Skip to main content

Tag: Champlain Towers South

Castles in the Sand

What’s Surfside got to do with it?

Florida is a big state, but not big enough to ignore disasters that happen four hours away.

In June, when the Champlain Towers South condo in Surfside collapsed, we all knew there would be more to this story, way more.

At that time, local politicians and engineers tried to put a positive spin on the disaster – if that was even possible in the wake of 98 deaths. The building had structural problems going back to the original construction; that was something we heard a lot about. But the fact that it was built basically on a sandbar surrounded by water could not be ignored.

In case you haven’t noticed the geography of Anna Maria Island, it too is built on a sandbar surrounded by water and the Island cities are starting to pay attention to that fact. Holmes Beach is the first of the cities to look into developing a recertification program for large buildings to identify structural issues, particularly in older condominiums. The recertification in Holmes Beach would apply to condos that are three stories over under-building parking.

The proposed program is structured so qualifying buildings would be inspected by a third-party engineer to determine if they are structurally sound. The inspections would occur every few decades subject to fines if any issues are not properly addressed. Holmes Beach will vote on this proposal at a future commission meeting.

This Holmes Beach proposition is modeled somewhat on the Florida Bar task force recommendation to the Legislature, also recommending structural inspections within the next three years for condominiums three stories or taller. It is still unclear if this recommendation means three stories above under-building parking or three stories from ground level. In addition, the Florida Bar task force recommends certifications for roof structures, fireproofing, elevators, plumbing, electrical systems and other items.

An interesting note is that the victims’ families of the Champlain Towers South collapse are suing the developers of a neighboring luxury condo. They are alleging that the nearby construction destabilized the building and helped lead to the collapse.

In spite of all the conversations about the stability of condo buildings, it doesn’t seem to be affecting the southeast Florida real estate market. The Miami area residential market is a popular destination for South American buyers. During the pandemic, however, this fell off because of travel restrictions into our country. Now that those restrictions have lifted, it is anticipated that the southeast coast of Florida will have a renewed sales boom from international buyers from Mexico, Columbia and Argentina.

On another note, I would be remiss if I didn’t point out that the federal government is about to back mortgages of nearly $1 million for the first time. Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac are expected to increase the maximum size of home mortgage loans early next year. This is a reaction to the rapid appreciation of home prices nationally over the past year.

The expectation is to raise their conforming loan limits to about $650,000 from $548,250 and up to about $1 million in what is considered “high-cost” markets from $822,375. There is no small controversy going on about this increase and the view that the American taxpayer is subsidizing affluent homeowners.

It’s pretty clear that what happens on Florida’s east coast doesn’t stay on the east coast. All barrier islands and waterfront communities throughout the state will be taking a serious look at the age and condition of condos in their area as well as the state of Florida setting future recertification guidelines. Hang on – there’s more to this story.

Holmes Beach building department

Former Island building official last to inspect Surfside condo

HOLMES BEACH – Just hours before the 12-story Champlain Towers South condo collapsed on June 24, former Holmes Beach Building Official Jim McGuinness inspected it.

The next day, he told the town commission that he saw nothing that would indicate the building would soon collapse.

McGuinness, who resigned from the city of Holmes Beach in 2019, is now the building official for the town of Surfside, and was the last person to inspect the building before its collapse.

He was on the roof of the doomed tower 14 hours prior to the building’s collapse to inspect the installation of anchors installed to allow window washers to safely lower themselves over the side of the residential condominium building. In addition to the recently installed anchors, McGuinness said other work was being done on the roof, but had been delayed due to ongoing rainfall in the area.

The building owners’ association, McGuinness said, was in the process of conducting the required inspections and tests for its 40-year recertification, due before the end of the calendar year. Though he said he had not received any of the required paperwork for recertification prior to the disaster at the Collins Avenue property, McGuinness told Surfside town commissioners that he believed the required inspections were largely complete.

To qualify for recertification, the building’s owners or association must complete all required inspections with a third-party firm, present them to the city’s building department for review and complete any required repairs before obtaining the certification for the building. Though the recertification program in Surfside is mandated by Miami-Dade County regulations, it’s up to the town’s building department to oversee the recertification process for buildings in their jurisdiction.

In a July 3 story, Fox News reported that the manager of the Champlain Towers condominium association complained by email on June 21 that the Surfside building department was stalling needed repairs at the tower, with McGuinness failing to respond to a May email concerning a parking plan for construction to repair the concrete slab underneath the pool deck. McGuinness responded to the email just hours before the building partially collapsed, according to the report. Engineering experts working with the Miami Herald stated that after review of photos and video of the building collapse the partial collapse could be due to the pool deck failing, falling into the garage below and pulling part of the building down with it.

An investigation into the tower’s June 24 partial collapse is ongoing along with an around-the-clock search for those still missing in the disaster. Ahead of Hurricane Elsa, the remaining portion of the Champlain Towers South building was imploded to keep the site as safe as possible for rescue workers and help them access previously unstable areas to search for the missing. As of July 9, 78 people were confirmed dead in the collapse and 68 were still reported as missing in the Surfside disaster.

Surfside Mayor Charles Burkett said an outside engineering firm is investigating the wreckage of the south tower along with its sister buildings to make sure those are still safe for residents and workers to occupy.

Investigations into the collapse also are being conducted by the U. S. Department of Commerce’s National Institute of Standards and Technology to determine what caused the partial collapse of the structure and what can be done to prevent similar tragedies in the future.

The Sun reached out to the city of Surfside’s building department and McGuinness for more information on recent inspections at Champlain Towers South, however, no response to emails, phone calls and text messages was received.

Prior to taking the building official position in Surfside, McGuinness worked for the city of Holmes Beach from March 23, 2015 until March 18, 2019 when he officially handed in his letter of resignation to Mayor Judy Titsworth. At the time of his resignation, McGuinness was being disciplined by the mayor.

In a discussion with The Sun, Titsworth said that while she could not speak to the circumstances surrounding McGuinness’s departure from the city, she would not consider hiring him back if given the opportunity. While she said McGuinness has a good understanding of the Florida Building Code, Titsworth added she was not happy with his performance and that personality conflicts caused a problem.

“It just wasn’t a good fit,” she said.

More recently on Anna Maria Island, McGuinness made headlines for his erroneous approval of a lighted sign and LED board at the Anna Maria Beach Resort on Gulf Drive prior to his departure from the city. His issuance of a permit for the backlit sign and message board against the city’s codes prohibiting backlit signs in residential neighborhoods has resulted in a lawsuit against the city from the resort’s owners and months of city commission discussion related to changes to the Holmes Beach sign ordinance to somehow accommodate existing backlit signs in residential areas. An update to the ordinance has not yet been approved by commissioners. The case in Manatee County Circuit Court is still pending.

Related coverage

 

Island building owners warned to investigate structural issues

 

Balcony collapses in Holmes Beach