be on the residents of Holmes Beach to supply funding through taxes for that, that Manatee County leaders should contribute more funding to the department or help out with policing.

When Commissioners Terry Schaefer, Carol Soustek and Jim Kihm all agreed that they supported the budget as-is with the police budget as presented, Christenson amended her suggested amendment for the budget to allow the police budget to remain intact but to require Tokajer to receive commission approval before being able to hire a new officer.

That amendment passed and then the budget with the amendment passed with unanimous support from commissioners.

For Tokajer to hire a new officer for the HBPD, he will need the support of three of the five Holmes Beach city commissioners, or a simple majority.

Related coverage

 

Holmes Beach leaders start 2021-22 budget talks

Introducing the 2021 Holmes Beach commission candidates

HOLMES BEACH – The November election is looming and there are five candidates seeking the support of voters to earn one of three seats on the city commission for the next two years.

The candidates include incumbent Commissioners Terry Schaefer and Carol Soustek, former commissioners John Monetti and Pat Morton and political newcomer Renee Ferguson.

The Sun reached out to each candidate and will feature their answers to some of the issues facing the city of Holmes Beach and its residents, beginning this week with the question, “Why should voters cast their ballots for you?”

Renee Ferguson

  • Regularly attends Holmes Beach city commission meetings, planning commission meetings, code compliance special magistrate hearings, parks and beautification committee meetings, Island Transportation Planning Organization meetings, Coalition of Barrier Island Elected Officials meetings, and Manatee County board of county commissioners’ meetings
  • Served on the Holmes Beach parking and congestion committee, code enforcement committee, form of government ad-hoc committee and dog park committee
  • Owned and operated an executive search firm for 28 years in Princeton, New Jersey, and as president of her professional personnel association
  • Volunteer work includes the Golden Retriever Rescue of Mid-Florida, Anna Maria Island Historical Society, Suncoast Waterkeeper, Friends of the Island Library and Roser Memorial Community Church
  • 11-year resident of Holmes Beach

Q: Why should voters cast their ballots for you?

“My civic responsibility to make our city the best coastal city in Florida is evident in my resume. For 11 years I have stepped up and served. I have been appointed to committees, volunteered at city functions, advocated for the city dog park, and attended and participated in commission meetings and work sessions. I have done hours of research in order to address areas that I felt needed resident input or clarification. I have committed myself to my city and its residents. I am a team player and a good listener. I strive to achieve fairness and compromise. My background is in Human Resources and this has taught me how to develop partnerships to bring people together for the betterment of all.”

John Monetti

John Monetti
  • Formerly served three terms as a Holmes Beach city commissioner and five years on the planning commission
  • Worked as the general manager of the Columbia Restaurant on St. Armands Circle for 27 years
  • Part of the Florida Restaurant and Lodging Association for 20 years, served three years as its president
  • Volunteer work includes The Center of Anna Maria Island, Anna Maria Island Chamber of Commerce and Anna Maria Elementary School Parent/Teacher Organization
  • 26-year full-time resident of Holmes Beach

Q: Why should voters cast their ballots for you?

“To elect a well-rounded individual who will try to offer a balanced approach to issues. I am a 26-year resident of Holmes Beach that can see perspectives as a family man with a wife and five children raised here, but also cognizant of our business community. They are not mutually exclusive.”

Pat Morton

Pat Morton

  • Formerly served for 17 years as a Holmes Beach city commissioner, was first elected in 2003
  • Formerly served with the United States military and currently works part-time at the Holmes Beach ACE Hardware
  • Member of the Florida Emergency Preparedness Association and certified by FEMA’s Emergency Management Institute
  • Previously served as Holmes Beach city commission liaison to Waste Pro, Holmes Beach police pension board and Manatee County Emergency Operations Center
  • 23-year Holmes Beach resident

Q: Why should voters cast their ballots for you?

“Because I have a tremendous history and proven record in supporting our residents and business owners. Balance is key. Too much legislation to benefit only one aspect of the city will tip the scales in only one direction. I will continue to look at the entire picture. This, after all, is a wonderful place to visit but an even better place to live and raise a family.”

Terry Schaefer

Terry Schaefer

  • Incumbent commissioner, first elected in November 2019
  • Serves as city commission liaison to the Anna Maria Island Chamber of Commerce, Anna Maria Elementary School, The Center of Anna Maria Island, Holmes Beach police pension board. Alternate liaison for legislative matters and the Manatee County Emergency Operations Center
  • Worked for 35 years in banking and business management
  • Volunteer work includes 16 years as a public school board member in Belleville, Illinois and 12 years as a board member of the Southwestern Illinois Development Authority
  • Member of the Key Royale Club and served on the Holmes Beach Form of Government Ad-Hoc committee

Q: Why should voters cast their ballots for you?

“I believe voters can have the confidence that my deliberations and opinions are based on solid research, fact-finding and the ultimate effect my decisions and vote will have on our community. My knowledge and experience of our city’s operations, gained over the past years’ service, provide the basis of evaluating each issue and deciding what the net benefit to our community will be. I also believe that it is vital to listen to my fellow commissioners’ statements concerning issues prior to my ultimate decision and vote. I have the time and desire to serve the city and will continue to invest the time in preparation for meetings in order to be fully prepared to discuss all agenda items. In addition, I have the lifelong desire to help when and where I can be effective.”

Carol Soustek

Carol Soustek

  • Incumbent commissioner, first elected in November 2014
  • City commission liaison to code compliance, Grassy Point Preserve, Manatee County Emergency Operations Center, planning commission and parks and beautification committee
  • Worked as a corporate accountant for more than 50 years
  • Volunteer work includes Anna Maria Island Turtle Watch and Shorebird Monitoring, Serving Anna Maria and Friends of the Island Library
  • Served as chair of the Holmes Beach Island Congestion Committee in 2013

Q: Why should voters cast their ballots for you?

“Much depends on your commissioners taking the right path for you. Please look at my voting record and you will see the ordinances I have voted on. Limited bedrooms in structures to four, larger setbacks between properties, house sizes to lot ratios, noise restrictions, safety on our roads and in our homes, protection of wildlife, dunes and sea oats, reduced parking in our residential areas, better site plans, mask regulations, vacation rental regulations. These are just a few of hundreds.”

Related coverage

 

The Holmes Beach commission race is on

 

Holmes Beach leaders start 2021-22 budget talks

County commissioner hopes to pave more of paradise

County commissioner proposes beach parking garage

HOLMES BEACH – Manatee County Commissioner Kevin Van Ostenbridge wants a new parking garage to be built on Manatee Beach’s sand parking lot, but the mayor of Holmes Beach so far appears unlikely to sign off on the project.

During a Manatee County Commission meeting last week and in a letter to Holmes Beach city officials, Van Ostenbridge said he would like to look at the possibility of building a parking garage on the county-owned property at the beach at the end of Manatee Avenue to provide more public parking for beachgoers. The garage would potentially be built in the primary parking area in front of the snack bar building at the entrance to the beach on Gulf Drive.

Van Ostenbridge also stated he wants Holmes Beach city leaders to dismantle their permit parking program for residents, opening up more street parking in residential areas for public use. He also has demanded that public beach parking be allowed at the Island Branch Library and Anna Maria Elementary School when those facilities are not otherwise in use. Providing public parking at the school requires permission from the School District of Manatee County and either a special permit or site plan amendment approval from the city of Holmes Beach. Public parking at the county library branch would require an amendment to the lease between the city and county for the land under the building.

If city leaders refuse, Van Ostenbridge said he’d consider refusing to provide beach renourishment funds for the Holmes Beach coastline. However, Manatee County commissioners have limited control over the disbursement of beach renourishment funds, which come primarily from federal and state resources – including the Army Corps of Engineers and the Florida Department of Environmental Protection – and a portion of Manatee County Tourist Development Tax collections.

Though Van Ostenbridge has repeatedly said he would pull beach renourishment funds from the city to try to force Holmes Beach leaders’ hands regarding parking, it could be a double-edged sword for Manatee County, opponents say. Any reduction in beach renourishment could shrink the county’s beaches on Anna Maria Island due to rising sea levels and erosion, potentially reducing tourism to the area and damaging businesses throughout the county. Anna Maria Island generates the majority of tourism funds for Manatee County.

Holmes Beach Mayor Judy Titsworth said a parking garage is not an approved land use in the city and would potentially require the approval of an ordinance to allow the use or a special exception from city commissioners. The parking garage also would have to meet city requirements concerning maximum height (three stories), setbacks, stormwater retention and drainage and other building codes.

Titsworth has said while she’s happy to have conversations with county leaders about parking, she doesn’t feel that Holmes Beach and its residents should bear the majority of the responsibility for providing beach parking for the entire county and its visitors.

While the mayor has mentioned the possibility of the county building a parking garage in past talks concerning beach parking, she suggested building that garage off of 75th Street in Bradenton and using public transportation to get beachgoers to and from Manatee Beach.

Parking program scrutinized

Van Ostenbridge is among those who led the charge against the city of Holmes Beach regarding the public parking available for beachgoers in the Anna Maria Island city. The disagreement between county commissioners and Holmes Beach city leaders has gone on for months, stemming from a decision on the part of city leaders to enact a residential permit-only parking program on some residential streets located next to beach access points following a COVID-19-related shutdown of beach accesses in early 2020.

The permit parking program was planned for several years before becoming a reality and was designed to help lessen the negative impacts of large numbers of beachgoers in residential areas. Some issues that residents reported include people trespassing on their property, damaging property and landscaping, using exterior water hoses and pools without permission and leaving trash and other debris on lawns.

Despite Van Ostenbridge’s claims that city leaders have reduced the number of public parking spots by about 2,000 spaces, Holmes Beach Police Chief Bill Tokajer, who helped implement the parking permit program, said that claim is false.

Tokajer has stated that before the COVID-19 parking closures, which have been lifted, the city had about 2,400 parking spaces, including those at beach access points, public parking areas and along the side of streets within a quarter of a mile of the beach. Now there are 1,261 parking spots that do not require a parking permit and 642 on-street parking spots that require a permit but become available to the public daily after 5 p.m. About 497 on-street parking spots were removed by city leaders in residential areas as a part of the parking changes.

Under an agreement with the county, the city provides many more spaces than the 500 or so that are required to receive beach renourishment funding, according to city officials.

Related coverage

 

Tensions mount in city-county parking debate

 

County commissioners refuse Holmes Beach funding request

 

Parking rift between city, county widens over Memorial Day

Holmes Beach leaders and Bali Hai owners face off

Holmes Beach leaders and Bali Hai owners face off

HOLMES BEACH – No agreement has been reached concerning the operations of the Bali Hai Beach Resort between the hotel’s owners and the city of Holmes Beach, despite a pending court case, numerous code compliance hearings, fines and a pending site plan amendment approval.

Attorney Louis Najmy, representing the resort’s owners, including local developer Shawn Kaleta, appeared before commissioners on Sept. 15 for a site plan approval hearing. Due to issues with the site plan and a lack of compliance with city regulations, the site plan approval was postponed to the first meeting in October. This would allow the resort’s representatives additional time to work with city staff to create a site plan proposal that meets all of the city’s requirements and determine what action needs to be taken by the resort to come into compliance with city regulations until the proposed site plan for activities on the resort property.

During the Sept. 15 meeting, city commissioners agreed that they were unable to approve the site plan as presented but that they’d rather provide at least a partial approval instead of outright denying the presented site plan and risk going to mediation in the court system. Najmy argued that the site plan as presented has met all of the city’s expressed requirements. He said that his client has not complied with the code compliance order from a special magistrate to cease operations at the restaurant’s bar and lounge, obtain after-the-fact permits for construction work done and cease operations at an installed spa or cease holding special events at the resort. His reasoning for the non-compliance is that he thought his client should be able to continue with operations as-is until a site plan was approved and then the resort’s operations would have to come into compliance. City commissioners said that was not the case and that compliance has to be achieved and fines paid before the resort would be considered to be operating in good faith.

Najmy said he believes the $1,000 per day fine currently in force against the resort due to non-compliance with city codes was enacted erroneously and he is contesting it.

The issues between the city and the Bali Hai go back over a year to when work was done at the resort without permits from the Holmes Beach building department and a bar and spa were opened on the property for guest use without an approved site plan for the change in use.

The work done on the property includes installation of railings on the second floor of the resort, the demolition of an owner’s unit on the second floor of an accessory building and a storage room on the bottom floor of the same building, the conversion of those spaces into an office and bar/lounge area and the conversion of a resort laundry facility into a spa.

On behalf of his clients, Najmy argued that the resort’s owners do not need site plan approval from the city to open a bar/lounge on the property. City Planner Bill Brisson said he can find no record that a bar/lounge was ever approved for the site, meaning that a site plan approval from city commissioners is required for the amenity to operate legally within Holmes Beach city limits.

Najmy said that his client is seeking to operate in good faith with the city, though commissioners pointed out that his client is still operating the resort in violation of city regulations.

City Attorney Patricia Petruff said that there can be no approval of the site plan without the resort’s owners being willing to first come into compliance with city regulations. She added that a path forward needs to be determined to bring the issue to a conclusion before the courts truly get involved.

Though there is a court case pending in Manatee County Circuit Court, a hearing was not scheduled as of press time for The Sun.

The site plan is scheduled to come back before commissioners on Oct. 12.

Related coverage

 

Legal issues put a damper on wedding plans

 

Bali Hai legal dispute continues

 

Bali Hai owners receive code fines

Rash triumphs in state investigation

Rash triumphs in state investigation

HOLMES BEACH – At the conclusion of a four-month-long investigation by the State of Florida Commission on Ethics, Commissioner Kim Rash is breathing a long-awaited sigh of relief.

Rash was accused of violating a section of the Florida Constitution by his former neighbor, Anastasios “Tosh” Tricas, in early May. Among other things listed in a May 1 complaint filed with Holmes Beach police following a noise complaint at Rash’s Holmes Boulevard residence, Tricas accused Rash of abusing his position as a city commissioner by stating that he did not have to comply with laws and regulations because city departments and staff members “work for him.” A hearing held Sept. 10 in Tallahassee found that there was no probable cause to substantiate the claims made by Tricas, and his complaint against Rash was dismissed.

Rash

With the conclusion of the investigation comes a measure of peace for Rash and his family. In speaking with The Sun, Rash said the accusations against him and the following investigation caused a tremendous amount of stress for his family, who supported him throughout the entire process. Unable to discuss the investigation until it officially concluded, Rash said that without the support of his wife, Theresa, and daughter, Melissa, the situation would have been unbearable. Now, he’s just happy to have the hearing and investigation over with and to publicly be cleared of the accusations.

“I’m just happy it’s over,” he said, adding that he can now move forward in his duties as a commissioner with a renewed focus on the residents he represents.

In a written statement, Rash said he wished taxpayer funds could have been put to better use than investigating the claims made by Tricas.

“I believe the unfounded allegations against me by my former neighbor, Tosh Tricas, were the result of retaliation following my family’s decline of the Tricas’ request for a shared pool,” Rash said in the statement. “Electronic and photographic evidence, as well as testimony from direct witnesses, show that allegations submitted by Mr. Tricas to the Florida Commission on Ethics were fabricated. I demonstrated, item by item, with a wealth of documentation that each of Mr. Tricas’ allegations were categorically false. I fully cooperated with this investigation and was 100% confident that there would be a full exoneration of these false and damaging allegations.”

Rash said he feels the issues between himself and his neighbor began when Rash had a pool installed on his side of the duplex lot the two shared until Tricas sold his side of the building in late June. Rash said Tricas and his family wanted to go in on the pool so that it would be shared with the two units. For resale purposes, Rash denied the request, putting the two neighbors at odds. When Tricas sold his side of the duplex, plans were shown on the listing for a courtyard pool that could potentially be installed on his property, however, Holmes Beach building records show that no one applied for permits for that pool.

Tensions between the neighbors came to a head early in the morning of May 1 when officers responded to the Holmes Boulevard property just after 6 a.m. to a noise complaint. Tricas said a stereo left playing in Rash’s living room while that family was out of town was disturbing his neighbors for a few days before calling the Holmes Beach Police Department to report the noise.

Videos from Rash’s security camera system show HBPD officers, joined at one point by a Manatee County Sheriff’s Office deputy, blocking traffic in front of the residence and walking the property while investigating the issue.

Rash sent a friend over to turn off the stereo and was issued a warning by officers, which would have ended the issue, but Tricas gave a five-page written statement to officers outlining other issues between himself and Rash. It was those complaints that made their way to the state ethics board as Tricas escalated the complaint.

Tricas could not be reached for comment.

With the conclusion of the ordeal, Rash said he’s happy to finally be moving forward and putting this issue behind him.

“Throughout this whole ordeal, I have continued to work and advocate for the residents of Holmes Beach. That is why I was elected, and this has continued to be my focus,” Rash said in his statement. “I am glad I finally have the opportunity to speak so that the residents of Holmes Beach finally know the truth. I am grateful for the support that I have received from so many of our Holmes Beach residents.”

Related coverage

 

Holmes Beach commissioner receives noise warning

 

Changes come to noise ordinance

 

City buzzing about noise regulations

The Holmes Beach commission race is on

HOLMES BEACH – Qualifying is over, and five candidates are entering the race for three open seats on the Holmes Beach city commission with the Nov. 2 election as the finish line.

Commissioners Carol Soustek and Terry Schaefer are the two incumbents hoping to hold on to their spots on the dais.

Soustek

If re-elected, this will be Schaefer’s second term as a commissioner. He was first elected to the city commission in November 2019.

Schaefer

Soustek was first appointed to the commission Nov. 25, 2014 to fill the unexpired term of previous commissioner David Zaccagnino. She was elected to the commission in 2015 and re-elected for two more terms in 2017 and 2019. If re-elected in November, this will be her third two-year term on the city commission.

Joining Soustek and Schaefer in this year’s race are Renee Ferguson and former city commissioners John Monetti and Pat Morton.

Monetti

This is Ferguson’s first attempt at joining the city commission, though she has actively participated in commission meetings and attended meetings regularly as a Holmes Beach resident.

Ferguson

Morton, who served as a city commissioner for 17 years, is hoping for another go at a seat on the dais after losing in 2020 to Commissioner Jayne Christenson.

For Monetti, winning in November would mark a return to the city commission after a nearly 10-year hiatus. Previously, Monetti has served not only on the city commission but also on the planning commission.

Morton

Commissioner Jim Kihm, whose term also expires in November, opted to not run for a third term as commissioner.

In an Aug. 27 email to his fellow commissioners and The Sun, Kihm said that he had decided not to run for re-election due to personal reasons.

“Today I am announcing my decision not to see re-election as commissioner for the city of Holmes Beach for personal reasons,” Kihm’s email reads. “I have enjoyed serving the people of Holmes Beach over the past four years and I feel that I am leaving the city in good hands as I finish out the rest of my current term. I would like to thank all the voters for putting their trust in me and electing me to serve them. I have made every effort to serve to the best of my ability.”

Kihm

City commissioners serve two-year terms on the dais. When Holmes Beach voters cast their ballots in November, the top three vote-getters will take the open commission seats. Voters are allowed to support up to three candidates at the polls, one for each available position.

With a five-person city commission, the coming election may prove to be very important for the future of Anna Maria Island’s largest city as most ordinances and resolutions require only a simple majority of three votes to pass or fail commission approval. A large change in the commission lineup could potentially mean big changes for how the city is governed.

Related coverage

 

Holmes Beach leaders start 2021-22 budget talks

 

County commissioners refuse Holmes Beach funding request

 

Holmes Beach commissioner receives noise warning

egal issues put a damper on wedding plans

Legal issues put a damper on wedding plans

UPDATED Aug. 30, 2021 at 12:05 p.m. – HOLMES BEACH – A local couple whose wedding plans were ruined by the Bali Hai Beach Resort was rescued by Island restaurateur Sean Murphy, who has offered them a wedding venue at one of his properties.

City Commissioner Terry Schaefer contacted Murphy after Bradenton couple David Naeher and Natalie Schofield appeared before commissioners on Aug. 24 to plead their case, hoping the city would approve their application for a special event permit to have their wedding on the beach in front of the Bali Hai.

Unknown to the couple, the resort – which advertises itself as a wedding venue – is not allowed to host weddings due to city permit violations.

Commissioners did approve the ceremony on the sand to take place pending a parking plan review by Police Chief Bill Tokajer, but gave the couple the bad news that their Oct. 16 reception cannot take place at the resort.

Ordinarily, Mayor Judy Titsworth said she would be able to approve or deny a special event permit, however, with the ongoing legal issues with the host resort, she felt it needed to come before commissioners.

City leaders’ issues with the Bali Hai and its ownership extend back for more than a year to when work was done on the property without permits and a bar and spa area were opened on the property without permits and an approved site plan amendment for the new uses at the resort. The resort’s owner, local builder Shawn Kaleta, is being fined $1,000 per day in code compliance fines and the site plan changes are outstanding. Titsworth said the site plan proposal is scheduled to come back before commissioners for discussion on Sept. 15.

Without an approved site plan or the proper permits and a pending court case in Manatee County Circuit Court, commissioners said that while they feel for the couple, they can’t approve any wedding events taking place at the Bali Hai. In addition, during a previous public hearing, attorneys for the Bali Hai said the resort would not be hosting weddings or seeking to host them in the future. In stark contrast to that statement, the Bali Hai’s website features a wedding planning page featuring events at the resort for up to 150 guests.

Grateful to Murphy, Naeher and Schofield both expressed their disappointment and anger at Bali Hai.

Schofield said she’s upset the resort sold her a wedding package that it wasn’t legally able to deliver. Now, she said, she has seven weeks to figure out what to do about the wedding and guests and has lost time that could be used to plan if they had found out up front that their reception couldn’t take place at their chosen venue.

Naeher said that when their application for the wedding was submitted to the city in July, he was told the reason it was denied was the lack of a parking plan for their 100 guests, something he thought could be easily remedied. Instead, while commissioners were willing to consider the wedding ceremony on the beach, an application for the reception, which would need to be submitted to the city for approval by representatives for the Bali Hai, would not be approved.

Commissioner Jayne Christenson said she thinks Bali Hai would go through with hosting the wedding reception whether it’s approved by commissioners or not.

If the wedding reception went forward at Bali Hai, the couple could end up with police officers or code compliance officers at their celebration and a fine being issued if there’s a noise complaint from nearby residential neighbors and a fine for the resort for hosting an event that’s not allowed to take place on the property and without a special event permit.

Titsworth said the court case is progressing as quickly as it can through the legal system and that the city will not give up the fight to bring the resort into compliance with city regulations.

Related coverage

 

Bali Hai legal dispute continues

 

Bali Hai owners receive code fines

 

Bali Hai site plan negotiations continue

Changes come to noise ordinance

HOLMES BEACH – City leaders are once again modifying the Holmes Beach noise ordinance in a bid to try to reduce excess noise in residential areas.

Commissioners voted unanimously on Aug. 10 to pass the first reading of an amendment to the city’s noise ordinance that adds language defining the term “plainly audible” and requires any mounted speakers to be pointed toward the home where they’re located instead of toward neighboring properties.

When considering the updates to the noise ordinance, commissioners sought the advice of attorney Erica Augello, who represents the city on code compliance matters.

Augello advised commissioners to remove language from the proposed update to the ordinance that would give officers too broad a reach when determining who the offender is in a noise violation. She said the proposed language would be unenforceable because it basically includes everyone in any way associated with the noise, from the person turning up the volume on a stereo to the company that made the speakers.

Another issue she found with the proposed ordinance changes was in the speaker direction specification. After some discussion, commissioners agreed to go with language that specifies that mounted speakers have to be pointed inward toward the property where they’re being used. Augello said specifying all speakers need to be pointed inward toward the property creates an enforcement issue because some speakers are portable and have a 360-degree shape, meaning they amplify sound on all sides. She added that it also becomes an issue for officers responding to a noise complaint in that they cannot enter a property to check the placement of speakers unless allowed on the property by the occupants.

In the language concerning the addition of the use of “plainly audible” as an enforcement tool for officers responding to noise complaints, the ordinance changes specify that the plainly audible tool can be used during nighttime and early morning quiet hours and that the offending noise must be easily heard by responding officers from a distance of 100 feet from the property line.

Commissioner Kim Rash said he’d like to see that distance reduced to 25 or 50 feet from the property line, however, Augello said it becomes more difficult to defend a case before a special magistrate or in court at a shorter distance. Police Chief Bill Tokajer said officers may be able to hear the noise from a closer distance and can use a different enforcement tool, such as the seven standards already in the ordinance for determining if noise is too loud or not.

Commissioners also agreed to have city staff look into a way that noise nuisance properties can be dealt with in a way other than fining different short-term vacation renters each week.

Commissioner Jayne Christenson said just fining a different group of renters each week will not change the overall behavior at rental homes.

The proposed changes to the noise ordinance will go back before commissioners for a final vote and a second public hearing during an upcoming regular meeting.

Related coverage

 

City buzzing about noise regulations

 

Holmes Beach commissioner receives noise warning

 

Commissioners consider changes to noise ordinance

Structural issues lead to new inspection regulations

Structural issues lead to new inspection regulations

HOLMES BEACH – City staff members are planning to present a proposed ordinance setting building inspection regulations to help identify structural issues before they become a hazardous situation.

Director of Development Services Eran Wasserman spoke to commissioners about the process for developing the proposed building inspection regulations during an Aug. 10 work session. Wasserman said he’s working with Building Official Neal Schwartz to create an ordinance to present to commissioners in the next 30 days outlining which structures will need to be inspected, how those inspections will need to be conducted and by whom and how often inspections need to be scheduled to recertify a property as safe.

The documents being used to help draft those standards are the ones required by Miami-Dade County, though Wasserman said the plan is to have stricter reinspection standards in Holmes Beach, including less time between inspections.

Commissioner Jim Kihm said he’s spoken to Schwartz, who’s talking with building officials from Anna Maria, Bradenton Beach and Longboat Key while drafting proposed standards for Holmes Beach.

Another consideration when deciding what regulations commissioners will want to enact in the city, Kihm said, would be what fees will need to be charged for the building recertification, if the city will require a third-party inspection before certification can be granted and what the penalty for noncompliance will be.

While the primary focus of the regulations would be multi-family structures, in light of a recent balcony collapse on a single-family structure, commissioners said they’d like to consider requiring anyone with a raised balcony to have their property inspected for structural issues on a regular schedule.

Raised balconies have recently been an issue in Holmes Beach. In recent months, a balcony on the rear of one of the Fountain Head Condominiums buildings, the north building at 3400 Sixth Ave., was reported by a repairman to have cracks in the stucco. In addition, a balcony recently collapsed at a single-family home at 4106 Sixth Ave. No one was injured at either property and both problems have been assessed by independent structural engineers.

The Fountain Head’s sister building at 3402 Sixth Ave., the south building, hasn’t had any reported issues with the structure or balconies, though Schwartz said the condominium association is planning to have it inspected as well to avoid any safety problems. He added that the north building’s balconies will have to be removed and rebuilt for the structure to be deemed safe. The units were built in 1984, according to Manatee County Property Appraiser records. They were used primarily as vacation rentals and were voluntarily evacuated on July 15.

The home at 4106 Sixth Ave. also has been voluntarily evacuated, Schwartz said, and permits have been issued for repairs, which include the rebuilding and shoring up of all balconies on the structure. That home is a part of the Holmes Beach Land Condos/6th Avenue Condominium Association Inc., along with five other structures on Fifth and Sixth Avenues built in 2002 and 2003 by 6th Avenue Development Inc. That company lists Ian K. Perryman as president and was dissolved on March 28, 2007. Holmes Beach building department records show that the builder of the properties in the 6th Avenue Condominium Association was Don Meilner & Son Construction Inc., which was officially dissolved in February 2021.

Schwartz said a letter was being distributed to the owners of all of the properties in the group to inform them of the balcony issues at the one property. The structural engineer’s report on the balcony collapse showed that it was caused by a property maintenance issue and not due to substandard construction methods. Schwartz said the letter was being distributed to put property owners on the alert for any possible issues.

Related coverage

 

City warns property owners to inspect structures

 

Building evacuated due to structural issues

 

Balcony collapses in Holmes Beach

 

Mark Platt

Island resident’s skateboard collection is art on wheels

HOLMES BEACH – Walking into the home of Mark Platt, you’ll see amazing, high-quality works of art on every wall, but it’s a little different than anything you will see in local galleries.

Platt has what he claims is one of Florida’s largest and most well-rounded collections of skateboards.

“It all started in the early 70s when skateboarding first began,” said Platt, explaining the genesis of his love for skating and collecting. “It’s just something that I caught on to right away and I really enjoyed doing. I pretty much skated for about 47 years.”

It’s not just skating; Platt has a passion for any board you can ride. He has been an avid surfer for decades and was one of the pioneers of snowboarding.

“I grew up in Michigan and started snowboarding in 1981 when I had to walk up a hill to take a ride when plastic snowboards first came out,” Platt said. “In 1985 I moved to Colorado, but there were only three mountains that allowed snowboarding – it had just started. In 1986 I did fantastic as an amateur so in 1987 I went pro in the Rocky Mountain division, eventually becoming 18th in the world.”

Platt says he used skateboarding to keep his balance at its peak during the snowboarding off-season. Whether it was surfing, skating or snowboarding, he says the balance required to do one will help you be successful at another. 

Platt is no longer able to surf, skate or snowboard due to the toll that decades of sports have taken on his body, but his passion for collecting has kept him close to the game.

“I started collecting seriously and professionally about 10 years ago,” Platt said. “I’m known as a builder; I like the hunt of putting boards together period correct. Everything you see here I have put together period correct. I’ve never bought anything that was already put together by someone else.”

Boards
A portion of Mark Platt’s collection of skateboards and snowboards. – Jason Schaffer | Sun

To understand what Platt means by “builder,” it’s important to understand that boards were used and wheels and components were replaced with aftermarket parts as they wore out. It’s much like a person who restores a classic car. They have to put together a car with serial numbers that match and use original parts to have the most valuable example. This can take years to accomplish, and Platt says the same is true with his boards. Finding original components from the 70s and 80s can be next to impossible, but that seems to be the thrill. 

As far as value, Platt says they can run from a couple hundred dollars to thousands. His most cherished and valuable example is a one-of-a-kind 1976 Kryptonics board with prototype wheels that never made it to market. There were only seven sets ever made and Platt said his board is the only complete example in existence. He says the value is in excess of $5,000, but isn’t entertaining any offers anytime soon. 

In addition to skateboards, Platt also has vintage surfboards, snowboards and related works of art, proof that art has no boundaries.