Skip to main content

Tag: Educational Outreach Center

Mote Marine’s City Pier plans reviewed

Mote Marine’s City Pier plans reviewed

ANNA MARIA – Building Official David Gilson and City Planner Ashley Austin presented their review of Mote Marine’s plans to install an educational outreach center on the Anna Maria City Pier to commissioners last week.

Mayor Dan Murphy received the latest plans from Mote Marine on Oct. 13. Gilson and Austin provided their analysis of the plans during the special city commission meeting held on Thursday, Oct. 20.

He said the purpose of the meeting was for Gilson and Austin to share their analysis of the plans, with a focus on two primary criteria – assessing whether the plans meet the city’s technical requirements and whether the proposed plans meet the city’s quality expectations for a project on city-owned property.

Mote’s educational outreach center will occupy the larger and currently vacant city-owned building at the T-end of the City Pier. The smaller pier building is occupied by the City Pier Grill & Bait Shop.

Murphy sought the commissioners’ initial thoughts and comments on the plans, saying that Gilson would send questions and comments to Mote representatives. The revised plans will then be presented to the commission, which will be asked to approve the plans and authorize the building permits needed for Mote to begin the interior buildout of the pier building and the installation of its marine life exhibits.

Gilson said if the plans had been submitted as a standard construction project, they’d be very close to being accepted, but with the city being the property owner, the permitting process is different.

Mote Marine’s City Pier plans reviewed
This illustration references Mote Marine’s exhibition gallery. – City of Anna Maria | Submitted

“The way the lease is written, the owner (the city) is going to have their fingers in this entire project. The lease puts us right in the thick of it and that’s going to be very helpful,” Gilson said.

Gilson recommended the city specify that Square D electrical breaker panels are used because city staff is familiar with that brand. He also requested additional information from Mote regarding the invertebrate touch tank exhibit that requires an electrical connection, specifically, who’s serving as Mote’s contracted electrical engineer.

Gilson said the plans include a blanket statement regarding the use of corrosion-resistant hardware. He recommends the plans specify that the screws, nuts, bolts and other hardware used will be made of stainless steel, similar to what was used for the construction of the pier and pier buildings.

The plans don’t specify which type of ceiling tiles will be used. Because of the saltwater exhibits to be contained inside the building, Gilson recommends using higher quality ceiling panels that resemble drywall and are more humidity resistant than normal ceiling tiles.

Austin said the installation of an educational outreach center that offers incidental souvenir sales in an already existing space is considered a tenant buildout rather than new construction, so setback restrictions and other construction criteria don’t apply. She noted the plans don’t address signs and said Mote will need to apply for a separate sign permit.

Mote Marine’s City Pier plans reviewed
This drawing is included in Mote Marine’s latest plans. – City of Anna Maria | Submitted

Commissioner Robert Kingan asked if the plans include a backup generator. Gilson said he didn’t see anything in the plans about a generator, but that he talked to someone at Mote who said battery backups would be used to keep the live exhibits oxygenated during a power outage. Gilson said the safety of the sea creatures is ultimately Mote’s responsibility.

Kingan asked if Mote had identified a specific contractor. Gilson said Mote has a contractor that they regularly work with but the plans and building permit applications have not yet been officially submitted to the city.

Commissioner Mark Short asked Murphy if the plans he received on Oct. 13 satisfy the deadlines the city commission established earlier this year when granting Mote a lengthy extension to complete the long-delayed project.

Murphy said the latest plans comply, and that the city will hold Mote Marine to the March 2023 completion and opening deadline the commission established earlier this year.

Murphy to Mote: Fish or cut bait

Murphy to Mote: Fish or cut bait

ANNA MARIA – Dr. Michael Crosby and his Mote Marine Laboratory associates have until Friday to present the final conceptual plans for an educational outreach center on the City Pier.

Mote’s latest plans are expected to be presented during a special Anna Maria City Commission meeting on Friday, April 22 at 2 p.m. The commission is willing to abandon the project if Friday’s deadline is missed.

On Sept. 30, Mote and the city of Anna Maria entered into a five-year, rent-free lease agreement that would allow Mote to occupy the larger city-owned building at the T-end of the City Pier. The smaller pier building is occupied by the City Pier Grill & Bait Shop.

Murphy to Mote: Fish or cut bait
The pier building’s bayside windows provide a view of Tampa Bay. – Joe Hendricks | Sun

In September, Mote Marine staff member Kevin Cooper said he expected Mote to complete its interior buildout and exhibit installation by March and open the facility soon thereafter.

As of Thursday, April 14, Mote officials and their contracted architect, Barron Schimberg, had not yet submitted their final plans for the long-delayed facility. Schimberg previously served as the city’s contracted architect for the pier replacement project completed in 2020.

Murphy to Mote: Fish or cut bait
The original plans presented in early 2021 included live marine exhibits. – Mote Marine | Submitted

The original plans that Mote presented in early 2021 featured live marine exhibits. In January, Mote provided the city with an alternate plan that featured virtual exhibits instead. Murphy said then that the city commission would ultimately decide whether the Mote facility includes live exhibits, virtual exhibits or both.

Project update

On Thursday, April 14, Murphy provided commissioners with a project update.

“We’ve had numerous false starts. I anticipated having a proposal for you today. I also anticipated having a proposal for you two weeks ago and a month ago. None of those have happened. For various reasons, the goal post has been moved several times. We’re now at the point where there’s no more moving the goal post. I had a conversation with Dr. Crosby last night. I told Dr. Crosby how disappointed I was that we didn’t have a proposal ready. They have all the information necessary to put together a proposal. This latest delay was caused by the architect. He had all the information, but didn’t have the time to put it together,” Murphy said.

“We have a lease contract that we signed back in September and that lease contract gave them 180 days to produce and/or request an extension. I’m here today to give you two options. You can enforce the contract as it is and decide to not extend it any further. This is the end of it and we tell Mote farewell and move on. The other option is that they have a proposal to us by Friday of next week. I propose to you that we’ve gone this far and that we go one more week,” Murphy said.

Murphy expects Friday’s presentation to include visuals, live exhibit examples and non-negotiable start and completion dates.

Commission feedback

In September, Commissioner Mark Short opposed the commission’s 4-1 decision to pursue an educational outreach center rather than a full-service restaurant or open-air cantina.

Murphy to Mote: Fish or cut bait
Commissioner Mark Short expressed his frustration during the April 14 meeting. – Joe Hendricks | Sun

During the April 14 meeting, Short said, “This Mote exhibit was supposed to be done now and we don’t even have the final plans yet. There’s been delay after delay. There’s nothing to show a year after the commission agreed to move forward with Mote and 180 days after the lease was signed. I’m fine giving them another week, but I just don’t think this is the right path to go down.”

“It’s been an extreme disappointment,” Commissioner Deanie Sebring said.

Sebring said the proposed shift to virtual exhibits seems to be an attempt by Mote to use the City Pier to advertise the new Mote Science Education Aquarium being built in Sarasota.

“What they offered us was something that was going to be quite unique and incredible and it’s turned into nothing. It’s disheartening. I’m getting a bad taste in my mouth thinking they’re not going have any live exhibits,” Sebring said.

Murphy to Mote: Fish or cut bait
The alternate plans provided in January proposed virtual exhibits. – Mote Marine | Submitted

Commissioner Robert Kingan said, “I completely agree. I think we should give them one more week, but that’s it. They’ve had ample time to make preparations.”

“I kind of agree, but my vision is a little longer-range. I think this project has the potential to be fabulous. I’m happy to give them another week,” Commissioner Jon Crane said.

“I agree with all of you. I’m disappointed that it’s taking so long, but I do think it will be a good project,” Commissioner Carol Carter said.

Murphy told Mote officials the city doesn’t want virtual exhibits.

“What we signed up for was live exhibits,” he said.

“The commission has to decide: Do you fish or cut bait?” he added.

The commission unanimously agreed to give Mote until Friday to present its final plans.

County support

In June 2021, the Manatee County Commission agreed to provide $500,000 for the design, interior buildout and installation of the Mote facility, with Mote covering the remaining $40,000-$50,000 in estimated start-up costs. Mote also agreed to staff the facility at its own expense for the duration of the lease, with the city covering the utility expenses.

County Commission Chair Kevin Van Ostenbridge attended Thursday’s meeting. He left before the Mote discussion ensued, but he addressed the commission before departing.

Murphy to Mote: Fish or cut bait
County Commission Chair Kevin Van Ostenbridge encouraged city officials to continue supporting the proposed Mote Marine facility. – Joe Hendricks | Sun

“I know there have been a significant number of delays. I share your frustration, but I think the project is a great project. I advocated strongly for the project and I was able to get our board to unanimously approve a half-million dollars for the project. I think it will be worth the wait,” Van Ostenbridge said.

“I did speak with Dr. Crosby this morning and he assured me that Mote now has all the information they need to move forward with the engineering. They want to make sure the pier can hold what they put out there and withstand the weight of the exhibits. There will be aquariums. There will be live exhibits. It sounds like things are headed in the right direction,” he said.

Funding finalized for Mote Marine facility on City Pier

Funding finalized for Mote Marine facility on City Pier

ANNA MARIA – The Manatee County Commission has officially authorized an interlocal agreement that provides the city of Anna Maria with $500,000 for the buildout and installation of the Mote Educational Outreach Center on the City Pier.

The county commission authorized the interlocal agreement on Tuesday, Oct. 12, after the Anna Maria City Commission approved the Mote Marine lease agreement by a 4-1 vote on Sept. 30.

The $500,000 in county funds is expected to cover the majority of the costs associated with the interior buildout of the city-owned building and the installation of the Mote Marine exhibits. Mote Marine will be responsible for any buildout and installation costs that exceed the $500,000 being provided by the county – with the exception of any additional costs associated with design elements or facility features sought by the city commission beyond those proposed by Mote Marine. The city will reimburse Mote Marine for the buildout and installation costs incurred and then be reimbursed by the county.

The lease agreement reached with Mote Marine in September will not generate monthly or annual rent revenues for the city, and the city will be responsible for the utilities and maintenance costs associated with the educational outreach center that will be staffed and operated at Mote Marine’s expense.

On Thursday, Oct. 14, Anna Maria Mayor Dan Murphy told city commissioners the next step in the process will be the presentation of Mote Marine’s buildout and installation plans. Murphy said those plans will require city commission approval. He also said those plans will be reviewed by the city’s building official and the city’s engineering firm before being presented to the city commission for acceptance or denial.

“If the plans are denied, the deal is off with Mote,” Murphy told the commission. “I chartered our building official and our city engineer with making sure that we’re getting a high-quality product.”

Murphy said he and Public Works Manager Dean Jones plan to meet with Mote Marine CEO and President Michael Crosby within the next 10 days or so to discuss the plans in progress.

“They are already actively developing their plans,” Murphy said.

Murphy said he hopes to bring the plan approval process to quick fruition, but as of last week he was unable to provide an estimated date as to when those plans will be presented to the city commission.

After the September meeting, Mote Marine Vice President of Communications and Strategic Initiatives Kevin Cooper said he expects the buildout and installation to be completed by March 2022, with the Mote Marine facility opening soon after that.

Related coverage

 

Anna Maria and Mote Marine reach pier lease agreement

Anna Maria and Mote Marine reach pier lease agreement

Anna Maria and Mote Marine reach pier lease agreement

ANNA MARIA – The city of Anna Maria and Mote Marine Laboratory have entered into a 10-year lease agreement for the installation and operation of the Mote Educational Outreach Center on the City Pier.

The city commission approved the lease agreement by a 4-1 vote during a special commission meeting on Thursday, Sept. 30, with Commissioner Mark Short casting the only opposition vote.

The Mote facility will be located inside the larger of two city-owned buildings at the T-end of the City Pier; and next to the City Pier Grill & Bait Shop that operates in city-owned space leased to business partners Brian Seymour, Vic Mattay and Nick Graham.

Anna Maria and Mote Marine reach pier lease agreement
The Mote Marine facility will be located inside this city-owned building on the Anna Maria City Pier. – Joe Hendricks | Sun

Earlier this year, the Manatee County Commission supported the Tourist Development Council’s recommendation that the county contribute $500,000 toward the initial buildout and exhibit installation costs. With the lease agreement now signed, the city must still finalize the $500,000 funding agreement with a county commission-approved interlocal agreement. The city will reimburse Mote Marine for its initial buildout and installation costs and then be reimbursed by the county.

Lease negotiations

Thursday’s discussion began with Mayor Dan Murphy stating he and Mote Marine Vice President of Communications and Strategic Initiatives Kevin Cooper engaged in “lengthy and productive” discussions that led to the final lease agreement presented.

“This is something we have been working on since Feb. 10th – the first time we made a formal presentation of a proposal to put Mote Marine out on the City Pier. We’ve had an incredible amount of public input over this issue of what should be out on the pier. I believe this is in fact – for the city, the residents and the visitors – the very best choice to put on that pier,” Murphy told the commission.

Murphy noted each commissioner was previously provided an earlier version of a proposed lease agreement that was then modified based on that initial input received from the individual commissioners.

“Kevin and I worked diligently to put together the best product we could,” Murphy said.

Commission comments

Commission Chair Carol Carter said she spent many years working with large research universities and she noted lease agreements with large research institutions usually present additional challenges.

“I know the mayor and our attorney and our treasurer/clerk have worked really hard because this is a different animal to deal with. I would just like to acknowledge all the work they’ve done,” Carter said.

Short then shared his views on the proposed lease agreement.

“On behalf of the city, I want to thank the TDC and the Manatee County Commission for approving the $500,000 that will be used for the buildout of the education outreach center. A lot of energy and effort went into this and I wanted to thank the mayor and staff for everything they did. I want to thank Mote for their interest and willingness to operate this educational outreach center for the pier,” Short said.

Anna Maria and Mote Marine reach pier lease agreement
This currently vacant space will be transformed into the Mote Educational Outreach Center. – Joe Hendricks | Sun

“I recognize – I think we all do – that this is not going to improve the bottom line of Mote. Based on the preliminary operating budget they provided us back in February, to operate this center is going to cost Mote somewhere between $200,000 and $400,000 a year. I don’t think having Mote on the pier is a bad thing. Although, to be honest, I’m not necessarily convinced it’s the best thing,” Short said.

“The $500,000 estimated cost has been funded. Any costs incurred above that will be paid by Mote unless the city decides there are certain things it wants done outside the scope of what Mote will do. The city will pay for all the utilities to operate the outreach center and the city will not receive any rent for the use of this facility for a period which could be up to 10 years based on the agreement,” Short said of the pier building originally offered for lease for the operation of a full-service restaurant.

“In spite of what we all believe is the educational benefit of operating this center on the pier, the fact remains that there will be no rent the city will receive,” Short reiterated.

He also expressed concerns about the potential 10-year agreement providing Mote Marine, and not the city, with the option to extend the lease for an additional five years.

With no more commission or public comment offered, Carter sought and received from Commissioner Jon Crane a motion to accept the lease agreement. Commissioners Deanie Sebring, Doug Copeland and Carter supported Crane’s motion.

“I very much appreciate the partnership growing between Mote and the city of Anna Maria,” Cooper told the commission.

Anna Maria and Mote Marine reach pier lease agreement
This rendering illustrates the basic floor plans for the Mote Educational Outreach Center and the already-operational City Pier Grill. – City of Anna Maria | Submitted

Copeland asked Cooper when he expects the buildout and exhibit installation to begin and be completed.

“Because we deal with multiple campuses across the state of Florida, we do maintain an internal team for facilities, exhibit design (and) habitat maintenance. With labor shortages and supply chain shortages, we still maintain that we’ll do a six-month buildout. We expect to wrap up construction in March,” Cooper said.

Post-meeting comments

After the meeting, Murphy signed the approved lease agreement, which Cooper took to Mote Marine President and CEO Dr. Michael Crosby, who signed the agreement that afternoon.

When contacted Thursday afternoon, Cooper said, “We’re excited to grow the partnership with the city of Anna Maria. It aligns very well with our mission to educate the public on the importance of coastal conservation and marine habitat resource management; and I think it aligns with what Anna Maria wants to do with the pier.”

Cooper said Mote Marine will select any additional contractors or subcontractors needed to supplement the work done by Mote’s in-house staff.

“Mote is operating as the contractor. We’ll be doing the conceptual design elements and also some of the installation. When subcontractors are necessary, we will be sending them out. The first phase for us is concept and design, and that has to be approved by the city before we’re able to start construction. We’ll start on that almost immediately. We will open the facility in close proximity to the completion of construction, assuming there’s no other challenges or issues that arise. We can make a pretty quick turnaround from the completion of construction to the opening of the facility itself,” Cooper said.

Anna Maria and Mote Marine reach pier lease agreement
Presented earlier this year, the rendering illustrates in a general sense what the Mote Educational Outreach Center will look like when completed in 2022. – City of Anna Maria | Submitted

According to Cooper, the current working title for the facility is the Mote Educational Outreach Center at the city of Anna Maria Pier, but that could change.

“That’s been the name in theory, but that’s a mouthful, so I don’t know if that’s going to be the name of the facility once it opens. As we begin to build out the design and go through the approvals with the city that may very well change,” Cooper said.

When contacted Thursday afternoon, Murphy said, “I’m very excited that we came to an agreement with Mote on the lease and can move forward with bringing this important addition to our city. The Mote outreach center will be both educational and entertaining for people of all ages and our pier provides the perfect backdrop for this facility. I thank our commission for having the foresight and good judgment to recognize the value of having this type of venue right here in our own backyard.”