Skip to main content
|

Charter review process discussed 

City Attorney Randy Mora recently discussed the city’s charter review process. – Joe Hendricks | Sun

 HOLMES BEACH – The Holmes Beach city charter has not been reviewed since 2019 – in part because the city’s charter review process currently calls for an elected charter review commission. 

The city charter establishes how the city government is structured and the roles of the mayor and commissioners. The charter establishes the appointment of the city clerk, city treasurer and city attorney. Among other things, the charter also establishes the city’s 36-foot building height limit. 

According to city ordinance, the charter shall be reviewed every fifth year by a commission of five members elected by the electors of the city in a city general election. 

In 2023, only one candidate, Bill Romberger, qualified to run as a charter review commission candidate, and no charter review was conducted in 2024. 

The Holmes Beach charter provides three ways to amend the charter. Charter amendments can be proposed by an elected charter review commission, by the city commission itself or by a citizen-initiated petition drive. Proposed charter amendments require the majority support of the city’s participating registered voters. The charter cannot be changed without the support of the voters. 

As currently written, the Holmes Beach charter does not provide the city commission the authority to appoint charter review commission members, but City Attorney Randy Mora is working on a potential solution that could produce a commission-appointed charter review commission at some point in the future. 

During the Oct. 27 city commission meeting, Commissioner Terry Schaefer noted Mora was previously asked to study the city’s current charter review process and advise the commission on how to potentially move forward to create a commission-appointed review commission. 

Mora said he planned to address the charter review process after the new mayor took office as a result of the city elections concluded on Nov. 3. 

Mora previously said Holmes Beach is an “anomaly” among Florida cities by requiring the election of charter review commission members. 

On Oct. 27, Mora discussed a possible solution to the elected member requirement. He suggested the city commission propose a charter amendment to be put before city voters during the 2027 general election. The proposed amendment would ask city voters to approve an amendment that would result in charter review commission members being appointed instead of being elected. 

“The most appropriate way to address that would be to put to the electors a vote to change that in your charter so we can have that be like any other board: appointed,” Mora said. 

“You do not need a charter review commission to come up with charter amendments,” he said, while also noting that he doesn’t want the city commission to “go crazy” in terms of proposed city commission-initiated charter amendments. 

The commission expressed preliminary, informal support for eventually moving forward in this manner.