Skip to main content

Tag: Robert Kingan

Kingan departs Anna Maria commission

ANNA MARIA – City Commis­sioner Robert Kingan has vacated his city commission seat.

On Dec. 7, Kingan participated in his final Anna Maria City Commission meeting, ending the two-year term he was appointed to in November 2021.

With Commissioner Deanie Sebring’s mid-term departure in September, Kingan’s departure creates a second vacancy on the city commission. Both vacant seats will be filled by city commis­sion appointment on Thursday, Jan. 25.

As the Dec. 7 meeting neared its end, City Clerk LeAnne Addy presented the attending commissioners with Christmas stockings. The other commission­ers’ stockings contained candy canes and bells, but Kingan’s contained lumps of coal. Mayor Dan Murphy joked that Kingan was deemed “the naughty commissioner” for leaving the commission.

Kingan departs Anna Maria commission
As a parting joke, Commissioner Robert Kingan received lumps of coal in his stocking. – Joe Hendricks | Sun

On a more serious note, Murphy then presented Kingan with a wooden plaque containing a ceremonial key to the city and thanked him for his service.

“You’ve done an excellent job. You’ve been a great com­missioner; a great example of community service. In two years, you contributed so much. You’re creative. You’re strong. You have direction. You’ve got scope. Thank you for everything you’ve done,” Murphy said.

“Thank you very much. I enjoyed serving,” Kingan said.

Kingan thanked the city staff, the sheriff’s office, the building department and the public works department and referred to them as the people who make the city run.

“Without your dedication, there would not be a functioning city. What you do is vital to making this organization run and it makes our job so much easier,” he said.

To Murphy, Kingan said, “It has been a pleasure to serve with you and this city is extremely blessed to have you as their mayor. You’ve been here 10 years and you’re still going strong. I thank you very much for all you’ve contributed and for our friendship.”

After thanking Kingan, Com­missioner Charlie Salem said, “For anybody interested in serv­ing – and for me, who’s new on this panel – this is the person you want to emulate. He’s dedicated. He’s extremely well-prepared. He’s been a great resource and I’m going to miss him.”

Commission Chair Mark Short thanked Kingan for helping the commission face the challenges they faced and for the progress they made during his time in office.

“Good luck Robert, with whatever you decide to do next,” Short said.

Participating by phone, Com­missioner Jon Crane said, “I’ll miss you.”

Speaking by phone, City Attor­ney Becky Vose said, “I just want to thank Commissioner Kingan for all his contributions.”

“It’s been great working with you,” Addy said.

Post-meeting comments

Before leaving city hall, Kingan spent a few minutes with The Sun discussing his departure and tenure as a commissioner.

“It was my first time in a political office. That was very new to me, but the desire to serve the city was there. I felt the Pine Avenue project was something I could contribute to because of my previous career in commercial real estate and development. If there’s one regret I have, it would be that we didn’t get further with the Pine Avenue project. We have a good game plan for Pine Av­enue, and including Magnolia and Spring is the way to go. I’d like to continue to be involved with that process to the extent of coming to meetings and giving my input and sharing my experience,” he said.

He cited the May opening of the Mote Marine Science, Education & Outreach Center on the City Pier as the commission’s most significant accomplishment during his time in office.

“It took a long time and a lot of cajoling, but we did get there,” he said.

Echoing comments he made at a previous meeting, Kingan said, “As I said a month ago, I was talking to the Mote Marine manager out on the pier, and they had 70,000 visitors by the end of October. They’re currently running at around 460 a day. If that isn’t a success story, I don’t know what is.”

Kingan was asked what he learned about the city while serving as a commissioner.

“First of all, the city is very well run. The team the mayor has built has done a fantastic job. They are always ready, willing and able to respond to any requests,” he said.

“I like the commission setup. The mayor comes to us and we’re the ones who make the decision. It is a strong mayor form of government, and that puts a lot of onus on that position, but at the same time, as individual commission members, we can contribute and have a real role and responsibility,” he said.

Kingan offered the following advice for his soon-to-be-appointed succes­sor: “Don’t be a one-issue candidate. If you have something that you’re worked up about, you have to get beyond that because this is a position where you’ll be making decisions about a whole range of different issues, some of which you’ve never even thought of. You also need to be willing to read the backup material and put in the work and research to be well-prepared.”

As for what he’ll miss most, Kingan said, “I’ll miss the camaraderie we have. I enjoyed working with the mayor and the other members of the commission, and the range of issues we’ve addressed has been very interesting.”

Kingan said he and his wife, Janet, are having a second home renovated off-Island but will continue using their Anna Maria home as their primary residence for the foreseeable future.

“I may come back (to the commis­sion) a few years down the line, but at the moment I’ve got a lot of things on the go. My wife is having major surgery at the end of January and I need to be available. There are reasons behind this decision,” he said.

Anna Maria seeks city commission applicants

Anna Maria seeks city commission applicants

ANNA MARIA – Mayor Dan Murphy and the city commission have established the timeline that will be used to fill two vacant city commission seats.

In late September, Commissioner Deanie Sebring vacated the remaining 14 months of her two-year commission term. The commission seat held by Commissioner Robert Kingan will be vacant in December after his current two-year term expires. Kingan chose not to seek reelection and no other candidate chose to run in this year’s race, which also sees commissioners Jon Crane and Charlie Salem running unopposed for additional two-year terms in office.

The person appointed to fill Sebring’s vacant seat will serve the remainder of a term that expires in December 2024. The person appointed to fill Kingan’s vacant seat will serve a term that expires in December 2025.

The commission generally meets two Thursdays a month (once in the afternoon and once in the evening), with additional meetings scheduled as needed. Commissioners earn $400 per month for their service.

On Oct. 19, Murphy and the four sitting commissioners made slight revisions to the previously discussed appointment timeline.

The city will begin soliciting candidate applications on Nov. 1, with applications available from the city clerk’s office or online at www.cityofannamaria.com. The application period closes on Friday, Dec. 15.

From Nov. 1 to Dec. 27, the city clerk’s office will accept candidate questions submitted by the public, the media, the mayor and the sitting commissioners. Questions can be emailed to amclerk@cityofannamaria.com. On Dec. 29, the compiled questions will be provided to the commission applicants who will then present their answers during a public forum at city hall on Thursday, Jan. 11, 2024 at 6 p.m. Forum attendees will be allowed to pose follow-up questions to the written questions addressed or not addressed by the candidates.

The two vacant commission seats will then be filled by commission appointment on Thursday, Jan. 25. The appointments will be based on the individual candidate rankings made by sitting commissioners Mark Short, Jon Crane and Charlie Salem. The two top-ranked candidates will be appointed.

During Thursday’s meeting, Crane questioned whether Kingan might be willing to serve a one-year appointment and then vacate that seat with one year remaining. Murphy said he would discuss that possibility with Kingan. After the meeting, Kingan was asked about his interest in serving one more year. He said at this time he has no intention of doing so.

Anna Maria Commission discusses nutrient removal project

Anna Maria Commission discusses nutrient removal project

ANNA MARIA – The City Commission is considering committing $50,000 in federal American Rescue Plan (ARP) funds for a nutrient removal project.

At the request of Commissioner Robert Kingan, a potential nutrient removal project was discussed in general terms on Feb. 23. Kingan previously suggested the commission hear from the city’s contracted engineers about alternatives to the $50,000 clam and seagrass restoration project proposed by restaurateur and businessman Ed Chiles and his restoration project associates.

The commission has not made any final decisions regarding how the $55,000 in ARP funds earmarked for an environmental/water quality project will be spent.

Wednesday’s discussion began with Mayor Dan Murphy noting the city has spent millions of dollars in the last several years installing vertical infiltration trenches – many of which are located in city rights of way alongside the streets of Anna Maria.

Murphy said the infiltration trenches help improve drainage, but their primary purpose is to filter nutrients and other pollutants from rainwater eventually discharged into Tampa Bay, Anna Maria’s residential canals and other bodies of water.

The limestone-covered trenches are filled with granite rocks and man-made filtration mesh that help filter the rainwater that passes through the trenches and into the city’s stormwater system and the soil and groundwater below.

Murphy noted that in addition to the cost of installing the trenches, there’s also the ongoing cost to maintain them – which he believes is a good investment, even though the periodic maintenance needs increase as more trenches are installed.

Engineering insight

Participating in Wednesday’s meeting by phone was Quinn Duffy, project engineer with Infrastructure Solution Services. He provided the commission with his insight on the effectiveness and value of infiltration trenches.

Duffy said the city’s past two phases of infiltration trench projects, and a current third phase, have been paid for by equal cost-sharing funding cooperatives with the Southwest Florida Water Management District at a total shared cost of slightly more than $2 million.

Duffy said the city has installed tens of thousands of linear feet of infiltration trenches. He said the trenches collectively remove about 600 pounds of nitrates per year, 107 pounds of phosphorus per year and have removed about 9.3 tons of suspended sediments. He said infiltration trenches remove 50-60% of the nutrients that pass through them, which he feels is a good return on the city’s investment.

Infiltration trenches cost an average of $63 per linear foot, he said, which are a cost-efficient means of treating stormwater on an Island that, in some places, has an elevation of three feet above sea level. He also said there are more costly and complicated stormwater treatment and drainage methods the city could explore.

Commissioner Jon Crane opposes the proposed clam restoration project because he’s not convinced clams filter red tide organisms and other harmful elements from the natural waters to the degree that Chiles and others claim.

“We’re charged with spending federal taxpayer money to do something good. The clams may or may not be good, but right now there’s no proof. I would rather put money into something we know works,” Crane said.

Anna Maria Commission discusses nutrient removal project
Commissioner Jon Crane opposes the proposed clam restoration project. – Joe Hendricks | Sun

Crane asked Duffy if he had any insight on the effectiveness of clams in terms of water filtration.

Duffy said he’s aware of studies conducted around the state, especially those conducted by the University of Florida. He said it would be possible to use those studies to compare the costs and benefits of a clam restoration project versus an infiltration trench project. He said the number and size of the clams would need to be factored into that comparison.

Duffy said infiltration trenches filter the water before it reaches the bay and other natural waters, while clams help filter the water they live in. Without doing more research, Duffy would not speculate as to the effectiveness of clams versus infiltration trenches.

Commissioner Mark Short noted the commission recently doubled the annual stormwater fees assessed to Anna Maria property owners. Those fees help fund stormwater and drainage improvements and maintenance.

Kingan made a motion to use $50,000 in ARP funds for a project that uses methods proven to remove nutrients, but his motion fell by the wayside without a vote as the discussion continued.

Anna Maria Commission discusses nutrient removal project
Commissioner Deanie Sebring supports the proposed clam restoration project. – Joe Hendricks | Sun

Commissioner Deanie Sebring expressed continued support for the clam restoration project. She said $50,000 is a “drop in the bucket” and the city should do something to help clean the local waters, even if the proposed project is experimental in terms of proven results.

Jim McDaniel serves as The Center of Anna Maria’s director of development. In recent years, The Center has embarked on environmental efforts that included mini-reef installations as part of its ongoing “Go Green” campaign. During public input, McDaniel said he is on a clean water committee in Holmes Beach and he encouraged the commission to consider all options.

Anna Maria Commission discusses nutrient removal project
Jim McDaniel encouraged the commission to consider all options. – Joe Hendricks | Sun

“Doing the ditches is so important, but I don’t see it as binary. I don’t think it’s one or the other. I stopped using ‘but’ when I write and I change it to ‘and.’ Try it. I think we need to do this and this and this. Together, we come up with better solutions,” McDaniel said.

Wednesday’s discussion concluded without any decisions being made and Murphy said the ARP project funding discussions would continue at a future meeting or meetings.

Related coverage

 

Marine biologist opposes clam restoration project

 

Decision still pending on clam, seagrass restoration funds

 

Commission considering clam, seagrass restoration request