Skip to main content

Tag: bait shop

Brian Blaine lived, loved until the end

Brian Blaine lived, loved until the end

ANNA MARIA ISLAND – Former City Pier bait shop bartender Brian Blaine passed away on Aug. 4 at the age of 51.

The Bradenton resident is survived by his significant other of nearly four years, Jill Anderson. Brian, who never married, also leaves behind his 12-year-old daughter, Molly Ann Blaine, and his 18-year-old son, William Robert Blaine, both of whom live with their mom in Bradenton.

“He loved to take Molly to the Bridge Street Pier and she’d throw pennies at the heart-shaped rock in the water like a wishing well. She also loved going to the Moose with us. He loved that little girl like no other,” Jill said.

Brian Blaine lived, loved until the end
Molly Ann Blaine loved her father, Brian Blaine. – Brian Blaine/ Facebook | Submitted

A celebration of life will be held on Sunday, Sept. 1 from 10 a.m. to 6 p.m. at the Drift In in Bradenton Beach. Attendees are invited to bring a covered dish to share, along with their memories of Brian. Steve Paradis will provide the live music in honor of his late friend.

“The Drift In was like home to Brian. That was like family. We were there every day. We spent Christmas and Thanksgiving there. He loved that bar. Brian didn’t want a funeral service. He wanted me to spread his ashes at the City Pier and have a celebration at the Drift,” Jill said.

“Brian was a wonderful man and a good friend to all,” Drift In manager Doreen Flynn said.

Beer on the pier

Brian sold bait, tackle and beer at the City Pier bait shop in Anna Maria for about six years when Mario Schoenfelder leased the city-owned City Pier Restaurant and bait shop buildings. He was among those displaced from their jobs when the City Pier was closed in September 2017 and later replaced due to damage inflicted by Hurricane Irma, including the loss of the bait shop roof.

Brian Blaine lived, loved until the end
In 2017, Hurricane Irma ripped the roof off the City Pier Restaurant bait shop. – Joe Hendricks | Sun

A few months later, on Thanksgiving morning, Brian, a former executive recruiter, and his former co-workers gathered at Bayfront Park to catch up and check in on each other.

Brian Blaine lived, loved until the end
In 2017, the displaced City Pier Restaurant employees gathered at Bayfront Park on Thanksgiving morning. – Joe Hendricks | Sun

“The pier is a magical place for us. It was my favorite place in the world. It’s the worst I’ve been paid, but the best corner office I ever had,” he said that day before passing out lottery tickets as holiday gifts.

Brian Blaine lived, loved until the end
City Pier Restaurant General Manager David Sork received a Thanksgiving lottery ticket from Brian Blaine in 2017. – Joe Hendricks | Sun

The new pier opened in mid-2020. Under new management, the City Pier Grill and bait shop opened later that year but Brian never worked there again.

David Sork was the general manager of the old City Pier Restaurant and bait shop. He now works at the Ugly Grouper in Holmes Beach.

“Brian wasn’t nearly as interested in the fishing end of things as he was in entertaining folks and pouring beers,” Sork said. “We were a big family out there and a lot of folks became really good friends. We came together for a common objective: to make a living and have a good time. Brian was incredibly friendly. He built relation­ships with the customers and had a lot of regulars. He absolutely loved that job and he did it well. He’d serve you a beer and a smile and engage in conversation. He was a happy-go-lucky guy and I’m glad he walked into my life.”

In early May, Brian posted on Facebook a photo of himself, Sork and former City Pier Restaurant staffer Rockey Corby. He referenced Sork and Corby as “the two greatest bosses ever in my life.”

Brian Blaine lived, loved until the end
Former City Pier Restaurant employees David Sork, Brian Blaine and Rockey Corby met up in early May. – Brian Blaine/Facebook | Submitted

When discussing his final visit with Brian, Sork said, “Rock and I got together with Brian and Jill a few months ago at the Drift In. We had a good time and it was nice to reminisce and laugh. There was always a big smile on that boy’s face.”

Trevor Peres owns and operates the T-Bone’s Famous Smokin’ Bar-B-Que food truck at Keyes Marina. He also plays rhythm guitar in the famous death metal band, Obituary. After moving to Holmes Beach in 2010, Peres met Brian while fishing at the pier.

Brian Blaine lived, loved until the end
After meeting at the City Pier Restaurant bait shop, Trevor Peres and Brian Blaine became good friends. – Jill Anderson | Submitted

“The City Pier had that cool little bait and tackle shop with a bar where you could buy beer. He loved beer, I loved beer, he played guitar and I played guitar, so we hit it off immedi­ately and became friends,” Peres said.

“Brian was cool and funny. When he was bartending, children would come over with their parents and he’d tell the kids knock-knock jokes. I found out he was from New Jersey so I started calling him ‘Jersey,’ and I’d say it with a New Jersey accent. He liked that,” Peres recalled.

Peres helped Brian record some of his own original songs at a friend’s recording studio near Lakewood Ranch.

“He was a huge Grateful Dead fan. I’m more Celtic Frost and Slayer,” Peres said of their differing musical tastes.

Peres, now a Bradenton resident, last saw Brian about a year ago at Danny’s Pizzeria.

“He was leaving and had a piece of pizza crust in his hand. Being silly like he was, he threw it at me and it hit my windshield. I never saw him again, but I talked to him on the phone two weeks before he passed.”

Love story

Brian was born in Newton, N.J. and grew up in nearby Sparta.

“He had some trauma and bad times and needed to get away. He got in his car and came here in 1998 and never left,” Jill said.

Regarding the bait shop and the pier, Jill said, “To him, that place was magical. He used to be a corporate headhunter. He made good money but it was high stress and he’d had enough. Working at the pier was the best job of his life and the happiest he’d ever been.

Brian Blaine lived, loved until the end
Brian Blaine and Jill Anderson loved hanging out at the Drift In. – Brian Blaine/Facebook | Submitted

“We met at the Drift In on Oct. 23, 2020. By fluke, he was out at night. He was usually a day drinker. My girlfriend and I came on a trip from Nebraska. Our second night here, I walked through the back door of the Drift and he was standing by the women’s bathroom. I walked up to him, he put his hand out, I put my hand in his and said, ‘Hi, I’m Jill.’ He said, ‘I’m Brian.’ He kissed me and I fell in love right then and there.

“I took him to our Airbnb and we stayed up all night talking. He was so deep and I felt so comfortable with him. We had so much in common. It really was love at first sight and we were lucky to have found that love that most people don’t find in their lifetime.”

Jill returned to Nebraska, to her children, family and a successful hair and nail salon that included a boutique, tanning salon and massage therapy. Jill and Brian visited each other several times before she moved to Bradenton in August 2021.

“I’d been a hairdresser for 35 years, but I knew when I met Brian that’s who I wanted to be with the rest of my life. I didn’t want to spend 10-12 hours a day in a salon anymore even though I loved it,” she said.

“Brian loved the Grateful Dead and went to 49 of their concerts. He loved Jerry Garcia and that music helped him through hard times and good times. He loved “Ripple” and I played a lot of Grateful Dead songs the night he passed away at our home in Bradenton.”

Many years before he met Jill, Brian wrote a song called “Tonight,” which later became their song; and he played it for her at the District 10 gathering place in Linwood, Nebraska.

“Brian would come back to Nebraska with me to see my family and kids. He made so many friends there. He loved driving down the gravel roads and being around the cornfields.

“We were best friends, lovers and confidants. Neither one of us worked and we were together all the time. We had the most amazing and romantic times. He always described us as ‘One: Pure and true,’ and we were.

“Around 2019, he was diagnosed with cirrhosis of the liver. He had other health issues too. In 2017, he had that flesh-eating bacteria on his hand. He had neuropathy in his feet and gallstones. He was officially diagnosed with end-stage liver failure last October. A liver transplant was the only thing that would have saved him, but he believed the doctors were wrong and his body would bounce back. He knew deep down it was from the beer, but he enjoyed beer and what’s life if you can’t enjoy it? He never complained or felt pity for himself and he always said there’s people out there who have it far worse. He tried to see the good in people and he loved talking to strangers. Every day, he tried to do a good deed to make somebody’s day special.

Brian Blaine lived, loved until the end
Jill Anderson lost the love of her life when Brian Blaine passed away. – Jill Anderson | Submitted

“I always hoped I’d find true love like my mom and dad had. Brian and I only had four years together, but that’s what we had. I’m so thankful he was in my life. He was my world and always will be. I lost my life partner, my best friend, my everything. I feel such an emptiness,” Jill said.

City Pier Grill opening soon

City Pier Grill opening soon

ANNA MARIA – The City Pier Grill could open this week or next, according to Brian Seymour, who will operate the business with partners Nick Graham and Vic Mattay.

The exact opening date will be announced on the City Pier Grill Facebook page.

When the business opens, the City Pier will be open to the public seven days a week for the first time since the new pier opened to the public three days a week in June. All seating will be outside.

“We are excited to get going, and the mayor’s excited to get the pier up and running. We want to get this pier open seven days a week and the city wants that as well,” said Seymour, of GSM Partners LLC.

“We’ll be open seven days a week from 7 a.m. until 10 p.m. We’ll be open 365 days a year. On holidays such as Christmas and Thanksgiving, there might be some adjusted hours, but we will be open so the locals and tourists can enjoy the pier on major holidays,” Seymour said.

“We’ve got our live bait tanks set up and ready to go. We’ll have bait and tackle, breakfast, lunch and beyond and sweet treats,” he added.

As the city’s new pier tenants, City Pier Grill will operate in and around the smaller of the two city-owned buildings at the T-end of the pier.

On Tuesday, Nov. 24, Seymour provided a tour of the work taking place.

City Pier Grill opening soon
The kitchen hood installation was among the work taking place during Thanksgiving week. – Joe Hendricks | Sun

While standing inside the 300-square-foot interior space, Seymour said, “We’re at the finishing stages. We’ll be finishing up the hood installation and installing the electrical plugs and plates and kitchen equipment soon.”

The food and beverage equipment includes two fryers, a flattop grill, a charbroiler, a small freezer, a beer and wine cooler and a kegerator.

Seymour said he hopes to have the final inspections completed this week, if possible.

“The tropical storm set us back,” Seymour said of the weather conditions and rough seas that delayed the gas company and plumbers from getting under the pier in a boat to complete those connections.

“We have a good core staff and we’re still looking for talented, experienced people. This is going to be a fast-paced, fun and energetic work environment,” Seymour said.

Those seeking employment can send an email to CityPierGrill@gmail.com or stop by in person after the opening.

Grill offerings

The breakfast menu will include breakfast sandwiches, waffles, pancakes, fresh fruits, coffees, teas and more.

The Bradenton-based Banyan Coffee Company will provide the coffees, brewed teas and ice teas and Mixon Fruit Farms in Bradenton will provide fresh juices.

“The lunch and beyond menu will have fish and chips, fish sandwiches, fish tacos, shrimp baskets, cheeseburgers, hot dogs and more. We have a vegetarian-type hot dog and burger too. We’ll have a made-to-order wedge salad and Caesar salad and we’ll have daily breakfast and lunch and beyond specials,” Seymour said.

“We’ll have a full sweet treat menu with soft-serve ice cream, gelatos, waffle cones and select pies from Hometown Desserts, a favorite here on the Island. We’ll have draft beer, local craft beers and a nice wine selection. We’ll have six beers on tap,” Seymour said.

“Our plan is to eventually have live acoustic music and we’re looking for local musicians who are interested in performing out here,” he said of the rear deck that faces the Sunshine Skyway Bridge.

City Pier Grill opening soon
With live bait wells out front, the City Pier Grill will operate in and around the smaller of the two city-owned pier buildings. – Joe Hendricks | Sun

Chris Powers will serve as operations manager.

“My duties will include making sure we have adequate staff at all times and that anyone who comes out for bait is taken care of. I’ll also have the duties of a pier attendant, making sure the guests are having a good time and are safe,” Powers said.

His son, Jacob Powers, will serve as executive chef.

“I’ll make sure we’ve got consistent food quality and the customers are happy with their experience and what they’re eating,” Jacob Powers said.

His kitchen experience includes stints at Slim’s Place in Anna Maria, The Feast Restaurant in Holmes Beach and a few restaurants in Tennessee. He also helped open and manage a French bakery.

Seymour, the owner/operator of the Anna Maria General Store, said, “Mostly recently, Jacob has been the chef at the General Store. His talents, creativity and ability to make great specials are definitely going to benefit us out here on the pier. We’re looking forward to him continuing his growth out here.”

Anna Maria Commission rejects Ugly Grouper pier lease offer

Commission rejects Ugly Grouper pier lease offer

Updated Aug. 3, 2020 – ANNA MARIA – The Anna Maria City Commission has rejected Ugly Grouper LLC’s offer to lease the city-owned restaurant and bait shop buildings on the new City Pier.

Thursday night, the commission voted 3-2 in favor of rejecting the lease offer presented by Mike Ross, co-owner of the Ugly Grouper restaurant in Holmes Beach. The motion made by Commissioner Jon Crane and supported by commissioners Carol Carter and Amy Tripp also terminated those lease discussions and negotiations.

Although they shared many of the same concerns regarding the offer presented, commissioners Joe Muscatello and Mark Short opposed Crane’s motion and supported giving Ross and Mayor Dan Murphy two more weeks to continue their negotiations.

In the wake of the decision, the city’s immediate goal is to find a vendor to operate a bait shop and snack bar, while questions remain regarding the need for a full-service restaurant on the pier.

Ugly Grouper offer

Before Ross presented his offer, Murphy said the commission had four options:

  • Accept the offer as presented and develop a final lease agreement.
  • Reject the offer and continue the pursuit of a modified offer.
  • Reject the offer and terminate the lease negotiations.
  • Consider the offer, but delay taking any formal action.

Murphy noted the offer Ross was presenting was the result of the fact-finding discussions he and Ross engaged in since mid-May.

“I think we could have the bait shop and snack shop open this fall, with the restaurant right after that,” Ross said during his opening remarks, while participating by phone.

He then read aloud the two-page Ugly Grouper offer previously emailed to Murphy and the commissioners.

Anna Maria Commission rejects Ugly Grouper pier lease offer
The floor plan submitted by Ugly Grouper LLC proposed a total of 162 seats. – City of Anna Maria | Submitted

The Ugly Grouper offer was accompanied by a floor plan and seating chart that proposed 162 total seats – 72 inside the restaurant, 46 in the covered, open-air breezeway and deck area just outside the restaurant building and eight outdoor bar seats along the side of the bait shop.

The floor plan proposed 36 additional seats in the uncovered common area on the deck behind the bait shop. Ross said that area could include a shade feature to be opened or closed depending on weather conditions.

Although not designated as fishing space, the floor plan indicated approximately 7 feet of mostly open space along the rear and side edges of the T-end deck.

Ross proposed a 10-year lease with four potential 10-year extensions. He proposed paying the city $14,000 per month in base rent – $4,000 less than the $18,000 offered in the group’s original response to the city’s request for proposals (RFP).

Based on an estimate from local builder Frank Agnelli, the Ugly Grouper offer proposed it would cost $1.02 million to complete the interior buildouts of the restaurant and bait shop buildings. Ross proposed the city pay $440,650 of that amount to cover the cost of air conditioning and heating equipment, electrical and plumbing outlets, drywall, flooring and walk-in coolers.

“City either pays Ugly Grouper $440,650 cash or credits Ugly Grouper in free rent for buildout of the restaurant – approximately 2.5 years free rent,” the offer sheet said.

Ross proposed initially paying the city $10,000 or $11,000 a month when business operations commenced and applying the remaining $3,000-$4,000 per month toward the city’s buildout costs.

Ross proposed his group pay 25% of the maintenance and cleaning expenses for the pier and the public restrooms.

Ross requested 64 parking spaces. He said the number of seats were more important than the number of parking spaces.

The Ugly Grouper offer proposed the city carry hazard and property insurance for the pier and pier building exteriors that covered the perils of fire, wind, hurricane damage and loss of income by the tenant. Ross said his group would carry a $1 million general liability policy and an additional liquor liability policy.

Commission response

Carter said the offer Ross presented was “quite different than the one we saw earlier.”

She then said, “Why have you increased the seating to this extent? We were familiar with about half that number previously. I am very concerned with this number of seats. The way you’ve laid them out doesn’t allow for a fishing pier and a public pier. It’s all restaurant,” Carter said.

Anna Maria Commission rejects Ugly Grouper pier lease offer
Commission Chair Carol Carter expressed concerns about the number of seats requested. – Joe Hendricks | Sun

Ross said the proposed number of seats would create a “win-win” scenario that provided the revenue needed for the restaurant operations and the rent revenue sought by the city. He also said having less than 150 seats would require a more expensive liquor license that costs $350,000. 

Murphy said he thought previous pier tenant Mario Schoenfelder was licensed for 70 to 80 seats.

During the meeting, Ross said he just received a text message confirming that Schoenfelder operated with 120 total seats.

“126 is our ask right now, with 36 public seats,” Ross told the commission.

General Manager Thad Treadwell later told The Sun that Schoenfelder operated with 96 inside seats and 24 outside seats.

On Sunday, Schoenfelder sent Murphy an email disputing those claims.

“TCPR Inc. operated 72 seats inside plus five seats at the bar – total 77 seats inside,” Schoenfelder’s email said.

Schoenfelder told The Sun in an email that he had an additional 25 outdoor seats, for a total of 102 seats.

During Thursday’s meeting, Ross said he was open to crunching the numbers to see what could be accomplished with fewer seats. He asked the commission if there was a hard line on the number of seats, but that number was not provided.

Tripp said the city carrying an insurance policy that covered the tenant’s loss of income did not sit well with her. Muscatello suggested it would be expensive and consume a significant portion of the city’s rent revenues.

Short compared the negotiations to buying a car and said, “The dealer tells you X, you come with Y and there’s some back and forth.”

Regarding the offer presented, Short said, “Are there surprises? Certainly, there are a lot of surprises. I’ve also heard a willingness to continue discussions to try to hone in and deal with some of the things I think we all have concerns about.”

Muscatello supported allowing the negotiations to continue for two more weeks, but he also questioned the need for a pier restaurant. He suggested that space might be better used for educational purposes by partnering with Mote Marine.

Public input

During public input, Bob Carter said the city already invested millions of dollars in the new pier and the RFP stated the pier tenant would be provided with empty shells that included roughed-in plumbing and electrical.

Carter shared his wife’s concerns about the additional seating. He said the pier is a public space to be shared by visitors, people fishing and restaurant patrons.

“When I looked at this plan, it looks like we built this for a restaurant,” Carter said, noting he’d be happy with a restaurant that only had a beer and wine license. “I urge the city not to accept this as is.”

Anna Maria Commission rejects Ugly Grouper pier lease offer
The Ugly Grouper floor plan proposed that 36 additional seats be placed on the deck area behind the bait shop. – Joe Hendricks | Sun

Former City Commissioner Doug Copeland participated in much of the pier replacement decisionmaking that occurred before he left office in December.

“I’m very disappointed,” Copeland said of the offer presented.

Copeland said the offer did not reflect what was proposed in the group’s original RFP response. He noted the RFP plainly stated the pier tenant was responsible for the interior buildouts and he encouraged the commission to reject the offer.

Post-meeting comments

After the meeting, Murphy commented on the commission’s decision.

“I support the commission’s decision because I think at some point in the future the city will be in a better position to rent that space out. Financially, we’re in good shape. We reconstructed that pier debt-free. That pier is totally paid for. If we had debt with that pier it would be a completely different picture. I think this presents an opportunity for the city to look at other alternatives,” he said.

“I think it was made clear that we don’t need to have a restaurant. But we do need something, and we need it quickly,” Murphy said regarding a bait shop and snack shop that offers a limited menu. “I’m going to pursue that vigorously.”

On Friday, Treadwell provided a statement.

“We appreciate the opportunity to work with the commission and Mayor Murphy on this project to reopen the Anna Maria City Pier bait shop and restaurant. We are disappointed we weren’t able to extend negotiations another week to clear up some miscommunications to try to reach an agreeable deal and open this fall. We are excited to see the historic City Pier reopen and will support whoever the new tenant will be,” Treadwell said.

Friday evening, Murphy sent commissioners an email regarding the pursuit of a bait shop/snack shop vendor.

Anna Maria Commission rejects Ugly Grouper pier lease offer
Mayor Dan Murphy is now in the process of preparing an RFP for a bait shop/snack shop operator. – Joe Hendricks | Sun

“As a result of our meeting last night, I was given direction to explore the provision of takeout food and beverage service from the bait-shop/snack bar on the City Pier. Accordingly, we are in the process of preparing an RFP to solicit bids for that type of service. This should be finalized and ready for your review in the next seven to 10 days, or less,” Murphy wrote.

“Since our meeting last night, four local restaurateurs have contacted the city and expressed a keen interest in providing takeout food and beverage service from the bait shop facility. Our intent is to solicit bids from any and all interested parties once the RFP is prepared and approved. In the meantime, please send any of your concerns, ideas or points of interest which you would like included in the RFP,” Murphy wrote.

New City Pier expected to open in April

New City Pier expected to open in April

ANNA MARIA – Mayor Dan Murphy expects the new Anna Maria City Pier to open in April, but he has not yet determined an exact opening date.

“It looks like in the April timeframe we’ll be opening the pier for fishing and sightseeing,” Murphy told the city commission on Thursday, March 12.

Murphy said Florida Power & Light completed its work on the pier that day. That work consisted of installing transformers and electrical connections needed to light the new pier and to power the new restaurant, bait shop and public restrooms at the pier’s T-end.

Murphy said he would provide a specific opening date once he completes an analysis of the remaining work that needs to be done.

Due to the lingering concerns and uncertainties associated with the coronavirus (COVID-19), Murphy said he and the commission will soon determine whether the city will host grand opening ceremonies for the pier as previously discussed.

Pier RFP deadlines

As of Sunday, no changes had been made to the existing schedule for interested restaurateurs to respond to the city’s request for proposals for a new pier tenant to lease the restaurant and bait shop buildings.

According to the city website, Wednesday, March 25 is still the last day to submit written questions about the city-owned spaces for lease. Wednesday, April 8 is still the deadline to submit the pier lease proposals scheduled to be opened inside the commission chambers at approximately 1 p.m. that day.

Murphy recently said he expects the new restaurant and bait shop to open during the fourth quarter of the current year or the first quarter of 2021.

Deadline extended for final pier lease offer

Deadline extended for final pier lease offer

ANNA MARIA – Mario Schoenfelder now has until Dec. 31 to submit his final offer for the lease of the restaurant and bait shop buildings being built on the new Anna Maria City Pier.

During an emergency commission meeting on Tuesday, Nov. 26, the Anna Maria City Commission unanimously granted Schoenfelder’s written request for more time to prepare and submit his final lease offer, which was originally due Friday, Dec. 13.

Mayor Dan Murphy told the commission Schoenfelder needs time to analyze the information he receives from his own contractor regarding the estimated cost for the interior build-outs for the city-owned buildings he hopes to lease. Murphy said Schoenfelder expects to have that information by Dec. 8 and he expects to submit his final offer by Dec. 30.

Mason Martin Builders is building the exterior shells of the new restaurant and bait shop buildings but that firm’s contract with the city does not include the interior build-outs to be completed by the pier tenant.

“I would recommend that we give him this extension, but it is certainly up to each of you,” Murphy said to the commission regarding Schoenfelder’s request.

Participating by phone, Commissioner Mark Short referenced the commission’s recent decision to authorize Murphy to prepare and have ready a request for proposals that would allow other restaurateurs to submit lease proposals if the commission rejects Schoenfelder’s final offer.

Short asked if giving Schoenfelder more time would delay that RFP process. Murphy said it would not. Short asked if the RFP would be ready to present to the commission on Jan. 9, if needed. Murphy said it would.

Murphy recommended the commission not make any final decisions regarding Schoenfelder’s final offer or the issuance of an RFP until a full commission is seated on Jan. 9. That’s when the commission will appoint someone to fill the commission seat Dale Woodland vacates on Dec. 5 due to his failure to properly qualify for the 2019 city elections.

Murphy said Schoenfelder will not return to the United States until March and would like to discuss his final offer with the commission as a whole.

“March is too long to wait. We need to know, and he needs to know, where we stand on his final offer,” Murphy said of that timeline.

Murphy said the commission discussion with Schoenfelder could take place in January via Skype, telephone or some other means of electronic communication, but the commission first needs to see his final offer.

Previous offers

Schoenfelder’s current pier lease expires on Dec. 15, 2020. In October, Schoenfelder rejected two lease options Murphy presented him. One option proposed a base rent of $21,600 per month with a 3% annual increase. The second option proposed a base rent of $18,900 per month, a $250,000 up-front payment and the same annual increase. In an email to Murphy, Schoenfelder noted his own previous offer was $12,000 per month.

When the old pier closed in September 2017, Schoenfelder was paying $9,240 a month, according to his lease contract. His monthly rent was scheduled to increase to $10,080 in December 2018, but that increase never occurred because his lease payments were suspended after the pier was closed.

 Other pier matters

On Nov. 26, the commission also authorized Murphy to sign a grant agreement with the Florida Department of Transportation (FDOT) for the additional $285,000 the Florida Legislature approved for the pier project earlier this year.

Deadline extended for final pier lease offer
On Tuesday, Nov. 26, this stack of Ipe hardwood decking awaited installation on the new pier walkway. – Joe Hendricks

Murphy said the $285,000 includes restrictions and auditing requirements that didn’t apply to the $750,000 state legislators approved for the pier project in 2018. The $285,000 can only be used for pier enhancements that include but are not limited to public restrooms, electrical wiring from the shore to the pier buildings, pedestrian lighting and pedestrian railings that extend from the pier entrance to the mean low tide level.

The commission approved Murphy’s related request to expand the annual financial auditing services the CS&L accounting firm provides the city to also include audits of the federal and state funds received and spent on the pier project. The pier-related audit reports will also be shared with county officials in appreciation of the county’s financial support of the pier project.

Construction begins on pier buildings

Construction begins on pier buildings

ANNA MARIA – The construction of the new Anna Maria City Pier bait shop began this week with Mason Martin Builders erecting the first bait shop wall on Tuesday, Oct. 8.

On Thursday, Oct. 10, Mayor Dan Murphy provided the city commission with an update that included photographs of the new bait shop being built on the new pier’s T-end.

Construction of Anna Maria City Pier buildings begins
The first bait shop walls went up on Tuesday, Oct. 8. – Scott Moore | Submitted

Murphy said he, Public Works Manager Dean Jones and Building Official Luke Curtis took a tour of the pier earlier that day and the construction of the new restaurant building had not yet begun.

“We’re making some great progress. This building is really sound, it’s over-engineered. When I compare to what we saw with the old pier, this is really something. It’s a monument to stability,” he said.

Construction of Anna Maria City Pier buildings begins
The new bait shop is now under construction. – City of Anna Maria | Submitted

When asked, Murphy said the installation of the pier decking should be completed in early November, including the section of the pier damaged by the Sept. 10 barge accident involving i+iconSoutheast’s construction barge.

Murphy said Mason Martin Builders will install the Ipe decking at the T-end of the pier.

Cleaning and oversight

Commissioner Doug Copeland commented on the bird droppings visible on the pier decking in one of the photos and asked how the city plans to deal with that issue once the pier is finished and opened to the public.

Commissioner Dale Woodland noted the city of Bradenton Beach pressure-washes its pier on a regular basis, once a week.

“It’s an issue,” Murphy said, noting that pressure-washing was already scheduled for the current week and the following week.

He also predicted there will be fewer birds on the pier once the public is using it again.

“The wood is so beautiful. When we finally open it, I want people to be able to appreciate that beautiful wood that we chose to build this pier. It’s so impressive,” Murphy said of the Ipe hardwood decking.

Construction of Anna Maria City Pier buildings begins
Mayor Dan Murphy is already formulating plans on how to keep the new pier clean and well-maintained. – City of Anna Maria | Submitted

The mayor then presented the commission with an idea for future consideration – the creation of a pier oversight board that would include a mix of city residents and perhaps others who possess expertise in finance, development and other skills related to the oversight of a city-owned pier.

“They would advise the commission on maintaining the viability of the pier and taking care of it on a continuing basis,” Murphy said, noting that other cities utilize similar advisory boards.

“The pier is probably the single biggest asset this city owns. If you include the land and the buildings and everything else, you’re probably looking at about $12 million. That’s a huge asset,” Murphy said.

Murphy said he would present the commission with a more formal proposal early next year.

Taking into account the delays caused in September by the potential approach of Hurricane Dorian and then the barge accident, Murphy recently estimated the pier walkway and T-end decking would be open to the public in late January or early February. He anticipates the pier being open to the public while the interior buildout of the restaurant and bait shop continues toward completion.

Pier lease update

Murphy also provided the commission with an update on his ongoing pier lease discussions with current pier tenant Mario Schoenfelder. Schoenfelder’s current lease expires in December 2020 and he has expressed interest in a new long-term lease that would maintain his previous pier-based bait shop and restaurant operations.

“I met with Mr. Schoenfelder this week. We had a very cordial meeting, exchanging information back and forth,” Murphy said.

“Mr. Schoenfelder is going to provide us with his take on rent by next week. When I have that in hand, I would like to ask you for an emergency meeting so that we could consider it. I don’t think it’s a good idea to keep this lease situation open for a lengthy period of time. We’re at a critical point. Based upon what Mr. Schoenfelder’s offer might be, I think it would be good that we consider it as quickly as possible. As soon as I get that information, I will send that to you and then ask the chair to consider having an emergency meeting so we can discuss it and vote on whether it’s acceptable or not,” Murphy said.

Murphy and Schoenfelder have also recently discussed the possibility of the city leasing him designated parking spaces at and near the pier. They have also discussed the shared maintenance of the pier facilities and the tenant’s insurance and property tax responsibilities.

Mason Martin Builders selected to build pier restaurant and bait shop

Mason Martin Builders selected to build pier restaurant and bait shop

ANNA MARIA – Frank Agnelli’s Mason Martin Builders is the city’s top choice to construct the restaurant and bait shop at the T-end of the new Anna Maria City Pier.

Based on Mayor Dan Murphy’s recommendation, city commissioners voted 5-0 in support of the mayor entering into contract discussions with Mason Martin Builders’ owner Frank Agnelli. That vote occurred during a six-minute emergency commission meeting on Thursday, June 6.

The city received four bids in response to its recent invitation to bid and request for proposals (RFP). Mason Martin Builders submitted the lowest bid at $1.04 million. D.L Porter Constructors’ bid was second lowest at $1.486 million, followed by the Burke Construction Group at $1.609 million and Jon F. Swift Construction at $1.688 million.

City Clerk LeAnne Addy provided the commissioners with sealed copies of the bid proposals during the previous week’s emergency meeting and the bids were made public during Thursday’s meeting.

Before making his recommendation, Murphy said the RFP states the contract will be awarded to the lowest responsible bidder as determined by the city to be in the city’s best interests.

Murphy said he defined the best interests of the city as having the ability to quickly get started, having the ability to complete the project and a reputation for completing projects, having a vested interest in the project and taking into consideration the city’s interests at every step of the way.

“Having taken all that into consideration, I can give you a recommendation. My recommendation is that we go with Mason Martin,” Murphy said.

Mason Martin Builders selected to build pier restaurant and bait shop
Mason Martin Builders owner Frank Agnelli was pleased by the commission’s decision. – Joe Hendricks | Sun

Commissioner Doug Copeland and commission chair Brian Seymour said they supported the mayor’s recommendation.

“They came up number one in my choices. They’re local, all the subs will be local and it makes sense to me,” Seymour said.

Commissioner Carol Carter said Mason Martin appeared to have the most thoroughly thought out response. Seymour agreed and said that helped him make his decision.

Copeland made the motion to authorize Murphy to attempt to negotiate a contract with Mason Martin and the commission unanimously supported that motion.

The negotiated contract terms must be brought back to the commission for final approval.

If those negotiations prove unsuccessful, Murphy would then seek commission authorization to attempt to negotiate a contract with the commission’s next highest-ranked firm, which was not determined at Thursday’s meeting.

Post-meeting comments

Last summer, Agnelli and his crew removed the engraved wooden planks from the old pier so they could be returned to those who previously purchased them from a third-party. Agnelli did that at no cost to the city. The unclaimed planks will be repurposed as memorial walls or for some other public use.

After Thursday’s meeting, Agnelli commented on the commission’s decision.

“I’m glad I got the job, I’m glad this gets to stay local and we’ll get it done quicker than anyone else. It’ll be great to have my name on it for my kids to see, so I’m pretty happy about that too,” he said.

Murphy congratulated Agnelli and said, “I look forward to working with him. We know each other pretty well and I look forward to a good relationship and a successful conclusion.”

Regarding last year’s plank removals, Murphy said Agnelli did it out of the goodness of his heart.

Murphy said it was too early to know exactly when the construction of the restaurant and bait shop spaces will begin.

Mason Martin Builders selected to build pier restaurant and bait shop
I+iconSoutheast continues its construction of the primary pier structure, decking and T-end deck area. – Joe Hendricks | Sun

I+icon’s construction of the pier structure, decking and T-end deck area is scheduled for completion on Aug. 27. I+icon did not bid on the construction of the restaurant and bait shop spaces to be built according to design plans created by architect Barron Schimberg.

Murphy said he expects to meet soon with current pier tenant Mario Schoenfelder regarding his financial contribution to the interior build-out of the restaurant and bait shop. Schoenfelder’s current pier lease with the city expires in December 2020 and he is being asked to contribute to the pier project if wants to remain on the pier beyond that.

Murphy estimated the final cost of the entire pier project will now exceed $5 million.

Related coverage

Pier building bids received but not revealed

Last pier piling driven

Pier pavilion closing temporarily

Pier Rendering

Kebony decking selected for new pier

ANNA MARIA – Commissioners decided on the look and feel of the decking for the new Anna Maria City Pier today.

On Tuesday, City Commissioners voted 4-1 in favor of Kebony hardwood being the material of choice for the new pier’s decking.

At an estimated cost of $3.24 per linear foot, the Kebony decking will be placed atop the concrete spun pilings and concrete support frames approved at the commission’s previous pier meeting.

Kebony is a modified wood product made of 25- to 30-year-old pine that is then modified to give it characteristics similar to tropical hardwoods. It will eventually fade to a shade of gray that resembles the existing wooden pier.

The Kebony is touted as being more stable than natural wood, splinter-free, barefoot-friendly and cooler to the touch. It comes with a 30-year warranty and a life expectancy of 50-75 years.

After Commissioner Carol Carter made the motion, the commission voted in favor of the Kebony decking, with Commissioner Dale Woodland casting the lone opposition vote. Woodland again expressed his preference that the existing pier be rebuilt as it was instead of completely replaced.

Carter made her motion after Commissioner Brian Seymour’s motion to go with IPE Brazilian hardwood decking at $3.91 per foot failed to garner any support from the other commissioners.

The commission did not give any serious consideration to the Azek composite product offered as a third decking option.

With these material selections made, Ayres Associates Vice President Jay Saxena told the commission the design firm now has the direction it needs to proceed with the design of the primary pier structure and decking.

Architect Barron Schimberg then presented preliminary plans and a 360-degree rendering of the proposed restaurant space, bar and bait shop to be built at the end of the pier.

No final decisions were made at the meeting regarding the preliminary restaurant and bait shop designs for the wood buildings that will resemble the appearance of the current buildings.

Schimberg’s design included metal roofs and a roof covering the space between the restaurant and the bait shop.

Schimberg recommends a trellised and skewered shade structure above most of the tables to be placed in the open space behind the bait shop.

He suggested that the commission consider sliding windows and doors in the restaurant space in order to allow for more of an open-air feel, when weather permits.

He also suggested installing solar panels atop the restaurant and bait shop.

Seymour suggested the solar panels and shade structure might be decisions that require some input from the pier tenant, whoever that turns out to be. Current tenant Mario Schoenfelder’s pier lease expires in December 2020 and the new pier would most likely open some time in 2019.

Mayor Dan Murphy said he planned to meet with Schoenfelder soon to discuss the tenant’s role and potential contributions to the construction project. The city and Schoenfelder must at some point determine whether he will remain the pier tenant after his lease expires.

During public comment, Anna Maria resident Dennis Ellsworth said the design presented by Schimberg made it look like the whole pier was a restaurant. Holmes Beach resident and frequent pier patron Mike Deal said the shade structure on the backside of the bait shop would ruin the pier for him, because he prefers the existing open space where a larger group of people can congregate. The existing pier will remain closed until it is demolished and replaced by a new pier.