Skip to main content

Tag: Holmes Beach

Island Express Care provides on-Island health care

HOLMES BEACH – The Oct. 19 opening of Island Express Care provides Anna Maria Island residents and visitors with an urgent care facility that doesn’t require leaving the Island.

Located at 5348 Gulf Drive, Suite 4, in Holmes Beach, near Hurricane Hanks, Island Express Care is now open seven days a week from 8 a.m. to 8 p.m.

David and Courtney Feiner opened a health care clinic on Anna Maria Island. – Island Express Care | Submitted

Island Express Care is owned by Holmes Beach residents Dr. David Feiner and Courtney Feiner, a former nurse, and their business partner, Dr. Benjamin Miller.

The Feiners became Holmes Beach residents in 2024 and are now raising their four children on the Island. David maintains his orthopedic surgeon’s practice in Orlando and commutes between his new hometown and his longtime workplace.

Courtney oversees the administrative functions of the new clinic while also running her Feiner Design Company interior design firm and raising their four young children.

From left, Nicole Otney, Elaine Kuzyk and Sandy Lindstrom are part of the Island Express Care team. – Joe Hendricks | Sun

The Island Express Care staff features nurse practitioners, registered nurses and X-ray technicians. When The Sun visited Island Express Care on Oct. 22, the on-duty staff included Courtney, X-ray technician Nicole Otney, registered nurse Elaine Kuzyk and nurse practitioner Sandy Lindstrom. Dr. Feiner and Dr. Miller are not members of Island Express Care’s day-to-day medical staff.

SERVICES OFFERED

Operating as a direct-pay clinic, Island Express Care offers walk-in urgent care; on-site X-rays; in-house lab tests; minor medical procedures and orthopedic treatments; physicals and screenings; injections and administered medications; an in-house pharmacy that includes antibiotics, anti-inflammatories and other medications; IV therapy and NAD+ IV therapy; and MedSpa and weight-loss services.

Island Express Care is located at 5348 Gulf Drive in Holmes Beach. – Joe Hendricks | Sun

A full 129-item fee schedule can be found at the Island Express Care website. The listed prices include $200 for an initial visit; $150 for a follow-up visit; $75 for X-rays; $100 telehealth appointments during normal business hours; $150 after-hours telehealth visits; $200 to $300 laceration treatment; $50 EKG tests; $200 general physicals; $75 K-12 school physicals; and free school physicals for eligible Anna Maria Elementary students.

The Island Express Care IV lounge. – Joe Hendricks | Sun

The IV therapy treatments are $250 to $300 and include a Myers’ Cocktail and various immunity, mental clarity, jet lag/energy boost, hydration boost, hangover relief, anti-aging, weight-loss, and recovery and reboot IVs.

OWNERS’ THOUGHTS

When speaking to The Sun, Courtney said, “I didn’t need to do any market research to know that there’s a huge need. I know there’s demand for it because my kids are constantly getting hurt. We’re doing sutures on our countertop. There was such a need on the Island for health care in general and everyone would have to go over the bridge to get that immediate care they need, especially pediatric patients, vacationers and locals. There was nothing here on the Island. We don’t want to travel over the bridge, especially during the busy season and we saw a great opportunity to do this for our community.”

Dr. Feiner said there have been many times when they’re at the Holmes Beach skate park and someone goes down with an injury that might entail a sprain or a broken bone. 

“Now, you can come right in, get your X-ray, get your splint and be on your way. If things can wait till the morning, certainly you can show up at 8 a.m., walk in and be seen. If not, then you need to go to the emergency room,” he said.

“I can’t tell you how many times you see on Island Ratz or one of the other social media groups someone asking where to go for urgent care? We’d been coming to the Island for the past eight years and I felt the need for this since before we moved here. I certainly think this fills a big void,” he said.

“In terms of our urgent care services, you come to us for anything that you don’t think you need to go to an ER for, but you can’t be seen by your primary doctor, or you can’t get in somewhere quickly,” he said.

Dr. Feiner said he’s also established a relationship with Coastal Orthopedics in Bradenton so patients can be referred there when needed.

When asked what conditions do not warrant a visit to Island Express Care, Dr. Feiner said, “You don’t want to come to us with significant chest pain or heart attack issues. You don’t want to come to us with stroke-like symptoms, severe abdominal pain and things like that. If you think you have to call an ambulance, you shouldn’t be coming to us. We’re not a substitute for the emergency room.”

PEPTIDES

“We’re interested in getting into the peptides and wellness treatments too,” Dr. Feiner said. “Maybe traditional medications aren’t the answer for everything and maybe there are some alternatives we can use to help people in a way that we haven’t done. All these GLP-1 weight-loss medications are peptides and that’s probably been one of the most revolutionary medicines we’ve seen in my lifetime. It’s made people’s diabetes go away, their hypertension go away and their weight come down.”

DIRECT PAY

“We are a direct pay clinic. We are not in network with any insurances. This allows us to give affordable and transparent care,” Dr. Feiner said. “That doesn’t mean you can’t come here if you have insurance. We’ll be able to see you. You’ll pay our prices and you can submit a bill to your insurance and they may reimburse you for it, they may not. Most people who are on vacation are going to be out of network anyway, so wherever they go, their insurance is not going to cover it until it’s gone through the proper channels.”

FACILITY DESIGN

Regarding the clinic’s design and layout, Dr. Feiner said, “Courtney designed everything. She put the plans together. It’s beautiful aesthetically and that’s all a credit to her. In terms of the efficiency and layout, I said what do I do in a normal day when I see 45 patients in a few hours? How do I move around? Let’s build a space where we can move around in that kind of capacity and efficiency.”

Courtney Feiner oversees the clinic’s administrative duties. – Joe Hendricks | Sun

The Feiners praised Duncan Real Estate’s April Green and Darcie Duncan for helping them find the right location for the clinic, after previously assisting them with the purchase of their home.

“April is one of the most loyal people I’ve ever met. And I’ve never seen somebody go above and beyond so much. Every step of the way, she’s been our number one cheerleader. April and Darcie have really looked out for us,” Dr. Feiner said.

He also thanked Courtney’s parents, Larry and Cheryl Mulvey, who recently moved to the area and watched the kids while he and Courtney prepared the clinic for its opening.

“We’ve put everything we can into this space and it was just a tremendous undertaking, certainly with four kids,” he said.

Regarding the community’s support as a whole, Dr. Feiner said, “We’ve had a huge support system to get this thing done and the whole Island seems to have a great feeling about this place.”

Jaxx Wing Co. opens in Holmes Beach 

HOLMES BEACH – Jaxx Wing Co. owner Josh Hatch has opened a new location in Holmes Beach in the leased space at 3009 Gulf Drive previously occupied by Double Deez Chicago Style Restaurant.

The Holmes Beach location opened on Thursday, Oct. 22, and now offers a sports bar menu and extended hours aimed at filling a late-night food gap on Anna Maria Island.

The Holmes Beach location is the fourth Jaxx Wing Co. restaurant. The original, Jaxx Sports Bar and Grill, is in Palmetto. Hatch, who served in the U.S. Coast Guard for six years, opened a Bradenton location in 2024 and recently opened a second Palmetto location.

Hatch said the Holmes Beach location came about unexpectedly. As a Harley-Davidson rider, he often stops at the Anchor Inn while riding the Anna Maria Loop. He noticed Double Deez was closed on Mondays and Tuesdays, and he asked the property owners – Anchor Inn owners Bobby and Darla Tingler – to let him know if the restaurant space ever became available. About eight months later, when the Double Deez lease was not renewed, Hatch was offered the space.

Jaxx Wing Co. is now open at 3009 Gulf Drive in Holmes Beach. – Leslie Lake | Sun

The Jaxx Wing Co. menu features wings, but “It’s wings, beer and more,” Hatch said, noting the restaurant also serves wine.

The wings come with 15 sauce choices, including Stingin’ Honey Garlic, sweet teriyaki, sweet Thai chili and Carolina Tangy Gold, as well as five different dry rubs. Ten wings cost $18 and 20 wings cost $33. An order of boneless wings is $15.

The starters menu includes loaded fried pickle chips, tater tots, soft pretzel bites, shrimp poppers and Southwest egg rolls. The salads range from $12 to $15 and include house, Caesar, Greek, chef and Buffalo chicken salads.

Selling for $10 to $15, the sandwiches and wrap offerings include a Buffalo chicken sandwich, a Reuben, a Philly cheesesteak, a chicken Caesar wrap and a classic BLT. The menu also includes quesadillas, nachos and a pickle-brined, breaded fried chicken sandwich.

The burgers range from $14 to $18 and include a classic build-your-own burger and “The Heart Attack” burger that’s topped with tomatoes, onions, cheese, pastrami and Thousand Island dressing.

The Holmes Beach location opens daily at 11 a.m. It closes at 10 p.m. Sunday through Thursday and at midnight on Fridays and Saturdays. Hatch said the hours may change as needed, but he wants Jaxx to be a late-night food option on the Island.

“We’ve been the people stuck on the Island whenever there’s nowhere to grab food,” he said.

Hatch also plans to attract business from visitors staying in vacation rental homes by offering to cater the visiting group’s first meal on arrival day.

“Getting here is the worst day. No one knows what to eat,” Hatch said.

He said a dedicated catering menu, including in-home setup, will follow once the kitchen is running at full speed.

To-go and delivery orders can be placed at Jaxx Wing Co. website or by calling 941-213-9789.

Removing, moving campaign signs is illegal

HOLMES BEACH – Holmes Beach Police Chief Bill Tokajer recently issued a reminder that moving or removing a political campaign sign is illegal in Florida.

On Sept. 21, Tokajer issued the following statement: “As election season is upon us, it is important to be respectful to those running for election. If you remove election signs from property you could be charged with theft. If you are not a police officer, code officer or the property owner, you are not allowed to move or remove election signs. You saying you did not believe it was properly placed does not give you permission to move or remove election signs.”

Tokajer advised calling the police department or the code compliance department if you think a campaign sign has been improperly placed, removed or tampered with.

On Monday, Sept. 28, Officer Alex Hurt responded to a call from a resident who reported a missing campaign sign.

According to the police department incident report, “While on routine patrol, I was dispatched in reference to a theft of a political sign. I met with the complainant who advised he had a sign for Mark Hebden for city commission in his front yard that was removed without his permission. Complainant advised that the sign was gifted to him and he did not purchase it. The complainant last saw the sign Monday evening and has not seen it since. The complainant does not wish to press charges at this time.”

Holmes Beach mayor discusses potential paid parking

HOLMES BEACH – Mayor Judy Titsworth recently shared her thoughts on the possibility of paid parking becoming a reality in Holmes Beach at some point in the not too distant future.

Titsworth addressed paid parking while giving her mayor’s report during the Aug. 25 city commission meeting. Titsworth noted she recently had her annual meeting with Manatee County officials and there was reluctance at the county level to discuss paid parking at the Island’s county-owned public beaches in Holmes Beach and Bradenton Beach.

“They didn’t want to talk about it this year because it’s election season and they know that’s going to cause some anxiety as soon as you talk about paid parking at beaches,” Titsworth said.

She also referenced the recently presented parking study in Anna Maria that proposes paid parking and resident permit parking.

She referenced the Anna Maria mayor and said, “I have been in conversations with Mark Short. We’ve seen that they are looking at what they have to do. They invested in a parking plan. It was just unveiled.”

Regarding what might happen in Holmes Beach, Titsworth said, “Everybody knows that we’ve done our parking map and we’ve identified what we would have if we went forward with paid parking. We’ve just been sort of waiting until we were pushed into paid parking. We all have to do it at the same time.”

Titsworth noted Anna Maria and Holmes Beach already use the same Passport program for the issuance of parking tickets and the collection of parking ticket fines.

Although she’ll be stepping down as mayor in November, Titsworth anticipates Holmes Beach implementing a paid parking program that would be similar to the parking program Anna Maria expects to implement in March.

“We would be looking at protecting Holmes Beach property owners. Anna Maria would be looking at protecting theirs,” she said.

“Although we might have little different scenarios with our paid parking, we’re hoping they would be very similar as far as use for the people that are using it. We’re doing the background work in case it looks like it’s going to happen, or in case these two cities decide let’s do it, let’s not wait for the county. Staff has been prepared to act if we need to,” Titsworth said.

The public parking area at the end of 52nd Street currently provides free parking. – Joe Hendricks | Sun

Commissioner Carol Whitmore asked about Bradenton Beach’s paid parking plans. She said it would be nice if all three Island cities worked in continuity.

Titsworth said most of the beach parking in Bradenton Beach is at the county-owned beaches, but she anticipates Bradenton Beach implementing some form of paid parking program too.

Commissioner Jessica Patel asked the mayor if Holmes Beach has a parking map. Titsworth said that map can be found at the city website.

Whitmore asked how much residents pay for parking permits in the areas where permit parking is already in place. Police Chief Bill Tokajer said the annual resident parking permits are $10.

“I’m not paying to park when I live here,” Whitmore said.

Commissioner and mayoral candidate Dan Diggins said paid parking will be a heated issue during the next couple of years.

“We’re gonna get you all the information, so if it does come forward, staff will be able to give you everything for your consideration,” Titsworth said. “It could be messy when you start going to paid parking, but we’ll have all that information for you when you’re ready to talk about it.”

City hosts annual vacation rental stakeholders meeting

HOLMES BEACH – The Holmes Beach Code Compliance Department hosted its annual vacation rental stakeholders meeting on Tuesday, July 21.

This year’s theme was “Preserving Paradise Through Partnership,” and the two-hour session held at Holmes Beach City Hall brought together vacation rental operators, property managers, property owners and representatives from the Holmes Beach Police Department, the Holmes Beach Code Compliance Department, the Manatee County Property Appraiser’s Office, the Manatee County Tax Collector’s Office, the West Manatee Fire Rescue District (WMFR), Waste Pro and the Anna Maria Island Turtle Watch and Shorebird Monitoring organization.

Holmes Beach Police Chief Bill Tokajer spoke during the stakeholders meeting. – Ernie Vanderwalt | Sun

WMFR Fire Marshal Rodney Kwiatkowski said short-term vacation rentals account for a large share of the emergencies the fire district responds to. He said 73% of structure fires that occurred in the district between 2020 and 2023 occurred at vacation rental properties. He said all of the district’s drowning and near-drowning calls during the same period occurred at vacation rental swimming pools.

Kwiatkowski said the fire district doesn’t take a political position on short-term rentals. The district’s focus is on enforcement of the state fire code that applies specifically to short-term rental properties. He noted the district cannot impose stricter standards than the state allows and can only enforce what state law requires. He encouraged vacation rental owners and managers to familiarize themselves with the state fire code.

Holmes Beach Development Services Director Chad Minor said the city has issued roughly 5,000 building permits since the 2024 hurricanes. He said permitting isn’t optional for storm repairs, and the city requires a permit for most storm-related repair work, including drywall replacement.

Holmes Beach Code Compliance Officer Nate Brown outlined the growth of the city’s vacation rental registration program. He said when the program launched in 2016, the city had 245 registered short-term vacation rental units and relied on city staff to manually monitor rental websites and follow up on complaints. He said the registration program now includes approximately 1,600 registered units, which makes manual enforcement unworkable.

The city now uses Rentalscape software that scans more than 10,000 vacation rental websites per day to flag properties that are unregistered or otherwise out of compliance. Brown said the software doesn’t resolve every issue, but it gives the city data needed to act on problems before they escalate, rather than responding after a violation occurs. He said the system also spreads enforcement evenly across all properties rather than singling out individual owners.

Domenico Fragomeni, from the Manatee County Property Appraiser’s Office, discussed tax compliance for rental properties. He said any property rented out at any point during the year, whether short- or longer-term, must be reported to the appraiser’s office by filing Form DR-405, the tangible personal property tax return, by April 1. He said owners who file on time typically qualify for a $25,000 exemption on furniture, appliances and other taxable property provided in the rental.

In Manatee County, all vacation rentals, resorts, hotels and motels rented for six months or less are subject to the 6% tourist development tax.

Turtle Watch Office Manager Danielle Kimberly said approximately 417 sea turtle nests had been located on the Island so far this season and reminded vacation rental stakeholders about the city’s turtle lighting regulations for beachfront properties.

Request to vacate city property to be placed on fall ballot

HOLMES BEACH – In November, Holmes Beach’s registered voters will determine whether an undeveloped and vacant city-owned alley will be vacated to the owner of the beachfront property at 2902 Avenue E.

The vacation request pertains to a 10-foot-wide city-owned alley situated between two parcels on a currently vacant lot that previously contained two residential structures.

In 2024, Blowfish Island Inc. purchased the beachfront property from PL Beach House LLC for $7.25 million. Blowfish Island Inc. is a business entity that lists Benjamin ten Haff as its manager. Ten Haff hopes to redevelop the beachfront property with the construction of two new homes.

The city charter requires all vacations of city-owned land to be approved by a majority vote of Holmes Beach’s registered voters.

During two public hearings in 2025, the city commissioners unanimously approved the city ordinance that provides the commission’s support for the requested property vacation. The ordinance was to be followed later by a city resolution that includes the ballot language to be presented to city voters in the election that will conclude on Nov. 3.

During the June 23 city commission meeting, Holmes Beach Director of Development Services Chad Minor presented the city commission with the resolution and the proposed ballot language that reads as follows:

“Shall the city vacate an unused and inaccessible ten-foot-wide alleyway bisecting the coastal residential property at 2902 Avenue East from north to south, where such alleyway shall be vacated in favor of the property owner for that property, where such alleyway is not directly connected to any public right-of-way, prior rights of way have already been vacated, and the city commission approved such vacation by supermajority vote at public hearings?”

Voters will be asked to vote “Yes” to approve vacating the alleyway or vote “No” to deny vacating the alleyway.

The meeting packet included a staff report that said, “The vacated alleyway is not directly connected to any public right-of-way, as those rights of way have already been vacated.”

The staff report notes the alley is 10 feet wide, 150 feet long and contains 1,500 square feet of gross land area. The alley bisects the parent parcels to the north and south that total 34,000 square feet.

“The parent parcel was platted for six lots with three lots on either side of the alley. The platted lots were generally 50 feet wide and 100 feet in depth,” the staff report says. “The property will continue to have ingress and egress from Avenue E, an improved right of way. The alleyway is totally inaccessible by and to the public. There is an existing public beach access located to the immediate south of the subject property.” 

Attorney Garret Barnes is representing ten Haff and Blowfish Island Inc. in this matter. 

In an April 2025 letter he sent to Minor, Barnes wrote, “My client owns six buildable lots however, as mentioned, and as an accommodation to the city, they will only build on three of those six lots. This would be the benefit to the city and neighbors as the density is cut in half.” 

Barnes later informed the city that the property owner now intends to build two homes, rather than three.

With ten Haff in attendance during the June 23 meeting, Commissioner Jessica Patel asked if vacating the alleyway equates to the city giving the land away with no payment received in return. 

In response, City Attorney Randy Mora characterized the measure as a housekeeping action, noting the alley benefits the adjacent property owner while providing no use to the city. 

He said the city-owned alley prevents the property from being developed as currently desired. 

Mora noted the commission previously decided the city did not need the property in question for city use. 

While addressing the commission, Barnes said when the six lots were purchased that alleyways on either side had already been vacated, but the remaining alleyway had not. 

“We don’t know why it wasn’t vacated,” he said. 

Nancy Deal was the only resident to provide public comment on the request to vacate the alley. 

“Land is precious on this Island. When a chunk of it is given away, it requires a serious decision about the ramifications and the setting of precedent,” she said. “In this case, the hunk of land apparently has been public property and will probably bring the recipient significant financial gain. I remember the Cooper property trade-off. The city of Holmes Beach did receive recompense in the form of some land in exchange for vacating city property. As a taxpayer, I ask what of the city of Holmes Beach receiving in exchange for vacating this particular public property?” 

With Commissioner Dan Diggins absent, the commissioners voted 4-0 in favor of adopting Resolution 26-06. City voters will now have the final say in the matter. 

Holmes Beach: A planned community 

BY LAUREL NEVANS
SPECIAL TO THE SUN

HOLMES BEACH – When you hear the words “planned community,” they may evoke visions of homeowner’s associations, cookie-cutter houses and things like that. 

But actually, that type of planned community did not become popular until the 1960s, long after the community of Holmes Beach was established. Holmes Beach is a good example of the earlier type of suburban planning utilized after World War II ended in 1945. 

A 1957 plat map of Holmes Beach. – Manatee County Library | Submitted

Urban planning has existed for centuries. Planned in 1791 by Pierre L’Enfant, Washington, D.C. is a notable example. But suburban planning was something that came to be in the 20th Century, gaining popularity after World War II. 

The “Greenbelt communities” represent the earliest examples. During the 1930s, the federal government developed three experimental communities to address housing shortages and unemployment during the Great Depression, and to serve as models for cooperative, garden-style suburban living. Of these three, Greenbelt, Maryland, is perhaps the best known, and it still thrives as a community today. 

Influenced by the European “Garden City” movement, President Franklin Roosevelt’s Resettlement Administration initiated the Greenbelt program. The program focused on creating self-contained, cooperative communities that combine the best features of city and country living. It included ample green space, separated land uses and common ownership. It emphasized affordable, high-quality housing and communal facilities, and design that prioritized safety and community interaction. It included public spaces to foster a stronger sense of community among residents. The Greenbelt towns introduced innovative suburban planning concepts that influenced subsequent suburban development projects. 

Levittown was America’s first mass-produced suburb. It was built by William Levitt in 1947 on Long Island, New York, to meet the post-war demand for affordable housing for returning veterans. Using unprecedented assembly line techniques, Levitt & Sons quickly and cheaply built thousands of identical, modest, single-story homes. With prices affordable to many families, they symbolized the “American dream” of homeownership and suburban life. 

Levittown was the first example of the kind of planned communities that remain to this day – communities planned with amenities that include village greens, playgrounds and shopping areas to create a complete community using principles inspired by the Greenbelt cities.

HOLMES BEACH PLANNING

This history of suburban planning inspired Jack Holmes. After World War II, Holmes transformed the area that became Holmes Beach from a sparsely populated settlement into a residential and tourist community that contrasted with the earlier slow, homesteading-based growth. 

Jack Holmes had a vision for Holmes Beach. – Joe Hendricks | Sun

Holmes created a 600-acre master-planned community centered around a marina to attract returning veterans and their families, and he focused on developing infrastructure that enabled suburban living. A significant element of Holmes’ planning was the dredging of canals and bayous, which created waterfront lots and maximized residential density. 

A small airstrip was built in 1947 and the MGM musical “On an Island With You” was filmed there. Holmes soon added a yacht club and shopping centers that catered to both residents and tourists. 

City Field was an airfield at one point in time. – Joe Hendricks | Sun

By the time Holmes Beach was incorporated as a city on March 13, 1950, Holmes had already built and listed for sale over 200 homes in the area.

In contrast to Levittown, Holmes Beach did not encourage “cookie-cutter” architecture. Holmes Beach was built using a variety of builders and developers; and although homes shared certain characteristics, none of the early homes looked identical to their neighbors. Small cottages with yards and gardens dominated the landscape, with some larger, elevated or multi-story homes thrown into the mix.

An old aerial view of Holmes Beach. – Manatee County Library | Submitted

When developing his planned city, Holmes envisioned a diverse and inclusive community. Although his vision was for a community that was primarily residential, he also recognized the importance of tourism and part-time residents and he planned for a community that accommodated full-time, part-time and transient residents. 

He also integrated many of the principles first established in the Greenbelt communities of the early 20th Century. One of the biggest differences between Holmes Beach and the Greenbelt communities is that Holmes Beach was designed to accommodate a wide variety of income levels, from working class to the more affluent. This is reflected in the various residential zoning codes that each reflected the character the neighborhood was being designed around. 

Many Holmes Beach homes were built alongside man-made canals. – Joe Hendricks | Sun

Holmes developed a “resort zone” to accommodate transient visitors. Manatee Public Beach was established in 1952 to accommodate “day trippers” – the people who lived on the mainland, came to visit for the day and returned home. In the 1970s, Manatee County took control of the public beach and began operating it as part of the county’s public park system.

ZONING DISTRICTS

Holmes integrated several other aspects of early suburban planning into his new planned community. In addition to residential zoning, he included spaces zoned for Public/Semi-Public Use (PSP,) Private Recreation/Open Space (POS), Public Recreation (REC), Conservation (CON) and Preservation. 

Lots were priced according to their zoning code, with non-residential and non-commercial lots priced so non-profit organizations and houses of worship could be part of the community he envisioned. The now-vacated Gloria Dei Lutheran Church property carries the PSP zoning designation and a similar future land use map designation in the city’s comprehensive plan. 

This is one of the smaller homes in Holmes Beach. – Laurel Nevans | Submitted

Holmes planned a downtown in central Holmes Beach that included commercially zoned spaces, and a second commercial zone at the southern end of the city, closest to the highest density resort housing zone (A1). 

The first shopping center was developed in 1952. This zoning was a key component of Holmes’ vision for his new community; and his vision continues to be reflected in modern day Holmes Beach, where every update to the city’s comprehensive plan reflects the principles Holmes established in the mid-20th Century.

The resort/tourist zone was planned to be west of the main thoroughfares, as were the primary parts of the commercial zones. This was done to make the community more walkable and alleviate the need for visitors to cross the main roads to reach the beaches and businesses. The city was also planned to include the amenities families and retirees would desire in a community.

HOLMES BEACH GROWS

Holmes Beach continued to grow through the 1950s and 1960s. In 1950, the Island’s school was moved to Gulf Drive in Holmes Beach. In the early 1960s, the community of Holmes Beach became known as the fastest-growing community in Florida and this contributed to the school’s growing population. 

In 1953, Holmes Beach annexed into the city the northern portion of the former resort community known as Ixelhurst. The Jones and Casanas subdivisions were also annexed into the city.

In 1957, School Key was purchased by Peter Michelson. Michelson dredged the canals and planned the residences along them and created the Key Royale golf community. The last buildable lot on Key Royale was not sold until the early 1980s and the family who purchased it raised a family there and still lives there.

The Key Royale community dates back to the late 1950s. – Joe Hendricks | Sun
This home is part of the Key Royale community. – Joe Hendricks | Sun
This vacant lot is for sale in the Key Royale community. – Joe Hendricks | Sun

Holmes Beach continued development through the 20th century. As the city grew, so did its mix of residential options. The smaller “mom and pop” motels were built in the A1/Resort Zone. 

Holmes Construction was joined by other local developers who built homes that honored the spirit of Jack Holmes’ vision. 

Condominiums joined the mix. After the first high-rise Martinique condos were built in the early 1970s, local officials enacted the height restrictions that now limit all development to a maximum of three stories. This was done to help preserve the Island’s low-key, “Old Florida” charm. In 2019, the height restrictions were enshrined in the city charter – a document that can only be amended and revised with the approval of the city’s registered voters. 

Most of the condos still standing today were built during the 1970s through 1990s, as was the Seaside Gardens development that utilizes ground-level single-family and multi-family dwellings.

ISLAND CHURCHES

The Island churches also started forming in the 1950s, including the Island Baptist Chapel (now CrossPointe Fellowship), the Episcopal Church of the Annunciation and Saint Bernard Catholic Church. Gloria Dei Lutheran Church was formed in 1959, after one of the last PSP-zoned lots was purchased. Constructed in 1964, the building’s distinctive roof became a local landmark. Due to a shrinking congregation and the damage the church building sustained during the back-to-back hurricanes in 2024, the iconic building and the land it sits upon are currently for sale. 

The owners of the Gloria Dei property hope to rezone the property for residential development. – Joe Hendricks | Sun

Last year, the church ownership group declined the city’s $3 million offer to purchase the building and the property for continued public use. The three-parcel property was then listed for $9.95 million. Discussions recently took place between city staff, the mayor and a representative of the property owner regarding the property owners’ desire to rezone the church property to R-1 to allow for the residential development and a higher selling price for the church property. 

The mayor, the city commissioners and several community members have already expressed a shared desire to preserve this architectural landmark and the green space that surrounds it for future generations to enjoy. The pending rezoning efforts will soon be the subject of city commission discussion, debate and decision making, with the public also weighing in on the property owners’ rezoning request. 

CHANGE OCCURS

Up until the early 2000s, Holmes Beach remained a “hidden gem,” with a population primarily consisting of year-round residents, families, part-time residents known as “snowbirds” and weekend visitors from the Tampa Bay region. Holmes Beach also thrived as a lesser-known tourist destination, with visitors flocking to the variety of accommodations in the resort-zoned areas and enjoying the eclectic mix of businesses and amenities available within the city limits. 

Still under construction, this is one of the largest homes in Holmes Beach. – Joe Hendricks | Sun

As the city’s charm attracted more visitors from all over the world, the character Jack Holmes worked so hard to foster began to change. Outside developers began buying the original houses and razing them in order to build large vacation rental homes. Older ground-level homes that long served as annual rentals and provided homes for working-class families and those who worked on the Island began to disappear, creating workforce housing shortages and affordability challenges.

Over time, the influx of vacation rental homes began to disrupt the balance and residential character Jack Holmes created. In response, the city began tightening its building codes in an attempt to protect the remaining character of Holmes’ planned community.

This concrete-block duplex sits next to a vacant lot. – Laurel Nevans | Submitted

City officials also have to contend with the ongoing efforts of the state officials who continue to erode the city’s home rule rights, favoring a “one-size-fits-all” redevelopment approach, rather than a careful, well-thought-out approach to community planning.

These changes have disrupted the residential character and the sense of community that many Holmes Beach residents still want to preserve – and many residents continue to encourage their city leaders to protect what can still be protected of Holmes’ original vision. 

CITY EVOLVES

The city’s comprehensive plan continues to emphasize the principles Holmes Beach was built upon. Revisions to the future land use maps reinforced the planning principles that guided the city’s original development. Zoning codes and city ordinances were tightened and more strictly enforced to help preserve and reinforce the original nature and character of the city. 

The old Holmes Beach City Hall. – Manatee County Library | Submitted
Development regulations and decisions are made inside Holmes Beach City Hall. – Laurel Nevans | Submitted

The Grassy Point Preserve was established to protect the largest tract of undeveloped land that remains within city limits and other public recreation spaces were enhanced. 

New development-related site plans were more thoroughly scrutinized for consistency with the comprehensive plan and the zoning districts.

Today, Holmes Beach is an immensely popular tourist destination that offers a wide range of vacation rental and resort options while also serving as home to permanent and winter residents whose residences range from “Old Florida” charm to modern luxury.

The challenges of modern planning and preserving what remains of the city’s “small-town” feel require city officials to balance the needs of residents with the needs of the tourism industry and the needs of the real estate markets. This includes preserving the non-commercial, non-residential open space, public spaces, recreational spaces and preservation areas that enhance the quality of life for Holmes Beach residents and visitors.

As the city grows, our city officials must continue to work hard to ensure the character and amenities Jack Holmes planned for remain and are updated to reflect the changes this new century has brought with it. This is needed so Holmes Beach continues to reflect the ideals and structure of a planned community, so we can continue to enjoy what makes this community so special. 

This particularly applies to preserving the non-commercial and non-residential elements, rather than allowing open space, public use space, recreational space and preservation areas to fall victim to the whims of modern-day developers who do not focus on community, but rather on how much money can be made.

Holmes Beach has always been a planned community, based on the concept that good planning strengthens a community. Jack Holmes believed private developers could foster human growth and that was reflected in his vision that called for diversity in land use, amenities, architecture and residential development. 

Holmes Beach has never been merely just another “cookie-cutter” beach town. It has always been a thriving residential community that shares itself with visitors, whether they come from two miles away or 2,000 miles away. And continued good planning will help ensure the community and Jack Holmes’ original vision continue to thrive.

Holmes Beach residents oppose potential ferry landing location 

HOLMES BEACH – At least 35 Holmes Beach residents have signed a petition opposing a potential Gulf Island Ferry stop in the Waterline/Keyes Marina boat basin along Marina Drive. 

On several occasions, Bradenton Area Convention and Visitors Bureau Executive Director Elliott Falcione has publicly expressed the county’s desire for a ferry stop in Holmes Beach. 

And in recent months, City Commissioner Carol Whitmore has publicly acknowledged her efforts to help bring a ferry landing to the Waterline Villas & Resort boat basin. Several other government officials have also privately acknowledged the county’s efforts to purchase a boat slip or slips from the Waterline Villas & Marina owner or owners to use as a ferry stop. 

For a ferry landing to happen, the county will also need a city commission-approved site plan.

When offering general public comment during the Jan. 13 city commission meeting, three Holmes Beach residents shared their concerns about the potential ferry stop location. When doing so, they reiterated concerns they and others recently addressed in emails sent to the mayor and commissioners.

Holmes Beach resident Dana Sky opposes a ferry landing in the Waterline Villas & Marina boat basin. – Joe Hendricks | Sun

Speaking first, Dana Sky said, “While water-based transportation can be beneficial when thoughtfully planned, this location is simply, in our opinion, not appropriate. Keyes/Waterline marina is located within a quiet, R-1 (zoned) neighborhood that has historically supported low-impact marina activity and minimal evening traffic. Introducing a high-frequency ferry operation here would fundamentally change the character of this neighborhood and create safety and congestion issues that cannot be reasonably mitigated.”

“A far more suitable alternative already exists: the Kingfish Boat Ramp. The Kingfish Boat Ramp is a public, commercial facility designed to handle visitor volume, vessel traffic and public access. It is not embedded in residential streets and provides local, walkable access to Manatee Public Beach and local businesses.

“It’s important to recognize that Holmes Beach contributes significantly to the county’s tourist development tax revenues. When properly allocated, these funds can support infrastructure that welcomes visitors while protecting residential neighborhoods. Investing in a well-planned ferry facility, such as Kingfish, aligns with the intent of those funds and the city’s responsibility to its residents,” Sky said.

“There’s also been discussion that this ferry could benefit Island employees or reduce traffic. We’ve spoken directly with many employees who work on the Island and they’ve consistently told us that they would not rely on this service to get to and from work. The schedules don’t align with their shift times, some days it doesn’t run and service is not reliable due to weather delays, weather itself and capacity limits. Employees cannot risk being late or stranded.

“Keyes/Waterline marina also lacks basic infrastructure, including restrooms, covered waiting areas, ADA (Americans with Disabilities Act) access, adequate lighting and safe queuing space. Marina Drive is already one of the Island’s most congested corridors and increased pedestrian crossings, especially after dark, would create additional safety risks,” she said.

In 2024, a Gulf Island Ferry boat docked at the Waterline Villas resort, but due to space limitations, it could not safely travel to the far end of the boat basin. – Joe Hendricks | Sun

“From a marine safety standpoint, the channel is narrow, constrained and heavily used. Large vessels cannot safely pass, visibility is limited and a prior ferry attempt was unsuccessful. A comprehensive navigational study would be a bare minimum before this could be reasonably considered.

“Finally, placing hundreds of transient visitors per day into the heart of an R-1 neighborhood directly conflicts with the city’s comprehensive plan and the expectations of us residents.

“In closing, we respectfully ask the city to remove this Keyes/Waterline marina from consideration and to direct any future planning to locations that are appropriate, publicly oriented and consistent with residents’ safety and quality of life – most clearly Kingfish,” Sky said.

Speaking next, Daria Grinenko said, “I agree with everything Dana said.”

She then addressed additional concerns she has.

“I want to address the negative impact this increased usage would have on marine life, including dolphins and manatees that frequent this channel, as well as mangroves that buffer the land. There’s a personal seawall in this channel that has a highly cultivated reef that could be ruined by this increased boat traffic.

“I’ve estimated in high season that the current boat tours and rentals in this marina go out 24 times a day and back in 24 times a day. This doesn’t count the countless fishing charters and other recreational boaters that are in and out getting fuel and bait at Keyes Marina. If you add 18 more ferry rides to this basin it could be devastating to this established sea life. These impacts should be professionally evaluated for consistency with the Holmes Beach comprehensive plan policies addressing environmental protections and coastal resource preservation,” she said.

Grinenko mentioned the site plan approval process the county would have to follow and she said that process should include traffic impact studies, boater and pedestrian safety studies, the evaluation of marine life preservation reports and a review of overall compatibility.

Izzy Sky said many ferry passengers enjoy a low-priced boat ride to the Island (from downtown Bradenton) and are allowed to bring their own food, beverages and coolers. He said this results in some passengers not spending money at the Island’s local businesses and restaurants.

“We cannot be sold out to boatloads of people just to visit the Island. My question is simple: Why? The cup is full. You add any more people, it overflows,” he said.

The new, larger and partially enclosed Manatee Belle will be put into service soon and join the two pontoon ferry boats already in service. – Joe Hendricks | Sun

When the speakers finished, Commission Chair Carol Whitmore said the commission could not discuss a site plan process that could come before the commission in a formal setting if the county pursues that ferry landing location.

When asked, after the meeting ended, Development Services Director Chad Minor said the city had not received a site plan approval application from the county for a ferry stop in the Keyes/Waterline marina basin.

Related coverage: Manatee Belle joins Gulf Islands Ferry fleet

Holmes Beach: The Year in Review

Holmes Beach: The Year in Review

HOLMES BEACH – The city of Holmes Beach celebrated its 75th anniversary in 2025 and the Dec. 5 celebration at City Field was symbolic of the city’s return from the back-to-back hurricanes that struck Anna Maria Island in 2024.

The anniversary celebration occurred on the recently resodded City Field that one year ago contained a massive mound of hurricane debris while serving as the city’s hurricane debris management site.

Holmes Beach: The Year in Review
Mayor Judy Titsworth gave a speech during the 75th anniversary celebration in December. – Joe Hendricks | Sun

The anniversary celebration was preceded earlier in the year with Mayor Judy Titsworth unveiling the new sea turtle-themed city flag that now flies over city hall. The city also produced smaller versions of the new flag and similarly designed T-shirts and hats that also feature the sea turtle logo.

Post-hurricane permitting

During each city commission meeting and planning commis­sion meeting in 2025, Develop­ment Services Director Chad Minor provided a post-hurricane permitting update that dated back to Hurricane Helene in September 2024.

On Dec. 16, Minor said the city, to date, had issued 3,764 post-hurricane permits and 79 demolition permits. He said 75 homes had been demolished and the city had issued 19 permits for new replacement homes. Minor said the city conducted 9,768 post-hurricane plan reviews and completed nearly 13,000 inspec­tions. He also said there were currently 1,660 active, registered vacation rentals in Holmes Beach.

Gloria Dei property

On Jan. 18, a “Holy Closure” service was held at Gloria Dei Lutheran Church, marking the end of its time as an active church and local congregation.

Holmes Beach: The Year in Review
The city’s $3 million offer to buy the Gloria Dei property was rejected. – Joe Hendricks | Sun

In late June, Taylor Rahdert, the real estate agent representing the property owners, informed Minor that the Florida Bahamas Synod Council declined the city’s $3 million offer to purchase the three-parcel church property for public use. The church building and property remain on the market with a $9 million asking price.

Speed control

In August, the recently installed automated speed cameras were activated near the Anna Maria Elementary school and dozens of warnings and citations were issued to drivers who failed to obey the 15-mph speed limit during the morning and afternoon hours when the students are arriving and departing.

Holmes Beach: The Year in Review
Automated speed cameras were installed by Anna Maria Elementary before the new school year began in August. – Joe Hendricks | Sun

Holmes Beach: The Year in Review
Two speed tables were installed along the 500 block of Key Royale Drive in October. – Joe Hendricks | Sun

On Oct. 31, two previously de­bated speed tables were installed along the 500 block of Key Royale Drive. Some 500 block residents supported the new speed tables and some Key Royale residents who live on the other side of the Key Royale Bridge opposed them.

 Millage, stormwater rates

In July, the city commission voted 3-2 in favor of setting the maximum property tax millage rate at 2.1812 mills rather than maintaining the current 1.99 millage rate. In September, the commission changed course and voted in favor of maintaining the 1.99 rate for another year.

During the same July budget meeting, the commission voted 3-2 in opposition to increasing the annual stormwater fee levied on Holmes Beach property owners from $2.95 per 100 square feet of property to $4.95 per 100 square feet and the $2.95 rate was maintained for another year.

Comings and goings

In February, longtime city commissioner Pat Morton announced his resignation, citing social media criticism of the city’s hurricane response as the primary reason. Later that month, the commission unanimously appointed planning commissioner Steve Oelke to fill the remaining months of Morton’s two-year term.

In the city election that conclud­ed Nov. 4, Oelfke was the leading vote-getter in the election that resulted in first-time candidate Jessica Patel being elected and longtime commissioner Carol Soustek not being reelected.

In October, Public Works Director and City Engineer Sage Kamiya announced he had ac­cepted an offer to serve as the city of Sarasota’s new city engineer. In December, Mayor Judy Titsworth announced Herb Raybourn, a stormwater consultant for the city, would serve as the city’s next public works director and city engineer.

In December, longtime City Clerk Stacey Johnston informed the mayor that she would be retiring in March.

On Dec. 16, City Attorney Erica Augello participated in her final meeting as the Holmes Beach city attorney and the commission sup­ported the mayor’s appointment of Randy Mora to serve as Augello’s successor. Augello will continue to represent the city in code compliance matters and she’s also currently serving as the interim city attorney for the city of Bradenton Beach – an assignment that may become permanent in 2026.

In November, the Rod & Reel restaurant opened in Holmes Beach as an extension of the Rod & Reel Pier and restaurant in Anna Maria that was destroyed by the 2024 hurricanes. Owner Oliver Lemke hopes to one day rebuild and reopen the pier and restaurant in Anna Maria.

Solo’s Pizza closed in late November, Cheesecake Cutie closed in December and the True Value hardware store changed ownership in 2025.

Holmes Beach celebrates 75th anniversary

Holmes Beach celebrates 75th anniversary

HOLMES BEACH – The city marked its 75th anniversary with a large, well-attended outdoor celebra­tion at City Field on Dec. 5.

The event was held on the recently resodded City Field grounds that one year ago served as the city’s hurricane debris staging site.

Co-sponsored by the Bradenton Area Convention and Visitors Bureau and Waste Pro, the Friday evening celebration included live music by Trevor Bystrom’s Rooster X-ing and Jah Movement.

Holmes Beach celebrates 75th anniversary
Trevor Bystrom’s Rooster X-ing performed at the anniversary celebration. – Joe Hendricks | Sun

City Field was surrounded by food and drink vendors and vending tents, trailers and vehicles occupied by local businesses, service providers and non-profit organizations. The family-friendly celebration included bounce houses and inflatable slides, a heartfelt speech by Mayor Judy Titsworth and the announce­ment of this year’s Citizen of the Year award winner.

Holmes Beach celebrates 75th anniversary
Youngsters enjoyed the bounce houses and slides. – Joe Hendricks | Sun

Shortly after 6 p.m., Titsworth stood on stage and said, “What an incredible night. It’s time our community had some fun. This year we celebrate an incredible milestone: 75 years as the city of Holmes Beach. It’s an honor to reflect on how far we’ve come and how this community grew into the vibrant, beloved coastal city we know today.

“As a lifelong resident, I can tell you there’s truly no better place to live, raise a family or visit. People travel from all over the world for our stunning beaches, small town charm and the unique character preserved by our height and density limits,” Titsworth said.

“Holmes Beach was founded 75 years ago by my grandfather, John E. Holmes Sr., along with partners who dreamed of creating a modest tropical community where families and retirees could enjoy Island living. In 1950, we had 65 residents and a property value under $500,000. Today, our value is more than $3.2 billion. That’s a testament to generations of thoughtful planning and community pride,” she said.

“Growing up here meant roaming freely, exploring our rich marine life and supporting local shopkeepers who made the Island feel complete. That sense of place – its biodiversity, simplicity and warmth – is what we have worked so hard to protect. Balancing the needs of residents, visitors and the environment hasn’t been easy, but it’s essential,” Titsworth said.

“Our emergency management team guided us through two catastrophic hurricanes (in 2024), removing 127,000 cubic yards of sand and debris. Everyone remembers ‘Mount Titsworth?’ We’re standing there,” she said of the debris removal efforts that subjected her and the city to criticism from some commu­nity members.

“I am deeply grateful to every person who played a role in our recovery,” she added.

She also mentioned the new sea turtle-themed city flags and hats, the city’s improved relations with county officials, the city’s decreased crime rates, Holmes Beach’s economic prosperity and the significant tourist development tax revenues generated by the Holmes Beach resorts and vacation rentals.

“Here’s to 75 years of tradition, resilience and community; and to the bright future ahead for the city of Holmes Beach,” she said.

Titsworth then surprised Hurricane Hanks restaurant owner Brian Mathae when she announced him as this year’s Citizen of the Year award winner.

Holmes Beach celebrates 75th anniversary
Hurricane Hanks owner Brian Mathae learned from Mayor Judy Titsworth that he was this year’s Citizen of the Year. – Joe Hendricks | Sun

After Mathae joined her on the stage, Titsworth said, “We’re honoring his unwavering com­mitment to helping others in the wake of the hurricanes, for going above and beyond in service and providing vital resources.”

She noted Mathae fed first responders and city staff during hurricane recovery efforts and be­fore that housed animals displaced by a fire at the Holmes Beach Business Center. She also praised his support for the Anna Maria Island Turtle Watch and Shorebird Monitoring organization.

“Your impact is immeasurable and you’re a true asset to the community,” Titsworth said.

Holmes Beach celebrates 75th anniversary
“Paw Patrol” character Marshal and WMFR Fire Marshal Rodney Kwiatkowski greeted young festival attendees. – Joe Hendricks | Sun

While standing near the West Manatee Fire and Rescue tent with “Paw Patrol” TV show character Marshal (a fire dog), Fire Marshal Rodney Kwiatkowski said, “It’s a beautiful night and a great crowd.”

At the Anna Maria Island Historical Society tent, Holmes Beach resident Carolyn Orshak said, “We recovered. It’s party time.”

Holmes Beach celebrates 75th anniversary
City Field was once again the scene of community celebration. – Joe Hendricks | Sun

Rob Self was born and raised in Holmes Beach and after listening to the mayor’s speech he said, “It’s great to see everybody out here again.”

Holmes Beach resident Tom McFarland said he too was happy to see events happening at City Field again.

City baseball field being restored

City baseball field being restored

HOLMES BEACH – The city-owned Birdie Tebbetts Field has been re-sodded and is being restored and enhanced.

Once a regulation-size field, the new field is built to Little League dimen­sions, has new sod, new layers of clay on the base paths and the pitching mound, a new pitcher’s rubber, a new home plate and new bases.

The restoration of the field is another step in the city’s ongoing hur­ricane recovery efforts that continue more than a year after Hurricanes Helene and Milton struck Anna Maria Island in 2024.

On Nov. 18, Development Services Director Chad Minor and Public Works Department Project Manager Matt Gorman briefly discussed the field restoration with the mayor and city commissioners. Minor said the clay had been ordered and was expected to arrive soon. Gorman said base paths would get about 2 inches of new clay and the elevated pitching mounds would get 6-8 inches of new clay.

Gorman said the backstop fence would be adjusted slightly to correct the field dimensions and some fence repairs would be needed as well. He said he hoped to have the restorations fully completed by Dec. 5.

“All the kids here who play baseball here are very grateful for this,” Com­missioner Jessica Patel said.

She noted some of the teams that play at the county-owned G.T. Bray Park in west Bradenton are looking for additional fields to play and practice on.

“Keep in mind it’s not lit,” Mayor Judy Titsworth said.

“This is the type of field I would have loved to play on when I was kid,” Gorman said.

“If you build it, they will come,” Titsworth said in reference to the classic “Field of Dreams” baseball movie starring Kevin Costner.

City baseball field being restored
The city-owned baseball field is named after former Major Leaguer George “Birdie” Tebbetts. – Joe Hendricks | Sun

The field is named after former Major League Baseball player, manager and scout George “Birdie” Tebbetts. From 1936-52, Tebbetts was catcher for the Detroit Tigers, Boston Red Sox and Cleveland Indians. He then spent 11 years as a manager for the Cincinnati Reds, Milwaukee Braves and Cleveland Indians.

In 1956, while managing the Reds, Tebbetts was named Manager of the Year by the Baseball Writers’ Associa­tion of America. He spent 28 years as a Major League scout. He moved to Anna Maria Island in the early 1960s and passed away in Bradenton in 1999 at age 86.

No millage increase for Holmes Beach property owners

No millage increase for Holmes Beach property owners

HOLMES BEACH – The mayor and city commissioners are maintaining the current 1.99 millage rate rather than increasing it to the maximum 2.1812 millage rate tentatively adopted by a 3-2 vote in late July.

During the city commission’s Sept. 11 budget hearing, City Treasurer Julie Marcotte presented a revised budget that’s now based on maintaining the 1.99 millage rate. The commission adopted on first reading the millage rate and budget ordinances that will be presented for final adoption on Thursday, Sept. 25. The new fiscal year begins on Oct. 1.

The proposed $22.07 million 2025-26 budget represents a $3 million decrease from the current $25.23 million fiscal year budget.

No millage increase for Holmes Beach property owners
Shown here at a July meeting, City Treasurer Julie Marcotte played a significant role in crafting the city’s 2025-26 fiscal year budget. – Joe Hendricks | Sun

When presenting the proposed budget in early July, Marcotte and Mayor Judy Titsworth proposed a tentative 2.1812 millage rate increase to help offset what was then expected to be an 8.33% decline in total as­sessed Holmes Beach property values. As the county’s property valuation process continued, the estimated total property value decrease was revised to 7.99% for the coming tax year. When property values increase and the millage rate remains the same, property taxes and the city’s property tax revenues increase; and the op­posite happens if property values decrease.

Marcotte said some of the budget revisions were the result of getting more detailed revenue projections from the state and county. She said updating the employee salary schedule and employee health insurance policy selections saved an additional $51,163 and updating the city’s property and casualty insurance costs saved an additional $28,000.

The revised budget includes an additional $100,000 increase in es­timated building permit fee revenues and the reallocation of $25,000 in city funds to the police department budget to help cover the cost of patrolling the county-owned beach and boat ramp. Titsworth hopes to recoup that $25,000 from the county during the new fiscal year.

The Islanders 4 Clean Water budget was trimmed by $15,000, the contin­gency fund was reduced by $150,000 and a $100,000 potable water project was removed from the budget.

The budget lists the mayor’s annual salary at $29,200 and the commis­sioners’ annual salaries at $8,340.

“With these changes, we were able to set the millage rate at 1.99 and have 25% of our unrestricted reserves that is suggested by the GFOA (Govern­ment Finance Officers Association) and auditors for our governmental needs,” Marcotte said.

When comparing the new budget to the current budget, Commission Chair Dan Diggins said the mayor and commission expenditures are decreas­ing by $50,000, general government expenses are decreasing by $200,000, police department expenditures are increasing by $200,000 (in part to hire an additional officer), building department expenses are increasing by $180,000 and anticipated Public Works Department expenditures are decreasing by $900,000 due to the completion of several projects.

Commissioner Steve Oelfke asked Marcotte if it’s accurate to say the city created a budget that provides a tax cut to the taxpayers. Marcotte said that is correct.

Commissioner Carol Soustek thanked the department heads and employees that eliminated or post­poned some of their planned projects and expenditures.

“What that does is show the com­munity that we understand where you’re coming from,” Soustek said in regard to potentially increasing the millage rate at a time when many property owners are still recover­ing from the 2024 hurricanes.

“I just want to congratulate the mayor and Julie for doing such remarkable work,” Diggins added. “It lets the community know that we understand what you’ve been through. I think it’s the right thing to do.”

“I wasn’t certain we could do this,” Commis­sioner Terry Schaefer said. “Getting it back to the existing millage without a loss to service is remarkable and I, too, want to compliment the mayor, our treasurer and all of the depart­ment heads.”

Participating by phone, Commissioner Carol Whitmore said, “Thank you mayor for working so hard on this. I know it wasn’t easy and I appreciate it; and so do our citizens.”

See the entire 2025-26 fiscal year budget here.

Vacation rental stakeholders share common goals

Vacation rental stakeholders share common goals

HOLMES BEACH – Working together and supporting each other’s efforts were two main themes shared during the Vacation Rental Stakehold­ers meeting held at Holmes Beach city hall on Sept. 10.

More than 50 short-term vaca­tion rental owners, managers and employees attended and participated in the two-hour meeting facilitated by Holmes Beach Code Compliance Chief James “JT” Thomas.

The speakers and presenters included Mayor Judy Titsworth, Police Chief Bill Tokajer, Development Ser­vices Director Chad Minor, Building Official Neal Schwartz, Development Services Coordinator Kim Charron, Code Compliance Officers Nate Brown and Sandy Olson, West Manatee Fire & Rescue Fire Marshal Rodney Kwiatkowski, Waste Pro District Manager Ben VanderBaan, Code Compliance staff member Allyson Kalicharan, Code Compliance Officer Jason Clayton and Thomas.

Vacation rental stakeholders share common goals
Mayor Judy Titsworth thanked the short-term vacation rental industry representatives for their efforts. – Joe Hendricks | Sun

Speaking first, Titsworth welcomed the vacation rental owners and repre­sentatives and thanked them for all the cooperation they’ve exhibited in recent years as part of the ongoing efforts to make Holmes Beach a place where people want to live and vacation.

Chief Tokajer said, “You guys are doing a great job,” when praising the vacation rental owners and manag­ers for significantly reducing noise complaints and preventing large house parties. He said guest parking remains a concern and he asked that rental guests be reminded to park between the lines (where lines exist), park in designated areas when applicable, park with the flow of traffic and park with all tires off the pavement.

Vacation rental stakeholders share common goals
The stakeholders meeting was well attended and more stakeholders arrived as the meeting progressed. – Joe Hendricks | Sun

In response to a question posed by an attendee, Tokajer said vacation rental guests must leave the Island when hurricane evacuations are ordered because no one will rescue them once the winds reach 45 mph. He also said rental guests will not be allowed through the post-hurricane re-entry checkpoints after 7 p.m. while those are in effect.

On behalf of the building depart­ment, Schwartz, Charron and Minor stressed the importance of securing the proper permits to make hurricane damage repairs – and to not be afraid to come to the city and work with the city to ensure full compliance with city code and National Flood Insurance Program and FEMA regulations.

“It’s not too late. Please come talk to us. We will work with you. We will issue after-the-fact permits,” Charron said, noting the city doesn’t want to lose the flood insurance discount given to all Holmes Beach property owners, which increases to 25% on Oct. 1.

“The doors are always open here,” Minor added.

In response to a question about bringing damaged and repaired vacation rental homes back online – including those recently purchased by new owners – Thomas said the city can assist with the research needed to obtain a city-issued vacation rental certificate.

Kwiatkowski stressed the point that the fire district’s now-mandatory annual inspections of short-term vaca­tion rentals (Transient Public Lodging Establishments) are conducted to save lives and ensure public safety and the fire district has no desire to slow or impede vacation rental activities.

Representing Waste Pro, Vander­Baan thanked the rental owners and managers for their cooperation and encouraged them to contact Waste Pro regarding any service issues. He asked them to remind guests to leave a clear path to and from the trash and recy­cling receptacles along the side of the house because Waste Pro employees will not attempt to retrieve or return the receptacles at the risk of damaging vehicles parked in the way. He also asked the rental owners and managers to remind their cleaning staffs not to bring to the street receptacles that require side-door service.

Vacation rental stakeholders share common goals
Meeting facilitator and Code Compliance Chief James “JT” Thomas guided the discussion with humor and inclusion. – Joe Hendricks | Sun

During the following day’s city commission meeting, Titsworth and commissioners Steve Oelfke and Carol Soustek praised Thomas for the congenial and engaging manner in which he conducted the annual stakeholders meeting.

The city’s presentations can be found here.
The WMFR presentation can be found here.

Holmes Beach commissioner proposes paid beach parking

Holmes Beach commissioner proposes paid beach parking

HOLMES BEACH – City commissioner Dan Diggins suggested implementing paid parking within a quarter mile of the city-controlled public beach access points located at numerous street ends throughout the city.

Diggins proposed the pursuit of paid beach parking as a non-agenda item during the commissioners’ comments given at the end of the Aug. 26 Holmes Beach City Com­mission meeting.

Holmes Beach commissioner proposes paid beach parking
Commissioner Dan Diggins asked his fellow commissioners to consider paid beach parking. – Joe Hendricks | Sun

Mayor Judy Titsworth and commis­sioners Steve Oelfke, Terry Schaefer and Carol Soustek said paid parking might be inevitable someday, and it might warrant further discussion now, but they don’t support paid parking at this time. Commissioner Carol Whitmore was more adamant and said she’d fight any city efforts to imple­ment paid beach parking.

When proposing paid parking and requesting future commission discus­sion, Diggins acknowledged he’s not a parking expert and he doesn’t have any logistics or specifics worked out. It’s simply an idea he’d like to pursue.

“I’ve been giving this a lot of thought and I talked to staff, I talked to the mayor, I talked to some of the county folks about this,” he said.

Regarding the currently free parking areas designated at the city’s street-end beach access points, Diggins said, “Where all the ropes and bollards are, those would be paid parking, with an exception for residents.”

Diggins referenced the 42-page Island-wide Urban Land Institute (ULI) study completed in 2015. The ULI study was never used to any significant degree by any of the three Island cities, which each contributed more than $30,000 to help cover the $125,000 cost of the contracted study that offered a never-implemented “Vision for Anna Maria Island’s Future.”

“One of the recommenda­tions said free parking is not a right,” Diggins said. “I’m just wondering if it’s time for us to revisit our paid parking policy at some point in the future and develop some type of plan for paid beach parking. I think it might be time to do that. The county would have to do it and the other cities would have to do it at the same time. I want to know what you guys think. I think it’s a way to raise revenue because we know revenue sources are drying up.”

Manatee County owns and controls Manatee Beach and the beach parking lot in Holmes Beach. The county also owns and controls Coquina Beach and Cortez Beach and their parking lots in Bradenton Beach.

Diggins said he talked to representatives of a couple of companies that provide paid parking systems and he was told the automated payment technology exists and the automated systems can also help motorists find available parking spaces without having to drive around looking for an open space.

“If you want to go to the beach, you have to pay for it,” Diggins said.

Commission feedback

Whitmore, a former county commissioner, said, “I 100% don’t support it. I didn’t support it when I was at the county.”

Whitmore said there’s not much left in life that people can enjoy for free anymore, especially the elderly and those who don’t have a lot of money.

“I don’t think that we should do that to our citizens. We have so many more important things to do than charge poor people for more stuff,” she said.

Holmes Beach commissioner proposes paid beach parking
Commissioner Carol Whitmore adamantly opposes paid beach parking. – Joe Hendricks | Sun

Oelfke agreed with much of what Whitmore said.

“I think we want to try avoid that as long as possible, but I think it might be inevitable at some point,” he said, noting he’d want the county to take the lead on paid beach parking.

“I do like the idea of look­ing for additional revenue sources. I would support increasing parking fines,” he added.

“I’m not for it,” Soustek said, noting the city “worked long and hard” on its current parking provisions.

The city’s current parking provisions include designated free parking spaces at the street-end beach access points and those areas are marked with ropes and bollards and small white, green and black markers that feature an encircled letter “P,” or parking bumpers designated with an encircled “P.”

Holmes Beach commissioner proposes paid beach parking
The encircled “P” markers on the 52nd Street beach access parking bumpers mean public parking is allowed, and is currently free. – Joe Hendricks | Sun

Holmes Beach commissioner proposes paid beach parking
Beach parking is allowed in areas where encircled “P” markers are placed on wooden bollards. – Joe Hendricks | Sun

Red and white signs designate the nearby city rights of way further from the beach access points where streetside parking is restricted to residents between 9 a.m. and 5 p.m., with city-issued stickers used to identify residents’ vehicles.

Holmes Beach commissioner proposes paid beach parking
Several designated Holmes Beach streets allow resident-only parking during the day.

“You’re never going to have enough parking out here. I don’t care what you do,” Soustek said.

“Until it’s an issue we have to look at, I would prefer not to,” she added, noting that she doesn’t mind discussing it further.

Schaefer said, “I’ve never been a proponent of paid parking. If it ever comes to pass, I can’t imagine charging our residents to park within our city.”

Schaefer noted the city had to previously defend itself from the previous county commission’s desire to build a multi-level parking garage at the county-owned Mana­tee Beach. Schaefer said he favors leaving the current parking provi­sions in place until it’s necessary to get in unison with what the county and the other two Island cities do in terms of paid parking.

Titsworth said the city did some preliminary research on paid parking when the since-discarded county parking garage was still in play, but she hopes paid beach parking doesn’t happen while she’s mayor.

“It’s inevitable. I hope inevitable happens when I’m not in this chair,” she said, adding that many residents live on the other side of the bridge now because they were priced out.

“The fact that they get to come back here and park for free and enjoy the beaches is good. Whether it’s now or later, that’s entirely up to this board,” she said, adding that she hopes it can stay free “for a little bit longer.”

Holmes Beach commissioner proposes paid beach parking
Free beach parking is available at the 52nd Street beach access in Holmes Beach. – Joe Hendricks | Sun

Regarding the search for additional revenues, Titsworth said convincing the Legislature to provide the Island cities with a larger share of the signifi­cant tourist development tax revenues generated on the Island is a more immediate concern than paid parking revenues.

After hearing what the mayor and other commissioners had to say, Diggins said it would likely take a year or two, or longer, to come up with a workable paid parking plan that includes the county and the other two cities and now is the time to start working on it.

“We could have a workshop on this,” Soustek said. “Be prepared to have this chamber filled. Bring them in and explain why you want to discuss it, because you feel the inevitability of it.”

“It’s worked in a lot of beach com­munities,” Diggins said.

Whitmore again noted some people, including those who live on the main­land, can’t afford to pay for parking when visiting the Island beaches.

“Those are the people that really need our beaches,” she said.

Oelfke and Schaefer supported discussing paid parking with county officials to get a feel for where they currently stand on the issue. Titsworth said she would ask county staff to add a paid parking discussion to the agenda for the joint Holmes Beach/Manatee County meeting to be held at the county administrative building in downtown Bradenton on Wednesday, Sept. 3 at 1:30 p.m. That meeting will be livestreamed at the county website.

“Don’t we have more important things to talk about?” Whitmore lamented.

Diggins noted the county plans to charge boaters to use the boat ramps to be built at the county-owned Cortez Marina when that county facility is constructed on the property formerly occupied by the Seafood Shack and Annie’s Bait and Tackle before the county bought the property in Decem­ber. There’s also been some informal public discussion about possibly charging boaters to use the other county boat ramps as well.

“People who use the service have to pay for it; and to me, paid beach parking fits in that category,” Diggins said. “We don’t have to implement it, but we can gather information to see what we don’t know.”

“I’ll fight it all the way,” Whit­more said.

Holmes Beach officials decline to increase beach cabana regulations

Holmes Beach officials decline to increase beach cabana regulations

HOLMES BEACH – Concerns about advertising and logos placed on rented beach cabanas have been addressed to the mayor’s satisfaction and the city is not taking any additional steps to regulate cabana rentals.

At the request of Commissioner Carol Whitmore, cabana rentals and commercial beach activities were discussed during the Holmes Beach commission’s July 25 meeting as a follow-up to a previous discussion Mayor Judy Titsworth initiated on June 24.

During the June meeting, Titsworth said city’s code compliance officers asked the beach cabana rental compa­nies to remove all advertisements and signage from their cabanas because the city’s sign ordinance prohibits advertising on the beach. The cabana companies were given until June 27 comply. Titsworth also expressed concerns about some cabana rental companies staking out prime beach areas by setting up cabanas that had not been reserved and in advance offering them for rent, and about commercial activity on public lands in general.

When the July 25 discussion began, Whitmore said she wanted to get a better understanding of how the cabana rental companies operate. She also questioned whether the city’s sign ordinance could be amended to assist businesses that provide a beneficial service to beachgoers.

“I think we’re trying to fix a problem that’s not broken,” Commission Chair Dan Diggins said. “I don’t like the idea of putting all these restrictions on people. We don’t do this to the golf cart folks. We don’t do it to Uber Eats. We don’t do it to anybody else, so why would we do it here? It’s a thriving business. They provide a great service to the community and tourism. The equipment is outstanding and most of it’s better than the crap people buy at Walmart and leave in the trash container or leave on the beach for somebody else to clean up.”

Regarding her previously stated beach advertising concerns, Titsworth said, “It’s fixed. We don’t have an issue with renting equipment and putting it on the beach. It was the signs. We have a sign ordinance that doesn’t allow advertising on the beach. They just can’t stake out ground ahead of time with their signs and QR codes saying, ‘rent me.’ ”

Holmes Beach officials decline to increase beach cabana regulations
Mayor Judy Titsworth said her beach cabana advertising concerns have been addressed. – Joe Hendricks | Sun

When addressing the many cabana company owners and employees in attendance, Titsworth said, “You can ruin something by too much of a good thing and I think we’ve all seen that. It’s one thing to have one cabana company that promises not to advertise and start putting stuff out (unreserved). It’s another thing when you walk the beach and see every single company with tents galore. Get rid of the advertising. We’re OK if you’re out there, but the minute you take it too far we’re going to have residents saying ban all tents on the beach. Everyone needs to try to reel it in. Let’s try not to graffiti the beaches.”

Commissioner Terry Schaefer said, “There’s never been opposition to the service. The whole issue was about advertising and pre-placement.”

He noted at least one cabana rental company was recorded placing unreserved cabanas on the beach.

“Not only do I see a benefit, I see providers who really want to engage,” Commissioner Steve Oelfke said.

He questioned if there’s more the city can do to ensure that those who have insurance and properly secure their cabanas aren’t negatively impacted by those who don’t. He also suggested a future commission work session discussion about the bigger issue of commerce on the beach and how to possibly preempt future unwanted beach commerce activities.

“I’m not touching that sign ordi­nance,” Commissioner Carol Soustek said, and she agreed with Oelfke about a beach commerce work session discussion and discussing how other coastal cities address those activities.

During public input, My Beach Con­cierge owner Perry Heldreth restated some comments he made a day earlier at the Anna Maria city commission meeting. He said the cabana rental company he and his wife Rebecca operate island-wide has a business license, a retail sales certificate, a multi-million dollar liability policy and workers’ compensation insurance.

“We try to do everything aboveboard,” he said.

Heldreth said the My Beach Concierge logo is nationally trademarked, similar to Tommy Bahama, and he questioned whether that allows their logo to remain on their Holmes Beach cabanas.

When addressing that question later, Development Services Director Chad Minor said, “If it’s com­mercial advertising, by ordinance, it’s prohibited on our beach.”

Holmes Beach officials decline to increase beach cabana regulations
AMI Cabanas owner Sarah Moreno addressed the mayor and commission.

Unable to wait for the cabana discussion because she had to get to her full-time job in Tampa, AMI Cabanas owner Sarah Moreno spoke during general public comment at beginning of the meeting. Moreno said she’s an Island native and AMI Cabanas is a family business with only 10 ca­banas. She supports de-branding rented cabanas and requiring cabana rental companies to be licensed and insured.

“There are some yahoos out there doing it wrong,” she said. “We are an LLC. We’re licensed. We have insurance. We do it right and we just ask that we are able to continue do it right.”

Related coverage:
Commercial activity on Anna Maria beaches prohibited
Beach cabana rentals under scrutiny
Mayor concerned about beach cabana rentals