Skip to main content

Tag: Holmes Beach

Holmes Beach dog park

Changes proposed for dog park

HOLMES BEACH – Dog park users and members of the Holmes Beach Parks and Beautification Committee are finally making some progress in determining changes to present to commissioners for the city’s dog park.

During a special committee meeting, users and committee members discussed how each would like to see the $50,000 in funds allocated for park improvements used. Some of the ideas, which will be presented to commissioners when a fully-formed plan is in place, include redoing the rusting fence, adding benches, adding turf in areas where grass doesn’t grow and putting in new water fountains for dogs and their humans.

Other ideas are to add access gates, change gate access to a push button system, add landscaping in and around the park and add sunshades. At the end of the meeting, after public input, committee members also amended a previous vote, agreeing to present an idea to commissioners to expand the park slightly by squaring it off on the south end where the park curves around the city’s ball field.

Committee member Joshua Linney said squaring off the south end of the park will add a small amount of space to the large dog park, allowing for more dog run areas, and also may allow committee members to move the dividing fence line between the large and small dog parks, giving both more room.

Committee member Dennis Groh proposed adding coco plums to the outer perimeter of the park to beautify the exterior while also helping to block sound from the park for surrounding residential homes. Committee members voted to add the plants to two sides of the fencing, but leave one open to allow easy sight lines for park goers. Also around the perimeter, committee members agreed to propose black, vinyl-coated fencing with four gates into the park, two for each side, along with maintenance entrances for city workers.

Inside the park, the vote was to add benches, add a metal sunshade to each side of the park, put in water fountains for both humans and dogs to use and add pavers underneath the benches. With the pavers, committee members hope to discourage dogs from digging underneath the benches.

Wolf Fibar, a material designed for use in dog parks that resists bacteria and resembles wood mulch, is recommended to be used experimentally underneath one bench to see how the dogs react to the new substance. Two trees are planned to be added to the interior of the park as a part of April Arbor Day celebrations.

Committee members said City Engineer Lynn Burnett is working to address the drainage situation in the park to prevent future flooding during rain events.

One item that was a hot-button issue for dog park users is current access to the park. Despite new large signs being added to the dog park advising of rules and regulations, users said only two gates to the park were opened, creating an access issue.

“I don’t understand what it takes to open a gate,” resident Don Anthony said. “What is preventing us from getting a sign and opening the south gate today?”

Public Works Foreman Dave Benton said part of the issue with putting up signs, which would allow gates to be opened, is the ongoing push to renovate the park. With work already being planned for the area, he said it would be preferable to wait until work is completed before placing the signs.

Committee member Zan Fuller committed to speaking with Mayor Bob Johnson and working to rectify the situation temporarily while park improvements are in the planning phase.

“Some of the things will be an easy fix,” Fuller said, “and some things will take some time.”

“Ya’ll have done wonders today,” Anthony said near the close of the meeting. “You’ve done more today than has been accomplished in years.”

As plans for dog park improvements continue to evolve, anyone with suggestions is asked to contact Linney at jlinney@holmesbeachfl.org to have their comments considered by committee members and discussed at a future meeting.

Related coverage

 

Plans form for dog park improvements

Help remodel the Holmes Beach Dog Park

Tree house

City to pursue tree house demolition in court

HOLMES BEACH – The beachfront tree house in front of Angelinos Sea Lodge won’t stand much longer if city leaders have anything to say about it.

City commissioners voted unanimously to reject demands from the tree house owners that would allow them to retain the structure and to pursue a court order to have the two-story tree house taken down.

Treehouse owners Richard Hazen and Lynn Tran were given until Feb. 9 to apply for a demolition permit with the city. In the hopes of reaching an agreement with the city to end years of litigation and keep the tree house, Hazen and Tran instead submitted a letter of notice and demand refusing to file for a permit and asserting that the city has violated their rights by attempting to force them to remove the structure.

Their demands, with a deadline of April 11, require the city to revoke a 2013 code enforcement board decision requiring the tree house owners to either get a building permit for the structure, which was denied by the city, or remove it.

Building Official Jim McGuinness refused to issue an after-the-fact permit for the tree house stating that its supports need to be deeper in the sand, the structure is not ADA compliant and it’s located over the erosion control line where building is only allowed by city and Florida Department of Environmental Protection special permit.

They also demand the city reimburse the couple for $180,000 in monetary damages and allow the tree house to remain aloft in its Australian pine and wooden piling perch as “exempt from permit requirements.”

If these demands are not met, Hazen and Tran said in their letter that they would continue to pursue the case in court.

In late 2017, Tran and Hazen petitioned the U. S. Supreme Court to hear the case. On Jan. 8, that request was denied, and the city sent a letter demanding the owners remove the structure.

With commissioners agreeing to seek a court order to force the removal of the structure, it looks like the tree house case may be going back to court for a final determination.

Holmes Beach formula business

Formula business ordinance gets contested first approval

HOLMES BEACH – Commissioners somewhat reluctantly voted unanimously to pass the first reading of the city’s formula business ordinance, moving forward regulations that would allow formula, or chain, businesses in the city’s downtown business district only by special exception.

Commissioners’ issue with the ordinance is that they couldn’t make the regulations more restrictive and spread it to other parts of the city while also making it legally defensible. Even City Planner Bill Brisson previously stated that if the ordinance were to cover the shopping centers on East Bay Drive, he would not be able to testify in court on the city’s behalf because the ordinance is built on preserving the character of the city. The character of that particular area has been defined as “modern shopping center” which wouldn’t be lost if more franchise shops opened up. The ordinance allows new formula businesses to open in the city’s downtown district by special exception only.

“It’s not what I want,” Commissioner Carol Soustek said, voting in favor of the ordinance.

Commissioner Rick Hurst agreed but also echoed the sentiments of Brisson and City Attorney Patricia Petruff by saying he wants to make sure whatever ordinance passes a vote can stand up in court. “I think we have to be smart about this,” he said.

Commissioners voted in favor of the ordinance, pushing it forward to a second public hearing and final vote in March with Commissioner Judy Titsworth abstaining because her family owns a shopping plaza in the downtown district.

Attorney Bradley Ellis, appearing on behalf of Benderson Development, owner of the largest shopping plaza on East Bay Drive, said as long as the city doesn’t attempt to regulate formula businesses on his client’s property, there’s no intent to challenge it legally.

Attorney Matthew Brockway, on behalf of the owners of the old Regions Bank building, did not agree.

holmes beach formula business
Owners of this building, the former Regions bank, are threatening a lawsuit if the city commission passes the formula business ordinance because it would prevent chain businesses, such as a real estate office franchise, from moving in. – Kristin Swain | Sun

The Regions Bank building, at 503 Manatee Avenue, is located in the C-1 district where retail businesses are not allowed. With his client considering asking for a rezone of the property to C-2 or C-3 to potentially attract more business owners to the property, Brockway said his client is prepared to challenge the ordinance, if it passes second reading, in court.

Titsworth said commissioners would consider the ordinance in the time between meetings and present any changes to be made to the regulations at the second public hearing, scheduled for March 1.

Related coverage

Formula business ordinance advances to first reading

Waterline

Waterline hotel readies for opening day

HOLMES BEACH – The Waterline Marina Resort and Beach Club is moving closer to opening day.

With temporary occupancy permits in place for much of the main lodge and the secondary Building B, employees are participating in on site training in hopes of a Nov. 29 soft opening. Currently, reservations for the hotel are not being accepted for dates prior to Dec. 15, though public relations specialist Kelly Prieto said the hotel will be opened to the public earlier if possible.

“We need to balance achieving key construction milestones with the holidays and the task of fully training our associates,” Prieto said in a Nov. 10 email. “Naturally, if we feel we can successfully open sooner, we will.”

Opening Waterline’s doors takes a lot more than employee readiness. In order to receive certificates of occupancy from the city’s building department, Building Official Jim McGuinness said issues identified on a punch list must be completed. Owner Mainsail Lodging and Development also must submit final elevation certificates and copies of field inspection logs, and finalize all accessory permits for the project. The site needs to pass final hardscape, landscape, stormwater, rodent proofing, elevator and accessibility inspections. For as long as Mainsail owns the Waterline property, the company is required to uphold an agreement with the city to not install locks that would allow sections of the two-bedroom suites to be rented separately. The company also must maintain drainage improvements on the adjacent Sunrise Lane. Inspections also are required for the pool area and commercial cooking equipment in the restaurant kitchen.

Until the resort property passes its final inspections and receives permanent occupancy permits along with business tax receipts from the city, the doors remain closed to anyone outside of the staff and employee trainers.

The 37-suite hotel is a part of the Autograph Collection of boutique hotels by Marriott. Mainsail was recently awarded the Partnership Circle Award, the highest honor awarded by Marriott to its affiliate owners and franchise partners for hospitality excellence. The hotel giant manages booking and reservations for the property located at 5325 Marina Drive.

skate park closed

Skate park improvements underway

HOLMES BEACH – After being closed for several months, work is getting underway to reopen the gates of the Holmes Beach Skate Park.

While commissioners allocated $100,000 for improvements to the Parks and Beautification Committee, City Engineer Lynn Burnett is already hard at work to make changes to the aging skate park. During a discussion with commissioners, Burnett revealed she’s already in talks with contractors to replace the current fencing and gates to make the park safer for users. She also is attempting to have a specialist come to the city to evaluate the existing skate ramps and obstacles. Part of the evaluation will include repair of existing facilities.

Once these improvements are in place, Holmes Beach Police Chief Bill Tokajer has a plan to more closely monitor who’s using the park to help lessen liability to the city and keep users safer while on premises. His department, charged with monitoring the skate park, purchased a camera system to be placed at both entrances to the park. The new system will allow police department personnel to monitor users without having to station an officer at the park. All skate park users are required to complete a form releasing the city from liability if injured and file it with the police department.

When the park comes under the planning authority of the Parks and Beautification Committee, Commissioner Judy Titsworth said she’d like to see the group discuss the possibility of increasing the size of the park to appeal to older children and teenagers. Currently, the skate park’s size and design are geared toward younger children and beginning skaters. Titsworth said she’d like to enhance the park to keep older children from leaving the Island to go skate at the larger park in downtown Bradenton.

“I’m hoping we can improve it for kids of all ages,” she said.

Holmes Beach election waving

Holmes Beach election results in

HOLMES BEACH – The voters have spoken and Jim Kihm, Carol Soustek, Rick Hurst and Pat Morton will fill the commission’s roster for the next year.

Bringing in the highest number of votes at 698, newcomer Kihm took one of the three two-year terms available. This will be his first term on the city commission.

Filling the remaining two-year terms are incumbent Carol Soustek and newcomer Rick Hurst. Soustek will be returning for her third term, having garnered 572 of the votes. Hurst will be serving his first term on the commission, receiving 556 of the votes.

Taking the one-year term on the city commission is incumbent Morton, who brought in 532 votes. This will be his eighth term as commissioner.

Because of an error in qualifying for last year’s election, Marvin Grossman was reappointed by his fellow commissioners for a one-year term. To put the seat back into its proper election order, Morton will have to run again in 2018 to remain on the commission for a two-year term.

Without enough seats for all candidates, incumbent Grossman was unseated, falling short with 496 votes.

For the first time in three years Holmes Beach hosted a municipal election night to fill its city commission dais. With five candidates and four available seats, 2,854 total votes were cast at the polls and by mail. As of September 2017, Holmes Beach has 2,935 registered voters according to the Manatee County Supervisor of Elections Office.

The first meeting for the new commission will be an organizational meeting, scheduled for Monday, Nov. 20 at 9 a.m. at Holmes Beach City Hall, 5801 Marina Drive.

Center of Anna Maria Island

Island Fitness moves into the Center

ANNA MARIA – The Center of Anna Maria Island is opening its door to welcome an established Holmes Beach business – Island Fitness is moving in with the nonprofit.

“I am looking forward to bringing my years of fitness experience to the community center to both increase the service offerings for Island Fitness members and to the community center’s current members,” said Island Fitness owner Brenda Canning in a press release. “I am confident that through this relationship we will be able to create a mutually beneficial opportunity for growth and community involvement.”

Though some of the details are still being worked out, the staff at Island Fitness will be taking over the Center’s second-floor fitness center. The change comes as Island Fitness’s Holmes Beach location’s lease ends, meaning members will now have to travel down the road to Anna Maria to use their memberships.

Center Executive Director Kristen Lessig said the arrangement is a win-win for both organizations.

“I am extremely excited about the opportunity to work with Brenda and the Island Fitness team,” she said in the Oct. 29 press release. “The Center team is looking forward to expanding our reach within the community through true collaboration. Brenda has an amazing reputation and following in the community, as well as expertise in the fitness industry that will add great value to the services we provide, while our expansive programs and committed staff will allow for Island Fitness members to truly be part of our efforts to preserve the sense of community on the Island.”

Lessig said the Center will remain home to Anna Maria CrossFit which is launching a kid’s program in November.

As the location change begins, Island Fitness members are invited to tour the Center and try one of the fitness classes currently offered. Lessig said one of the details still being ironed out is how current Island Fitness memberships will be honored at the business’s new location and what membership structure will be offered in the future. A finalized timeline for the transition and further details are scheduled to be released to both Island Fitness and Center members by e-mail in the coming weeks.

 

national night out bikes

Celebrating community at National Night Out

HOLMES BEACH – The rain didn’t stop the fun at National Night Out.

The annual event drew more than 1,000 people to Holmes Beach City Field on Oct. 3 to celebrate fun, friendship and community. In its second year, Holmes Beach Police Chief Bill Tokajer estimates the crowd more than tripled from the year before.

“It was a tremendous success,” Tokajer said. He gives credit for the event to city staff and HBPD officers, including Sgt. Vern McGowan and Officer Josh Fleischer who spearheaded the evening.

Bob Baublitz from Waste Pro mans the grill while Tracey Meehan and Commissioner Carol Soustek hand out hot dogs. – Kristin Swain | Sun

“It was great,” Commissioner Judy Titsworth said. “I ran into people I haven’t seen since high school. It was amazing. I can’t believe what you pulled off.”

In addition to the efforts of city staff, individual, group and business sponsors stepped up to help bring the night together. Sponsors donated toys, food, drinks, bicycle helmets, 74 bicycles and their time to unite the community. Families came out from the Island and the mainland to participate in the carnival-like festivities.

West Manatee Fire Rescue firefighters help fit kids for bicycle helmets. – Kristin Swain | Sun

“Thank you to all of our sponsors. The event would not have been the success it was if we didn’t have the community participation from our sponsors who went all out to make sure the kids had a great night,” Tokajer said. “It was just heartwarming to see the children from this community get together and take part in an event that was meant to get people together.”

Anna Maria Island Privateer Cindy “Lady Sinthia” Meeks preps for the bilge rat toss. – Kristin Swain | Sun

National Night Out is a country-wide program aimed at bringing community members together to celebrate a safe, fun, family-friendly night out in their neighborhood.

“There wasn’t a kid who left there without something to take with them, some kind of gift,” Tokajer said.

One of the highlights for Tokajer was his time in the dunking booth.

“Everyone came out to dunk the Chief,” he said, calling out Soustek and City Treasurer Lori Hill for dropping him in the water a total of three times. Also participating in the fun were his daughter and grandkids who submerged him a few times. “It was fun,” Tokajer said.

Christina Walker and daughter Khaleessi go greet father and grandfather HBPD Chief Bill Tokajer after sinking him in the dunking booth. – Kristin Swain | Sun

“It was a fabulous event, thank you so much,” Commissioner Jean Peelen said, congratulating city staff. She suggested working with other communities and organizations next year to make sure the event continues its mission of benefitting high-risk kids.

City Engineer Lynn Burnett said she knew this year’s National Night Out event benefitted some high-risk kids at G.D. Rogers Garden-Bullock Elementary School in Bradenton. During the event, a teacher from the school working with severely handicapped kids approached Public Works Foreman Dave Benton. After hearing about the children at the school, Benton sent the teacher home with four bicycles and several boxes of toys.

“Any opportunity that presented itself, your staff took it and went full force,” Burnett said.

Tokajer said city staff is already hard at work planning next year’s event.

“It’s going to be bigger and better next year,” he promised.

Boat canopies

Boat canopies scheduled for vote

HOLMES BEACH – The showdown between city leaders and residents of Westbay Point and Moorings over boat canopies is finally coming to an end.

During a Sept. 28 workshop, commissioners committed to placing the item on the Oct. 10 agenda for a vote. The decision comes after months of conversation between commissioners and residents of the neighboring condominium complex.

Residents argue the canopies block views and reduce property values. Holmes Beach Police Chief Bill Tokajer argues the boat canopies protect valuable rescue boats. The canopies were installed in late 2016 over private boat lifts for the HBPD and West Manatee Fire Rescue. Though commissioners gave approval, the canopies remain a sore spot with residents.

“I’m totally in opposition,” Westbay resident Penny Gray said of the canopies. “Those need to come down.”

Gray was only one of a dozen residents attending the Sept. 28 meeting hoping for answers. Commissioner Judy Titsworth asked residents to submit questions in writing for the Oct. 10 meeting. In addition to commissioners, surveyor Leo Mills Jr. is expected to answer resident questions. Mills completed the riparian rights survey proving the canopies are legally placed.

“We’re trying to be patient,” resident Robyn Kinkopf said. “I feel we deserve to have our questions answered.”

Property manager Robert Glynn feels commissioners are interpreting the city ordinance governing the placement of boat canopies incorrectly. He argues that placing the canopies on a waterway with residential neighbors violates the ordinance. Titsworth says it’s up to commissioners how to interpret the ordinance.

“It’s a big decision for all of us,” she said. “We already spent taxpayer money to put it up and it will take taxpayer money to remove.”

Commissioner Marvin Grossman was ready to make a decision that night. Legally though, no action can be taken by commissioners during a work session.

“This is ridiculous,” he said. “The canopies seriously block some condos. We went along with this because we were told it wouldn’t block anything.”

Grossman suggested exploring other options such as boat covers instead of the boat canopies.

“Even though we’ve spent some money, it was a mistake,” he said.

Though present, Tokajer remained mute on the issue.

The Oct. 10 vote determines if the canopies come down at the 63rd Street boat ramp. Options under consideration by commissioners include relocation of the lifts and canopies or an alternative type of protective covering at the current lift location.

Gloria Dei Lutheran Church

Land purchase concerns commissioners

HOLMES BEACH – A potential land purchase by the city is moving forward faster than some commissioners would like.

During their Sept. 26 meeting, Holmes Beach commissioners voted to approve a $5,000 expenditure for two land appraisals. They also voted to give Mayor Bob Johnson authority to enter into an agreement for bond services on the city’s behalf. The reason for both votes is to allow the city to move forward in considering purchasing land from Gloria Dei Lutheran Church. Some commissioners aren’t quite comfortable with the move.

Commissioner Judy Titsworth said she “doesn’t feel the city should be in the land acquisition business.” If a surplus of funds exists, she suggests using them to deal with other issues facing the city.

“I don’t feel comfortable getting into debt at this point,” she said, adding it would be different if the purchase was a need for the city rather than a want.

Commissioner Marvin Grossman said he felt the issue was moving forward too quickly without commission approval of the purchase, public input or adequate information.

“It’s a very difficult decision,” he said. “It’s a funny point now to start talking about it. You don’t hire people before you make up your mind. I feel like we’re doing this in reverse. I’m willing to go along with this to explore it further.”

The rear two parcels of land could be used as a city park or rezoned for single-family homes. – Kristin Swain | Sun

If purchased, the city would own three parcels of land at the church site. Two of the parcels, located in the rear of the church, provide green space. Without a definite plan in place, Grossman and Titsworth want to explore possible uses for the property. The third triangular-shaped parcel in the front of the church property could be used to realign the Palm Avenue entrance to Marina Drive. To alleviate congestion at the intersection, Marina Drive would be aligned further to the north, away from the nearby entrance to Key Royale.

The Gloria Dei land purchase could see this Marina Drive entrance move farther north, away from Key Royale Drive. – Kristin Swain | Sun

The purchase could cost the city more than $1.3 million. City Treasurer Lori Hill said the two agreements approved didn’t obligate the city to anything other than the appraisal costs. If commissioners move forward, $7,500 is due for acquiring the bond. Additional financial costs for the purchase are estimated at $35,000 or less. Despite not needing voter approval for the purchase, commissioners agreed public input is needed.

Grossman said he’d prefer to not pay more than $800,000 for the property.

Resident Jim Kihm said he wants to know the city’s vision for the property. With so much about the transaction unknown, he wants more discussion before city leaders commit.

Commissioner Carol Soustek wants the city to look toward the future when considering the purchase. “We need to move forward with this and give it some more thought,” she said.

Agreeing with Titsworth, Commissioner Jean Peelen said she feels it’s less about providing green space and more about saving the church.

“It colors my feelings about it and not in a good direction,” she said. “Every church on this island is having issues. Congregations are disappearing. I’m not totally comfortable with Holmes Beach and its rationale for going through with something this expensive.”

“It’s not really our problem to save the church,” Titsworth said. “It’s not our role. I do hope they survive.”

With the appraisal expenditures approved, commissioners agreed to continue the discussion once all three parcels are valued. Mayor Bob Johnson said he’d had a discussion with Gloria Dei’s leadership but no offer would be made without commission approval.

Holmes Beach logo OLD

Commission split over city manager

HOLMES BEACH — Commissioners are on both sides of the fence over whether or not to hire a city manager.

During a May 23 work session, members of a residents’ committee presented the pros and cons of hiring a manager.

For the residents, transitioning to a city manager form of government has primarily positive outcome scenarios, according to members of the committee.

“I wish I could say I found some negativity, but I didn’t,” resident and committee member Renae Ferguson said. “I think the results we got were enlightening to say the least.”

Ferguson reported that out of the 12 coastal cities spoken to, all were pleased with the results of having a city manager, versus only a mayor, to handle the day-to-day operations of the city. The reason was listed as the consistency a city manager provides.

Unlike a mayor, who faces re-election every two years, a city manager is a hired employee who is expected to be with the city long-term. City managers also are required to meet certain job qualifications whereas a mayor can be anyone who qualifies to run for office. In Holmes Beach, that means meeting a residency requirement and candidate paperwork deadlines.

If commissioners choose to pursue hiring a city manager, a mayor would still be elected every two years but would be responsible for oversight rather than the daily activities of city government.

Mayor Bob Johnson said he’s in favor of creating a city manager position to foster continuity for staff and residents after his current term expires.

Johnson previously announced he wouldn’t be seeking a third term as mayor. His current term expires November 2018.

Commissioner Carol Soustek agreed with Johnson.

“It’s a small city with big city problems,” she said of Holmes Beach. Soustek expressed concern that with a shrinking pool of residents, particularly those willing to take on the role of mayor, it may be time to consider revamping the city’s form of government.

“It’s not a choice up here anymore, it’s kind of a necessity to consider this,” she said.

Commissioner Judy Titsworth isn’t sure a city manager is the right move for Holmes Beach. She said she would like to see an election pass without a mayoral candidate stepping forward before she considers installing a city manager.

“If each charter position was hired as a competent team player to uphold the wishes of the commission through the mayor, our charter would work,” she said. At this time, Titsworth said she’s unwilling to expend the time and effort needed to review and change the city’s charter to accommodate a city manager position.

“I think you’re naïve about the charter,” Johnson said. “We have a good staff, that’s not the issue. The issue is stability. The city is suffering in a way it doesn’t need to.”

“This is definitely one thing that doesn’t need to be rushed,” Titsworth said.

Soustek recommended moving the discussion to the next work session for further contemplation by commissioners.

“Come back again,” she said to members of the residents’ committee. “It will be continued.”

FDOT approves Holmes Beach speed changes

HOLMES BEACH — It didn’t take long for the Florida Department of Transportation to respond to Holmes Beach commissioners’ request to return the Holmes Beach speed limit to 35 miles per hour west of the Anna Maria Island Bridge.
Holmes Beach drivers were in an uproar after the FDOT lowered the speed limit across the bridge from 45 to 35 m.p.h. and reduced speed west of the bridge from 35 to 25 m.p.h. without notice.
During a special meeting convened Feb. 16, commissioners unanimously voted to request a reversal of the FDOT decision.
David Gwynn, FDOT Director of Transportation Operations, sent a same-day response Feb. 22 to Holmes Beach Mayor Bob Johnson’s e-mailed request to increase the speed limit west of the bridge to its previous posted limit.
While Gwynn agreed to reverse the change, in his e-mail, he maintained the speed study completed prior to the change and submitted to the city after new signs were posted remains valid. He said another one would not be conducted by the department at this time. The change took effect Feb. 28.
Commissioners also voted 4 to 1, with Commissioner Pat Morton dissenting, to increase the speed limit from 25 to 35 m.p.h. along a stretch of Gulf Drive from 43rd Street to 52nd Street near Anna Maria Elementary School.
The change went into effect Feb. 22.