Skip to main content

Tag: Bradenton Beach

Sandpiper residents request lighted crosswalk

Sandpiper residents request lighted crosswalk

BRADENTON BEACH – At the request of Sandpiper Resort Co-Op residents, city commissioners are committing up to $50,000 to install a lighted crosswalk at the intersection of Gulf Drive and 27th Street North.

Manatee County will reimburse the city for half the crosswalk costs as part of a 2018 interlocal funding agreement that provides each Island city with up to $333,000 in matching surplus beach concession funds for public projects.

The commission is also pursuing additional crossing, safety and lighting improvements along Gulf Drive near Katie Pierola Sunset Park and the Gulf Drive Cafe.

On Thursday, April 4, the commission unanimously authorized a contract with MSB Services not to exceed $50,000 for the installation of the 27th Street/Gulf Drive crosswalk. The contract includes the original $31,490 MSB Services estimated to install the rapid flashing beacon crossing.

At the suggestion of Vice Mayor Jake Spooner, the contract also provides up to $18,510 in additional funds for the possible inclusion of an audio signaling component that would provide the blind and visually impaired with audio confirmation that the push-button crossing lights have been activated.

The commission previously discussed a lighted crosswalk at the 26th Street North/Gulf Drive intersection but agreed to move it down one block where an unlighted crosswalk already exists with trolley stops on both sides of Gulf Drive.

“It makes a lot more sense to have it at 27th Street because of the trolley stops,” Spooner said. “It’s a really busy area. There’s also someone living in the park that has a disability.”

Spooner submitted the crosswalk request after Sandpiper resident Doug LeFevre made him aware of the mobile home community’s safety concerns.

Spooner said City Engineer Lynn Burnett recently told him it could take up to seven years for the Florida Department of Transportation to install the requested crossing on the state-owned road. Spooner said the new lighted crosswalk will resemble the crosswalk previously installed near the Runaway Bay condominiums.

Resident concerns

Spooner asked Deputy Clerk Ruth Stief to read aloud a letter from the Sandpiper residents that was signed by Co-op President Ivan Harper.

“We are a senior community located on the east side of Gulf Drive. We have 166 units within the Sandpiper. We have had numerous incidents reported from our residents about close calls or waiting long periods of time to cross the street to either access the beach or catch the trolley going southbound. We have a number of residents over the age of 70 as well as a visually-impaired resident. We are asking for the city to provide a flashing light at the crosswalk to ensure the safety of our residents,” the letter said.

Addressing the commission, Sandpiper resident Bob Gumson said, “I’m probably the visually-impaired person that was referred to. I’m totally blind. It’s a serious concern crossing that street. I’d like to be able to cross the street and take the trolley to the beach. The only way that’s going to happen is to get some kind of signaling light that stops traffic.”

Gumson referenced the White Cane Law that requires vehicles to come to a full stop when a pedestrian is attempting to cross the street using a white cane or with the assistance of a guide dog.

“I have stood there with my cane out and cars don’t stop. They just whiz by. You’re supposed to stop for a white cane,” Gumson said.

“Mr. Gumson is probably the most active blind person I have ever been around. We love him dearly, but we have a lot of other folks who are not technically disabled but have difficulty navigating the street,” Harper added.

After the meeting, Spooner said, “It’s always a pleasure when we can help resolve public concerns in our community, especially when it comes to safety. It was a refreshing reminder of the bright side of being a public servant.”

Castles in the Sand

Traffic, real estate sales up

If you want to know why you’re starting to analyze traffic patterns so you can plan your trips to the supermarket, doctor’s office and Trader Joe’s, here’s the reason. During 2018, Sarasota and Manatee counties had more closed sales, an increase in overall inventory and a rise in median prices compared to 2017.

Sarasota single-family median home prices increased by 5 percent to $282,500, and Manatee single-family median home prices increased by 1.9 percent to $300,475 from 2017. Sarasota median condo prices increased by 3.2 percent to $232,300, while Manatee median condos increased by 5.8 percent to $190,500.

Meanwhile, the volume of single-family home sales in Manatee increased by 7 percent and in Sarasota, the increase was 0.5 percent. Condo sales in both counties as reported by the Realtor Association of Sarasota and Manatee, recorded the highest number of sales over the last 10 years. Sarasota increased by 8.1 percent and Manatee increased by 11.1 percent.

These are great numbers especially when you look at them compared to last year’s sales number as reported by the National Association of Realtors. Nationally, last year was the weakest for home sales since 2015 with buyers pulling back because of rising mortgage interest rates, a shortage of starter homes and a volatile stock market. However, the February home sales of previously owned homes nationally were up 11.8 percent, the largest monthly gain since 2015, obviously due to the lowering of mortgage interest down to 4.28 percent in March from 5 percent at the end of last year.

Let’s take a look at Manatee County’s February closed sales reported by the Realtor Association of Sarasota and Manatee:

Closed single-family sales were up 4.8 percent, the median sale price was down slightly by 0.5 percent to $298,500 and the average sale price was up 2.6 percent to $389,119. Median time to sell was 97 days up a little from 93 last year and the month’s supply of available properties was 4.5 months – no real change.

Condo sales were down, closed sales were down 14.9 percent, the median sale price was down 11.4 percent to $189,000 and the average sale price was also down by 10.9 percent to $227,849. Median time to sell was up to 101 days from 94 and the number of months supply of available properties was up to five months.

Keep in mind these types of statistics are a snapshot in time and there are a variety of things that can influence sale prices and sale numbers in any given month. It’s the overall picture for a sustained period of time that really tells the story, and the year over year story for Manatee and Sarasota Counties is spectacular.

The months of March and April traditionally experience the most closed sales, so I look forward to when those numbers are compiled before we head into our slower summer season. That said I may have to revise that statement down the road since there doesn’t ever seem to be a slow season anymore.

It goes without saying that Florida’s Gulf Coast is one of the most beautiful areas in the country.

We have beaches, sun, culture, low taxes and great choices when it comes to purchasing a home. And what comes along with all that is more people, more cars and overbooked restaurants, even Sarasota Airport is reporting a 35 percent increase in traffic during February this year, but would you change anything?

It just might take a little better planning.

More Castles in the Sand:

Should you digitally – or actually – renovate?

Technology can’t replace real estate brokers

Leffis lizard to be relocated

Leffis lizard to be relocated

BRADENTON BEACH – The case of the Leffis lizard is solved.

Reports of an iguana at Leffis Key concerned Suzi Fox, director of Anna Maria Island Turtle Watch and Shorebird Monitoring, and Michael Elswick, division manager of the Manatee County Parks and Natural Resources Department.

Leffis lizard to be relocated
Black spiny-tailed iguanas could prey on shorebirds and sea turtles. – Manatee County | Submitted

Black spiny-tailed iguanas prey on sea turtle hatchlings and bird eggs, and shorebird nesting season and sea turtle nesting season are beginning, Fox said.

The invasive species, Ctenosaura similis, is an omnivore that eats just about anything and can grow to more than 5 feet long, Elswick said.

The lizards are established in five counties to the south, including Charlotte County, where tens of thousands have been trapped and removed, he said, adding that the black spiny-tail iguana is not a threat to humans or pets.

Another lizard threat from Hillsborough County to the north is the black and white Argentine tegu lizard, also an omnivore, he said.

But the Leffis lizard appears to be a green iguana.

Birders discovered the lizard in high tree branches at Leffis Key this morning.

“We’re probably talking about an escaped pet that may persist for some time in the wild but which is ultimately not a threat,” he said, adding that green iguanas are herbivores, which eat plants.

Leffis lizard to be relocated
The Leffis Key iguana appears to be of the green variety, not the more menacing black spiny-tailed iguana. – Sue Goetzinger | Submitted

The county will still try to locate and trap the iguana, because its chances for survival are slim if it is an escaped pet, he said. If it is used to being fed, it may have trouble feeding itself, and predators like snakes and ospreys are abundant at the park.

“It shouldn’t be too hard to find a home for a green iguana,” Elswick said.

Once they catch it, that is.

If you see a black spiny-tailed iguana or Argentine tegu on the Island, email the photo with date and location to Michael.Elswick@mymanatee.org.

Avenue C projects winding down

Avenue C projects winding down

BRADENTON BEACH – Avenue C residents should see drainage projects completed before summer, according to city officials.

City commissioners have approved Westra Construction’s request to extend its contract with the city by an additional 90 days. The contract is for the city-funded drainage improvements and driveway restorations taking place along Avenue C.

The new, city-funded infiltration trenches are covered with polymer, honeycombed, geogrid soil reinforcement panels and topped with 89 stone, grass, sod or some other surface material.

This is a new approach for the city of Bradenton Beach and a deviation from the past practice of topping the drainage trenches with white, lime rock 57 stone.

Avenue C projects winding down
The new drainage trenches along Avenue C feature polymer geogrid reinforcement panels. – Joe Hendricks | Sun

City Engineer Lynn Burnett said Westra requested the contract extension to help ensure the best possible transition and connection between Avenue C and the Lay-Z Liv-N condominium complex parking lot.

The county-funded Avenue C paving will complete that section of the county’s force main replacement project.

“In order to have the best finish and tightest lay-in of the geo-grid pavers in between the Lay-Z Liv-N driveway and the asphalt, they would like to do the asphalt overlay, let it cure for 30 days, then come in and saw-cut it once it’s cured, lay the pavers and that way it will be a nice clean joint and cut,” Burnett told the city commission on March 21.

Burnett said the county-funded final resurfacing of Avenue C will happen after the county does its final testing and inspection of the force main replacement project.

“I’m happy with the work and the progress that they’ve made. Hopefully, we’ll be wrapping this up in the next few weeks and couple of months,” Burnett said.

Westra is doing the city drainage and county force main projects as two separate but congruent projects.

Mayor John Chappie said he’s been impressed by the results he’s already seen when driving down Avenue C after it rains. He said the rainwater is draining off faster than it did before.

Avenue C projects winding down
This is what Avenue C, near the Lay-Z Liv-N condominiums, looked like in June 2018. – Joe Hendricks | Sun

Intersection wrap-arounds

Burnett said she thinks the commission’s previous request for the city-funded drainage improvements to wrap around the Avenue C intersections can be accomplished at no additional cost.

“I just hope it fixes that ponding that’s been there for years and years. That would make people happy,” Commissioner Ralph Cole said of the drainage improvements.

Commissioner Jake Spooner asked if the geogrid will be fully covered once the pavement is fully resurfaced. Burnett said yes, but maintenance will be needed if the surface materials are removed by someone squealing their tires or some other means.

Sunshine filings continue

BRADENTON BEACH – Several court filings have been made recently regarding the Sunshine Law lawsuit filed against six former city advisory board members.

On Friday, March 21, one day after deposing City Attorney Ricinda Perry, defendant John Metz’s attorney, Thomas Shults, filed a motion to dismiss Perry as the co-counsel representing the city of Bradenton Beach in the Sunshine Law lawsuit. The filing notes Perry is listed as a witness for the city.

Citing rules regulating the Florida Bar, Shults’ motion to dismiss says, “Ricinda Perry cannot serve both as an advocate at trial for the city and a witness on the city’s behalf.”

Attorney Robert Watrous is the lead attorney for the city of Bradenton Beach and co-plaintiff Jack Clarke in the efforts to determine if six former city board members violated the Florida Sunshine Law in 2017. Perry serves as co-counsel and paralegal Michael Barfield is providing Watrous and Perry with additional legal assistance.

Right after Perry’s March 20 deposition, Watrous said he has not yet decided whether he will call Perry as a witness in the trial currently scheduled to take place in July.

On Friday afternoon, Barfield and Watrous were asked if they thought the motion to dismiss Perry had legal merit.

“We don’t think so. Motions to disqualify one’s counsel is one of the most disfavored motions there is,” Barfield said. “The citizens of Bradenton Beach wisely rejected Mr. Metz as a candidate for elected office. Mr. Metz is free to be frivolous with his own funds, but it’s sad when he wastes taxpayer resources in his personal crusade against the city attorney.”

Sunshine Law questioned

On March 15, Shults filed a notice of filing return of service of constitutional question on Florida’s Office of the Attorney General. The court document includes a copy of the certified mail receipt sent to Attorney General Pam Bondi in Tallahassee.

On Oct. 10, 2017, Shults previously filed a notice of constitutional question that questions whether the Florida Sunshine Law enacted by the Florida Legislature in 1995 infringes on an individual’s First Amendment rights regarding free speech, assembly, association and petition rights. The 2017 filing also questions whether the Florida Sunshine Law is “vague and overbroad.” The 2017 filing was sent to Bondi’s office when it was filed.

According to Perry and Barfield, representatives of the Attorney General’s Office have expressed interest in potentially joining the city and Clarke as co-plaintiffs in this case.

Mapes going pro se

On March 14, defendant Reed Mapes’ attorney, Jim Dye, filed a motion for withdrawal of counsel informing the 12th Judicial Circuit Court that he would no longer be representing Mapes. On Friday, March 21, Judge Edward Nicholas issued an order approving that request. Mapes now joins Tjet Martin, Patty Shay, Bill Vincent and Rose Vincent as pro se defendants who are representing themselves.

More depositions scheduled

On March 14, Watrous filed notice of taking depositions for defendant Rose Vincent and former CNOBB member Mike Bazzy on May 8, former CNOBB member Carol Harrington and continued deposition for former CNOBB webmaster Michael Harrington on May 14, former CNOBB members Connie Morrow and Janie Robertson on May 20 and former Bradenton Beach Mayor Bill Shearon on May 24.

On March 14, Shults filed a notice of taking depositions for Mayor John Chappie and Commissioner Ralph Cole on May 31, City Planner Alan Garrett on June 12, Building Official Steve Gilbert and Commissioner Jake Spooner on June 13 and Commissioner Marilyn Maro on June 18.

Related coverage

City attorney deposed for Sunshine lawsuit

Commission rejects Sunshine lawsuit counteroffer

City attorney deposed for Sunshine lawsuit

City attorney deposed for Sunshine lawsuit

BRADENTON – Attorney Thomas Shults spent six hours deposing City Attorney Ricinda Perry under oath.

Perry’s videotaped deposition took place Wednesday, March 20 at the Manatee County Judicial Center in Bradenton. The deposition was part of the ongoing pre-trial discovery process in the Sunshine Law lawsuit the city of Bradenton Beach and co-plaintiff Jack Clarke filed in 2017.

Shults spent much of the day posing questions unrelated or distantly related to the city’s efforts to obtain a judge’s ruling as to whether defendants Reed Mapes, Tjet Martin, John Metz, Patty Shay, Bill Vincent and Rose Vincent violated the Florida Sunshine Law while serving on a city advisory board in 2017. At the time, the six defendants were also members of the non-city-affiliated Concerned Neighbors of Bradenton Beach (CNOBB) group.

Among other things, the civil lawsuit alleges the advisory board members violated the Sunshine Law when discussing CNOBB’s potential pursuit of a charter amendment that would prohibit parking garages. The lawsuit complaint states parking garages were previously discussed by the Planning and Zoning Board that included Mapes, Metz, Shay and Bill Vincent and could have foreseeably come before those individuals again in their official capacities.

Shults spent the first 80 minutes questioning Perry about her education, bar exams, electronic communications and role as the city attorney. He spent the next 60 minutes questioning her about the 2018 lawsuit the Keep Our Residential Neighborhoods (KORN) political action committee filed against the city.

The KORN lawsuit was filed after the city commission rejected the group’s request to place four petition-initiated charter amendment questions on the 2018 city ballot. Judge Lon Arend recently ruled the KORN amendments must be placed on a future ballot.

Attorney Robert Watrous, representing the city and Clarke, accused Shults of engaging in discovery for the KORN lawsuit instead of the Sunshine lawsuit. Mapes and Metz served as KORN officers.

Two and a half hours into the deposition, Shults referenced a 2015 Arizona court ruling that may support Metz’s affirmative defense argument questioning whether the Florida Sunshine Law is unconstitutional because it infringes on an individual’s First Amendment right to free speech. Shults also referenced a recent Texas Court of Criminal Appeals ruling that struck down a provision of the Texas Open Meetings Act the court deemed unconstitutionally vague.

“I pay attention to Florida law,” Perry said.

Parking garages

Three hours into the deposition, Shults asked Perry if anyone ever applied for a permit to build a parking garage in Bradenton Beach. Perry said she didn’t know because the city was founded in the 1950s and she has not been the city attorney that entire time.

When asked if anyone applied to build a parking garage during her time as city attorney, Perry said that would be a question for City Planner Alan Garrett or Building Official Steve Gilbert. She noted that in 2016 then-mayor Bill Shearon proposed partnering with Manatee County to build a parking garage near the public works building.

Perry said she reached out to the CNOBB members before the lawsuit was filed and encouraged them to refrain from engaging in discussions that could result in Sunshine violations. She said those efforts included a written appeal to Shearon to take preventative action – a request Shearon didn’t act upon.

Perry also noted CNOBB meeting recordings posted at the CNOBB website were later disposed of by website administrator Michael Harrington, which he acknowledged when deposed under oath.

Shults referenced a recording of the July 25, 2017, CNOBB meeting and asked Perry if she heard Metz use the term “parking garage” when she previously listened to the recording.

“I heard enough to know Mr. Metz participated in a conversation that violated the Sunshine Law,” Perry said.

On that recording, Metz can be heard sharing his thoughts on whether CNOBB should pursue a parking garage prohibition.

“I say that we do and that we put it more that no parking garage built for public paid parking or something like that. It doesn’t matter whether it’s by the municipality or some huge corporation,” Metz said during the July 25 meeting.

Perry said she also heard Mapes and Shay on the recording.

“I know they were talking about city business and taking votes,” she added.

CNOBB ultimately decided not to pursue a parking garage prohibition, but KORN later took up that initiative.

Shults’ last line of questioning pertained to several disputes Metz has had with city officials and city staff.

“When I look at Mr. Metz, I see a man who is probably so unhappy. He’s widowed and has absolutely no relevance as an attorney anymore because he’s not licensed in Florida. He wants some semblance of validity and some purpose to serve. I actually feel very sorry for him,” Perry said.

At 5 p.m., Shults adjourned the deposition and said he would set a date for its continuance. Watrous objected to setting more deposition time for Perry. Shults said he would seek a court order if needed.

Related Coverage

Commission rejects Sunshine lawsuit counteroffer

Sunshine lawsuit depositions continue

Trial date set for Sunshine lawsuit

Commission rejects Sunshine lawsuit counteroffer

Commission rejects Sunshine lawsuit counteroffer

BRADENTON BEACH – Bradenton Beach commissioners have rejected the settlement counteroffer proposed by the six defendants in the 2017 Sunshine Law lawsuit.

The defendants had until midnight Monday night to accept the city commission’s March 1 settlement offer and did not do so.

On March 12, the commission voted 4-1 to reject the defendants’ counteroffer prepared by attorney Thomas Shults. Shults represents John Metz; the counteroffer was also approved by co-defendants Reed Mapes, Tjet Martin, Patty Shay, Bill Vincent and Rose Vincent, and included a March 15 deadline.

The commission majority opted instead to stick with the settlement offer the commission unanimously authorized on Feb. 28.

The city’s offer required the defendants to acknowledge that “errors were made as it relates to the Sunshine Law.”

The defendants’ counteroffer said, “errors may have been made,” which was deemed unacceptable by Mayor John Chappie and commissioners Ralph Cole, Marilyn Maro and Jake Spooner.

The city’s offer proposed that the defendants pay the city $500 each or $3,000 collectively. City Attorney Ricinda Perry said that amount was in accordance with Florida Statutes.

Regarding public meeting meetings and public records, F.S. §286.011 says, “Any public officer who violates any provision of this section is guilty of a noncriminal infraction, punishable by fine not exceeding $500.”

The defendants’ counteroffer proposed that they collectively donate $10,000 to the Annie Silver Community Center and encouraged the city to do likewise.

The civil lawsuit filed by the city and co-plaintiff Jack Clarke seeks a judge’s ruling as to whether the six defendants – all of whom were commission-appointed city advisory board members at the time –  violated the Florida Sunshine Law by discussing their official city business outside of properly noticed public meetings.

Those 2017 discussions occurred during Concerned Neighbors of Bradenton Beach (CNOBB) meetings at the Annie Silver Community Center, the Pines Trailer Park and through private email exchanges. Those email exchanges and recordings of the CNOBB meetings were later obtained by the city’s legal team.

Commission discussion

During the work meeting, Perry said Shults and Mapes’ attorney, Jim Dye, asked her to ask the commission if the “acknowledgment of errors” language was negotiable.

“I think we’ve been very consistent with our settlement offer with regards to acknowledging errors were made. Nothing’s changed,” Chappie said.

Participating from afar by cell phone, Commissioner Randy White expressed support for the counteroffer.

“Let’s just break bread. I think we should just close this out,” White said.

“We’ve been consistent from the very beginning,” Chappie said, adding that the commission is concerned about openness and transparency in government. “I just can’t back away from that.”

“We didn’t ask them to have meetings outside of city hall. We didn’t ask them to do any of the stuff they allegedly did,” Cole said.

“I do think they do need to acknowledge they made mistakes. ‘May’ is not there, it’s a way to put a spin on it,” Cole added.

“It’s just the stubbornness of a couple of the defendants,” Spooner said. “It’s all about that word ‘may’ even though every deposition that goes by more comes out and makes it more apparent that it’s obvious that mistakes were made. That’s why we’re still here today.”

Maro said she thought the city’s offer and the request for an admission of errors was fair.

“This is our best offer. It’s not going to get any better,” Spooner said before the votes were cast.

“I think it’s pretty clear, our motion stands as is,” Chappie added.

After the meeting, Perry emailed Shults and Dye and informed them the commission was unwilling to negotiate further.

“The offer given to your clients was the ‘best and final’ and the ‘may’ provision is not up for debate,” Perry wrote. “Absent some concession by the defendants as to the mistakes made, my client is absolutely committed to seeing this out to the end.”

No winners in noise battle

There are many sides, but no winners in the battle over residential noise on Anna Maria Island. On one side are full-time residents who want to maintain the peace and quiet of their once completely residential neighborhoods. On a second side are the visitors who pay a premium to enjoy our beautiful island and want to have a good time while they’re here. A third side features the island’s three law enforcement agencies who are tasked with keeping the peace. No matter which side you’re on, there’s no solution that gives everyone everything they want.

As a full- or part-time resident, you might have an expectation of being able to spend an afternoon in solitude on your balcony. You have every right to that. But the people vacationing next door also have every right to enjoy the pool at their rental house. And because of overbuilding and small lots, that pool may only be 10 or 15 feet from your balcony, making silence impossible.

Even if winning the battle isn’t possible, maybe a cease-fire is.

We must admit that the Anna Maria Island of the past is gone and it’s not coming back. A balance needs to be found so that we can all move forward in our blended community. Maybe the way forward is through respect and mutual understanding.

Visitors need to respect that they are in a residential neighborhood where people live. If you wouldn’t do it at your home, please don’t do it at ours.

Residents need to be reasonable. If someone’s having a loud party during quiet, late-night hours, call your local law enforcement agency and allow them to do what they need to do to get the situation resolved. If a couple of kids are laughing and playing in the pool at noon, accept that there are children in the neighborhood and sometimes kids make noise.

Being on vacation doesn’t mean the rules don’t apply to you and being a resident doesn’t give you more rights than the visitor next door. Without tearing down every other house on the island, there’s almost no way to guarantee that you won’t hear some noise from your neighbors.

It’s also important that officers take community member concerns seriously. Public education programs are in place to help visitors understand the rules in each city. Maybe more outreach is needed for island residents to better understand what is considered a noise issue and how to handle issues in their neighborhoods.

People on every side are essential to preserving our way of life. We have to find a way to live together in harmony so that we can all enjoy our little piece of paradise.

Sunshine defendants propose settlement counteroffer

Sunshine defendants propose settlement counteroffer

BRADENTON BEACH – The six defendants in the 2017 Sunshine Law lawsuit filed by the city of Bradenton Beach have made a counteroffer to the city commission’s recent settlement offer. Attorney Thomas Shults drafted the counteroffer on behalf defendants John Metz, Reed Mapes, Tjet Martin, Patty Shay, Bill Vincent and Rose Vincent. The counteroffer was emailed to the parties involved at 9 a.m. on Friday, March 8. The counteroffer drafted by Shults attempts to revise a clause included in the settlement offer unanimously approved by the city commission on Feb. 28. “All defendants shall acknowledge they had concerns about the application of the Sunshine Law as it relates to the meetings at issue in this case and further acknowledge that errors were made as it relates to the Sunshine Law,” says the clause included in the city’s settlement offer.

The defendants’ counteroffer proposes that language be revised to say, “errors may have been made” instead of, “errors were made.” The counteroffer proposes the defendants collectively make a $10,000 donation the Annie Silver Community Center instead of paying the city $500 each or $3,000 collectively, as proposed in the commission’s settlement offer. The counteroffer states the city may instead designate all or some the defendants’ $10,000 to another charitable entity that benefits the city and its residents. The counteroffer encourages the city to also consider contributing an unspecified amount to the Annie Silver Community Center, which is not a city-owned or operated entity. The defendants’ counteroffer stipulates a Friday, March 15 acceptance deadline. The city’s settlement offer stipulates a Tuesday, March 19 acceptance deadline. The city’s deadline is based on witness depositions being scheduled to resume on March 20, at which time the city’s legal fees will again increase significantly. As of Feb. 28, the city’s legal fees exceeded $168,000, according to City Attorney Ricinda Perry. When contacted Friday afternoon, Perry said she reached out to Shults that afternoon to further discuss the settlement language
pertaining to the defendants’ admission of errors. Perry noted the defendants’ proposed $10,000 donation to a charitable entity would negate the $3,000 the city requested be paid to the city. Perry also said a matching donation from the city would require an additional expenditure of taxpayer dollars. On Monday morning, Perry said she and Shults planned to speak by phone later that day. The city commission must approve any settlement offer or counteroffer made by Perry and the defendants must approve any offer or counteroffer made on their behalves. If a settlement cannot be reached, the case will continue proceeding toward the trial scheduled in mid-July.

Past Actions

In September 2017, the city rejected a settlement offer proposed on behalf of five of the six defendants, minus Metz, that stated: “There will not be an admission or denial of liability or fault, but a recognition that the parties agree it is in their best interests to settle the differences.” To date, the city commission has not expressed interest in a settlement that does not include an admission of errors from the defendants. The August 2017 lawsuit filed on behalf of the city of Bradenton Beach and co-plaintiff Jack Clarke seeks a judge’s ruling as to whether four Planning and Zoning Board members and two Scenic WAVES Committee members violated the Florida Sunshine Law. The lawsuit alleges the six defendants, who are now former board members, violated the Sunshine Law when they discussed parking garages and other advisory board business or foreseeable advisory board business during Concerned Neighbors of Bradenton Beach (CNOBB) meetings that occurred that summer. The CNOBB meetings were not conducted at city hall, were not publicly noticed by the city clerk’s office and were not considered city meetings.

Related coverage

Sunshine lawsuit depositions continue

Trial date set for Sunshine lawsuit

Commissioner deposed regarding Sunshine lawsuit

Moose Lodge loses dear friend and driving force

Moose Lodge loses dear friend and driving force

BRADENTON BEACH – Members of the Anna Maria Island Moose Lodge #2188 are mourning the loss of longtime Lodge Administrator Ernie Casali Jr.

An email from the AMI Moose Lodge #2188 in Bradenton Beach announcing Casali’s passing was sent to lodge members on Monday, March 4.

“It is with a sad and heavy heart that we must inform you of the passing of our Administrator Ernest Casali Jr. late Sunday afternoon,” the email said.

“Most of you know him as Ernie C., the man behind the ‘all famous’ emails. However, he will be remembered more so for all the amazing things he has done for the Anna Maria Island Moose Lodge #2188. He is the heart and soul that created our lodge that we all enjoy today. Without his vision, dedication and hard work, we would be just another spot on the map, instead of the wonderful and unique lodge that we have here.

“As we say farewell Ernie C., you will forever be in our thoughts. We thank you from the bottom of our hearts for all that you did for your family, the community and all Moose members everywhere. We love you, Ernie,” the email concluded.

Casali was the driving force behind the 2015 lodge renovations that produced the second-story deck that overlooks the beach and the Gulf of Mexico.

He was master of ceremonies during the Wednesday night Queen of Hearts drawings, raising hundreds of thousands of dollars for the Moose Lodge and the charities it supports. The Queen of Hearts drawings also produced hundreds of thousands of dollars in prizes for Moose members.

Casali’s emails to lodge members covered a wide range of topics including who was eligible to participate in the Queen of Hearts drawings, where members and guests were to park and not park, and on at least one occasion, his candid thoughts on another nearby Moose Lodge.

Moose members reflect

“I’ve known Ernie for over 10 years and he was my teddy bear,” lodge member Sandra Zenzel said.

“We did a lot of tremendous things together – not only for the Moose fraternity but for the community. We would shop for food for needy families and toys for the needy kids at Christmas time and deliver them. He was one-in-a-million. He was the kindest, gentlest and most compassionate person I’ve ever known. His heart and soul were into the Moose. We want to keep his legacy going,” she said.

Zenzel said plans for a memorial service were still pending as of last week.

“Right now, the whole family and the whole staff is grieving so we don’t know when that will be. Everything will be held in the lodge,” Zenzel said.

Zenzel said Casali served as lodge administrator for 14 years.

While assisting with Thursday evening’s food service, Moose member Sherrie Snider said, “Everything Ernie did for the lodge he’s done for the people within the lodge. He personally took care of us, watched out for us and was as concerned for us and the people here as he was for the lodge. It was a personal thing for him.”

Kay Amodio is the 2018-19 Senior Regent for the Women of the Moose Anna Maria Island Chapter #1601.

“What a gentleman. What a wise businessman,” she said. “He was so loving and kind and fair. He taught me so much in the short time I’ve been Senior Regent. He built this Moose into the greatness that it is. The Moose fraternity has lost a good friend and a good brother,” she said.

While sitting at the bar, Moose member Steve (last name not given) said, “I’ve known Ernie for the last seven or eight years. You always knew where you were with Ernie. He was the biggest-hearted guy I think I ever met, but at the same time, he knew how to ensure that the line was toed. He was a very dear friend and he did wonderful things for this lodge.”

Wendy Quinn has worked at the lodge for 13 years. She took a break from her bartending duties to share her thoughts on Casali.

“This is hard. He’s been my boss for 13 years, but he was more than a boss to me. He was family. He’d help anybody out that needed help. He did so much for this lodge, it’s immeasurable. He was one of my best friends. I love him and he’ll always be in my heart,” Quinn said.

Lt. John Cosby and other off-duty members of the Bradenton Beach Police Department provide security for the Queen of Hearts drawings.

“Ernie was truly one of those nice guys,” Cosby said. “He was very caring too. And what he’s done for that Moose Lodge – he took it from a shack that was basically falling down and brought it to what it is today. It’s a destination now. Moose members are coming from all over the country.”

Castles in the Sand

Are you smarter than a hedge fund manager?

The most expensive home in U.S. history was just sold. It’s a four-story condo on Central Park South in New York City dubbed “billionaire’s bunker” and closing for $238 million. The buyer is a hedge fund manager who collects houses around the world so no surprise that the Big Apple was next on his hit list.

Those of us who live a little closer to earth will be interested in my latest three-month analysis of properties in the three cities of Anna Maria and Cortez that have sold or are listed over $1 million. This time we’re looking at November and December 2018 and January 2019. The residential closed property numbers are from the Manatee County Property Appraisers Office and the available or pending properties as of this writing are from realtor.com which reflects properties listed on the multiple listing records.

The little area of Cortez did not have any properties closing over $1 million during these months. The previous analysis was for a four-month period and showed two properties closed. The combined cities of Holmes Beach and Bradenton Beach closed 7 properties ranging from $2,300,000 to $1,050,000. The four-month analysis previously showed there were 14 properties closed. The City of Anna Maria closed 14 $1 million or over properties ranging from $3,300,000 to $1,010,000. The previous four-month analysis reported 17 closed properties over the $1 million mark.

Although the sold properties appear to be a little lower considering we’re comparing three months to four months during the holiday season when there aren’t too many serious buyers around, I think we’re just fine.

The available properties are another story, every location is up considerably from the last analysis. Starting with Cortez, there are currently 6 over $1 million properties on the market or pending, ranging from $1,500,000 to $1,100,000, the last analysis had five.

The combined cities of Holmes Beach and Bradenton Beach have an incredible 85 properties $1 million or more currently on the market or pending. The range is from a high of $9,500,000 to $1,049,000. There is one listing which happens to be land for $7,775,000; one property over $5 million; two properties over $4 million, five properties over $3 million and 16 properties over $2 million. The balance of the properties are between $2 million and $1 million. The previous analysis had 68 properties on the market.

The City of Anna Maria is also listing more properties than during the previous analysis. As of this writing, there were 58 either available or pending properties ranging from $5,496,000 to $1,065,000. There are two over $4 million; three over $3 million and 15 over $2 million; the balance of the available properties are between $1-2 million.

Lest we forget, it’s early March and the buyers are just starting to sniff around.

When you see the listing prices of the island properties lined up in a row it’s a little mind-blowing, considering what you could buy on the island in previous years. It may not be as mind-blowing as the price tag on a home in a 1,000-foot-tall tower with a view of Central Park, but we have our own views and we’re sticking to them. Are we smarter than a hedge fund manager? You bet we are.

More Castles in the Sand:

House hunting – the fun and not so fun

Florida’s new foreign buyers

A home’s equity is sometimes subjective

Dock floats delivered, project moving forward

Dock floats delivered, project moving forward

BRADENTON BEACH – It took two years, but the Bradenton Beach Community Redevelopment Agency (CRA) finally has all the parts needed to install a floating public dock next to the Bradenton Beach Pier.

According to police chief and pier team facilitator Sam Speciale, 157 dock floats were delivered to the Hecker Construction Company in Gibsonton on Monday, March 4. Speciale provided CRA members with a project update on Wednesday, March 6.

“Everything is at Hecker. The only thing we have left is the permit,” Speciale told the CRA members.

He said Hecker Operations Manager Eric Shaffer is already working with Building Official Steve Gilbert to acquire the city-issued building permits needed before the dock installation can begin.

Speciale said Hecker’s engineer is now revising the permitting documents and expects to deliver them to Gilbert next week. He also said Shaffer plans to make an onsite visit of the pier next week.

“Hopefully, we will have a date they are going to start to install the day dock,” Speciale said.

Dock floats delivered, project moving forward
Police chief and pier team facilitator Sam Speciale provides a dock project update. – Joe Hendricks | Sun

CRA member and Bradenton Beach Mayor John Chappie thanked Speciale and City Attorney Ricinda Perry for their efforts that kept the delayed dock project moving toward its anticipated completion.

Hecker Construction was originally subcontracted by Technomarine to install the dock. Hecker will now work directly with the CRA to complete the dock project.

The new dock will be installed along the south side of the pier in the same location as the original floating dock removed in 2016 due to repeated storm and wave damage.

Business impact

When installed, the new dock will provide more than 200 feet of free, short-term public docking for recreational boaters.

It will also provide designated short-term docking space for tour boats, water taxis and a proposed high-speed ferry service between Sarasota, Bradenton Beach and Bradenton. The lack of adequate dockage in Bradenton Beach delayed the anticipated start of the ferry service by more than a year, according to Paradise Boat Tours General Manager Sherman Baldwin.

Baldwin noted that for the past two years his passengers and other local tour boat passengers have had to embark and disembark from the nearby city-owned dock often referred to as the “dinghy dock.”

Baldwin said a return to the floating dock will make it much easier for tour boat passengers to get on and off the boats, especially for those with disabilities.

“In terms of the ferry business, my partners have been waiting patiently for a place for us to dock in Bradenton Beach and it looks like that’s going to happen,” Baldwin said.

Baldwin has already secured ferry docking locations in Sarasota and Bradenton. He said he now hopes to launch the ferry service during the peak tourist season of 2020.

Dock floats delivered, project moving forward
The new floating dock will be installed in the vacant space previously occupied by the city’s original floating dock. – Joe Hendricks | Sun

“We’re masters of our own fate now. We have what we need and it’s exciting to see this thing is finally going to happen,” Baldwin said. “I commend the CRA. In light of some real challenges they kept pushing and it looks like that patience has paid off.”

Anna Maria Oyster Bar president and former CRA member John Horne said this is the best news he’s heard in 18 months. His Bradenton Beach restaurant operates in pier-based space leased from the city.

“We’re looking forward to our guests and all those who love Bridge Street returning by boat and helping reduce some of the auto traffic. We get several calls a week asking about dockage and we can’t wait to christen the new floating dock,” Horne said.

Obligations met

The CRA entered into the dock contract with Technomarine in early 2017. The first anticipated installation date was September-October of that year. Manufacturing delays that Technomarine attributed to Hurricane Irma were then followed by several other delays and missed deadlines.

Providing the floats fulfills Technomarine’s contractual obligations and allows for the finalization of the CRA-approved mutual release and settlement agreement that Perry and Technomarine attorney Julianne Frank negotiated last December.

Approximately $36,000 of the $119,980 originally budgeted for the CRA-funded dock project remains available for the permitting and installation phases. Manatee County is reimbursing the CRA for half the project costs using funds generated by the 5 percent tourist tax.

Sunshine Law trial delayed until July

Sunshine Law trial delayed until July

BRADENTON BEACH – The trial for the Sunshine Law lawsuit filed against six former city advisory board members has been rescheduled for July 15. The trial was previously scheduled to take place in mid-March.

A pretrial conference has been scheduled for July 8.

The depositions for City Planner Alan Garrett, City Attorney Ricinda Perry and defendant John Metz also have been rescheduled. Perry is now scheduled to be deposed by Metz’s attorney, Thomas Shults, on Wednesday, March 20.

On behalf of the city of Bradenton Beach and co-plaintiff Jack Clarke, attorney Robert Watrous is now scheduled to depose Metz on Thursday, May 30. Garrett’s recently-postponed deposition has not yet been rescheduled.

The attorneys also have submitted the lists of witnesses they will or may call upon to testify during the trial.

Paralegal Michael Barfield is assisting Watrous and said the trial was pushed back due to temporary health issues experienced by some witnesses and Shults’ plans to soon take a long vacation out of the country.

The court-ordered mediation session previously scheduled for Monday, Feb. 25 is expected to take place as planned. The mediation will provide all parties involved an opportunity to discuss a potential settlement, but Perry previously told the city commission she doesn’t believe a settlement is likely.

The only known settlement offer to date occurred in September 2017, when the defendants, minus Metz, offered to pay their own legal fees and pay $100 each toward the legal fees incurred by the city and Clarke. That settlement offer included no admission or denial of liability or fault and noted that all six defendants had resigned from their positions as city advisory board members. The city rejected that settlement offer.

Additional actions

During the Feb. 7 city commission meeting, Perry said Shults now plans to depose Mayor John Chappie, commissioners Ralph Cole and Jake Spooner and Building Official Steve Gilbert as well.

Sunshine Law trial delayed until July
City Attorney Ricinda Perry provided city commissioners with a lawsuit update on Feb. 7. – Joe Hendricks | Sun

Perry also said former Concerned Neighbors of Bradenton Beach (CNOBB) webmaster Michael Harrington may be deposed a second time due to discoveries made during his first deposition in January.

During his deposition, Harrington testified under oath that he thought he had deleted all of his email correspondence pertaining to CNOBB. He later realized that was not the case and turned those and other emails over to Barfield and Watrous.

Harrington also testified under oath that he asked for the hard drive in his malfunctioning computer to be destroyed and he confirmed that former Planning and Zoning Board and CNOBB member Reed Mapes asked him to delete two CNOBB-related emails.

While deposing Clarke in January, Shults laid the groundwork for a potential line of defense based on the legal argument that the city and Clarke filed the lawsuit in bad faith due to contentious relationships between Metz and Clarke and Metz and the city.

In 2015, Metz filed an unsuccessful lawsuit against Clarke. In 2016, Metz filed a still-pending lawsuit against the city and Gilbert. In 2017, Metz was unsuccessful in his efforts to prevent Cole from continuing to operate his Coastal Watersports rental business on beachfront property leased from the Silver Surf resort.

The lawsuit

The 2017 lawsuit seeks a ruling from 12th Circuit Court Judge Ed Nicholas as to whether four former Planning and Zoning Board members (Metz, Mapes, Patty Shay and Bill Vincent) and former Scenic WAVES Committee members Tjet Martin and Rose Vincent violated the Florida Sunshine Law by discussing past, present and potential board and committee matters during CNOBB meetings that occurred that summer at the Annie Silver Community Center and the Pines Trailer Park. Under the law, official board and committee member business is only supposed to be discussed at properly-noticed city meetings, most of which take place at city hall.

The CNOBB members discussed the potential pursuit of a citywide prohibition on parking garages. They also discussed the updated Community Redevelopment Agency that references parking and other potential CRA projects. Email exchanges obtained from the defendants and others during the pretrial discovery process also include several references to parking garages, the CRA plan and other city business.

While deposing Mapes, Shay and Bill Vincent, Watrous established that these matters were previously reviewed by the advisory board members and he asserted they could have foreseeably come before them again.

Bridge Street options discussed

Bridge Street options discussed

BRADENTON BEACH – There isn’t much community support for closing Bridge Street to vehicular traffic, but some rare and limited public support exists for building a parking garage near the Bradenton Beach police station a few blocks away.

The notion of closing Bridge Street or reducing it to one lane was discussed at an open town meeting at city hall on Wednesday, Feb. 6. The purpose of the evening meeting was to give residents and business owners an opportunity to provide architectural designer Emily Anne Smith with their thoughts on closing or reconfiguring Bridge Street, which runs through the heart of the downtown business district.

More than 30 people attended the meeting and were provided with a seven-page document titled “Parking Study for Town Meeting.”

Bridge Street options discussed
The city commission chambers were full during last week’s town meeting. – Joe Hendricks | Sun

Two pages were dedicated to the number of seats and parking spaces Smith counted at the bars, restaurants and businesses along Bridge Street – including Commissioner Jake Spooner’s soon-to-be-built retail and restaurant building.

According to Smith, there will be 1,157 seats and 214 parking spaces once Spooner’s new building opens. Eight-two of the existing parking spaces are private, and Smith’s figures don’t include shoppers who aren’t also visiting dining and drinking establishments. Smith’s document also notes there are 173 employees working in the Bridge Street businesses.

“Parking has always been the problem in this town,” she said, noting that she finds it amazing that there are so many places to eat and drink along one small-town street.

As part of her yet-to-be-developed master plan for the city’s CRA district, Smith envisions a bright red Bradenton Beach Choo-Choo – an electric tram that provides free transport to and from the public parking south of Bridge Street at Cortez Beach and Coquina Beach.

Public discussion

Joe Cuervo and his son Tommy own the Drift In at the east end of Bridge Street. Tommy questioned whether people would be willing to drive past Bridge Street to park and catch a tram. He said when he goes somewhere with his wife and young children he has no desire to drive beyond his intended destination or load strollers onto a tram. He also noted Drift In has its own parking lot and said he and his dad oppose any plans to close Bridge Street.

Joe Cuervo joined Tommy in his opposition to closing the street but said he would have no problem making it a one-way street. Anna Maria Oyster Bar President John Horne said he liked the idea of a one-way Bridge Street with angled parking because it would create more parking.

Resident Dan Morhaus noted you can often walk faster than a tram that gets stuck in traffic.

BridgeWalk resort owner Angela Rodocker likes the idea of closing Bridge Street and converting it into small parks and public spaces.

“I think it would be beautiful,” she said, noting that it would also be safer for pedestrians.

Rodocker said she and others have been talking about Bridge Street’s parking problems since a parking and congestion committee was formed in 1998.

“We’ve all had to protect our lots like crazy,” she said of those who have their own parking lots.

Rodocker said she doesn’t understand the opposition to a parking garage when it’s based primarily on the claim that a parking garage can’t be visually attractive.

Business owner Samantha Heil fears closing Bridge Street would further reduce the already limited parking and negatively impact those businesses.

Pines Trailer Park resident Fidencia Pla was among the residents who expressed concerns that reconfiguring the Bridge Street’s traffic flow would divert more traffic through the residential neighborhoods along Church Street North and Bay Drive South.

Business owner Mark Mayo said, “We need to get the parking off Bridge Street,” and he mentioned using the current city hall property for parking if a new city hall is built elsewhere.

Former City Commissioner Jan Vosburgh said she 100 percent disagreed with putting public parking right across the street from the Gulf of Mexico. She then suggested a parking garage near the police station.

City Engineer Lynn Burnett said making Bridge Street a one-way street and building a parking garage nearby would open up several options.

Last year, City Commissioners unanimously adopted two ordinances that prevent the construction of a stand-alone or multi-level parking garage anywhere in the city. Any plans to build a parking garage would require those ordinances to be amended. No decisions were made at last week’s meeting and these discussions will continue.

Related coverage

Does Bridge Street need a redesign?

City hall building replacement discussed

City hall building replacement discussed

BRADENTON BEACH – City officials are trying to figure out whether it makes more sense to floodproof and hurricane-harden city hall or to build a new city hall complex.

These ongoing discussions also involve the adjacent city-owned Tingley Memorial Library and the police department and public works buildings around the corner on Highland Avenue. No final decisions have been made regarding any of the existing buildings, including the library.

These previously-discussed matters were discussed in greater detail at the Jan. 22 City Commission work meeting. In the wake of those discussions, Mayor John Chappie wants residents to know there are no plans to eliminate the Tingley Memorial Library, although it could be relocated depending on what long-term decisions are made.

“Any talk of getting rid of the Tingley Memorial Library, our historic library, is just not true. In my view, the library has to be part of any final decisions we make,” Chappie said on Thursday, Jan. 31.

City hall building replacement discussed
The city-owned Tingley Memorial Library was built in 1993 and opened in early 1994. – Joe Hendricks | Sun

During the work meeting, Building Official Steve Gilbert provided his insight on floodproofing and windproofing the existing city buildings and the possibility of building a new city hall complex.

A memo from Gilbert included in the commission’s work meeting packet notes the current city hall was built around 1970-71, before the creation of the Florida Building Code. It is located below the current flood plain and it is not known if the exterior walls, slab and foundation would resist floodwaters or wave action.

The memo states the current city hall could be floodproofed by installing exterior flood barriers that would also require new foundations to anchor them. The Public Works Department would need to maintain the flood barriers and erect and dismantle them before and after storms.

According to Gilbert’s memo, the elevated library building – built in 1993 – is above the flood plain, will likely need a new roof, ramp and stairs within the next few years and could be storm-hardened by installing hurricane-rated doors and windows.

“Any talk of getting rid of the Tingley Memorial Library, our historic library, is just not true. In my view, the library has to be part of any final decisions we make.” – John Chappie, Bradenton Beach Mayor

Gilbert told the commission the ground-level public works building built in the early 1970s and the partially-elevated, two-story police station thought to have been built in the 1980s could be more easily floodproofed than city hall.

He noted these discussions are driven by increasing flood insurance premiums. According to City Treasurer Shayne Thompson, it will cost $18,334 to insure city hall during the 2018-19 fiscal year and those premiums will increase as FEMA’s flood insurance subsidies are eliminated.

Gilbert guessed it might cost between $150,000 and $350,000 to install flood shields at city hall and make additional windproofing improvements to the roof, but the actual windproofing costs remain an unknown. He said floodproofing city hall for flood insurance purposes would not guarantee the building would still be standing or usable after a major storm.

Vice Mayor Jake Spooner said he wasn’t convinced that flood shields were a viable solution for city hall.

City hall building replacement discussed
The police department and public works buildings are located next to each other at the end of Highland Avenue. – Joe Hendricks | Sun

From public safety, response and resilience perspectives, Gilbert suggested a new city hall complex could be built to withstand Category 4 and 5 hurricane-force winds and be located next to the police station.

According to a 2014 Sun interview with librarian Eveann Adams, the city library that operates outside of the county library system dates back to at least 1959 and was known as the Bradenton Beach Library when operated at another location.

The library is named in honor of Beulah Tingley, the longtime Bradenton Beach resident who passed away in 1986 and bequeathed to the city roughly $500,000 to maintain a city reading room.

According to Adams, the current library building was first put into use in February 1994 and dedicated in Tingley’s honor on Feb. 28, 1995. She said the 2,800-square-foot building includes 1,900 square feet of shelf space that holds approximately 10,000 books and other materials.

The library operates on its own separate budget, which is overseen by the City Commission with assistance from city staff. According to City Clerk Terri Sanclemente, the current library fund balance is $465,469 and the average annual operating expenses are $31,907, including Adams’ salary. Library volunteers provide the additional staffing.

“Integrate everything in one complex that’s next to the bridge, where we can get back to work as soon as the storm has passed,” Gilbert told the commission.

When asked about that concept the following week, Gilbert said a new city hall complex could possibly consist of two levels located over parking and connected to the second floor of the Police Department. He said the existing Public Works building could be upgraded for floodproofing and windproofing purposes to help keep it viable during and after a storm event.

Public Works Director Tom Woodard said the metal guard rails between Cortez Road and the police department parking lot can be removed to provide direct access to the bridge if needed.

Funding options

During the work meeting, Gilbert guessed it might cost $2-$2.5 million to construct the new city hall complex, which could potentially be funded by selling the current city hall and library properties.

Spooner suggested taking out a loan to build a new city hall, keeping those city properties and converting them into a metered, ground-level city parking lot.

He said a 100-space parking lot charging $5 a day could generate approximately $182,000 per year. Those revenues could be used to make the loan payments and would continue after the loan was paid off.

Chappie said he wasn’t sure he could support a parking lot being built on properties located right across the street from the Gulf of Mexico. He leans more toward selling one or both of those properties to pay for a new building – a building he later reiterated should include space for the city library.

Commissioner Ralph Cole said he was open to discussing all options and everyone agreed that the value and the sales value of the properties and buildings need to be assessed before these discussions resume.