Skip to main content

Tag: Holmes Beach

Holmes Beach millage rate increasing, stormwater fee remains same

Holmes Beach millage rate increasing, stormwater fee remains same

HOLMES BEACH – Divided and passionate about both critical funding decisions, city commis­sioners voted to increase the property tax millage rate and not increase the annual stormwater utility fee.

The millage increase decision was made during the commis­sion’s July 25 special meeting, when the 2.1812 maximum millage rate was adopted for the 2025-26 fiscal year that begins on Oct. 1. The stormwater fee decision was made during the regular commission meeting that followed.

Millage rate

The proposed 2025-26 fiscal year budget prepared by City Treasurer Julie Marcotte antici­pates $23.9 million in matching city expenditures and revenues – a $1.3 million decrease from the $25.2 million listed in the current fiscal year budget.

Applying the 2.1812 maximum millage rate, Marcotte anticipates the city receiving $6.73 million in ad valorem property tax revenues in the coming fiscal year – a slight increase from the $6.7 million in the current fiscal year.

Increasing the millage rate from the current 1.99 mills to 2.1812 mills will offset the 8.33% decline in aggregate property values experienced in Holmes Beach. Property owners will pay $2.18 per every $1,000 of assessed property value and due to lower property values, most property owners will pay about the same next year as they did this year.

During public input, resident Margie Motzer said the city budget increased 212% between 2012 and 2024.

Holmes Beach millage rate increasing, stormwater fee remains same
Resident Nancy Deal encouraged the mayor and commissioners to listen to the residents’ desires. – Joe Hendricks | Sun

Resident Nancy Deal said the city of Bradenton Beach isn’t raising its current 2.3329 millage rate and is delaying projects and personnel hirings to help offset the decreased property values and property tax revenues. Deal said she lost a car during the 2024 hurricanes and would like to buy a new one but that purchase must wait. She suggested the mayor and commission take a similar approach to their budgetary decisions.

“I hope you can listen to what the residents have to say about how hard it is right now,” she said.

Holmes Beach millage rate increasing, stormwater fee remains same
Resident Renee Ferguson said the mayor and city commissioners need to tighten their belts when managing the city’s finances. – Joe Hendricks | Sun

Resident Renee Ferguson said, “As far as the millage is concerned, it just doesn’t seem appropriate to raise it now. People are suffering. A lot of us had to go into our pensions and our savings because the insurance companies didn’t cover a lot of the expenses we incurred. Asking the people to tighten their belts seems unfair. I think the city really has to think about tightening theirs.”

Holmes Beach millage rate increasing, stormwater fee remains same
Commissioner Carol Whitmore opposed both proposed increases. – Joe Hendricks | Sun

Regarding the proposed millage increase, Commissioner Carol Whit­more said, “The citizens can’t handle it. I can’t handle it. I had to break into my IRA to get an air conditioner. I don’t have insurance because I can’t afford it. We’ve all been through hell. We can’t do this to our citizens this year. We have to be more conservative.”

Commissioners Dan Diggins, Terry Schaefer and Carol Soustek noted the maximum millage rate could still be lowered before the final budget adoption occurs in September, but Mayor Judy Titsworth said the proposed budget is based on the 2.1812 millage rate.

Soustek, Schaefer and Commissioner Steve Oelfke voted in favor of setting the maximum millage rate at 2.1812 mills and Whitmore and Diggins opposed it.

Stormwater fee

Schaefer and Diggins supported the proposed $2 stormwater fee increase and Oelfke, Soustek and Whitmore opposed it.

In June, Public Works Director Sage Kamiya proposed increasing the annual stormwater fee from $2.95 per 100 square feet of property to $4.95 or $9 per 100 square feet. He said the $9 rate would help fund $21.9 million in complaint-driven drainage and stormwater projects over the next five years, with matching grants provided by other agencies cover­ing a significant share of those costs.

Holmes Beach millage rate increasing, stormwater fee remains same
Public Works Director Sage Kamiya sought a $2 stormwater fee rate increase for the coming fiscal year. – Joe Hendricks | Sun

During the July 25 commission meet­ing, Kamiya proposed tiered annual increases that would begin with an increase of $2 per 100 square feet in the coming fiscal year, potentially followed by additional $2 increases during the next two fiscal years and $1-per-year increases during the two years after that.

According to Kamiya, the current $2.95 rate will generate an estimated $862,453 in stormwater fee revenues during the coming fiscal year and a signification portion of that money will be used to maintain the existing stormwater system. Not increasing the fee will limit the city’s pursuit of drainage and stormwater improvements and matching grants and some projects included in Kamiya’s $21.9 million potential projects list will be delayed or discarded.

“Stormwater management is impor­tant when you live on a barrier island,” Titsworth said. “That $800,000 isn’t going to buy you very much.”

Oelfke said the city needs to do what it can to support and retain the perma­nent residents that help create the city’s heritage and culture.

“If it saves one homeowner from moving, it’s worth holding off,” he said of the proposed increase.

Schaefer said the owner of a 5,000-square-foot property currently pays a $147 annual stormwater fee. He said a $2 increase would result in a $247 stormwater fee; and the owner of a 7,500-square-foot property would see their stormwater fee increase from $221 to $371.

Regarding the stormwater-related recommendations made by Kamiya and the city’s contracted stormwater engineer, Herb Raybourn, Schafer said, “I believe we’d be remiss if we didn’t pay attention to these warnings.”

Schaefer said the city should stop spending money on consultants if the commission isn’t going to follow their advice.

After saying she respects Kamiya’s expertise and understands the impor­tance of the city’s stormwater system, Soustek said, “This year, I have had a very hard time, along with everybody else. It’s taken a tremendous amount of insurance money and private money and I can’t, right now, give any more money.”

When expressing his opposition to the stormwater fee increase, resident Win Bishop said the mayor and com­missioners need to be more financially responsible by decreasing expenditures and using reserve funds to pay for stormwater improvements.

“There isn’t that many of us that still live on the Island, but you might want to consider what we want,” he said.

Related coverage:
Holmes Beach considering millage increase
Significant stormwater fee increase proposed

 

Lower stormwater fee increase preferable

In the aftermath of the devastating 2024 hurricane season, our initial thought was that the suggested increase in Holmes Beach stormwater fees is a small price to pay. However, research suggests that more time is needed to study the issue.

First, increased rates do not necessarily guarantee the most effective stormwater mitigation. Land acquisition for pumps and reservoirs has been identified as a major component of stormwater management and has been skillfully managed by other Florida cities. Cape Canaveral is a role model for stormwater planning and grant utilization. St. Petersburg has the Shore Acres Resiliency Infrastructure Project where they are currently using a $1 million state grant towards another pump construction.

While Holmes Beach had a $12 million reserve, there were available properties on the market in the $1-2 million range that could have provided the needed space.

Second, in 2020, former Manatee County Commissioner Joe McClash wrote “Proposed Stormwater Utility Fee Would Be an Unfair Tax.” He explained that the fair way of calculation is by usage. Holmes Beach calculates using lot area, while many Florida municipalities calculate using impervious coverage. It is the impervious surfaces which displace the water and more fairly represent the impact.

In Holmes Beach, commercial properties are allowed 70% impervious coverage; residential properties are allowed 40%, yet the fees are calculated at the same rate for all “real property.”

We have properties which have maxed out their impervious area, elevated their lots and pools and installed walls. All impacts are not created equal.

Third, Mr. McClash mentioned how governments themselves contribute when they make special exceptions such as rezones which increase densities. Holmes Beach has honored multiple rezones despite resident opposition. We know firsthand that, despite code, excessive landfill is sometimes brought in and required swales are omitted. The City Center project elevated parts of Marina Drive by a foot, and now, property owners are being charged to remedy the additional flooding that it most assuredly created.

Fourth, contrary to the thought that this is the perfect time for presenting this increase, it may contribute one more layer to the litany of reasons for the exodus of residents.

Urgency does not necessarily make the most productive outcomes. Now may be the opportunity to make fees more appropriately “user based.” Perhaps approving the 4.95% rather than 9% now would be a modification that would allow the city time to address the need for calculations based on impervious coverage rather than lot area.

Dick and Margie Motzer

Holmes Beach

 

Holmes Beach considering millage increase

Holmes Beach considering millage increase

HOLMES BEACH – Mayor Judy Titsworth and city staff presented a proposed $23.7 million 2025-26 fiscal year city budget that’s currently based on increasing the current millage rate from 1.99 mills to 2.1812 mills.
At 2.1812 mills, Holmes Beach property owners would pay an ad valorem city property tax rate of $2.18 per every thousand dollars of assessed taxable property value.
City commissioners are expected to formally adopt this year’s maximum millage rate during their Monday, July 22 meeting that starts at 2 p.m. The adopted maximum millage rate can then be lowered, but not increased, before two budget adoption hearings are held in September. The 2025-26 fiscal year begins on Oct. 1.
When presenting the proposed budget during the city commission’s July 8 budget work session, City Treasurer Julie Marcotte said the millage rate increase is proposed to offset the 8.33% decline in Holmes Beach property values, as established by the Manatee County Property Appraiser’s Office.

Holmes Beach considering millage increase
City Treasurer Julie Marcotte presented the proposed budget. – Joe Hendricks | Sun

According to the property appraiser’s 2025 Taxing Authority Report, the 4,759 parcels in Holmes Beach have a total taxable value of $3.26 billion. Development Services Director Chad Minor said 1,671 of those parcels are being used as vacation rentals. According to the 2024 report, 4,762 parcels in Holmes Beach had a total taxable value of $3.54 billion.
Marcotte said the lower property values would produce a $590,000 decrease in the city’s ad valorem property tax revenues if the 1.99 millage rate is maintained. The proposed millage rate increase would result in the city receiving about the same amount of city property tax revenues as it did this year at the 1.99 rate.
An increased millage rate combined with lower appraised property values would result in most property owners paying about the same amount of city property taxes in the coming fiscal year. Property owners are also subjected to the taxes and fees levied by the county, school board, fire district and other taxing authorities that account for a significant portion of a property owner’s total annual tax bill.

BUDGET SPECIFICS

State law requires cities to operate with balanced budgets where projected revenues match the projected expenditures. The $23.7 million in projected 2025-26 revenues includes $7.46 million in reserve funds to be carried over from the current 2024-25 fiscal year budget, which is $25.2 million.
The proposed budget for the general operations of the city that includes employee salaries and benefits is $1.77 million – a decrease from the $1.94 million budgeted this year.
The current fiscal year police department budget is $5.49 million. Marcotte and Police Chief Bill Tokajer propose increasing it to $5.52 million for the coming fiscal year. The proposed increase includes Tokajer’s yet-to-be-approved request to hire an additional officer with a starting pay range between $68,000-$72,000.
The building department budget Marcotte and Minor proposed would increase from $1.37 million to $1.6 million, but increased building permit revenues and other development fees are expected to cover the additional expenses incurred by the one department that generates as much or more money than it spends.
The public works department budget proposed by Marcotte and Public Works Director Sage Kamiya anticipates expenditures decreasing from $4.08 million to $3.58 million in the coming fiscal year. Kamiya said his department is currently three employees short of being fully staffed and he’d like to hire at least one additional employee if approved by the city commission.
Commissioner Terry Schaefer said the proposed public works budget is about $500,000 lower than the current fiscal year and to him that justifies hiring an additional employee and adding about $63,000 to the city payroll.
The proposed budget doesn’t yet factor in a proposed stormwater fee increase from $2.95 per 100 square feet of property to $4.95 or $9 per 100 square feet. The proposed budget lists $1.88 million for anticipated stormwater drainage project expenses and Kamiya said that projection would change if additional revenues are to be generated by a stormwater fee increase.
The projected $765,236 for code compliance department expenditures is about $10,000 higher than the current fiscal year.
Commissioner Carol Whitmore opposes increasing the millage rate at a time when many property owners are still recovering from hurricane damage sustained in 2024. She opposes adding an additional police officer and an additional public works department employee to the city payroll and she opposes the proposed stormwater assessment fee increase to be determined during the commission’s Tuesday, July 22 meeting.

Holmes Beach considering millage increase
Commissioner Carol Whitmore opposes the proposed millage rate increase. – Joe Hendricks | Sun

 

Mayor concerned about beach cabana rentals

Mayor concerned about beach cabana rentals

HOLMES BEACH – Mayor Judy Titsworth is concerned about beach cabana rental signage and cabanas being placed in prime beach locations before they’re rented.

Titsworth shared these concerns during the June 24 Holmes Beach City Commission meeting. She said it was brought to the city’s attention that company logos and website references appeared on rented beach cabanas.

“You’re not allowed to have signs on the beaches and it’s advertising for businesses. There’s not sup­posed to be commercial use on preservation (zoned) land,” she said.

Mayor concerned about beach cabana rentals
Mayor Judy Titsworth is concerned about commercial activity on public land. – Joe Hendricks | Sun

According to Holmes Beach city code: “Any sign to be located on property designated as preservation shall require the approval of the city commission prior to the issuance of a permit with the fee for such sign to be set by the city commission.”

“It was an eyesore, so we asked them to remove all of their advertisements and signage off their cabanas,” Titsworth said.

Cabana rental companies were given until June 27 to remove the signage and advertising from their cabanas before police officers and code compli­ance officers began issuing citations.

Titsworth noted that federal law prohibits the city from regulating what the signs say but the city can regulate their placement, size and style.

Staking a claim

Titsworth said that eliminating cabana signage addresses one concern but the city also received complaints about cabana rental companies staking out prime beach locations by placing cabanas and chairs in those locations before they are reserved and rented.

“Some of these companies are actually going out first thing in the morning and putting out a lot of their cabanas in a lot of really great spots and they’re claiming them before other people can get to them and they’re not rented,” Titsworth said.

She said some non-reserved cabanas have QR codes on them that allow some­one to rent them after they’ve been placed on the beach without a reservation.

“They’re making money off of it and this is public land. How do we allow them to commercialize and make money on public sand when we don’t allow other people?” Titsworth said of the cabana rentals in general.

“We’re looking at these different types of things that could potentially move in there. My goal is that our beaches don’t become the causeway,” Titsworth said in reference to the Palma Sola Causeway along Manatee Avenue in west Bradenton. In recent years, the east end of causeway has become heavily saturated with commercial activities that include horseback rides, personal watercraft rentals and more.

Titsworth said city code prohibits commercial transactions in public spaces but most of those transactions are now conducted through company websites or online payment services like Venmo and Zelle.

Mayor concerned about beach cabana rentals
These beach cabanas contained no exterior signage and had been reserved in advance. – Joe Hendricks | Sun

Titsworth said she, City At­torney Erica Augello, Development Services Director Chad Minor and Code Compliance Chief James Thomas are researching what more can be done to regulate commercial activities on the beaches and how other coastal communities address these concerns.

“It gets harder and harder to enforce. Everybody’s trying to make money and they’re doing it now on public land and we’ve got to reel it in,” Titsworth said. “And there’s more things people are going to be coming up with in order to profit off the beaches. What would prevent someone from dropping off 25 kayaks and a QR code and pick them up at the end of the day?”

Commissioner Carol Whitmore questioned whether the use of state and federal funds to renourish the beaches might limit the city’s ability to regulate commercial beach activi­ties, asking whether a city-issued occupational license is required.

Titsworth said occupational licenses pertain to ‘brick and mortar’ businesses that have actual physical locations but some cabana compa­nies don’t have a primary physical location in Holmes Beach.

Mayor concerned about beach cabana rentals
Beach cabanas provide beachgoers with shade and shelter from the sun. – Joe Hendricks | Sun

Commissioner Dan Diggins asked whether Manatee County has any regulations that address commercial activities at the county-owned Manatee Beach. Titsworth said she’s not aware of anything other than the county sign restrictions.

According to county code, “Private vendors, concessionaires providing concession services or activities in county parks may only do so by obtaining a concessionaire permit for such activity, or a franchise license agreement, and paying a franchise license fee.”

Manatee County uses the same contracted beach concessionaires at Manatee Beach in Holmes Beach and at Coquina Beach in Bradenton Beach.

Commissioner Terry Schafer asked whether the city’s goal is to prohibit beach cabana rentals. Titsworth said that wasn’t the intent, but she questions how the city can allow beach cabana rentals on preservation-zoned public land when other commercial activities are not allowed.

“It’s a fine line. We’ve got to do some more work,” Titsworth said.

Mayor concerned about beach cabana rentals
On June 26, beach cabanas occupied a significant portion of the 68th Street beach access shoreline. – Joe Hendricks | Sun

A visit to the 68th Street beach access at 10 a.m. on June 26 (a Thursday) revealed beach cabanas lining the shoreline in both direc­tions and occupying much of the area closest to the water. Some cabanas were occupied, some were not and it was not clear which cabanas were rentals and which were not.

Pickup truck collides with low-speed vehicle

Pickup truck collides with low-speed vehicle

HOLMES BEACH – A pickup truck collided with a low-speed vehicle (LSV) on Gulf Drive on Tuesday evening, resulting in two of the seven LSV passengers being transported to a walk-in emergency room for non-incapacitating injuries.

The accident occurred at the Gulf Drive and 52nd Street intersection at approximately 6:53 p.m. on July 1.

According to the report obtained from the Holmes Beach Police Department, Vehicle 1 (V1) was a 2004 Chevy Silverado pickup truck owned by a Bradenton man whose age is not listed in the report. The pickup truck was carrying one passenger.

Vehicle 2 (V-2) was a six-passenger 2025 HDKP-brand electric low-speed vehicle (LSV) owned by Just 4 Fun beach rentals in Holmes Beach. The LSV was driven by a 46-year-old man from Tampa, whose birthday it was, according to the birthdate listed on his driver’s license.

According to the police report, the pickup truck and the LSV were both traveling northbound on Gulf Drive. The LSV was stopped in traffic and attempting to make a left turn onto 52nd Street when the pickup struck the passenger-side rear of the LSV.

“I spoke with D1 (Driver 1) about what had happened and he stated that he was talking to his friend in the front passenger seat and he looked over at him during conversation and when he looked back V2 (the LSV) was stopped in traffic and he could not stop in time. D1 was deemed to be at fault and was issued a citation for careless driving,” according to the reporting officer.

The name of the person who received the citation is redacted in the report.

According to the report, no one was ejected from the LSV but two passengers were transported by Manatee County EMS to a Manatee Memorial walk-in emergency room with non-incapacitating injuries.

Alcohol use was not suspected as a contributing factor and the LSV sustained minor damage estimated to be approximately $500. Both vehicles were able to leave the scene under their own power.

Tuesday’s accident occurred one day after a 15-year-old girl fell out of a golf cart in Anna Maria and suffered traumatic head and chest injuries and was transported by helicopter to Tampa General Hospital.

Related coverage:
Teenager seriously injured in Anna Maria golf cart accident

City hosts hurricane preparedness workshop

City hosts hurricane preparedness workshop

HOLMES BEACH – During the city’s town hall-style Hurricane Preparedness Workshop, members of the city’s emergency operations team spent nearly two hours sharing information about hurricane prepara­tion, response and recovery.

Held at Holmes Beach City Hall on June 6, the workshop was livestreamed and the archived video can be viewed at the city website.

After thanking the 25 or so audience members in attendance, Mayor Judy Titsworth said, “If I’ve learned any­thing from our past two hurricanes, it is you can never be too prepared.”

City hosts hurricane preparedness workshop
Mayor Judy Titsworth is in charge of the city’s hurricane preparations. – Joe Hendricks | Sun

Regarding mandatory evacuation orders, she said, “I know how hard it is to leave your home and not know the condition of it while you’re waiting to get back on the Island. We are going to continue to do everything we can to get you back on the Island as soon as possible.”

She said the debris removal costs and damage to city assets from Hur­ricanes Helene and Milton total nearly $8 million, but the city expects to be reimbursed for most of that.

“Hurricanes are inconvenient. They’re messy and they expose the character and resiliency of all affected,” she said. “Hurricane pre­paredness is a price you pay for living on this Island and there isn’t a better place I would rather be.”

Police Chief Bill Tokajer made it clear that he and his officers will not remain on the Island during the next major hurricane. He and several officers stayed during Hurricane Helene and became trapped inside the police department by the storm surge that Kamiya said reached 7 feet in some areas.

City hosts hurricane preparedness workshop
The storm surge pole by the city skate park illustrates how high the recent storm surges were. – Joe Hendricks | Sun

Tokajer stressed the need to follow evacuation orders. He said once the winds hit a certain speed (35-55 mph depending on the agency), calling 911 will get you on a waiting list but no one’s coming to get you until the winds die down.

Tokajer advises making an evacuation plan and an evacuation kit ahead of time. An evacuation kit should include food, water, prescription drugs, batteries, flashlights, sanitary products, phone chargers, back-up power supplies and other supplies needed to survive a week or two without replenishment. He also suggests withdrawing cash ahead of time because ATM and credit card transactions may not be possible if the power’s out.

“Don’t wait. Stock up early on supplies,” he said.

City hosts hurricane preparedness workshop
Plan ahead when preparing a disaster kit. – HBPD | Submitted

Tokajer recommends putting insurance documents and other important documents on a thumb drive, along with photos of your household appliances and other belongings they may have to be replaced.

In addition to the city website and the city and police department Facebook pages used to share hurricane informa­tion in the past, the city has implemented the city-specific TextMyGov messaging system. Send a text to 91896 that says “HOLMESBEACH” and enter “YES” in response to the confirmation message.

When returning to the Island after an evacuation order has been lifted – but while reentry restrictions and checkpoints remain in place – residents, property owners and business owners will need a valid reentry hang tag. Holmes Beach residents, property owners and business owners can obtain reentry tags at the police department’s front counter, inside the city hall building.

City hosts hurricane preparedness workshop
Police Chief Bill Tokajer displayed a city-issued reentry tag. – Joe Hendricks | Sun

Tokajer advises not leaving electric cars, golf carts, e-bikes and other electric vehicles in garages and ground-level storage areas where they could come in contact with saltwater and start a fire.

West Manatee Fire Rescue Fire Inspec­tor Cierra Price also stressed the importance of removing electric vehicles from the path of a potential saltwater storm surge.

“If you’ve ever seen a lithium (battery) fire, they’re really hard to put out. Don’t park them in your garage. Your house will catch on fire,” she said.

City hosts hurricane preparedness workshop
Fire Inspector Cierra Price represented the West Manatee Fire Rescue District. – Joe Hendricks | Sun

Price advises residents and property owners to disable their fire alarms and home security systems before evacuating to help prevent false alarms. She said the West Manatee Rescue Fire district responded to 92 false alarms in October 2024, around the time Hurricane Milton struck, and the monthly average is between seven and 20.

“You’re now taking emergency services to a false alarm when we could be responding to an actual emergency,” she said.

Price said during mandatory evacuations and emergency declarations residents and property owners are allowed by law to disable their fire alarm panels by shutting off the power and removing the backup batteries.

Public Works Director Sage Kamiya said his department’s first post-storm priority is clearing the city streets, followed by the removal of household and landscaping debris placed in the streetside city rights of way.

Titsworth said drywall, roofing and other construction materials are not supposed to be placed streetside for free debris removal and should be removed by the contractors or subcontractors doing the repairs.

Code Compliance Chief James Thomas said those caught illegally disposing of trash and debris after a hurricane will be ticketed and fined.

City hosts hurricane preparedness workshop
Code Compliance Chief James Thomas spoke about improper debris disposal. – Joe Hendricks | Sun

Building Official Neal Schwartz said there is a lot of confusion about FEMA’s 50% substantial damage rule and how that’s applied to individual properties.

“We do not make a determination if a property is 50% damaged or not. That is up to the homeowner/contractor that is going to fill out the required 50% cost breakdown from FEMA,” he said.

City hosts hurricane preparedness workshop
Kim Charron and Chad Minor spoke about repair permitting requirements. – Joe Hendricks | Sun

“This is why we require permits for all storm recovery work,” Development Services Coordinator Kim Charron added. “We have to track any repair costs and submit it to FEMA. Any repairs for storm damage have to be documented with a building permit.”

Development Services Director Chad Minor said hurricane repairs and restorations done without a permit can still be remedied.

“There is a way to get it done right,” he said. “Come in and talk to us. We can assist with those issues. We can right the ship.”

Below are the presentations given during the hurricane preparedness workshop:

Holmes Beach Police Department

WMFR Lithium-Ion battery information

Holmes Beach Public Works Department 

Holmes Beach Building and Code Compliance Department

Holmes Beach storm surge information

Separating hurricane debris

FEMA – How to prepare for a hurricane

FEMA – National Florida Insurance Program Resources

Related coverage:
AMI Sun Hurricane Guide 2025

 

Holmes Beach hurricane preparations

Lessons for Holmes Beach guide this year’s hurricane preparations

HOLMES BEACH – As the largest and most populated of the three Anna Maria Island cities, Holmes Beach city officials learned a lot from the challenges presented by Hurricanes Helene and Milton last year.

“I am so proud of the training and preparation that our team went through prior to the two storms last year,” Mayor Judy Titsworth said. “I learned you can never be too prepared and I think we did an outstanding job. Our costs are upwards of $8 million and FEMA and our insurance providers will cover the majority of these costs thanks to our staff having pre-event contracts in place and our consultants engaging with our Emergency Operations Team on documentation and reimbursement applications. And our Development Services team was fully staffed and prepared for rapid damage assessments and permitting. Our citizens and businesses need to understand their roles in the preparation and recovery processes and patience is a big part of the equation, as is humanity.”

Mayor Judy Titsworth and Police Chief Bill Tokajer guided the city’s hurricane recovery efforts. – Joe Hendricks | Sun

Police Chief Bill Tokajer said, “The city has conducted training for many years on hurricane preparation and recovery and there’s no better training than living through the events you train for. Last year, we had real-world experience rather than a tabletop exercise and the city is truly prepared for whatever comes our way.”

Holmes Beach hurricane preparations
Sand deposited by Hurricane Helene’s storm surge was piled high on both sides of some Holmes Beach streets. – Joe Hendricks | Sun

Before, during and after Hurricanes Helene and Milton, the city used the city website, social media platforms and press releases to communicate hurricane-related information and this year the city has added the TextMyGov notification system. To receive real-time updates, register in advance by sending a text to 91896 that says “HOLMESBEACH” and then enter “YES” in response to the confirmation message you receive.

Holmes Beach hurricane preparations
Signing up for TextMyGov notifications is a quick and easy process. – Joe Hendricks | Sun

“Communication is key and choosing the wording is important,” Tokajer said. “We used the word ‘curfew’ instead of ‘checkpoint.’ This was taken by people to mean they had to leave the Island by 7 p.m. What we intended was to let people know if they left the Island they would have to go through a checkpoint and provide re-entry tags to return.”

Holmes Beach hurricane preparations
Hurricane Helene inflicted substantial damage on this beachfront structure in Holmes Beach. – Joe Hendricks | Sun

Tokajer learned another valuable lesson during Hurricane Helene: “We rescued many people the night of Helene – until the water was too deep for the rescue vehicles. As the storm surge rose, we were trapped in the police department. The biggest mistake I made was having my officers and myself stay and I will not make the mistake of keeping our officers in harm’s way like I did last year. When you are told to evacuate, you need to take that seriously. There will not be any first responders to come rescue you until the storm passes,” Tokajer said.

“Have an evacuation plan. Know where you plan to go. When leaving the Island, take your medications, re-entry tag and turn off the electricity. Don’t leave electric vehicles, golf carts or e-bikes in the garage or somewhere else where flooding could cause fires; and take all items off balconies that could become flying debris.”

Holmes Beach hurricane preparations
Hurricane Helene’s storm surge partially buried this vehicle in Holmes Beach. – Joe Hendricks | Sun

Re-entry tags obtained in 2023 or later are valid until 2028. If you need a new one, one tag per resident, property owner or busi­ness can be obtained with proper identification at the Holmes Beach Police Department, 5801 Marina Drive.

Tokajer said the city’s hurricane recovery and response was a team effort: “We had assistance from 32 different police departments after the storm, which we will be forever grateful for. If we must evacuate the city, under the leadership of Mayor Titsworth we’ll work as fast as possible after the storm passes to make sure the area is safe so you can return quickly. We are praying for a storm-free season.”

Holmes Beach hurricane preparations
City Field became ground zero for Holmes Beach’s daunting debris removal efforts. – Joe Hendricks | Sun

Public Works Director Sage Kamiya said, “While we prepared and practiced for emergency response and recovery ahead of the storms, practicing is quite different than the real deal and recovering from the two catastrophic events we experienced firsthand. In past years, we’ve been able to practice small components of a storm – flooding from Hurricanes Idalia and Debby, wind damage and vegetative debris from Ian and flooding from several storms in August 2024.

“We learned preparation is important. The hurricane exercises, emergency operation plan development, practicing evacuating city equipment, preparing facilities and obtaining necessary tools all helped staff respond to these catastrophic events. Each storm brings more lessons we can use and this year Public Works purchased 800 MHz radios so we can communicate sooner and easier with the county and with city staff when cellular service is down.

“It’s not a sign of weakness to ask for help,” Kamiya said. “We invited an incident management team from Texas, public works crews from Santa Rosa County and others from across the state to assist us in our response. If needed, we are prepared to seek mutual aid support again. As a result of these experiences, I believe we are as prepared as ever for this storm season.”

Development Services Director Chad Minor oversees the city’s building, code compliance and planning departments and he feels the insights gained last year will strengthen the city’s resilience and recovery efforts moving forward.

“First and foremost, we observed that the city’s approach to FEMA compliance, flood prevention, building and land development codes and active code compliance efforts resulted in many structures avoiding sig­nificant damage and loss of property. This underscores the importance of continued investment in code compliance, floodplain management and the modernization of building and land development codes,” Minor said.

“During the recovery phase, timely access to damage assessments proved critical. Processes and procedures were put in place to streamline permitting and the city continues to waive permit fees for much of the ongoing storm-related recovery work. Valuable lessons were learned and processes and procedures were refined throughout the recovery process. As a result, city staff is well-equipped to respond should the community be faced with another event,” Minor said.

Related coverage:
AMI Sun Hurricane Guide 2025

Water main project update provided

Water main project update provided

HOLMES BEACH – On May 5, Holmes Beach Public Works Director Sage Kamiya received a project update from Manatee County on the water main replacement project that’s been underway for several months along 62nd through 65th streets between Marina Drive and Holmes Boulevard.

Dated March 31, the AMI Water Main Replacement PH 42 43 schedule that Kamiya received from the county and shared with the mayor and city commissioners calls for the current portion of the county project to be completed by mid-to-late June.

Kamiya’s email update included the May 2 email that Manatee County Public Works Infrastructure Inspection Officer Scott Burnard sent Holmes Beach Public Works Project Manager Matt Gorman.

“Currently connecting water services to new water main. Still need to tie-in the water main at 62nd and 63rd at Marina,” Burnard stated in his email. “Dewater is still in place at the end of 62nd and Marina and 63rd and Marina for tie-ins. Hoping to do these next week but not confirmed as of today. As part of this overall project there are three other streets to be done. These have not been scheduled at this time. They are 54th, 55th and 65th.”

On April 8, city Commissioners Terry Schaefer and Dan Diggins asked Kamiya to provide a project update and both commissioners said they received inquiries from impacted residents.

“I think we’ve all driven by it and there’s an odor that’s coming from it,” Schaefer said.

“You’re smelling the sulfur that is naturally occurring,” Kamiya said of the odor created by the dewatering process needed to accommodate the pipe installations.

Kamiya also noted that the city has no control over a county project.

A visit to the worksite on May 8 indicated the dewatering process remained ongoing, the odor was still present and barricades and other project-related items were still in place in some areas within the project area.

Events

Events

Thursday, April 24

AMI Chamber Business Card Exchange and Anna Maria Island Historical Society Pat Copeland Scholarship Awards, Anna Maria Island Historical Museum, 402 Pine Ave., Anna Maria, 5-7 p.m., $5 for members, $10 for prospective members.

Friday, April 25

Arbor Day tree plantings:

  • Bradenton Beach at Bridge Street west roundabout and Gulf Drive; ribbon cutting of sabal palm, native shrubs and ground cover. 10 a.m.
  • Holmes Beach at 34th and Sixth Avenues; planting of Jamaican caper tree or fiddlewood. 11 a.m.
  • Anna Maria at Villa Rosa Park, South Bay Boulevard; planting of green buttonwood. Noon.
  • Annie Silver Community Center at 103 23rd N. Bradenton Beach; planting of mahogany tree, sabal palm and silver buttonwood; meet your county forester with hot dogs, brats and refreshments. 12:30-1 p.m.

Saturday, April 26

Reel for Rotary fishing tournament. Benefit for disaster relief efforts in Cortez village, support of “Learn to Swim” program and programs at Anna Maria Elementary School. Registration at ianglertournament.com.

Government calendar logo

Government calendar

Anna Maria

10005 Gulf Drive

For information, call 941-708-6130

Please visit www.cityofannamaria.com or contact city hall for more information.

Feb. 13, 10 a.m. – City Commission meeting

Feb. 17, all day – City offices closed, Presidents Day

Feb. 27, 1 p.m. – City Commission meeting

 

Bradenton Beach

107 Gulf Drive N.

For information, call 941-778-1005

Please visit www.cityofbradentonbeach.com or contact city hall for more information.

Feb. 17, all day – City offices closed, Presidents Day

Feb. 19, 1 p.m. – Scenic WAVES meeting

Feb. 20, 9:30 a.m. – Community Redevelopment Agency meeting

Feb. 20, noon – City Commission meeting

 

Holmes Beach

5801 Marina Drive

For information, call 941-708-5800

Please visit www.holmesbeachfl.org or contact city hall for more information.

Feb. 12, 9 a.m. – Clean Water Ad-hoc Committee meeting

Feb. 17, all day – City offices closed, Presidents Day

Feb. 25, 2 p.m. – City Commission meeting with work session to follow

Island-wide

Feb. 18, 6 p.m. – West Manatee Fire Rescue board meeting, administration building, 701 63rd St. W., Bradenton

Gloria Dei church closes, property to be sold

Gloria Dei church closes, property to be sold

HOLMES BEACH – Gloria Dei Lutheran Church has closed and city officials hope to purchase the building and property if financially feasible.

On Jan. 18, the church hosted a Holy Closure service as its final service. The church and its 3-acre property will be put on the market and the Florida-Bahamas Synod of the Evan­gelical Lutheran Church of America is handling the sale.

According to a message shared at the Gloria Dei website, “On Jan. 1, the Synod Council assumed responsibility for all decisions re­lated to the property, its contents and the transition process. The congregation of Gloria Dei will no longer be an active congregation. Continued worship at Gloria Dei for any additional time is not feasible.”

The message includes a statement from Tampa-based Bishop’s Assistant Rev. Ron Rose: “We were warmly invited to attend and participate in worship at Redeemer Lutheran Church in Bradenton. This congrega­tion is dealing with similar issues affecting small congregations every­where. They look forward to getting to know us and to exploring future possibilities. We want to maintain the close bonds and support we have as a church family. We can continue to worship together at Redeemer as we plan for a successful transition to a new congregation.”

Video of the final service is posted at the church’s Facebook page, accom­panied by a single comment from Elle Orr that says, “A sad day for sure.”

 City interest

When discussing the pursuit of resiliency grants and other state and federal funds with city commissioners on Jan. 14, Mayor Judy Titsworth mentioned the church closure and the future sale of the building and property at 6608 Marina Drive.

Gloria Dei church closes, property to be sold
Gloria Dei Lutheran Church recently hosted its Holy Closure farewell service. – Joe Hendricks | Sun

Titsworth wants to pursue the finan­cial assistance needed to purchase the property for use as city-owned green space. The potential funding sources include a federal FEMA grant, a state appropriation or revenues from the county commission-controlled tourist development tax fund. Titsworth said Congressman Vern Buchanan already offered his assistance.

Titsworth said the city might have to put some “ skin in the game” as well and that could entail taking out a loan or dipping into the city’s reserve fund.

“Three acres? This is our one chance to get a great place like that. That’s what I think reserves are for,” she said.

Commissioner Carol Whitmore said that Sen. Jim Boyd told her that Gov. Ron DeSantis is expected to reduce the state appropriations given to local governments this year.

City Director of Development Services Chad Minor said he recently spoke with Rose about the pending sale.

“I expressed our interest in having a seat at the table as they consider future plans for that property,” Minor said. “Once they get their appraisal, they will be putting it on the market. They have a responsibility to their group and they’re going to get the highest and best price they can for that property; and we’re more than welcome to throw our hat in the ring.”

Titsworth said the green space could be used for art festivals, a farmers market and other public uses.

“It’s something that could be a trea­sure for the people that live out here,” she said, noting the property could also be used as a temporary hurricane debris staging area if needed.

Gloria Dei church closes, property to be sold
The School For Constructive Play preschool is displaced by the church closure. – Joe Hendricks | Sun

Whitmore said the School For Constructive Play is displaced from the church building and is temporarily operating at The Center of Anna Maria Island and pursuing the licensing needed to operate a preschool there.

When contacted by The Sun, The Center’s Executive Director Chris Culhane said the School For Con­structive Play obtained a temporary displacement permit from the state Department of Children and Families and they are working with DCF to obtain the permits and licensing needed to keep the preschool there if needed.

Titsworth said she will work with Minor, Public Works Superintendent Sage Kamiya and the city’s lobbyist to identify the most favorable uses of the building and property in terms of pursuing federal, state or county funding.

“Things like green space, soccer fields, a public-private partnership with an art league, allowing the school back in. Something where it can still be used for the community,” Titsworth said.

Regarding the church’s architecture and unique roof structure, she said, “It’s a landmark. I’d like to rehab the building and get it back to its glory. It’s a gorgeous building.”

Minor noted the property carries public/semi-public zoning and future land use designations. Commissioner Dan Diggins asked if the property could be used for commercial pur­poses. Minor said that would require a comprehensive plan amendment, a future land use map amendment and a rezoning amendment.

Titsworth noted that about six years ago, the church leaders sought to rezone a portion of the property to allow the construction of residential duplexes. Those efforts failed because the commission wanted that property to retain its public/semi-public land use and zoning designations.

Bringing the informal discussion to a close, Commissioner Terry Schaefer said, “We need to be prepared when we get the nod to sit at the table. I’m also working on other sources of funding this. If we get that chance, we don’t want to be in a position to say we’re interested but we don’t know how to fund it.”

Government calendar logo

Government calendar

Anna Maria

10005 Gulf Drive

For information, call 941-708-6130

Please visit www.cityofannamaria.com or contact city hall for more information.

Jan. 23, 2 p.m. – City Commission meeting

 

Bradenton Beach

107 Gulf Drive N.

For information, call 941-778-1005

Please visit www.cityofbradentonbeach.com or contact city hall for more information.

Jan. 22, 10 a.m. – Pier Team meeting

Jan. 28, 9 a.m. – City Commission work meeting

Jan. 29, 1 p.m. – Scenic WAVES workshop

 

Holmes Beach

5801 Marina Drive

For information, call 941-708-5800

Please visit www.holmesbeachfl.org or contact city hall for more information.

Jan. 23, 11:30 a.m. – Police officer’s pension board meeting

Jan. 28, 2 p.m. – City Commission meeting with work session to follow

Feb. 5, 3:30 p.m. – Planning Commission meeting

Letter to the Editor: Residents insist on equal protection in noise ordinance

The Holmes Beach Commission is working diligently on the Island Bazaar site plan for the old Wells Fargo location in addressing the noise issue, the discussion of which was initiated by the mayor. We learned long ago that noise is a difficult issue to understand unless you have actually experienced it. It is an issue that has been greatly researched, and the mayor’s dialogue touched on some of what is deeply rooted in that research, and that is that there can be negative impacts. The reduction to 50 decibels during the day in this resolution was noteworthy; it will be great for the mayor and her family, who live nearby.

We all know that we have lost many residents, and for some, noise was a contributing factor. Sometimes the sustained shouting, yelling and screaming in our neighborhoods is what forced people out. For years, noise was mischaracterized, and residential zones were misreferenced as vacation rental districts, resort zones or commercial zones, although the zone should have no bearing since the noise control ordinance is citywide. It took seven years for reprieve for us, and although the situation is better, it is not 50 decibels during the day.

That level of protection is now only in this one geographic region, at the old Wells Fargo location. It may not have been the intent to deny equal protection to others within the city, but it is reasonable that all residents should be protected equally regardless of where they live. Many residents have been exposed to similar levels of sustained and repetitive noise; we are not seeing any reason that others should be treated differently. It is reasonable that equal protection, both literally and figuratively, should be provided to everyone in the city and that there should be even enforcement.

Considering that the 14th Amendment grants equal protection, we think the city needs to take action to apply that same daytime 50 decibel level citywide.

 

Dick and Margie Motzer

Holmes Beach

Holmes Beach logo

Holmes Beach: Year in Review

TREEHOUSE COMES DOWN

Holmes Beach: Year in ReviewAfter more than a decade in court, Holmes Beach treehouse owners Lynn Tran and Richard Hazen waived the white flag in July, removing their beloved treehouse from the beach side of Angelinos Sea Lodge. The treehouse was built in 2011 without permits and became the subject of several court cases, ultimately leading to a judicial order to remove the structure. Fans said goodbye to the treehouse over the July 4 holiday. Demolition was completed on Aug. 30.

ELECTION PRODUCES TIGHT RACE

Holmes Beach: Year in Review
Titsworth
Holmes Beach: Year in Review
Roth

Holmes Beach Mayor Judy Titsworth has two more years in office, winning by a thin margin over political newcomer Mike Roth. Titsworth took home the win by 41 votes. Joining Titsworth on the Holmes Beach dais are re-elected Commissioner Dan Diggins and returning Commissioner Carol Whitmore.

RESIDENTS FIGHT CONSOLIDATION, PARKING GARAGE

Plans by former Manatee County commissioners to build a three-story parking garage at Manatee Beach and consolidate the three Anna Maria Island cities were thwarted by voters. Residents, business owners and visitors all came together to fight against both measures, holding a rally in Holmes Beach in May and a Hands Across the Sand event in April.Holmes Beach: Year in Review

PARKING GARAGE PLANS STRUCK DOWN

While Manatee County officials still have permission in the form of a bill approved by the Florida Legislature to build a three-story parking garage at Manatee Beach, those plans are currently on an indefinite hiatus. Voters fought against the parking garage, a project of former county commissioner Kevin Van Ostenbridge, at the polls on Nov. 4. Van Ostenbridge was ousted as the District 3 commissioner and new Commissioner Tal Siddique has pledged to abandon the project.

OPPAGA STUDY RESULTS PENDING

The Office of Program Policy Analysis and Government Accountability study by the state concluded in 2024, but the results have not yet been released. Ordered in 2023 by members of the Manatee County state legislative delegation, the study looked at possible alternatives to having three city governments on Anna Maria Island, including consolidation of the three cities into one and annexation into unincorporated Manatee County or the city of Bradenton. The study was met with much criticism by the public. Holmes Beach Commissioner Terry Schaefer says he plans to review the results of the study with Rep. Will Robinson Jr. in the new year.

MILLAGE RATE LOWERED, TAXES UP

Holmes Beach commissioners voted to lower the millage rate from 2.05 to 1.99 mills, a 2.5% reduction for taxpayers. Despite the lowered millage rate, property taxes still went up by 7.63% for owners due to an increase in property values as assessed by the Manatee County Property Appraiser’s Office.

HURRICANE DEBRIS REMOVAL QUESTIONED

Holmes Beach: Year in ReviewAfter hurricanes blew through the area in September and October, many residents questioned how well the city was handling debris removal along city streets. Hurricane Helene flooded the Island, leaving mountains of sand behind and Hurricane Milton downed trees and fences and caused widespread wind damage, leaving hundreds of tons of debris in its wake. Debris removal has been completed on the Island.

HURRICANE HELENE FLOODS ISLAND

Hurricane Helene swept past Anna Maria Island in the Gulf of Mexico on Sept. 26, but that doesn’t mean the Island was spared from the storm’s wrath. Police Chief Bill Tokajer said that at one point during the storm, his officers measured 2 feet of water standing in the center of Gulf Drive near city hall. The storm caused major flooding and displaced tons of sand from Island beaches.

HURRICANE MILTON CAUSES WIDESPREAD DAMAGE

Anna Maria Island was evacuated for a second time in 2024 when Hurricane Milton approached, making landfall near Siesta Key overnight on Oct. 9. While Hurricane Helene brought the water, Milton brought the wind, downing trees and power lines and causing widespread damage. Milton hit just two weeks after Helene impacted the area. While debris removal has been completed, recovery efforts are still ongoing.

CITY ENACTS VACATION RENTAL MORATORIUM

After a second major hurricane swept through the area in as many weeks, Holmes Beach city leaders voted to enact a vacation rental moratorium in an effort to keep tourists away while recovery efforts were in their early days. Rental agents and owners opposed the moratorium, which initially banned vacation rentals in the city for 45 days. Commissioners revisited the moratorium in 30 days and opted to end it two weeks early.

LIGHTNING STRIKES TWO HOLMES BEACH BUSINESSES

Holmes Beach: Year in ReviewA thunderstorm on Aug. 22 resulted in a two-alarm fire when lightning struck the Holmes Beach Business Center, damaging two local businesses. The lightning strike hit the roof of the west side of the complex, damaging West Coast Air Conditioning and Heating and Fun and More Rentals. Firefighters from West Manatee Fire Rescue and three other local districts quickly extinguished the fire. No one was injured but the building sustained major damage.

WATER TAXI STOP DISCUSSED

Manatee County and Holmes Beach leaders argued over the potential for a water taxi stop in the Island’s biggest city over the summer. In July and August, county officials made it clear that they want a stop for the Gulf Islands Ferry service in Holmes Beach, preferably somewhere near city center. Holmes Beach city leaders were divided on the idea with some favoring a stop at Kingfish Boat Ramp. Discussions were derailed by the arrival of hurricanes Helene and Milton.

BEACH PARKING BY THE NUMBERS

Public parking for beach access was a hot topic of conversation early in 2024 with Manatee County commissioners vowing to build a three-story paid parking garage at Manatee Beach to create more spaces. City leaders contended that there are more than enough parking spaces available in Holmes Beach for the number of people who can comfortably be accommodated on the beach.

Letter to the Editor: Holmes Beach residents lament development vote

We would like to extend a special thank you to all who spoke during public comment at the public hearing for the extensive site plan application for the former Wells Fargo property in Holmes Beach City Center.

What was previously a “sleepy” bank at an already tenuous intersection where there was a recent fatality, there will now be retail, indoor and outdoor dining, miniature golf, an arcade, a tour boat, an ice cream shop and storage facilities. It will have 125 seats, 93 parking spaces, six golf cart spaces, and 36 bicycle spaces.

There were multiple knowledgeable speakers addressing obvious issues – traffic, safety, noise, parking, exodus of residents from overdevelopment, etc. We were pleased to even have a speaker from Anna Maria, an articulate one we might add, just like the others. Thanks to all!

Regardless, the application passed unanimously. It was reminiscent of the county’s Aqua by the Bay hearings, or the county meeting where wetland barrier protections were rolled back. We will be forthright in adding that all of this has been on the heels of buzz about the applicant’s contributions to the recent mayoral campaign.

When is intensity too much intensity? Commercial zoning is not an unlimited license for special exceptions for development. One speaker said succinctly, “Is there any weight for the residents? The city needs to please the residents, not the developers, tourists and contractors.”

So residents, please hang on. Bridge Street is “coming soon to a theater near you,” smack dab in the middle of Holmes Beach City Center. You might want to heed a bit of advice from a former city commissioner: “Never underestimate how far a 5-year-old can hit a golf ball!”

Dick and Margie Motzer

Holmes Beach