Skip to main content

Tag: Holmes Beach

Bali Hai legal dispute continues

Bali Hai legal dispute continues

MANATEE COUNTY – A court has ruled in favor of the city of Holmes Beach’s quest to stop the use of a lounge and bar installed without proper permits at the Bali Hai Beach Resort. Unfortunately for the city, the ruling was open-ended, at least for 30 days.

Manatee County Circuit Court Judge Charles Sniffen heard arguments from attorney Erica Augello for the city and attorney Michelle Grantham representing the Bali Hai’s ownership. The ruling involves the city’s motion to dismiss a counterclaim from the resort owners.

Sniffen ruled in favor of the city’s motion to dismiss but with the stipulation that the resort’s attorneys have 30 days to amend the counterclaim and resubmit it for consideration by the court.

In the counterclaim, Bali Hai’s owner alleges that the city’s demand for a site plan and that service stop until the site plan is approved at the onsite bar/lounge is financially damaging the resort, which was installed without permits from the Holmes Beach building department. The resort’s owner is seeking financial relief from the city and requested a trial in the amended counter-complaint filed April 26, alleging breach of contract.

During the Aug. 5 hearing, Grantham presented a letter from city attorney Patricia Petruff stating that city leaders would work with the resort to allow service to hotel guests to continue at the onsite lounge if the resort’s owners submitted a site plan for approval by city leaders and all applicable fees. Grantham said her client submitted the requested site plan despite believing it’s not necessary for the use of the lounge and that the letter constitutes a contract between her client and the city.

The lounge, along with other construction work done on the resort property, has been a point of contention between city leaders and the resort’s owner for more than a year due to no permits being applied for or given by the city’s building department for the work. The changes on the property also require a site plan approval under city code, which has not been given by city commissioners due to ongoing issues with the site plan submitted by the resort’s representatives. The resort’s representatives have argued since early 2020 that a site plan approval is not needed for the lounge and that it was an existing use on the property. City representatives have said the lounge was not an existing use and needs approval in order to operate legally.

Despite the ongoing issues, the resort’s lounge has continued to operate, leading to the city’s lawsuit against the resort owner to stop the use of the lounge and the sale of alcohol on the property until the site plan can be approved.

When ruling on the city’s motion to dismiss the amended counterclaim with prejudice, Sniffen said he does not see any evidence from what was presented that the city entered into a contract with the resort or how the resort’s representatives providing a site plan for approval would benefit the city. He added that for it to be a contract, the city would need to benefit in some way from the agreement.

Instead of dismissing the counter-complaint with prejudice, which would prevent the resort’s attorneys from resubmitting the claim for reconsideration by the court, Sniffen gave Grantham 30 days from the date of the hearing to amend the countercomplaint and resubmit it for a future hearing.

Related coverage

 

Bali Hai owners receive code fines

 

Bali Hai site plan negotiations continue

 

Bali Hai site plan review hits a snag

City warns property owners of potential structural issues

City warns property owners to inspect structures

HOLMES BEACH – After a balcony fell off a building and residents were evacuated at a nearby condo due to balcony problems, city leaders are warning property owners to be on the alert for structural issues that could cause personal injury or death.

The Sun made a public records request for the identity of the builders and other construction information on the single-family residence and the Fountain Head condominium on Sixth Avenue, which also has a sister building, but city staff delivered only permit records for pools and air conditioning units, which are available on the Manatee County Property Appraiser’s website.

Building Official Neal Schwartz said he was surprised that there were no other records on the properties, and that since he came to the city two years ago, he’s focused on keeping complete and accurate records in the building department. With the addition of an electronic method of submitting and approving documents for permits, Schwartz said the process of maintaining records has become easier and less susceptible to loss, unlike documents that were submitted on paper and stored either in paper files or on microfiche in the past.

After the condo at 3400 Sixth Ave. was found to have potential structural issues with the balconies on the back of the building, the owners of the units in the sister building were warned of potential issues. Now the city’s building department and code compliance staff are also sending letters of warning to owners of structures similar to the home at 4106 Sixth Ave., where a rear balcony collapsed in late June.

In the letter to property owners, Schwartz said the city is detailing the issues found at the home and suggesting that the work originally performed on the balconies of the damaged structure was likely performed by the same contractor as the other matching structures on Fifth and Sixth Avenues. The letter goes on to warn property owners of the potential for issues with the balconies and to encourage them to be alert to any problems.

The affected properties are 4105 Fifth Ave., 4107 Fifth Ave., 4104 Sixth Ave., 4108 Sixth Ave. and 4110 Sixth Ave.

Schwartz said that the property owner at 4106 Sixth Ave., Virginia Stewart, according to Manatee County Property Appraiser records, has voluntarily evacuated the property and her insurance company has engaged a structural engineer who inspected all of the balconies on the home and reported that the damage was most likely caused by lack of maintenance. The report also states that all of the balconies on that home, which was built in 2002, are unsafe and need to be replaced before the property can be cleared for occupation. Schwartz said the process is underway and permits have been issued for the repairs.

Schwartz said the letters to property owners were not sent out immediately due to the finding that the collapsed balcony was primarily caused by lack of maintenance rather than a problem with the initial construction.

Related coverage

 

Building evacuated due to structural issues

 

Island building owners warned to investigate structural issues

 

Balcony collapses in Holmes Beach

City buzzing about noise regulations

HOLMES BEACH – More changes are on the way for the city’s noise regulations with the proposed addition of the term “plainly audible,” a requirement to face noise-producing electronics toward the rental units and a proposition to get a financial bond or some other financial security for unpaid noise citations.

Commissioners discussed the issue of excessive noise in residential communities during a July 27 work session. Despite Holmes Beach Police Chief Bill Tokajer saying the city’s current ordinance is working and is “a model ordinance” being emulated by other cities, commissioners are considering adding the current regulations to help curtail noise between houses.

One of the things already being used by police and code officers responding to noise violation complaints is “plainly audible.” Commissioners agreed that the term needs to be added to the current noise ordinance for clarification and enforcement.

Tokajer said he’s instructed officers arriving at a noise complaint to judge if the noise being heard would disturb them at night in their home. If so, he said officers can consider the noise complaint valid. Currently, officers use the plainly audible method in addition to noise meters and the seven noise standards already set out in the ordinance when responding to quiet hours noise complaints between 10 p.m. and 7 a.m. A motion to use the plainly audible standard during the day failed to achieve a consensus between commissioners.

With increased enforcement, Tokajer said officers have issued more tickets in 2021 than in 2020, with 37 noise citations issued through the end of June. He said officers issued 29 citations all year in 2020.

He added that officers received 330 calls for service for noise issues in 2020 and 164 through June 30 in 2021.

Commissioners agreed to move the first reading of the amended noise ordinance to a future meeting.

Other changes being considered to the city’s noise regulations include a requirement to face a noise-producing device, such as a stereo or boom box, toward the rental unit where it is located to reduce noise to neighboring properties, and the placement of a sign reminding visitors that they’re renting in a residential neighborhood outside by pools. Both changes are under consideration to be added to the city’s vacation rental ordinance.

Commissioners also instructed staff to look into options for obtaining a bond or some other financial security instrument for unpaid noise citations. Thus far, Tokajer said all noise citations issued have been paid. Commissioners agreed they’d like to get out in front of the potential problem of unpaid fines before it becomes an issue.

Related coverage

Holmes Beach commissioner receives noise warning

Commissioners consider changes to noise ordinance

New moratorium in effect on vehicle rental businesses

New moratorium in effect on vehicle rental businesses

HOLMES BEACH – Concern about the number of low-speed vehicles in the city and the potential for incoming additional rental companies has prompted Holmes Beach commissioners to enact a six-month moratorium.

The moratorium, approved in a four-to-one vote during a July 27 meeting with Commissioner Jim Kihm dissenting, blocks the applications for new low-speed vehicle rental businesses coming into the Island city. It does not apply to current businesses or those with pending site plans, such as the pending application for The Toy Barn.

Kihm said he feels that some discussion on the number of low-speed vehicles in the city may merit some conversation but he felt that a moratorium would be premature at this point.

The issue was brought to the attention of commissioners by fellow Commissioner Jayne Christenson. She said she feels that the number of low-speed vehicles taking to city streets is dangerous, particularly with some people not wearing seat belts, piling more people in the vehicle than it safely seats and generally treating the vehicles as toys while on vacation. She suggested the moratorium as a way for city officials to research the problem and try to find a way to make city streets safer without allowing any new rental businesses to set up shop in Holmes Beach.

City Attorney Patricia Petruff warned commissioners they need to manage their expectations concerning the moratorium, noting that while it does prevent a business from opening a brick-and-mortar location in the city, it doesn’t stop one from bringing vehicles in on a trailer to deliver them.

When it was suggested the city require a business tax receipt for anyone doing a business delivery in the city, it was quickly shot down because of the potential logistical and legal issues it would cause. Petruff said it wasn’t realistic for commissioners to require a BTR for anyone delivering in the city because it wouldn’t just apply to low-speed vehicle renters but also food delivery and other services.

Kihm said he would like to spend some time looking at what the issues are concerning the golf cart-like vehicles and mini cars rented by vacationers. And while he’s concerned about traffic, Kihm said moving vehicles through the Island cities is a multi-faceted problem that’s going to need creative solutions.

Commissioner Carol Soustek said she’s unsure of what the city can do as the low-speed vehicles are considered legal vehicles and the city cannot regulate the number of vehicles on the road.

Christenson said she’s heard a low-speed vehicle rental business, one that’s already bringing vehicles into the city for rent without having a brick-and-mortar location, ZoomAround, is considering purchasing the former Wells Fargo location at the corner of Marina and Gulf Drives, just in front of the Shops at Waterline where The Toy Barn is planning to relocate if their site plan is approved by city leaders.

Though the former Wells Fargo property is currently listed as off the market, no sales have been recorded according to Manatee County property appraiser records.

For a vehicle rental business to open in the space, City Planner Bill Brisson said it would require a special exception for the change in use at the property from commissioners. The sale of the property also could negatively impact the Waterline Marina Resort and Beach Club which has a lease with Wells Fargo for the use of 20 parking spaces for the resort and adjacent marina.

Brisson said the parking spaces, which are part of the former bank property, are part of the required parking for the resort and marina.

Commissioners instructed staff to send a letter with approval from Mayor Judy Titsworth to management at the Waterline resort to see what their plans are for the required parking spaces for the resort and marina.

Related coverage

Interconnected site plans denied for now

Golf carts causing frustration, accidents

Commissioners ready autocycle moratorium

Eat elsewhere: Beach Bistro owner to unvaccinated diners

Beach Bistro owner to unvaccinated diners: Eat elsewhere

HOLMES BEACH – While the debate over masks and vaccinations heats up due to the Delta variant of COVID-19, one Island business owner says he doesn’t want unvaccinated customers walking through the doors.

That’s the new policy at the nationally-renowned Beach Bistro and The Doctor’s Office cocktail lounge.

Owner Sean Murphy has gone to great lengths to keep staff and customers safe. The Beach Bistro was the first establishment in the U.S. to acquire state-of-the-art air purification units developed in Denmark that were specifically designed to destroy airborne viruses, he said.

“I called my cousin who is an anesthesiologist and works in a sterile environment. I told him I needed to purify the air in my restaurant, how do I do that?” said Murphy, who also owns The Doctor’s Office and the temporarily-closed Eat Here restaurant in Holmes Beach. “My cousin introduced me to two brothers in Denmark whose father specialized in viral air purification who developed a unit that uses a massive fan to move air which is filtered through ultraviolet light, a HEPA filter and ionization.”

In addition to the floor units, Murphy also upgraded the air conditioning in the restaurant to utilize the same technology and move inside air out and outside air in. All of the air in the restaurant is replaced every three to four minutes.

“My goal is to be the safest restaurant in America,” said Murphy, who hopes his efforts will encourage other restaurants to do what he is doing.

In addition to the air filtration, all of Murphy’s employees at Beach Bistro and The Doctor’s Office – which is following the same policies – have been vaccinated. The restaurateur brought the vaccinations to the employees at the establishment and rewarded each employee with a $100 bonus for getting the vaccine.

Murphy says diners have responded positively to the policy, with nine out of 10 people fine with it, he said. But the people who don’t like it have been especially unpleasant in their responses.

“There’s a nasty little streak on Facebook that’s calling us communists and fascists. One person even said they wanted to get COVID then come here and eat,” Murphy said.

The restaurant can’t legally ask for proof of vaccination, Murphy said. Under Florida Senate Bill 2006, passed in May and made effective on July 1, businesses are not allowed to require customers to provide documentation of COVID-19 vaccination.

But Beach Bistro is reservation only, and when his staff asks if diners have been vaccinated and they say “yes,” Murphy said he believes they are being honest.

Holmes Beach leaders start 2021-22 budget talks

Holmes Beach leaders start 2021-22 budget talks

HOLMES BEACH – Budget discussions are underway in Holmes Beach and commissioners so far have only made a few minor adjustments to the proposed 2021-22 fiscal year finances.

City Treasurer Lori Hill presented the proposed $11,156,128 budget to city commissioners during a July 13 work session. In addition to the more than $11 million break-even revenue/expense budget, Hill’s proposal also included $9,306,655 estimated reserves and carryover from the previous year for a total of $20,462,782.

Some revenue, including proceeds from the half-cent sales tax, state revenue sharing, and communication tax are all estimates until final numbers are received from the state, Hill said. Until the end of the current fiscal year, Sept. 30, the $5,526,635 in unassigned reserves/general fund is also an estimate.

Commissioners voted unanimously on July 15 in a special meeting to set the maximum millage rate for the coming fiscal year at 2.25 mills, the same as the current year and in line with what Hill suggested during the budget workshop.

Millage is the tax amount charged to property owners by the city for each $1,000 of assessed property value determined by the Manatee County Property Appraiser’s Office.

Despite proposing the same 2.25 millage rate as the current year, Hill said the city’s ad valorem revenue would increase by 6.93% due to an increase in property values.

The 2.25 mills rate is 6.24% higher than the rollback rate of 2.1178 mills which would bring in the same amount of ad valorem revenue as the current fiscal year.

While some commissioners questioned whether or not they could potentially lower the millage rate and still meet the city’s financial goals for the 2021-22 fiscal year to give property owners a tax break, Hill said that the city cannot lower the millage rate and still receive federal American Rescue Plan Act funding. Currently, she said she does not know how much funding the city could receive under the program, which will see funds distributed by state officials, or what those funds could be used for. Commissioners agreed to reassess their options in September during the two required public hearings for the budget when they hopefully will have more information on the possible amount of funding and its approved uses.

During budget discussions, commissioners reviewed areas where there are significant changes proposed, including in the police department, public works and outside agency funding.

Outside agency funding, which includes city contributions to The Center of Anna Maria Island and other nonprofit organizations on the Island, only saw a $2,500 increase from the previous year to a total of $27,500 but was a topic of some debate among commissioners. Ultimately, commissioners voted three-to-two, with Commissioners Jim Kihm and Jayne Christenson dissenting, to budget $25,000 for a contribution to The Center, one that would be guaranteed and not require commissioners’ to approve before it can be distributed to the nonprofit. The contribution is $2,500 higher than the $22,500 that has been given in previous years. The additional $2,500 in the $27,500 line item is to be distributed to other Island nonprofits at the mayor’s discretion.

The general government budget also increased by $4,000 after budget discussions at the workshop to allow for any commissioner who wants one to receive a city-issued laptop to conduct city business with instead of using their private devices.

The mayor and commission budget remained largely the same at $205,006, with $1,820 added for increases in elected officials’ stipends and $2,785 in increased computer and information technology services.

The budget for the Holmes Beach Police Department is proposed to increase by $374,105 to $3,990,311 for the 2021-22 fiscal year. Increases in the budget include the rehiring of a records clerk for the department, a position that was lost during the 2018-19 fiscal year and put off to cut costs in the 2019-20 and 2020-21 fiscal years. It also includes the addition of another officer to assist in the promotion of Det. Sgt. Brian Hall to lieutenant and succession planning for the eventual retirement of Chief Bill Tokajer.

Other costs are the long-planned 911 upgrade that every law enforcement and first responder agency in Manatee County is required to participate in, the purchase of a new vehicle for the new hire officer, a new computer server, $64,000 for new tasers for officers to replace aging ones that are out of warranty and associated liability protections, $5,000 for five new bulletproof vests and $5,200 for the purchase of a new bulletproof shield. Tokajer said he hopes to recoup some of the funds for the bulletproof vest purchase via a grant.

The budget for the public works department is proposed to increase by $688,280 to $2,660,173. Planned spending in that department includes the addition of one new employee, an in-house engineer, $100,000 to repair 13 trolley stops and add two new ones, new phones and software for employees and rollover funds for lighting and landscaping at city center.

Mayor Judy Titsworth said that some of the funding for the in-house engineer position is planned to be recouped in lowered professional service fees paid to outside engineering firms by the city.

The building department’s budget is proposed to come in at $821,536, an increase of $191,960 over the current fiscal year. Planned spending includes the addition of a new employee, new computer equipment and a new server and $105,000 to be paid to LaRue Planning for services to the city, not including a payment of $27,000 for the final year of the comprehensive plan review which staff from LaRue is assisting planning commissioners on. The comprehensive plan expenditure is noted under the general government budget.

The Code Compliance budget is projected to increase by $50,197 to $640,863 to account for the hiring of a new full-time employee and the purchase of a new Ford F150 vehicle. Other line items, including professional services where officers plan to spend $32,000 less than the previous year.

Holmes Beach commissioners plan to host the first of two required budget hearings where the public is invited to speak and ask questions about planned spending at 5 p.m. on Sept. 15. The final budget hearing is planned for 5 p.m. on Sept. 28. The new budget will go into effect on Oct. 1.

Copies of the proposed budget are available to the public in the lobby at Holmes Beach City Hall.

 

Related coverage

County commissioners refuse Holmes Beach funding request

Holmes Beach police get two new ATVs with COVID grant

 

Interconnected site plans denied for now

Interconnected site plans denied for now

HOLMES BEACH – Two business owners who submitted site plans for approval by city commissioners didn’t receive good news from commissioners but there’s still hope for approval at a future meeting.

During a July 15 work session, Holmes Beach commissioners heard proposals from the owner of the Shops at Waterline commercial plaza. And while the two-site plan proposals were submitted separately, commissioners had a hard time evaluating one independent of the other, particularly because they involve alterations at the same commercial space.

First up was the proposed site plan from the Shops at Waterline, owned by W.J. Keel Holdings LLC. City Planner Bill Brisson said the minor site plan approval was remanded to commissioners by Building Official Neal Schwartz due to issues with the site plan submittal. Some of the issues, Brisson said, include an incorrect calculation of required onsite parking spaces, lack of dumpster size, screening and placement indicated on the proposed site plan drawings and a mystery spot of a newly enclosed area with an entrance from the adjacent Sunrise Lane that has no usage noted on the plans. Brisson also said that work had been done on the interior of the building without obtaining the proper permits from the city’s building department.

While the proper permits can be obtained from the building department after the fact, those permits will carry a fee three times larger than what would’ve been charged had permits been secured before construction. The permit fees are based on the value of the proposed construction.

As a result of the unpermitted construction, Schwartz said that drywall was removed from three units and electrical and gas lines were unsecured, requiring the gas to be turned off for an extended period. The lack of gas to the shopping plaza caused the tenant restaurant Eat Here to be closed to the public for a few weeks due to a reliance on gas in the kitchen.

Schwartz said that there are too many unknowns in the space for him to approve the minor site plan changes administratively.

Since attorney Aaron Thomas, who represents both the owners of the shopping plaza and The Toy Barn, had contracted COVID-19 and was unable to attend the meeting, his associate Anisley Mena attended and spoke on his behalf.

Mena said that the plaza ownership was awaiting city direction on where to place trash dumpsters and that the changes made were internal only. She asked that the site plan be considered separately from the one proposed by The Toy Barn.

Rather than move the site plan approval to a first reading at a regular meeting, commissioners agreed to allow the applicant to resubmit with additional information and consider the site plan again at a future work session, the same response given to The Toy Barn and owner Travis Lantz.

Lantz said that he plans to work with the city and his attorney to resubmit his site plan for a future location for The Toy Barn at the Shops at Waterline Plaza.

He plans to take up about 3,500 square feet of space in the plaza to house his business’s office and provide a storage facility for his lithium battery-powered vehicles during the off-season when not so many are rented.

The plans submitted to city officials also include the installation of a garage door to allow vehicles to be pulled into the space for storage and maintenance from an access point on Sunrise Lane, something the residents of Sunrise Lane aren’t in favor of as discussed by their attorney during the work session.

During the presentation, Brisson said Lantz also planned to use some of the business’s required parking to store vehicles outside the shop. He said when all of the required parking for the businesses and proposed businesses in the plaza was computed, he came up with a required 66 spaces needed, with 71 total parking spaces located onsite. That means that instead of the 18 spaces indicated in the site plan approval request for parking rental vehicles, Lantz would only have five spaces available for parking rental vehicles. The plans also include a small charging area for golf carts and other vehicles near the proposed garage access.

To allow The Toy Barn to conduct its business in the plaza, Brisson said, requires a special exception because the rental business isn’t covered in uses allowed in the C-3 commercial district. To obtain that approval, the site plan submittal has to meet 12 standards required for a special exception under the city’s land development code, including the production of a traffic study to show how the proposed use will affect traffic in the area.

Lantz said that because his business is primarily a mobile one with vehicles going straight from one rental to another, he doesn’t feel it will negatively impact traffic in the area and that the garage door access on Sunrise Lane would only be used by his employees, not by renters of the vehicles.

Another concern Brisson mentioned is the business negatively affecting nearby residential property values and the quality of life for adjacent residents. Lantz said he’s willing to install an attractive, quiet garage door and that his vehicles are all electrically powered, meaning they make little to no noise to disturb residents.

Lena said she and Thomas would respond in writing to all of the commissioners’ concerns to help move the site plan approval process along.

For his part, Lantz said he plans to continue pursuing the Holmes Beach location for his business and will be attending every meeting where the site plan is discussed to answer any questions from commissioners, city staff and the public.

Related coverage

Commissioners ready autocycle moratorium

New structural problems in Holmes Beach

Building evacuated due to structural issues

HOLMES BEACH – A four-unit building on Sixth Avenue was voluntarily evacuated on July 15 after a repairman noticed structural issues with the balconies.

Building Official Neal Schwartz said that the issues at the building at 3400 Sixth Ave. could lead to a collapse, but that they were discovered before any other damage occurred. The property owners voluntarily vacated the premises until the problem could be assessed by a structural engineer and repaired, he said.

Caution tape warns visitors to stay away from the pool deck after balconies on the building were discovered to have structural issues. – Kristin Swain | Sun

All of the balconies on the building are compromised and will have to be replaced, then the building will have to be inspected before it can be deemed safe for habitation, he said.

The building, part of the Fountain Head two-building complex, is mostly used as vacation rental units, Schwartz said. He added that while the exterior stucco is separating from the building on the south end of the property, the building at 3402 Sixth Ave. is not experiencing any issues, though he said condominium association officials plan to have it checked just to make sure.

A sign posted on the staircases to access the residential units at 3400 Sixth Ave. warn that the building is unsafe and that anyone who enters does so at their own risk. – Kristin Swain | Sun

The four-plex was constructed in 1984 according to Manatee County Property Appraiser records.

Code Compliance Officer Kim Charron said the issues with the balconies were reported to the department by a rental agent who was told by a repairman that there was something suspicious going on with the balcony at one of the units. The matter was then turned over to the city’s building department.

If Sixth Avenue sounds familiar, it’s because the north end of the street is where a balcony collapsed at a residential home in late June.

That home at 4106 Sixth Ave. is still awaiting repairs, though Schwartz said no issues have come up concerning the structure of other homes in the area with a similar build.

The Sun submitted a public records request to learn the name of the contractor who built the home and other similar structures in the area. As of press time for The Sun, the city had not released the requested records.

With structural issues at residential properties making some homeowners nervous, Schwartz said he recommends that anyone who has concerns or who spots a potential issue in their home, business or rental property contact the city’s building department for an inspection. He said it’s better to catch potential issues before they become a safety hazard.

Related coverage

 

Balcony collapses in Holmes Beach

 

Island building owners warned to investigate structural issues

 

Former Island building official last to inspect Surfside condo

Mugshot

Island Grill employee faces child pornography charges

HOLMES BEACH – A Manatee county resident and employee of the Island Grill has been arrested by Manatee County Sheriff’s deputies and charged with 26 counts of possession of child pornography, a felony, based on two cyber-tips from Dropbox Inc.

Owen Hagan, 27, also was in violation of his probation from a 2020 DUI involving property damage after missing a recent court date in May, according to a police report.

Deputies learned that Hagan had recently moved to Florida from Ohio to live with his mother in a Palmetto mobile home park, where they executed a search warrant on March 17. The warrant included an IP address provided by the cyber-tip from Dropbox Inc. advising that a user named Owen Hagan had uploaded at least 11 video files, 10 of which depicted child pornography. When police arrived, Hagan’s mother advised deputies that Hagan was at the residence in his bedroom. 

During the search, Hagan’s iPhone 6 was confiscated by police after he declined to allow officers to look through it, although he had previously provided the password upon request. A further search of Hagan’s bedroom resulted in no more electronic devices being found. A later forensic search of Hagan’s phone found multiple visits to dropbox.com with emails being used that matched email addresses found on the phone. It was also found that the user of the phone visited multiple known child pornography sites. In total, 26 files involving sexually explicit images and videos of children as young as 3 years old were discovered on the iPhone, according to the report.

Hagan is currently in the Manatee County jail on a $650,000 bond and arraignment is set for Friday, July 23 at the Manatee County Judicial Center. 

Holmes Beach building department

Former Island building official last to inspect Surfside condo

HOLMES BEACH – Just hours before the 12-story Champlain Towers South condo collapsed on June 24, former Holmes Beach Building Official Jim McGuinness inspected it.

The next day, he told the town commission that he saw nothing that would indicate the building would soon collapse.

McGuinness, who resigned from the city of Holmes Beach in 2019, is now the building official for the town of Surfside, and was the last person to inspect the building before its collapse.

He was on the roof of the doomed tower 14 hours prior to the building’s collapse to inspect the installation of anchors installed to allow window washers to safely lower themselves over the side of the residential condominium building. In addition to the recently installed anchors, McGuinness said other work was being done on the roof, but had been delayed due to ongoing rainfall in the area.

The building owners’ association, McGuinness said, was in the process of conducting the required inspections and tests for its 40-year recertification, due before the end of the calendar year. Though he said he had not received any of the required paperwork for recertification prior to the disaster at the Collins Avenue property, McGuinness told Surfside town commissioners that he believed the required inspections were largely complete.

To qualify for recertification, the building’s owners or association must complete all required inspections with a third-party firm, present them to the city’s building department for review and complete any required repairs before obtaining the certification for the building. Though the recertification program in Surfside is mandated by Miami-Dade County regulations, it’s up to the town’s building department to oversee the recertification process for buildings in their jurisdiction.

In a July 3 story, Fox News reported that the manager of the Champlain Towers condominium association complained by email on June 21 that the Surfside building department was stalling needed repairs at the tower, with McGuinness failing to respond to a May email concerning a parking plan for construction to repair the concrete slab underneath the pool deck. McGuinness responded to the email just hours before the building partially collapsed, according to the report. Engineering experts working with the Miami Herald stated that after review of photos and video of the building collapse the partial collapse could be due to the pool deck failing, falling into the garage below and pulling part of the building down with it.

An investigation into the tower’s June 24 partial collapse is ongoing along with an around-the-clock search for those still missing in the disaster. Ahead of Hurricane Elsa, the remaining portion of the Champlain Towers South building was imploded to keep the site as safe as possible for rescue workers and help them access previously unstable areas to search for the missing. As of July 9, 78 people were confirmed dead in the collapse and 68 were still reported as missing in the Surfside disaster.

Surfside Mayor Charles Burkett said an outside engineering firm is investigating the wreckage of the south tower along with its sister buildings to make sure those are still safe for residents and workers to occupy.

Investigations into the collapse also are being conducted by the U. S. Department of Commerce’s National Institute of Standards and Technology to determine what caused the partial collapse of the structure and what can be done to prevent similar tragedies in the future.

The Sun reached out to the city of Surfside’s building department and McGuinness for more information on recent inspections at Champlain Towers South, however, no response to emails, phone calls and text messages was received.

Prior to taking the building official position in Surfside, McGuinness worked for the city of Holmes Beach from March 23, 2015 until March 18, 2019 when he officially handed in his letter of resignation to Mayor Judy Titsworth. At the time of his resignation, McGuinness was being disciplined by the mayor.

In a discussion with The Sun, Titsworth said that while she could not speak to the circumstances surrounding McGuinness’s departure from the city, she would not consider hiring him back if given the opportunity. While she said McGuinness has a good understanding of the Florida Building Code, Titsworth added she was not happy with his performance and that personality conflicts caused a problem.

“It just wasn’t a good fit,” she said.

More recently on Anna Maria Island, McGuinness made headlines for his erroneous approval of a lighted sign and LED board at the Anna Maria Beach Resort on Gulf Drive prior to his departure from the city. His issuance of a permit for the backlit sign and message board against the city’s codes prohibiting backlit signs in residential neighborhoods has resulted in a lawsuit against the city from the resort’s owners and months of city commission discussion related to changes to the Holmes Beach sign ordinance to somehow accommodate existing backlit signs in residential areas. An update to the ordinance has not yet been approved by commissioners. The case in Manatee County Circuit Court is still pending.

Related coverage

 

Island building owners warned to investigate structural issues

 

Balcony collapses in Holmes Beach

Balcony collapses in Holmes Beach

UPDATED JULY 4, 2021 AT 12:24 p.m. – HOLMES BEACH – A balcony fell off a resident’s home last week, causing no injuries but plenty of concern among city leaders about the quality of construction of similar buildings.

While completing a vacation rental inspection at a property on June 28, Code Compliance Officer James Thomas said he stepped out of the back of the house and noticed something strange – the second-floor balcony of a neighboring home had collapsed.

Thomas said he went to the home at 4106 Sixth Ave. to investigate but was denied admittance by the homeowner, Virginia Stewart. Fearing for the safety of the structure’s occupants, Thomas called the Holmes Beach Police Department and West Manatee Fire Rescue for reinforcements.

Balcony collapses in Holmes Beach
Holmes Beach Code Compliance Officer James Thomas posts a notice in front of a home with structural issues on Sixth Avenue. – Kristin Swain | Sun

Police officers and Fire Marshal Rodney Kwiatkowski gained him entrance to the home where they were joined by Building Official Neal Schwartz to inspect the damage to the home.

A section of a second-floor balcony overlooking the backyard pool area had collapsed, raining debris down on the pool area including large sections of a concrete railing, which damaged the pool pavers below, along with wood and stucco pieces. Thomas said the balcony itself seemed to be a wooden structure on the back of the house that had been coated in stucco, collapsing due to structural issues.

The property owner was advised of the international property maintenance code violations at the home and that the structure was deemed unsafe for human occupancy, meaning that anyone staying at the property is doing so at their own peril. Stewart was given a copy of the notice of violation on July 1 by Thomas. He said she’s willing to work with the city’s building department to correct the issues on the property. However, if Stewart doesn’t have the structural issues addressed promptly, Thomas said she could face a hearing with the city’s special magistrate to force the issue. Thomas said his goal is compliance and to help make the property safe for the owner to live there, not to take her to a hearing.

The owner of this home in Holmes Beach will have to get the structural issues at the property fixed or face a special magistrate hearing. – Kristin Swain | Sun

Of continuing concern to the city is not only the property at 4106 Sixth Ave., but also the ones surrounding it.

Stewart’s home was built in 2002 and is now known to have structural issues. Thomas said there are several more matching homes in the same area, all built by the same builder around the same time as Stewart’s, which could all have the same problems and pose a potential safety hazard to the public. Many of those homes, he added, are currently used as vacation rental properties, making the potential for an accident worse.

The name of the builder was not confirmed by city staff, and Manatee County Property Appraiser records for the property did not state the identity of the builder or their company. The Sun has made a public records request for the property records from the city of Holmes Beach and will update this story as more information becomes available.

After the June 24 partial collapse of the Champlain Towers South building in Surfside, leaving a known 22 people dead and 128 unaccounted for as of July 3, Holmes Beach city leaders are looking into ways to inspect aging buildings in the Island city to prevent the same kind of tragedy from happening in their neighborhoods. Though Holmes Beach doesn’t have any buildings as large as the 12-story structure in Surfside, there are several aging multi-story buildings in the city, including two seven-story condominiums at Martinique (see related story).

With the partial collapse of a balcony at a home built less than 20 years ago, Thomas said city leaders aren’t taking chances with the safety of residents and visitors.

Working with the city’s building department, he said all of the homes built in the same manner as Stewart’s house will be at least visually inspected by city staff if staff members are not allowed on the property by the homeowners. If allowed on the property, a more thorough safety inspection can be conducted.

During a July 1 special meeting, Commissioner Terry Schaefer said that following the building collapse in Surfside, he had spoken with Schwartz about the structural status of buildings and homes in Holmes Beach. Schaefer said Schwartz is looking into what can be done to inspect and evaluate buildings in the city to address any potential structural issues before they endanger the public.

Related coverage

 

Island building owners warned to investigate structural issues

Surf campers shred the Gulf

Surf campers shred the Gulf

The West Coast Surf Shop Surf Camp in Holmes Beach is underway this month and everyone from toddlers to teens is learning to surf, with the cooperation of the Gulf of Mexico’s gentle waves, courtesy of Tropical Storm Elsa. The campers are known by their surf nicknames.

Shimmer rides it in to the beach.

Shimmer rides it in to the beach.

Panda pumps the wave to gain speed.

Panda pumps the wave to gain speed.

Boogie caught the outside break all morning.

Boogie caught the outside break all morning.

Sweet Pea catches a big wave.

Sweet Pea catches a big wave.

Noserider Nick works on his form.

Noserider Nick works on his form.

Shreddley McGnarley works up to the nose, with former surf camper, now instructor, Ethan Isaac (aka Bear) keeping the balance.

Shreddley McGnarley works up to the nose, with former surf camper, now instructor, Ethan Isaac (aka Bear) keeping the balance.

Baby Killer Whale is up and shredding.

Baby Killer Whale is up and shredding.

Lil’ Cheetah perfects her tube stance.

Lil’ Cheetah perfects her tube stance.

Noserider Nick

Noserider Nick

Land swap decision moves to November ballot

HOLMES BEACH – After hours of discussion spread across several meetings, city commissioners have made a decision – the proposed land swap with two Holmes Beach residents is going to the voters to be approved or denied.

The property at 104 34th St. is owned by Jonathan and Jessica Cooper. Their beachfront parcel is bisected by a 50-by-100-foot city right of way that was originally platted to be an extension of Fourth Avenue. Now, however, that extension would just be a road to nowhere as a section of that right of way has already been given to the McGuinness family, which owns a property neighboring the Cooper parcel. In exchange for a 25- by-100-foot section of the right of way to expand their buildable area on their lot, the Coopers, represented by attorney Maggie Mooney, offered the city a 2,911-square-foot trapezoid section of beachfront property to align the city’s interests on the beachfront with the property swapped in the McGuinness deal. Mooney said the couple would also be willing to pay up to $10,000 for dune restoration at a nearby beach access point or donate $10,000 to the city to be used for an environmental project of city leaders’ choosing.

Mooney added that the Coopers do not plan to rent the property but to use it exclusively for their personal use, along with friends and family. To sweeten the deal, Mooney said if the land swap goes through, the couple would be willing to agree that the property will not be rented for a period of 10 years, an agreement that would go with the property if it is sold within the 10-year period.

A 2019 amendment to the city’s charter requires that for a land swap or other transfer of city property to take place, it has to first be approved by a supermajority of commissioners to be placed on the ballot for the next regular election. It then must be approved by a majority of Holmes Beach voters and then it goes back to city commissioners for final ordinance approval. The Cooper land swap will be the first time the charter amendment is tested with voters.

Commissioner Jayne Christenson voted against putting the item on the Nov. 2 ballot for voters. In a presentation to her fellow commissioners, she said her concerns stem from the value the Coopers are getting with an increased lot size of buildable property versus what the city would be getting in exchange. She added that if the Coopers are committed to not renting the property, she would like to see the beachfront lot rezoned to R-1, which only allows rentals of 30 days or more.

Commissioner Kim Rash echoed some of Christenson’s concerns but said that on something this important, he feels the decision should be placed in the hands of the city’s voters. He added that it would be up to the Coopers and their representatives to convince voters that the land swap is a good decision to make for the city.

Mayor Judy Titsworth said she feels the measure should go through, noting that if they wanted to, the Coopers could build a garage on the beachfront side of their property and pave the right of way for their personal use to access their property, giving the city nothing in exchange. This way, she said at least the city would benefit in some way from the proposed land swap.

Related coverage

 

County commissioners refuse Holmes Beach funding request

 

Memorial Day weekend parking sparks drama in Holmes Beach

 

More fines added to treehouse owners’ tab with Holmes Beach

Fourth of July fireworks

July 4 fireworks rules a bit complicated on AMI

ANNA MARIA ISLAND – Before you stock up on fireworks to celebrate Independence Day in any of the three cities on the Island, it’s important to know the rules and laws, which vary depending on the city.

In April 2020, Gov. Ron DeSantis signed Senate Bill 140 into law. The bill allows people 18 and older to buy fireworks to use on three holidays: New Year’s Eve, New Year’s Day and Independence Day. The previous law required signing a waiver saying the fireworks were for specific agricultural reasons.

While the new law is clear, local cities and counties have their own rules that supercede what the state allows. Each of the three cities that make up Anna Maria Island has a slightly different approach to how fireworks violations will be enforced, but setting off fireworks of any kind is forbidden on any of AMI’s beaches. Fireworks can disturb nesting shorebirds, sea turtles and other Island wildlife.

Good news: Least terns nesting on AMI
Least terns, a threatened species, are nesting on AMI’s beaches and can be frightened off their nests permanently by fireworks. – Rusty Chinnis | Sun

Bradenton Beach

The Bradenton Beach police will be enforcing a local ordinance that does not allow fireworks on the three state-designated holidays, and will confiscate fireworks from anyone caught setting them off. It’s also possible to be issued a citation, even on July 4.

Bradenton Beach is home to the popular Coquina Beach.

“Anything that shoots up in the air is illegal: Bottle rockets, roman candles, mortars, they’re all illegal, said Det. Sgt. Lenard Diaz of the Bradenton Beach Police Department. “You’re looking at shooting those things off near a residence, and the residences are so tightly packed together here that the possibility of something catching on fire is very real.”

The Sandbar restaurant will not be hosting a Fourth of July fireworks show this year.

Holmes Beach

Holmes Beach will be taking a different approach to the issue of fireworks for the holiday, only taking action if the fireworks are being used in an unsafe manner that could endanger the public or those setting them off. 

“State law said it’s ok to set them off on the 4th, so we’ll honor that and encourage safety and common sense,” said Police Chief William Tokajer, adding that anyone being reckless or unsafe is still subject to a citation and the risk of having their fireworks confiscated.

Manatee Beach is located in Holmes Beach.

Anna Maria

The city of Anna Maria is patrolled by the Manatee County Sheriff’s Office. The department refers to Manatee County Ordinance 04-27, which covers fireworks rules and laws at length and also echoes other area laws that prohibit individuals from lighting any shell that flies in the air or explodes above the ground without a permit. A spokesman did not directly address whether or not they recognize the state bill that legalizes fireworks on July 4.

Turtle hatchlings expected to hatch in early July could be disoriented by fireworks, and never make it to the Gulf of Mexico. Submitted | AMITW

“Our response to fireworks enforcement has not changed. When deputies respond to complaints involving fireworks, their goal is to obtain voluntary compliance through education,” said Manatee County Sheriff’s Office Public Information Officer Randy Warren.

All departments agree that if you choose to light fireworks, you should be aware of your surroundings, not use them in densely populated areas, and not use them on the beach, where wildlife may be at risk.

Related coverage

 

Bird Tips

 

Turtle Tips

Bali Hai owners receive code fines

Bali Hai owners receive code fines

HOLMES BEACH – The fight for compliance with city codes is still ongoing between the owners of the Bali Hai Beach Resort and city leaders. Now, the owners of the resort are going to have to pay fines until the issues are resolved.

Two cases against the hotel ownership were heard during a June 11 code compliance special magistrate hearing. One concerned work being done without a permit and the second was the operation of a bar/lounge without an approved site plan.

Though no one appeared on behalf of the owner to argue the case, the attorney for the city, Erica Augello, said she received an email from attorney Louis Najmy during the hearing objecting to Special Magistrate Michael Connolly not granting a continuance to the two cases and objecting to not being able to attend the hearing held at Holmes Beach City Hall by Zoom or teleconference. In his email, Najmy also said he had previously requested discovery by the city, which he had not received.

Connolly said he was not inclined to grant a continuance for the case, while code Officer James Thomas said he’d spoken to Najmy several times in previous weeks about the hearing and issues at the property.

In his case submittal, Thomas said he’s viewed construction work being done on the second level of a small accessory building on the property multiple times without permits since 2020. Previously, Connolly ruled against the property for completing demolition work in the same space without permits. Now, Thomas said that space has been rebuilt and is being occupied as an office without permits and without inspections to make sure the area is safe.

In addition, a bar/lounge is being used on the bottom floor of the same building without an approved site plan in violation of city codes. While the resort’s owners have submitted site plans to the city over the past year, Building Official Neal Schwartz said issues still persist with the site plan submittals. Though one was scheduled to go before city commissioners for approval earlier in 2021, the item was pulled from the commission’s agenda by the applicant to make changes. It has not yet been resubmitted to be scheduled for a public hearing.

In addition to the bar/lounge operating without an approved site plan, Thomas said he’s received numerous complaints from neighbors about noise and other issues related to the bar/lounge use on the property.

During public comment, a neighbor to the Bali Hai, Jeanetta Moss, said that since the new owners took over the property she’s had problems with loud parties, drunk people and people trespassing on neighboring residential properties.

“The Bali Hai has not been a good neighbor since the renovations occurred,” Moss said. “I hope they will be compliant and be the good neighbor it once was.”

In both cases, Connolly ruled against the resort’s ownership, requiring them to pay $127.24 in administrative fees and $500-a-day fines until the resort is in compliance with city codes in each case, resulting in a $1,000-a-day fine for the owners. He also ordered the owners to obtain after-the-fact permits for all work done without a permit, cease all operations of the bar/lounge until the property is brought into compliance and for them to schedule a public hearing for the site plan approval by the end of June with city leaders.

Related coverage

Bali Hai site plan negotiations continue

Bali Hai site plan review hits a snag