Skip to main content

Year: 2020

Reel Time: Orange Hammock Ranch

I first heard of Orange Hammock Ranch from Jon Thaxton, a former Sarasota Commissioner and a longtime champion of conservation efforts in southwest Florida. I remember him saying that if this almost 6,000-acre property is preserved, it will represent a crowning achievement in his lifelong efforts. That got my attention as I respect Thaxton, now the Senior Vice President for Investment at the Gulf Coast Community Foundation, for his decades of service to the environment. I was heartened when I learned that in early February, the Florida Cabinet had approved the purchase. Under the terms of the agreement, the state agreed to pay $19.5 million through the Florida Forever program and the Sarasota County-based Conservation Foundation of the Gulf Coast committed to $1.5 million for a total of $21 million. The Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission has been designated as the managing agency for the property. According to Foundation President Christine Johnson, “Saving Orange Hammock Ranch has been a conservation priority for our community for decades! This property is a breathtaking slice of old Florida and holds the trifecta of land conservation benefits – protecting drinking water, preserving wildlife habitat, and providing exceptional public access.”

Orange Hammock Ranch is located north of Interstate 75 in the city of North Port. Besides the inherent ecological value of the property itself, it is important because It connects RV Griffin Preserve with the Longino Preserve through approximately 6 miles of shared boundaries, and bolsters the 120,000-acre buffer along the Myakka River and the connection between the Myakka and Peace rivers. An estimated 60-75% of the property is wetlands or within a 100-year floodplain. The rainfall that collects on the property feeds Snover Waterway and the Myakkahatchee Creek, both of which are critical sources of North Port’s drinking water. On this property there are hundreds of acres of wetlands intermixed with pine flatwoods, globally-imperiled dry prairie as well as other native habitats. The property is home to quail, indigo snake, the Florida black bear and will be a viable habitat for the Florida panthers that are being bred in the nearby Babcock-Webb Wildlife Management Area.

The importance of purchases like this really hit home when I read a letter written by a 12-year-old neighbor, Brice Claypoole. Brice’s mom, Ali, had read an op-ed on Orange Hammock in a local newspaper by New College Professor Jono Miller and knew Brice would be interested.  Brice loves all things nature and is a familiar face at every Sarasota Bay Watch event. At a recent Sister Keys Invasive Clean-Up, he met Manatee County’s Environmental Programs Manager, Damon Moore. Moore was so impressed with Brice’s enthusiasm that he enlisted him to help with a county restoration project at Coquina Beach. While I correctly view projects like this for the value they represent in the here and now, I was suddenly struck by the importance of these wild places to future generations of Floridians like Brice. Protecting the wild areas of Florida like Orange Hammock Ranch, critically endangered by rampant development, should be a top priority for all Floridians. if we are to assure that children like Brice (and future generations) have the opportunities we’ve had, we need to contribute our time and money to their protection and make sure our legislators know that projects like this are a priority to us. And let us not forget the importance to the water that surrounds us and the fish we pursue!

Short-term vacation rentals reopen for holiday weekend

Short-term vacation rentals reopen for holiday weekend

ANNA MARIA ISLAND – Anna Maria Island’s short-term vacation rentals were allowed to reopen in time for Memorial Day weekend, with some restrictions.

On Thursday afternoon, Gov. Ron DeSantis and the Florida Department of Business and Professional Regulation (DBPR) approved the Manatee County short-term vacation rental reopening plan submitted by County Administrator Cheri Coryea. The state approval took effect immediately.

While local municipalities can still ban vacation rentals, all three Anna Maria Island cities are allowing rentals to reopen.

“Vacation rental check-ins are now allowed in Anna Maria,” Anna Maria Mayor Dan Murphy said Thursday afternoon after reading the approved plan.

Murphy then issued a local emergency order rescinding a previously issued order that prohibited new vacation rental reservations in that city.

The city of Holmes Beach recently allowed its local emergency orders banning short-term vacation rentals to lapse.

“I do not plan on a Holmes Beach directive extending the rental ban at this time,” Mayor Judy Titsworth said Thursday afternoon.

The city of Bradenton Beach never issued any COVID-19-related local emergency orders that further restricted vacation rental activity beyond the prohibitions set forth in DeSantis’ executive orders.

“Under the plan, vacation rental agencies may now accept bookings from residents of U.S. states with an overall COVID-19 case rate within the state of less than 700 cases per 100,000 residents as of May 15. Reservations from COVID-19 hot spots identified by the governor are to be avoided for the next 30-45 days. Reservations from international travelers will not be accepted,” according to the press release Manatee County issued Thursday afternoon. “Other guidelines spell out protocols vacation rental owners must follow to implement social distancing and still others that address the cleanliness standards of the property.”

The press release noted the short-term rental guidelines would be mostly self-policed and enforcement would be complaint-driven.

“We’re asking that vacation rental managers take extra precautions to make sure their renters have access to and follow the guidelines in the approved plan. Owners should ensure that their renters are aware and abide by the approved plan, but also any municipal restrictions in the city where the rental is located,” Coryea said in the press release.

When discussing the plan on Tuesday, May 19, county commissioners initially proposed a 24-hour turnaround time for cleaning and sanitizing vacation rentals between guest departures and new guest arrivals.

During public comment, several vacation rental owners said a minimum 24-hour turnaround time would prohibit back-to-back seven-day rentals and result in numerous cancellations.

The commission then decided to simply require “ample time” for cleaning and sanitizing and the approved five-page plan includes an entire page of cleaning and sanitation guidelines.

“Extra time must be allowed for enhanced cleaning procedures to take place between stays based upon the use of appropriate cleaning and sanitation according to CDC procedures and in accordance with this plan,” the plan says.

Local reaction

On Friday, Sato Real Estate co-owner Barbara Sato said via email, “We are very relieved that vacation rentals are open. It has been so frustrating answering the numerous daily phone calls asking when the governor will open rentals again – and why hotels, motels, and resorts are open and not being able to give them a reasonable answer. Needless to say, the word is out and our phone has been ringing non-stop. We think the approved plan is very good. I personally emailed Elliott Falcione, from the Visitors Bureau, and County Administrator Cheri Coryea to thank them for their teams’ hard work in getting it approved so quickly.”

Short-term vacation rentals reopen for holiday weekend
The phones were ringing off the hook at Sato Real Estate on Friday. – Joe Hendricks | Sun

When contacted Friday via email, Murphy said, “It is too soon to tell the impact this policy might have on the city, but we are grateful that the county has incorporated a bi-weekly review process to make adjustments to the plan. Our two areas of concern are:

  • Enforcement: Some of the requirements would appear to require an extensive enforcement effort. If these turn out to be an issue, we are not equipped to enforce some aspects of the order.
  • Remote check-in: Although seemingly in everyone’s best health interests, this policy presents serious issues of potential fraud and possibly criminal activity. The policy needs to be revisited,” Murphy wrote.

“We look forward to partnering with the county to improve the plan going forward,” he added.

Short-term vacation rentals reopen for holiday weekend
The folks at Duncan Real Estate are happy to be back in the short-term vacation rental business again. – Joe Hendricks | Sun

On Saturday afternoon, Duncan Real Estate owner Darcie Duncan said via text message, “We opened Friday morning to the sound of phones ringing off the hook with guests ready to book for the summer. We have all our compliance requirements in place and we were ready for guest check-ins Saturday morning. We are thrilled and looking forward to increased bookings due to pent-up demand.”

Island bar owners, bartenders protest continued closures

Island bar owners, bartenders protest continued closures

BRADENTON – Members of Anna Maria Island’s bar industry joined their peers in protesting Gov. Ron DeSantis’ decision to keep Florida’s bars and nightclubs closed.

The Tuesday, May 19 protest took place in front of the Wade Thompson law office on Manatee Avenue West, near downtown Bradenton. Protestors wore masks to demonstrate their willingness to comply with COVID-19 safety measures.

On St. Patrick’s Day, March 17, DeSantis issued Executive Order 20-68, an order that suspended the sale of alcohol for onsite consumption at bars and nightclubs that generate more than 50% of their revenue from alcohol sales.

Island bar owners, bartenders protest continued closures
Anchor Inn owner Darla Tingler and Drift In owner Joe Cuervo want to reopen their bars. – Joe Hendricks | Sun

DeSantis’ order currently impacts six stand-alone bars on the Island: The Drift In, the Sports Lounge and Tommyknockers Saloon AMI in Bradenton Beach and the Anchor Inn, D Coy Ducks and The Doctor’s Office in Holmes Beach. Bortell’s Lounge in Anna Maria is currently closed for renovations. DeSantis’ order also prevents the Moose Lodge in Bradenton Beach from reopening.

DeSantis’ initial phase one reopening plan took effect May 4 and was expanded on May 18. As of Saturday, the full phase one reopening plan still excluded bars and nightclubs.

Tuesday’s protest coincided with a petition letter Thompson sent to DeSantis and other state and local officials on behalf of The Association of Independent Bars of Manatee.

The association was founded by Papa Joe’s Sports Bar and Scalawags Pub owners Joe and Amy Harris and Gators Lounge & Package owner Brent Cohenour and his wife Kelly. According to the petition letter, Thompson is part owner of Gators Lounge & Package.

Island bar owners, bartenders protest continued closures
Anna Maria Island Beach Café bar manager Jason Benn got plenty of responses to his sign.

The association includes Anchor Inn owners Darla and Bob Tingler, Drift In owners Joe and Angie Cuervo and Tommyknockers Saloon AMI owners Frank and Sheila Commendatore.

During the protest, Joe Cuervo said, “In the middle of March, I got five hours’ notice that I was going to be shut down. We want Governor DeSantis to know that we want to open our businesses. We’ve got families to feed and bills to pay. What difference is there getting a Coke or a drink or a beer at a bar versus going into a restaurant? Those licenses are only about $1,800 a year. Our liquor license cost us over $350,000. We need to get back to work. I’m paying my employees, but I’m about out of money. I need to get some relief and open this up.”

Standing beside Cuervo, Darla Tingler said, “We can’t open our doors just because we don’t serve $25 grouper sandwiches. We could probably social distance better in our bars than they can in many restaurants. I want to be treated equal to those that already have their doors open. We’ve missed St. Patrick’s Day, we’ve missed Easter weekend, we’re going to miss Memorial Day weekend and we missed season.”

Anna Maria Island Beach Café bar manager Jason Benn, Sports Lounge bartender Courtney McGough, Drift In bartender Dan Cleary and Drift In patron Donald White also participated in the protest.

“I just want my barstool back,” White said.

“We want to get the bars back open again so everybody can get back to work and make money,” Joe Harris said.

Similar protests have occurred in Tampa, St. Petersburg, Daytona Beach and elsewhere in Florida.
On May 19, David Marshlack, owner of JWags Saloon in St. Petersburg, filed a lawsuit against DeSantis.

“We are going to have our day in court. This should be fun. Now they have opened movie theatres, massage parlors, breweries and the casinos, but bars can’t open still. Guess we are going to find out how they came up with this set of rules,” says the JWags St. Pete Facebook page.

Petition letter

Thompson’s May 19 petition letter said, “The Association of Independent Bars of Manatee would like to remind the governor, state and local governmental officials that our staff and employees are loyal, hard-working people with families that rely on them, who pay taxes and are proud members of our community. Many of them work long hours, have limited resources, and live paycheck-to-paycheck without a safety net or other support to help them.

“Our businesses offer our community an essential place for citizens to congregate, network and socialize. These businesses have been mistreated and discriminated against without due consideration or scientific analysis by the government’s unilateral decision to keep us closed without the opportunity to offer alternative and mitigating, operating procedures which would adequately protect our customers, employees and their families. The resulting hardship on our business, staff and employees is unfair and avoidable. We would hereby demand immediate consideration by the governor, state and local authorities of lifting the ban on the continued closing of bars and lounges,” the letter said.

The letter also addressed modified business practices that include hand sanitizing stations for patrons and employees, compliance with social distancing and CDC guidelines, single-use cups and masks worn by bar employees.

Alternate administration building plan rejected

Alternate administration building plan rejected

BRADENTON – The majority of West Manatee Fire Rescue’s commissioners agreed to continue moving forward with the construction of their own administration building rather than purchase suites in a shell building near Blake Medical Center.

Commissioner Al Robinson brought the idea back to the table during a May 19 meeting, asking realtor J. Daniel Douglass to provide information on a shell building on 21st Avenue West in Bradenton.

Out of the four units in the building, Douglass said there are three units available with a total of 6,140 square feet. The building, designed to serve as medical offices, currently holds one medical office and is a shell building with sprinklers, a ceiling and air conditioning already installed. Located across the street from the Bishop Animal Shelter, the property features a total of 29 parking spaces and does not meet the hardened hurricane-force wind load that commissioners previously said is wanted for the district’s new administration building.

Robinson urged his fellow commissioners to carefully consider purchasing all three units and selling one if the district finds it doesn’t need that much space for administrative staff.

Douglass said that the three units could be purchased for $549,000 and would cost about $614,000 to build out as office space, ending with a total purchase price of $1.2 million, not including condominium fees associated with the property. He added that the building is an as-is purchase.

Commissioner Randy Cooper said he was concerned with the lack of ability to store or stage equipment at the site as it has much less space for parking than the currently planned administration building.

Commissioners Larry Jennis and George Harris both said they have concerns about the building. Some of those concerns voiced by Jennis include that the building isn’t hardened and doesn’t have adequate parking space. Harris added that the location also is problematic, being well outside of WMFR’s district.

Chief Ben Rigney said he’s been working with representatives from Hall Darling Design Studio and expects to have a not-to-exceed price for construction of the district’s new administration building for commissioner consideration in August.

In April, Rigney presented a potential design for the new administration building that features office space, storage and a hardened conference room that could be used as a westside emergency operations center in the event of a hurricane. The building is currently planned for construction on a lot purchased by the district in 2019 and located off Manatee Avenue behind the Fountain Court Shopping Center.

“I think we’re making good progress,” Jennis said of the potential construction project.

Related coverage

Commissioners consider plans for new building

WMFR commissioners discuss assessment increase

WMFR commissioners vote on assessment increase

WMFR commissioners vote on assessment increase

BRADENTON – Property owners in the West Manatee Fire Rescue District will see an increase in their assessment rate when TRIM notices are mailed in the fall.

During a May 19 meeting, commissioners voted 3-1 with Commissioner Al Robinson dissenting, to raise the assessment rate 2.6% over the current year’s rates. Commissioner David Bishop was absent.

At the 2.6% increase, the district’s revenue will increase by $189,436, eliminating the need for district leaders to draw from reserves to meet anticipated needs including capital projects and projected increases in insurance, pension fund contributions and a potential increase in employee compensation. Commissioner Larry Jennis reminded his fellow board members that the coming year is a bargaining year with the firefighters’ union. For the 2020-21 fiscal year, WMFR’s staff projects bringing in $7,475,424 in revenue from assessments.

With the increase, the base rate for a residential property increases to $195.53 from $190.57 with the square foot rate increasing from $0.1124 to $0.1153. The total assessment rate for a 2,000 square foot residential building will increase from $302.97 to $310.85.

For commercial buildings, the base rate will increase from $473.62 to $485.94 with the square foot rate increasing from $0.2051 to $0.2104. The total assessment rate for a 2,000 square foot commercial building will increase from $678.72 to $696.37.

Before the vote was taken, Commissioner Al Robinson expressed concern about raising the assessment rate in a year that has produced financial hardship for many property owners.

“I’m not in favor of raising anything,” Robinson said. “We have plenty of money.”

Chief Ben Rigney said that the district’s staff typically spends about 95% of the funds budgeted each year. Any rollover amounts are put into savings for future capital expenses, equipment purchases or emergency savings in case of a natural disaster.

“I think it’s very evident that our staff has been frugal in spending taxpayer dollars,” Commissioner George Harris said, adding that he believes the board makes a sound decision each year concerning assessment rates.

Each year, the amount that commissioners can increase the assessment rate is based on a rolling five-year personal income growth number or PIG. This year, the maximum amount allowed for an increase is 5.46%. Because he expects the next year’s PIG to be much lower, Rigney asked commissioners to consider a 4% increase, which was rejected by board members.

“I know it was a tough decision but we have to do what’s best for the district,” Commissioner Randy Cooper said after the vote had been taken.

Related coverage

WMFR commissioners discuss assessment increase

WMFR commissioners review 2019 results

Mary Fulford Green

Green named 2020 MHS Outstanding Alumna

CORTEZ – Dr. Mary Frances Fulford Green, valedictorian of the Bradenton High School Class of 1942, has been selected as Manatee High School’s 2020 Outstanding Alumna.

Bradenton High is one of the former names of Manatee High.

Among her accomplishments, Green has been instrumental in preserving the historic fishing village of Cortez, where she was born. She was a driving force in creating the Florida Institute for Saltwater Heritage (FISH) that purchased 100 acres on Sarasota Bay to protect and enhance the habitat for fish, birds and other wildlife, and she wrote the application and lobbied successfully to have Cortez put on the National Register of Historic Places. She also is among the founders of the Cortez Village Historical Society.

Green helped to create the career counseling program at State College of Florida and was one of the founders of HOPE Family Services. She was a licensed mental health counselor and served as a full-time volunteer with the Manatee Mental Health Association, volunteering with the Manatee County Drug Court and several Florida prisons to mentor those incarcerated.

When class reunions became too difficult for aging classmates to attend, Green began calling all her 1942 classmates and still sends a newsletter to keep them informed about each other.

Due to the COVID-19 pandemic, the annual Outstanding Alumni Banquet has been postponed, but organizers hope to honor Green later this year.

The Manatee High Alumni Association has recognized and honored outstanding MHS alumnus/alumna with achievement awards since 1994.

Here are all the MHS Outstanding Alumni from 1994-20.

Castles in the Sand

Does anyone have a clue what’s going on?

Just like the coronavirus predictions about numbers of infections and deaths have been off the mark, so too are the predictions about the future real estate market. There are a whole range of conflicting opinions out there, all from reputable sources saying exactly the opposite things; what’s a girl to do?

So far, in spite of the shrinking economy and evaporating jobs, in the housing market values are stabilized and, in some regions, even higher. This of course has to do with the classic supply and demand dynamic that we’ve been experiencing for a long time, only now supply is contracting even faster.

The National Association of Realtors (NAR) reported that the March median home price nationally rose 8% from March of 2019. Manatee County’s March median sale price was also up by 2.4%. They also reported that buyer demand fell 8.5% nationally for March compared to last year but at the same time, supply is at a five-year low.

The NAR says homeowners are waiting to list their homes either because they have decided not to move, or they are worried about letting buyers into their homes during the pandemic. Many homeowners say that until the lockdowns are lifted, they will just take a “wait and see” attitude to selling. In addition, homes that are currently on the market are not cutting prices. According to Realtor.com, by the end of last month, only 4% of sellers cut their prices, indicating buyers haven’t viewed their homes in person. Nevertheless, buyers are out there still looking for a bargain and could possibly trip on a situation where homeowners absolutely need to sell because of coronavirus fallout.

Mortgage applications were also down by 20% at the end of April compared to a year earlier. The fear here is that down the road, values could drop when the forbearance period ends, and homeowners cannot keep up with the payments.

The way it stands now is some economists expect home sales to crash this year while some say prices and sales will climb slightly or hold flat. Fannie May said in April that it expects the median existing home price to tick up to $275,000 this year from $272,000 last year while CoreLogic calls for a nationwide home price increase of 0.5%. Zillow says home prices are likely to drop 2% to 3% compared to last year. The more you read about these predictions the more you realize no one really knows.

Let’s look at the April sales numbers in Manatee County reported by the Realtor Association of Sarasota and Manatee comparing April of this year to April of last year.

Single-family closings for this April compared to last year were down 21.2%. Median sale price was $340,000, up 7.9%, and average sale price was $406,699, up 4.1%. New pending sales were down 36.7% and months supply of available properties was 3.3 months, down 17.5%.

Condo closings were down 30.9%. Median sale price was $212,000, up 7.9%, and average sale price was $236,764, up 0.3%. New pending sales were down 53.3% and months supply of available properties was 4.4 months, down 6.4%.

All of the negative figures are no surprise relative to what we have been living through. However, the average and median sale prices are up, much like the trend around the country. Keep in mind that sales statistics are a lagging number frequently based on negotiated contracts that may have been in the pipeline prior to the shutdown.

All we can do is keep watching the numbers and hope that as businesses open more sales will be booked. At this point it’s anyone’s guess what’s going to happen with the virus or with the real estate market. Stay tuned and stay well.

Reel Time

The quality of our fishing future

Fishing and the outdoors experiences that my love for the sport have occasioned have played a pivotal role in my life for almost seven decades. This infatuation has also made me passionate about working to protect the natural world that provides me with sport, inspiration and a desire to see future generations have some of the same opportunities that I’ve had.

That’s why I keep coming back to what I think is a crucial responsibility, being aware of how elected officials voted when it comes to the quality of the air I breathe, the water I drink and the water that the fish I love to pursue swim in. It’s become painfully apparent to me that the politicians we elect all too often have a different agenda than what they present to us when they want our vote. That’s why I have decided that I’m not a Republican or a Democrat. I don’t vote red or blue, liberal or conservative. What I am is an environmental voter.

What does that mean? It means I research how a politician who wants my vote has voted on issues, not what they promise. In this day of the internet, there’s really no excuse for not getting information based on facts instead of innuendo. A word of caution of course. All too often we make the mistake of looking for information that supports views we already hold rather than a search for the facts. Both are available in spades so be selective when choosing your sources and check to make sure they have no underlying (alternative) agenda. Here are a couple of resources you might want to explore.

Florida Conservation Voters has a scorecard that tracks how politicians have voted on important issues like clean water and clean air. Their mission is to elect lawmakers who protect our environment and healthy communities for everyone. Their vision resonates with mine: “Our vision for Florida’s future is one where our environment is recognized as the irreplaceable foundation of our economy, culture, and quality of life. It’s a future where our economic development, energy innovation, and conservation goals align. We envision a government that reflects the people it serves and lawmakers who vigorously fight for policies that protect our environment and create a healthy, sustainable future for all Floridians.”

There are also resources on the internet that, with a little research, will reveal how a senator or representative has voted on varying issues. Check them out at www.senate.gov and www.congress.gov.

Floridians, especially those who are blessed to live on a barrier island, can see firsthand the effects of poor policy and pollution on the waters that surround our homes. If you haven’t noticed, take a look at all the algae that is accumulating in our bays right now. Yes, some of that is a natural occurrence, but personally I’ve never seen so much so early in the season.

Bottom line, do a little homework going forward and see how those who claim to have your interests at heart actually voted and where their true allegiance lies. It’s a vital component of an informed electorate and will affect the quality of life and fishing we are leaving our children, grandchildren and future generations.

Holmes Beach parks reopen to public

Holmes Beach parks reopen to public

HOLMES BEACH – The city’s parks are now open to both residents and visitors alike.

Mayor Judy Titsworth made the announcement during the May 12 city commission meeting, held via teleconference, that all of the city’s parks were reopened to the public as long as groups in each area were kept to no more than 10 people at one time and everyone practices social distancing. If crowds at city parks become a problem, she added that she would consider closing them again.

In addition to the skate park, large dog park, basketball courts and tennis/pickleball courts, Titsworth said the new playground is finished and open for children to play. Commissioner Kim Rash is helping public works employees install a fence around the playground in the coming weeks.

Also newly completed are the shuffleboard courts, though Titsworth said they still need to have benches and a scoreboard installed.

“They are beautiful,” Titsworth said.

The remodeled small dog park is scheduled to open by the end of May. While the rest of the city’s park facilities are open to the public, the multi-use field at the city field complex remains temporarily closed due to re-sodding.

Related coverage

 

Skate park opens to cheers from local skaters

 

Pups and owners celebrate dog park opening

Bradenton Anna Maria Island Longboat Key

TDC recommends opening vacation rentals

MANATEE COUNTY – The Manatee County Tourist Development Council (TDC) took the first step on Monday to reopen vacation rentals countywide, including on Anna Maria Island.

TDC Chair and Manatee County Commissioner Misty Servia persuaded fellow TDC members to recommend that Manatee County commissioners remove the COVID-19 prohibition on short-term vacation rentals.

Under Gov. Ron DeSantis’ plan effective Monday, county commissioners can submit a plan to the Florida Department of Business and Professional Regulation for approval to allow short-term vacation rental properties to reopen to guests. The plan would likely require working with owners and managers of vacation rentals to come up with strategies to meet the Centers for Disease Control (CDC) requirements for disinfecting and cleaning of units between guests.

Elliott Falcione, executive director of the Bradenton Area Convention and Visitors Bureau (CVB), said that he’s been working with other west coast Florida county leaders to help develop a plan for vacation rentals that would provide some consistency for owners and visitors.

Servia added that coordination with the leaders of the three Anna Maria Island cities, where many of the county’s short-term rentals are located, would be a key component to success. Falcione said that no matter what plan is enacted, it will be up to the city leaders to oversee the operation of the vacation rental properties.

Local vacation rental owners who spoke during public comment said they are ready to reopen their units to visitors and are willing to abide by any necessary regulations to keep their properties safe for renters.

The recommendation passed in a unanimous vote. Members Ed Chiles, an Island restaurateur, and Wayne Poston, mayor of Bradenton, were absent from the meeting.

Marketing during COVID-19

The new short-term marketing recovery plan, debuted by Falcione and Dave DiMaggio, has two implementation phases. Phase one involves bringing visitors in from drivable markets, including Tampa, St. Petersburg, Orlando, West Palm Beach, Miami-Dade and Broward counties and Atlanta with plans to expand the advertising area up as far north as Memphis and Nashville and as far west as New Orleans.

Palm Beach, Miami-Dade and Broward counties are the worst three counties in the state for COVID-19, with nearly 27,000 cases, according to the Florida Department of Health.

Manatee County has 867 cases as of Monday.

DiMaggio said that when deciding which markets to spend advertising dollars in, the overall health of the area and whether it’s a COVID-19 hotspot will be considered first along with how economically stable the target markets are.

The second phase involves bringing airline passengers back to the area. DiMaggio said that the success of phase two involves coordinating and sharing data with local airports, including Tampa International Airport and Sarasota-Bradenton International Airport. For some of this data, he said he would be looking closely at the information provided by Anne Wittine of Research Data Services, the county’s tourism consultant, to see how comfortable people feel about travel and flying to their vacation destinations.

Wittine presented the results of a travel sentiment pulse poll which showed numbers trending upward over the past two weeks toward people being more comfortable with travel and ready to take a vacation. While 52% of the people polled are concerned about reopening the state too quickly, Wittine said that 15.9% of people say that travel is essential to them and they’re ready to get back out there. Of the people who participated in the poll, Wittine said she’s seeing a trend toward people’s intent to travel increasing in the late summer months, specifically July. She added that of the people willing to travel, 78.2% of them feel most comfortable traveling by car, which lines up with the first phase of the TDC’s new marketing plan.

DiMaggio said the second phase includes continuing to target drivers and targeting fliers from the Midwest and northeast of the United States.

He said he expects that some segments of the market will be slower to recover, including people who travel for sporting events, work conferences and travelers from the United Kingdom and Central Europe.

Falcione said that he would be utilizing a month-to-month budget approach, periodically re-evaluating how and where the CVB’s limited advertising budget is spent to determine where those funds will have the most impact to help get the local tourism economy back up and running.

The TDC next meets June 15 at the Bradenton Area Convention Center in Palmetto.

Related coverage

DeSantis expands reopening plans, opens door for vacation rentals

DeSantis: Restaurants, retail can open; vacation rentals cannot

Mayor issues executive order for vacation rentals

Parking still a problem in Holmes Beach

Parking still a problem in Holmes Beach

HOLMES BEACH – Beachgoers beware. Right of way, street and beach access parking are still closed in Holmes Beach with most parking spaces planned to remain closed to drivers once the COVID-19 threat is over.

During a May 12 commission meeting, Police Chief Bill Tokajer updated commissioners on a plan to eliminate right of way and street parking on all streets in the city west of the Gulf, East Bay, Marina and Palm Drive main thoroughfare. Tokajer said that “no parking” signs and poles had been ordered and were expected to arrive within the next few weeks with additional time needed for sign installation. With the current plan, he said it would be the end of the month before any street parking spaces are open to the public, including visitors and residents.

Until those signs are installed, all street, right of way and beach access parking remains closed to the public. Violators may receive parking tickets or have their car towed at their own expense. Banners proclaiming the parking regulations are on display throughout the city.

Once the new “no parking” signs are installed, only the beach access parking spaces and street parking on the east side of the city will reopen, eliminating about 2,000 parking spaces. If beach parking becomes a problem on the east side of the city, Tokajer said he would review the situation and come back to the mayor and city commission with a new plan.

Church, business lot issues

One problem that’s already made itself apparent now that Manatee Beach is reopened at full capacity to visitors is local churches lending their parking lots to beachgoers. Because the parking lots are privately owned, the city can’t regulate parking in them, however, Mayor Judy Titsworth expressed concern that not only are the lots being used for beach parking, pushing beachgoers through neighborhoods to beach access points, there’s also no way to enforce social distancing. With the public beach parking lot also now opened to full capacity, Tokajer said enforcing social distancing in that lot is also a problem.

For owners of private lots, including parking lots at commercial businesses and shopping plazas, if no parking signs are present, business owners can call HBPD officers to ticket violators who are parking in the lots to go to the beach. However, while HBPD officers will have cars towed if they are parked at beach access points, on city streets and in the right of way, it’s up to the parking lot owners to have vehicles towed out of their spaces.

Titsworth said she would reach out to the churches and other private lot owners to follow up on how the lots are being used and let them know what services HBPD officers can offer for parking violators.

Currently, Tokajer said there are no plans to up the city’s parking violation fine from $50 though he added that the issue would be revisited if necessary in the future.

HBPD officers are taking over the enforcement of parking at the Manatee Beach lot, along with social distancing and monitoring of beachgoers. If police enforcement at the beach becomes an issue, Tokajer said he’d ask Manatee County leaders to step in and bring staff back to the beach to deal with issues. On the weekends, Friday through Monday when beach traffic is typically at its highest, Tokajer said his officers would have reinforcements from the Manatee County Sheriff’s Office.

Related coverage

Parking remains closed in Holmes Beach

Officers enforce new parking measures

Holmes Beach parking closed for beachgoers

Business owners won’t get break on fees

Business owners won’t get break on fees

HOLMES BEACH – After discussing eliminating the fees for business tax receipts in the 2020-21 fiscal year, commissioners are now leaving the fees intact and considering lowering property taxes instead.

During a May 12 work session, commissioners brought their previous decision to eliminate the BTR fees for commercial and home-based businesses back to the table and reversed it, reinstituting the fee.

Mayor Judy Titsworth said that if commissioners want to eliminate the fee for one year, it would still cost the same amount to operate the program, revenue that would need to be made up in a different way. She added that eliminating the BTR fee for a year wouldn’t financially help vacation rental owners.

Commissioner Carol Soustek said that she’d like to find a way to help more people than just business owners. She said that she doesn’t feel like the city can ask for a tax increase in the coming fiscal year and that she’s concerned about giving away money when the city’s leadership isn’t sure that there will be enough funds to operate at current levels.

Commissioner Kim Rash said that eliminating the BTR fees only gives a minimal financial break to business owners and sets a wrong precedent for other people in the city.

Commissioner Terry Schaefer said he was still in favor of eliminating the BTR fee for one year and wants to see the city’s leaders make up the lost revenue by cutting spending. His fellow commissioners agreed that cutting spending for the next fiscal year is a goal, but Commissioners Jim Kihm, Pat Morton and Soustek said they’d rather use the rollback rate for property taxes and reduce or keep taxes the same for property owners in the coming year rather than eliminate the BTR fees for one year.

“We need to come up with a reasonable budget and reasonable ad valorem rate that applies to everyone,” Kihm said.

Related coverage

Commissioners give relief to local businesses

DeSantis expands reopening plans, opens door for vacation rentals

DeSantis expands reopening plans, opens door for vacation rentals

JACKSONVILLE – Florida restaurants can increase their indoor seating capacity from 25% to 50% beginning Monday.

Retail operations can increase their capacity from 25% to 50% and gyms and fitness centers can reopen Monday at 50% capacity.

Bars, movie theaters and vacation rental operations remain prohibited statewide, but Gov. Ron DeSantis is now allowing individual counties to submit vacation rental reopening plans.

DeSantis announced these additional phase one reopening steps during his Friday afternoon press conference in Jacksonville. He said Florida is now headed into a full-fledged phase one reopening as a continuation of the initial phase one reopening strategies that started on May 4.

DeSantis set forth these additional measures in Executive Order 20-123. The order notes restaurants are no longer required to maintain a 6-foot distance between tables when expanding to 50% capacity.

“Bar counters are to remain closed to seating, and outdoor seating remains available with social distancing,” the order says.

Vacation rentals

During Friday’s press conference, DeSantis did not mention short-term vacation rentals until a member of the media asked about them. In response, DeSantis said he was not reopening short-term vacation rentals statewide, but individual counties can request short-term vacation rental openings. 

According to EO 20-123, “Counties may seek approval to operate vacation rentals with a written request from the county administrator and the county’s safety plan for vacation rental operations submitted to the DBPR (Florida Department of Business and Professional Regulation) secretary.”

A pending lawsuit against DeSantis seeks to lift the vacation rental ban entirely.

On Saturday, Manatee County Administrator Cheri Coryea addressed the governor’s announcement in an email she sent to county commissioners, Anna Maria Island mayors and others.

“I am sure you have been receiving emails and telephone calls asking you to reopen vacation rentals in Manatee County based on the governor’s county-by-county directive on Friday afternoon. Tourism remains the top industry in Manatee County and vacation rentals are a critical part of the tourism industry network that runs so successfully in our county and your city,” Coryea wrote in her email.

“The governor’s directive gives local governments the ability to present a safety plan for vacation rental opening rules to the state for consideration. Local standards are to be guidelines which are both acceptable to the local community and that align with the governor’s ‘Safe. Smart. Step-By-Step Plan for Reopening Florida.’ The governor’s Reopen Florida Plan is a set of benchmarks and guidelines under which we have already followed to craft our own return to work plan for county operations,” Coryea wrote.

DeSantis expands reopening plans, opens door for vacation rentals
Vacation rental reopenings can now be addressed on a county-by-county basis. – Joe Hendricks | Sun

“In the coming days we will apply the same Safe. Smart. Step-By-Step guidelines for the board to consider that allow vacation rentals to reopen safely for visitors, vacation rental owners and hospitality staff. Your observations and experience in your city are important in this endeavor and will be considered as a part of the plan. As with all our reopening strategies to the County Commission, public health and safety will be at the forefront of the deliberations to address the vacation rental sector in Manatee County,” Coryea wrote in conclusion.

Coryea also distributed copies of a DBPR document containing additional information and safety measures for vacation rentals pursuant to EO 20-123, effective May 18 for counties that decide to allow vacation rentals.

The DBPR document says, “Effective May 18, the following measures are recommended as minimum standards for vacation rentals that are accepting reservations and guests for any length of stay:

  • “Maintain adequate time between the conclusion of a guest stay and the check-in of the next guest stay for appropriate cleaning and sanitation;
  • Clean and disinfect all frequently-touched surfaces in the property between each guest stay;
  • Wash all linens, dishware, and other service items available for use by guests between each guest rental;
  • Provide sufficient soap and surface sanitation supplies for guests to utilize in the vacation rental property during the guest’s rental period;
  • Ensure adequate safety protocols are in place and publicly displayed, in line with CDC guidance, regarding shared or multi-residence amenities such as pools, gyms, and other communal spaces.”

Effective May 18, DBPR also recommends the following best practices for vacation rentals that are accepting reservations and guests for any length of stay:

  • “Use mobile platforms for customer service and communication with guests, including the acceptance of payments by mobile or electronic methods;
  • Minimize direct guest contact with property owners or managers through remote check-in and check-out procedures;
  • Post signage or other notices regarding the cleaning practices that are completed prior to each guest stay;
  • Display signage or notices to guests in the rental property to frequently remind guests to take steps to prevent the spread of COVID-19, including the wiping and sanitation of touched surfaces.”

The county commission will meet on Tuesday, May 19 and the meeting agenda includes discussion of ongoing issues relative to the coronavirus (COVID-19) emergency.

Bar protest planned

Bar owners and members of the Association of Independent Bar Owners of Manatee met with an attorney Saturday who volunteered to draft a letter to send to DeSantis and state legislators requesting that Florida’s bars and nightclubs be allowed to reopen.

DeSantis expands reopening plans, opens door for vacation rentals
Anna Maria Island’s stand-alone bars remain closed as the governor’s reopening plan expands. – Joe Hendricks | Sun

Via executive order that took effect on March 17 (St. Patrick’s Day), DeSantis closed all Florida bars and nightclubs that generate more than 50% of their revenue from alcohol sales.

In conjunction with the attorney’s letter, an organized protest is scheduled to take place Tuesday afternoon and begin between 3:30 and 4 p.m. at the Wade Thompson law office at 1720 Manatee Ave W. in Bradenton.

Organizers encourage protest participants to wear masks and gloves and practice social distancing to display the industry’s willingness to comply with COVID-19 safety guidelines.  Several Anna Maria Island bar owners and bartenders have indicated they plan to participate in Tuesday’s protest.

A petition to reopen Florida’s bars and nightclubs has also been initiated at www.MoveOn.org.

Castles in the Sand

When the real estate market sneezes, it infects everyone

The last thing anyone wants these days is for someone next to you in line at the market, the bank or in our slowly-opening restaurants to sneeze near you. But if the real estate market starts to get seriously infected from the effects of the coronavirus, it may start to sneeze all over related industries.

The American housing market is such a major influence on the country’s economy that even a slight downturn could have a very big effect on goods and services generated from buying, selling and building new homes. Right now, there are large portions of the country where the real estate market is at a total standstill because of lockdowns. Properties cannot be shown to prospective buyers, sellers are taking their homes off the market and construction of new homes and apartments has mostly stopped.

Obviously, there are hundreds of industries related to the real estate market that are losing money and jobs. The construction industry is being particularly impacted per the Commerce Department which reported a 22% decrease in new home construction in March from February. The Northeast region is experiencing the most pronounced decrease in new home construction with a 42.5% decline during this period.

New construction generates a plethora of jobs – carpenters, plumbers and electricians in addition to support and office staff. The materials alone needed to build range from lumber to sheetrock to paint to concrete and roofing not to mention heating and air conditioning systems.

Sales of existing properties are also down across the country as they are right here in Manatee County. If and when this will turn around as we in Florida start to open our economy, we just don’t know. But what we do know is that a slow real estate resale market touches so many other areas of the economy.

When someone purchases a home, they spend money preparing that home for the specifics they need and require for their family. Even the lack of simple renovations like new flooring, appliances, landscaping and paint will have an effect on the economy. This is in addition to major renovations to existing homes that have been sold or aren’t even on the market yet. The fallout from homeowners holding up on renovations can’t be calculated but inevitably will be substantial.

And what about the financial part of all this? Job loss is now measured in the millions, impacting tax revenue at every level of national, state and local governments. Much of this loss will ultimately be traced back to the real estate market, including the hard-working real estate professionals whose income and careers have been upended.

The one bright light for the real estate industry has been its ability to pivot to electronics to market and close properties. Agents all over the country are running virtual open houses and creating video tours for available properties. Video chats are taking the place of conference room meetings and available digital mortgage platforms can remotely verify employment and assets. A decade ago, the housing market would have been completely shut down during a situation like this; now at least everyone can move forward, even if at a slower pace.

So, no sneezing in public – we all have to do our part. As far as the real estate market, we don’t really know what the future is and neither does anyone else. Stay safe and wear a mask.

Coast Lines: Save the refuge for the birds

Coast Lines: Save the refuge for the birds

Friday, May 15 is Endangered Species Day, a great day to get outdoors and try to spot local birds, turtles and manatees that are on the federal and state imperiled species lists.

It is not, however, a great day to take your two quarantine-weary dogs in a fast red boat to Passage Key, a national wildlife refuge off the northern tip of Anna Maria Island, and let them off their leashes as you walk around the island, allowing them to repeatedly flush hundreds of birds off their nests during nesting season, causing the birds to screech and stay away from their eggs and their young for extended periods.

But that’s exactly what one couple did last Friday evening with their dogs.

In case you didn’t know, walking on Passage Key is against the law. Bringing dogs onto the key is against the law. Nine rather large signs state: “National Wildlife Refuge | Bird Sanctuary | Area Closed.”

Coast Lines: Save the refuge for the birds
Signs on Passage Key clearly state: “National Wildlife Refuge | Bird Sanctuary | Area Closed.” – Cindy Lane | Sun

Laws can’t always be quickly enforced on an uninhabited island. But people coming ashore and disturbing protected shorebirds should not be overlooked by law enforcement.

“Due to its value to nesting seabirds, shorebirds and wading birds, Passage Key National Wildlife Refuge is closed to the public use year-round,” according to the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service.

Among the threatened birds nesting on Passage Key are black skimmers and American oystercatchers. Non-threatened birds include brown pelicans, laughing gulls, sandwich terns and royal terns.

“Threatened” is a category of protection under the Endangered Species Act, passed by Congress in 1973, administered by the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service and the National Marine Fisheries Service, and commemorated on Endangered Species Day on Friday. “Imperiled species” is the general term that includes endangered species (the most critically threatened of all), followed by threatened species (less critically threatened), and species of special concern (the least critically threatened).

Coast Lines: Save the refuge for the birds
American oystercatchers are among the threatened birds that nest on Passage Key. – Cindy Lane | Sun

On and around Anna Maria Island, several threatened species are common, including:

Birds

  • American oystercatcher
  • Black skimmer
  • Least tern
  • Little blue heron
  • Piping plover
  • Reddish egret
  • Roseate spoonbill
  • Snowy plover

Mammals

  • West Indian manatee

Reptiles

  • Gopher tortoise
  • Green sea turtle
  • Loggerhead sea turtle

The Endangered Species Coalition recommends 10 things you can do to help protect imperiled species like these.

  • Learn about endangered species in your area. Teach your friends and family about the wildlife, birds, fish and plants that live near you.
  • Create a backyard wildlife habitat. Put bird feeders and other wildlife attractants, such as bird houses and baths.
  • Plant a pollinator garden with native vegetation in your yard. Native plants provide food and shelter for native wildlife like butterflies.
  • Minimize use of herbicides and pesticides that can affect wildlife.
  • Reduce your use of water in your home and garden so that animals that live in or near water can have a better chance of survival.
  • Place decals on windows to deter bird collisions.
  • Slow down when driving to avoid collisions with animals.
  • Recycle and buy sustainable products.
  • Don’t litter.
  • Never purchase products made from endangered species like ivory, coral and tortoise shell.

And please, stay off Passage Key.